Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there is a sub-class of people in our society

342 replies

bluewanda · 21/09/2023 21:27

Baby boy died in 'filthy' home with 'traces of cocaine in his system'

https://mol.im/a/12545263

What the hell is wrong with these people. How the fuck can they subject an innocent baby to such a horrific life?! These children should be removed at birth because they don’t stand a chance. It is so utterly depressing.

Baby boy died in 'filthy' home with 'traces of cocaine in his system'

Little Grant John Storey-Delaney died while in his baby bouncer at his Rochdale home. He was found 'turning grey' by his mother Sophie Riley with a blanket over his face

https://mol.im/a/12545263

OP posts:
T1mumtobe · 21/09/2023 23:22

Flickersy · 21/09/2023 22:59

The poor little boy everyone on here is wailing and rending their clothes over would grow up to be one of these "sub human" people you all hate.

So given your wish for them all to be sterilised and wiped out, can you tell me why you consider this such a tragedy? I'm not being goady - there's a tonne of cognitive dissonance and lack of real understanding on this thread, not to mention the horrific othering of Them as though they're a different species which We could never be.

The truth is that any one of us or any one of our children could lose jobs, fall victim to addiction, to a violent relationship etc. Most of us on this thread will have been lucky in that we had stable homes, parents who were invested in us, and who were in turn lucky enough not to have serious mental health issues or addictions.

Families and people like those in the story don't have that. They will have been exposed to drug and alcohol abuse, physical abuse from a young age. Possibly a complete lack of schooling. No support network to turn to, and frankly no idea that could even be a possibility. What chance does a child have growing up in that environment? And when that child grows up and has a child of its own, why would you expect their entire history to magically disappear and them to turn into a stable, switched on parent?

The only way to stop this is to break the cycle by seriously ramping up mental health and addiction services, funding social services properly etc.

Exactly. You have hit the nail on the head.

The kids who survive this kind of parenting, often start committing crimes in teenage years and everyone quickly screams "lock them up" and talks about them like they're subhuman, even though 5 years earlier they'd have offered unlimited sympathy. It's depressing as fuck and absolutely a societal problem, these issues are worse in societies with higher levels of inequality but people talk like nothing could be done? You just don't want to have to contribute towards the cost of it.

MyHornCanPierceTheSky · 21/09/2023 23:22

Seems like there were severe failures here from social services
Nope. Seems like the parents were shitty scumbags who neglected and killed their child.
Why do people keep forgiving the bloody parents?!!

Bored1000 · 21/09/2023 23:22

Everything about it is depressing, what is more depressing is the thought that there are many many more poor little children living through a similar type of hell with useless feckless parents in horrendous conditions that we will never hear about

msmonstera · 21/09/2023 23:21

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

paintityellow · 21/09/2023 23:20

Oblomov23 · 21/09/2023 23:14

I don't agree it's a failings of welfare state or SS, it takes a certain kind of person to do such a thing.

In some cases it's a person who's mentally ill, completely inadequate, addicted to drugs or alcohol, of such low intelligence they are genuinely incapable of looking after a child, or so damaged themselves they don't even know what a normal home looks like. By allowing people like that to take on full responsibility for a tiny baby the State is failing many vulnerable children. Some children would genuinely be better off being removed from their parents at birth and being adopted into a loving and caring home. And the rights of those children need to be paramount, not the rights of their birth parents to keep them and then neglect or harm them.

madroid · 21/09/2023 23:18

@bluewanda Could government-funded programmes not make a difference - education, therapy, counseling etc?

Yes, and the last Labour govt funded one. It was called Homestart. It focused on helping families with children that needed help.

But nothing works properly any more. Public services have been underfunded for so long and staffing levels cut across the board. Need has increased through poverty, cost of living and more elderly people as a proportion of the population. We need this govt out so that services can recover.

BertieBotts · 21/09/2023 23:17

The use of the term "subclass" is a bit confusing, you seem to mean that you consider people who could neglect a baby to be sub-human, not that they are some kind of sub-class, as others have pointed out, class has nothing to do with this and it is unfortunately not new, babies have been dying due to neglect in horrific circumstances basically since people had a definition for the word neglect.

Is the class thing about judgement of people who don't work or who receive welfare benefits? Because certainly not all people in that situation are neglectful parents.

Or is it about people who are addicts and live in squalor? I don't think anybody is arguing that people living in that situation can safely raise children. I think we would all agree that should be subject to some kind of social services intervention.

Seems like there were severe failures here from social services - with previous children removed there are usually fairly stringent checks I thought? I wonder why that was not done this time. Cutbacks or social workers with too high a workload? Not joined up paperwork?

Poor baby RIP :(

Oblomov23 · 21/09/2023 23:14

I don't agree it's a failings of welfare state or SS, it takes a certain kind of person to do such a thing.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 21/09/2023 23:13

ConsuelaHammock · 21/09/2023 22:52

I’m ok with eugenics in some instances. Especially if it’s to protect children from the kind of life and death this baby experienced.

I'm actually rather fond of not being aborted by force - not just for my personal benefit, but because we have no business supporting the forcible abortion and sterilisation of women we don't approve of - it would never stay as 'just' a punishment for being a shit parent, it would become brutalising women deemed to be of poor genetics, of minor learning disabilities, neurodiversity, suffering from trauma, of being the wrong racial make up, being born into poverty - and then, if a forced abortion is a bit unpleasant to read of over one's cornflakes, they'll be oh, so nice and merely forcibly sterilise them instead. best do it before they're likely to first conceive, about 11 years old should cover all outliers. After all, they'll know exactly what girls are going to end up like that, it's just being forward thinking to ensure none of these unsuitable females end up in the breeding pool...

If it's a woman's right to choose whether she continues with a pregnancy because it's her body, it cannot ever be the right of the State to make a decision either way - even when you don't like her. Because giving the State that right means all women lose their reproductive rights and puts us straight back at the point where Europe found itself just under a century ago and China has been enforcing on minorities right up to the current day.

MyHornCanPierceTheSky · 21/09/2023 23:11

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Pretty soon, if not already calling someone 'bigoted' isn't going to be the big GOTCHA! that people want it to be!
"Oh no, someone who has completely opposite views to me, has called me bigoted! Boo hoo.'

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 21/09/2023 23:10

Detective Inspector Maxwell said it was 'one of the worst addresses' she had seen in her near three decades within the force, with litter trays full of cat urine and feces

Poor wee soul . never stood a chance , did he ? Sad.

Pollyputhekettleon · 21/09/2023 23:10

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 21/09/2023 23:08

Rich people abuse children. Remember Saville and Harris? Gary Glitter? Rich people are just better at covering it up.

What I said is true. Read it as many times as you need to and/or look it up. The education system needs a massive overhaul until people understand basic statistical concepts.

Mistressanne · 21/09/2023 23:09

swimminglessonadvice · 21/09/2023 22:43

What confuses me and I’m from an Immigrant family is how can my Grandparents and parents come here and work in foundaries, mills etc then buy businesses and now we are lawyers and doctors. They came from another country from poverty. They couldn’t speak English or read or write it, yet here are their children and grandchildren in professional jobs.

Whereas those born with the privilege of being born and brought up in this country are trapped in a poverty cycle but we came from poverty, no benefits system and knew education was our way out.

Intelligence, that’s what.
These people even with an education wouldn’t be very bright.
Years ago they would have worked in factories or on the land because otherwise they wouldn’t have any money. And also societal pressure encouraged working.

80skid · 21/09/2023 23:09

I never forget Social Services explaining that you shouldn't judge by "your standards ". The implication being that even if the situation is totally intolerable by "normal" standards, by the standards of the sub class you refer to, it's totally fine and normal. Horrific interaction that was sadly indicative of the under resourced social care system we have. The base line "standard " our society's babies should live above clearly needs to be raised massively

Pollyputhekettleon · 21/09/2023 23:09

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Is what I said true or is it false?

SequentialAnalyst · 21/09/2023 23:09

Look at the house. Would you like to live there?

AnnaBlush · 21/09/2023 23:08

@bluewanda
i do actually agree with your point! I tried to go back earlier and change the word ‘responsible’ to contributed.
The only reason I was highlighting the legal context- is people seem so quick to blame only social workers as if they do not have to follow the law.
I agree ultimately its parents who are responsible for such tragedies

Flickersy · 21/09/2023 23:08

OneNameTwoNameThreeName · 21/09/2023 23:03

You say you feel terrible for the poor little baby (and children like him) who didn’t even have a chance. Me too. But at what point do you feel he would have had a chance and is thus fully responsible with zero excuses to be made for what happens in the next generation?

If a baby born to addict parents, neglected from birth, likely with predisposition to mental health problems, possibly a low IQ. Somehow survives the abuse, the parents who don’t give a shit if they go to school or not or how and with whom they spend their free time, exposed to alcohol and drugs in pre teens, no role models in life (yes perhaps teachers/people on tv etc, but not anyone ‘like them’ and in their world. Abusive relationships modelled left right and centre. This kid makes it to 18. Somehow. Fair chance has exactly zero GCSEs. Drinks. Possibly drugs. May already have kids. Likely in very unhealthy relationship. Friends all from similarly chaotic circumstances with similarly chaotic current lives…

So at what point did the poor baby who never had a chance become despicable scum that you feel is accountable for not just pulling themselves up by their bootstraps, getting a job, being a productive member of society, stop drinking/drugs (that they may have been addicted to since literal childhood), knowing not to expose themselves/their kids/their partner to alcohol/drugs/abusive relationships, etc etc?

Edited

I suspect for posters on here it's probably in the teenage years, when they stop being cute.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 21/09/2023 23:08

Pollyputhekettleon · 21/09/2023 23:00

What I said is true. Look it up.

Rich people abuse children. Remember Saville and Harris? Gary Glitter? Rich people are just better at covering it up.

paintityellow · 21/09/2023 23:07

HopefulElle · 21/09/2023 23:01

Absolutely heartbreaking. I know it’s irrelevant, really, but stories like this make my own infertility so much harder to bear. What a life my husband and I would have given this boy, and what a horrific life, and death, he had instead.

I think it's very relevant. There are so many people out there dying to adopt and who would welcome a baby into their home with open arms. Instead we send so many new babies to filthy, awful homes to be cared for by inadequate, abusive or neglectful parents until they either die, as in this and so many other tragic cases, or grow up to repeat the behaviour they have learnt from their negligent parents, carrying it forward to another generation.

Flickersy · 21/09/2023 23:07

MyHornCanPierceTheSky · 21/09/2023 23:05

The truth is that any one of us or any one of our children could lose jobs, fall victim to addiction, to a violent relationship etc. Most of us on this thread will have been lucky in that we had stable homes, parents who were invested in us, and who were in turn lucky enough not to have serious mental health issues or addictions.
@Flickersy I'd like to think the majority of mnetters wouldn't kill their child.

You can like to think whatever you want.

The facts of the matter, however, are that addiction, abuse, trauma and mental illness will really warp a person's idea of right and wrong.

Fallingthroughclouds · 21/09/2023 23:05

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 21/09/2023 23:05

Blackbyrd · 21/09/2023 22:52

We need to seriously reconsider the wisdom of paying addicts benefits in cash. All they do is immediately go and score, caring nothing for anyone or anything else. A childless single person on UC over 35 with the "disability" element and the lowest rates of PIP is getting well over £1100 pcm cash in hand. Housing costs and Council Tax are also generally paid in full and there's plenty of free food for the taking

TBH, if I was disabled and on benefits in this country, I'd probably turn to street drugs to block out that misery as well. Being on benefits was utterly miserable 15 years ago and UC has been brought in since then to make it even worse.

If you take away cash benefits and replace them with food stamps, how does the claimant replace the vacuum cleaner or go to the launderette? There's practical reasons for giving claimants money.

Grant's mother wasn't fit to parent for reasons that will go deeper than her drug use. Drug use is a symptom of problems as well as a problem in itself. Giving her food stamps wouldn't have fixed that.

MyHornCanPierceTheSky · 21/09/2023 23:05

The truth is that any one of us or any one of our children could lose jobs, fall victim to addiction, to a violent relationship etc. Most of us on this thread will have been lucky in that we had stable homes, parents who were invested in us, and who were in turn lucky enough not to have serious mental health issues or addictions.
@Flickersy I'd like to think the majority of mnetters wouldn't kill their child.

OneNameTwoNameThreeName · 21/09/2023 23:03

You say you feel terrible for the poor little baby (and children like him) who didn’t even have a chance. Me too. But at what point do you feel he would have had a chance and is thus fully responsible with zero excuses to be made for what happens in the next generation?

If a baby born to addict parents, neglected from birth, likely with predisposition to mental health problems, possibly a low IQ. Somehow survives the abuse, the parents who don’t give a shit if they go to school or not or how and with whom they spend their free time, exposed to alcohol and drugs in pre teens, no role models in life (yes perhaps teachers/people on tv etc, but not anyone ‘like them’ and in their world. Abusive relationships modelled left right and centre. This kid makes it to 18. Somehow. Fair chance has exactly zero GCSEs. Drinks. Possibly drugs. May already have kids. Likely in very unhealthy relationship. Friends all from similarly chaotic circumstances with similarly chaotic current lives…

So at what point did the poor baby who never had a chance become despicable scum that you feel is accountable for not just pulling themselves up by their bootstraps, getting a job, being a productive member of society, stop drinking/drugs (that they may have been addicted to since literal childhood), knowing not to expose themselves/their kids/their partner to alcohol/drugs/abusive relationships, etc etc?

Swipe left for the next trending thread