Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there is a sub-class of people in our society

342 replies

bluewanda · 21/09/2023 21:27

Baby boy died in 'filthy' home with 'traces of cocaine in his system'

https://mol.im/a/12545263

What the hell is wrong with these people. How the fuck can they subject an innocent baby to such a horrific life?! These children should be removed at birth because they don’t stand a chance. It is so utterly depressing.

Baby boy died in 'filthy' home with 'traces of cocaine in his system'

Little Grant John Storey-Delaney died while in his baby bouncer at his Rochdale home. He was found 'turning grey' by his mother Sophie Riley with a blanket over his face

https://mol.im/a/12545263

OP posts:
Sussurations · 22/09/2023 07:27

Addiction is a scourge and society needs better ways of dealing with it. i also agree that domestic violence is a significant factor and one that should be dealt with differently.

There are far too many parents who see their children as possessions - things they have a right to keep, to see, to take from the other parent.

Money is not the only answer, but things like Homestart might help parents who just don’t know better or who need support. They are never going to help parents like the ones in this case.

Drug addiction, violence, serious (ie dangerous) squalor, refusing to engage with SW should be massive red flags that allow much more draconian action by SWs, police and the law where vulnerable children are involved. These children have rights.

Some people might be part of a ‘subclass’ that is a drain on society and causes all sorts of issues for themselves and others but that is a slightly different issue to people who are a risk or an outright danger to the
children in their care. There may well be significant overlap in the two groups but it ought to be possible for society to act for the good of the children. These parents bear the responsibility for killing their child but we as a society ought to be able to take a clear-sighted look at it.

Personally I would crack down really hard on drug use/addiction where there is a child in the house. People can be addicted behind closed doors of course, but these parents were known to authorities. If the parents could be sent to a compulsory rehab and be offered sterilisation as an option, and the child removed at birth and adopted, there would be a chance of better outcomes.

swimminglessonadvice · 22/09/2023 06:39

Not to drip feed but there is addiction (alcohol and gambling) there has been abuse and murder. There are major mental health issues too (depression, suicide). But we are a generation that is saying the buck stops with us and we invest heavily in our mental health. However it’s because we have the financial and educational means. My mum literally grew up in rags, she was abandoned by her mother; my dad was an alcoholic BUT we (as in their children) still went onto university and have professional jobs. It was chaotic growing up in our house. Our parents and GPs didn’t speak English well, were uneducated.

Your point about depravation doesn’t ring true, our families lived in third world conditions even in this country in deprived areas.

MyHornCanPierceTheSky · 22/09/2023 05:52

Was the mother bf? Am confused if not as to how cocaine and cannabis ended up in system of a baby who wouldn't have weaned yet.
Still people with the 'it's ss fault' probably the same people who would be on here shrieking about baby stealers and intrusive, over judgemental ss if they had gone in and removed Grant at birth.

Thatladdo · 22/09/2023 04:08

The majority of people dont come into contact with these people, some dont beleive they exist - genuinely they think its just a scornful label or made up joke in bad taste - you often see this on MN.
Some people dont realise how insulated they are in their little bubbles of middle class or even upper working class they dont know what its actualy like at the rough end.

YoureALizardHarry11 · 22/09/2023 03:21

People don’t end up ‘’scumbags’’ for no reason. Like a pp said, situations like this are borne out of generations of poverty and abuse. If the parents were parented properly and adequate protective factors were present they likely wouldn't be addicts in the first place to put a poor child in that situation. It’s just a sad cycle that continues.

Do PP’s think someone is born and just suddenly decides to be a scumbag for no reason? There’s all sorts of things at play.

Social services have let the child down for a start.

Coyoacan · 22/09/2023 03:15

I remember when I had a baby and I still lost patience with her at times. But I had economic security and had had a loving upbringing. How much harder things are for parents how lack one or both of those elements. Unless the OP is planning concentration camps for the people she identifies as the underclass, we as a society really need to improve living conditions for everyone

Lwrenagain · 22/09/2023 03:09

I'm very tired so forgive me please if I've missed the point here or generally say something daft.

I'm from an "underclass" area, it's entrenched with decades of poverty, addiction and chaos in many homes.

Often the people who live these lives have very low intelligence and struggle with the basics such as hygiene, keeping a home clean and even feeding themselves, let alone a poor baby.

I have some shocking and devastating stories from people I went to school with, most of which I don't think people who haven't experienced these low social economic areas as someone who's lived there could even imagine to be true, but sadly they are.

I think it's easy to blame scummy parents and in cases of abuse, rightly fucking so.
But these cases where the parents simply cannot care for a child I think we need much harsher tactics from outside agencies allowed.
Refusing social workers is an absolute joke, I mean, red flag or what?
Engaging with support workers and being made to attend courses for learning about basic hygiene and how to prepare and cook food and safety feed a child, they shouldn't be even optional if you've got social care involvement for negligence. And these people who are negligent need monitoring.
If children have poor school attendance, why? Are they dirty or hungry, why?
We're too easy of this because of funding and every other reason but the reality is, even if the reasons for why these families can't care for children aren't simply just because they're awful people, these babies and children will continue to die.

user1492757084 · 22/09/2023 02:25

Greensleeves · 21/09/2023 21:37

It's horrific, but what do you mean by "sub-class"? Do you think there is something fundamentally different about people who end up in horrendous living situations, addiction, poverty, abuse cycles etc? I can see why it is tempting to buy into the idea that those people are congenitally flawed, not like the rest of us etc - the Victorians certainly thought so - but it's not a very constructive approach to what are essentially systemic social problems borne out of plain old poverty, deprivation, inequality of opportunity and lack of compassionate social infrastructure.

Edited

How incredibly heart breaking.
Addiction can affect any person. I'm assuming breast milk can carry traces of substances. Thorough investigations of mothers and newborns might still overlook a mother who actively tries to cover up addiction or even occasional drug use. It's very very sad and good reason for drug use to be further included in all pregnancy education and antenatal check ups.

Ponoka7 · 22/09/2023 02:23

swimminglessonadvice · 21/09/2023 22:43

What confuses me and I’m from an Immigrant family is how can my Grandparents and parents come here and work in foundaries, mills etc then buy businesses and now we are lawyers and doctors. They came from another country from poverty. They couldn’t speak English or read or write it, yet here are their children and grandchildren in professional jobs.

Whereas those born with the privilege of being born and brought up in this country are trapped in a poverty cycle but we came from poverty, no benefits system and knew education was our way out.

It isn't so much poverty as deprivation. The deprivation, abusive childhoods go back generations. There are people who being born in this country doesn't bring any privilege, whereas you are privileged via your upbringing. This child's mother had MH issues, they could have been hereditary, hence a lack of support.

Ponoka7 · 22/09/2023 02:14

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 22/09/2023 00:31

Indeed, they don't. But the mother didn't dose Grant with drugs as the term "give" would imply.

Grant didn't die because of the trace drugs in his system, the coroner was clear on that. He died, ultimately, because his mother was generally unfit to parent him.

His parents weren't fit to parent him. Let's not say that it's ok for a father to allow the death of a child.

Ponoka7 · 22/09/2023 02:10

AnnaBlush · 21/09/2023 22:22

In response to poster suggesting professionals should protect children@Bemyclementine the parents should have protected the child . Or anyone who insight into the family . Eg parent friends/ friend if they visited home
child protection is everyone’s duty
Children services were involved - but unless they have good evidence cannot force enter into the home.
They likely didn’t have enough evidence to put child on CP register. They cannot make a judgement based on past behaviour alone
I don’t understand the expert suggesting ‘a child in need’ should be seen weekly ( that’s a CP requirement). If a family decline input- without good reason children services legally cannot enforce visits - so perhaps blame the courts/ laws for not protecting the child- not just the local authority.

Edited

I think that more than likely fault will be found in the original decision to put the baby on a CIN plan rather than CP.
Another issue is that the systems aren't joined. Health isn't joined with SS. That was another Tory contract given out that wasn't fit for purpose. Had the systems been joined then the Mother's MH would have been known by the SWs. Had the right questions been asked when writing up the pre birth plan, there would have been enough to put the baby on a CP plan, or even removal. The lack of joined up working was a factor in Baby Ps death, yet here we are sixteen years later. The parents in this case stopped engaging with everyone at two months in. It was then up to the professionals to save this child's life.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 22/09/2023 01:02

oakleaffy · 22/09/2023 00:44

What the heck wasn’t he removed from that stinking hovel?
Reeking litter trays, a sweltering house, scabs on his head, left for goodness knows how long in an inappropriate sleeping environment-
The drugs to be in his system must have been significant to have been picked up in his tiny body, it’s awful neglect.
Litter strewn about the place- probably with maggots and flies in the heat-

That poor baby.
Social workers should have insisted that access was given if the parents denied it-
He could have been a loved baby who stood a chance if removed early on.
Although attachment disorder can manifest in adopted and fostered children, it’s better than death.

It wouldn't take much to find traces in him.

With the parents' histories, he should have been taken away when SS were denied access the first time. Court warrant, five o'clock knock, police with the big red key.

And so should the cats be taken away.

oakleaffy · 22/09/2023 00:50

Livinginanotherworld · 21/09/2023 23:46

Unless they need the excess heat to grow a certain plant ?

That was my thought- But the water temperature was set to 80 degrees centigrade
that’s searingly scalding, surely.

oakleaffy · 22/09/2023 00:44

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 22/09/2023 00:31

Indeed, they don't. But the mother didn't dose Grant with drugs as the term "give" would imply.

Grant didn't die because of the trace drugs in his system, the coroner was clear on that. He died, ultimately, because his mother was generally unfit to parent him.

What the heck wasn’t he removed from that stinking hovel?
Reeking litter trays, a sweltering house, scabs on his head, left for goodness knows how long in an inappropriate sleeping environment-
The drugs to be in his system must have been significant to have been picked up in his tiny body, it’s awful neglect.
Litter strewn about the place- probably with maggots and flies in the heat-

That poor baby.
Social workers should have insisted that access was given if the parents denied it-
He could have been a loved baby who stood a chance if removed early on.
Although attachment disorder can manifest in adopted and fostered children, it’s better than death.

CCTVcity · 22/09/2023 00:33

BertieBotts · 22/09/2023 00:10

OK so what makes someone good or bad? Just born that way or made? (Maybe it doesn't matter?)

What should happen to the bad people? If you had a magic/all-powerful solution. What about a realistic/practical solution - could you identify them early before they hurt anyone?

If you managed to get rid of all the bad people, would there be more bad people that came to take their place? Do you think there will always be a certain percentage of people who are just bad/evil? Like if you got rid of the worst 1% then the people occupying the 2% slot would get worse? Or would it be gone because there's a clear line and it's not muddy.

I'm not trying to make myself feel anything, I'm just interested, having a discussion, because clearly not everyone sees things in the same way. Actually most people seem to have the good people / bad people viewpoint so I was just wondering how different people see that as working.

Edited

Lol I had a moment there where I thought you were an ai bot breaking into sentience. There’s been some weird posts tonight all over.

If you are… well life’s complicated.
If your not.. that’s a lot of questions

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 22/09/2023 00:31

oakleaffy · 22/09/2023 00:27

Well I’m certain most families don’t have food contaminated with class A drugs and cannabis that they pass on to children.

Indeed, they don't. But the mother didn't dose Grant with drugs as the term "give" would imply.

Grant didn't die because of the trace drugs in his system, the coroner was clear on that. He died, ultimately, because his mother was generally unfit to parent him.

oakleaffy · 22/09/2023 00:27

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 22/09/2023 00:17

Read the article, she didn't dose the child, the drug traces are from incidental contamination of his food.

Well I’m certain most families don’t have food contaminated with class A drugs and cannabis that they pass on to children.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 22/09/2023 00:27

Pollyputhekettleon · 21/09/2023 23:10

What I said is true. Read it as many times as you need to and/or look it up. The education system needs a massive overhaul until people understand basic statistical concepts.

Most of the first page results in DuckDuckGo for "is there a correlation between poverty and abuse" are multiple links to "The Relationship Between Poverty and Child Abuse and Neglect: New Evidence" co-written by clinicians at Tavistock and Portland. You know, the people who have been giving puberty blockers to children. The education needs a massive overhaul until people learn to check whether a source is reliable. A source that does not value child safeguarding highly enough to keep mentally-unwell and traumatised children off experimental medication is not a source that I trust about anything safeguarding-related.

oakleaffy · 22/09/2023 00:23

Feral class
Living outside the law , feckless, couldn’t give a toss about anything but their own needs and wants
Kids need taking away asap from parents like these- To save their lives.

Pandering to the parents isn’t on.

Kids lives matter.

bombastix · 22/09/2023 00:20

@BertieBotts - cannot tell you exactly but I can tell you a very good sign. That is violent or aggressive conduct. Literally the surest sign ever that a person has problems. Irrespective of sex or class, that one.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 22/09/2023 00:17

MumblesParty · 21/09/2023 23:32

I’m pretty sure that however poor I was I wouldn’t be giving a baby cannabis and cocaine

Read the article, she didn't dose the child, the drug traces are from incidental contamination of his food.

WandaWonder · 22/09/2023 00:12

Yes there is, but not sure it is, generally not saying on here or not, assumed it is just with people sat around lazy on welfare

Sometimes, the middle classes/'rich' are more creative at hiding it

BertieBotts · 22/09/2023 00:10

OK so what makes someone good or bad? Just born that way or made? (Maybe it doesn't matter?)

What should happen to the bad people? If you had a magic/all-powerful solution. What about a realistic/practical solution - could you identify them early before they hurt anyone?

If you managed to get rid of all the bad people, would there be more bad people that came to take their place? Do you think there will always be a certain percentage of people who are just bad/evil? Like if you got rid of the worst 1% then the people occupying the 2% slot would get worse? Or would it be gone because there's a clear line and it's not muddy.

I'm not trying to make myself feel anything, I'm just interested, having a discussion, because clearly not everyone sees things in the same way. Actually most people seem to have the good people / bad people viewpoint so I was just wondering how different people see that as working.

bombastix · 22/09/2023 00:10

Mountaineer0009 · 21/09/2023 23:55

it could be debated that you could have a perfect society and some will still turn to drugs, booze etc, obviously i know its more detailed than that but it seems with some people its a mix of perspectives.

Drugs and alcohol are symptoms of other problems. Most addicts have psychological issues, or have had some sort of trauma. That is not to excuse. Addicts are pathetic people.

The issue is rather like domestic violence. Preventing violent men from being in a domestic environment would change society, if every man that beat his partner or his children went to prison and could not see his children you would a good chance of changing this. If this man could not see those children and mess them up and bully the mother so she teaches her children that they can be victims, it would change things.

Our society is too permissive about domestic abuse. Change that, you will change society.

Afterrain · 22/09/2023 00:09

I know people who were very poor from difficult backgrounds in the 1970s. All but one went on to make successful lives and had aspirations of a better life, become good citizens, achieve higher education. Some of whom are Consultants, barristers etc. Many of whom were brought up in tenements with shared bathrooms. Traditional manual jobs disappeared.
Poverty is not an excuse for poor choices or lack of education or humanity. Parents for generations have hoped that their children have better life outcomes than their poverty ridden lifestyles. They seek better educational outcomes.
Many struggled but sought to achieve and had hoped that off spring could overcome their background.
This has been the history of the working people of this country.
Sadly, I do believe that there those who do lack aspiration, self motivation and desire to do better for their future offspring.
I found this lack of aspiration lacking
They were use to available jobs without the prerequisite qualifications or experience needed in other parts of the country. In the intermediate years this geographical impasse has lessened.

.