Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there is a sub-class of people in our society

342 replies

bluewanda · 21/09/2023 21:27

Baby boy died in 'filthy' home with 'traces of cocaine in his system'

https://mol.im/a/12545263

What the hell is wrong with these people. How the fuck can they subject an innocent baby to such a horrific life?! These children should be removed at birth because they don’t stand a chance. It is so utterly depressing.

Baby boy died in 'filthy' home with 'traces of cocaine in his system'

Little Grant John Storey-Delaney died while in his baby bouncer at his Rochdale home. He was found 'turning grey' by his mother Sophie Riley with a blanket over his face

https://mol.im/a/12545263

OP posts:
oakleaffy · 22/09/2023 12:41

Pollyputhekettleon · 22/09/2023 07:41

They're ignoring behavioural genetics as always. All behaviours are partly genetic in cause, to varying degrees. Genetic susceptibility to alcoholism, or addition to any drug, for example, is heritable. The children of two alcoholics, adopted at birth to a non alcoholic family, remain more likely than others to become alcoholics themselves.

The same applies to all the behaviours, personality traits, and IQ, that underlie different criminal behaviour as well as child abuse. Risk-taking, for example, disagreeableness, low IQ, impulsiveness, low conscientiousness, inability to empathize, mental health problems, personality disorders. That's one of the reasons why there is a correlation between suffering child abuse growing up and criminality in later life. Environment is the other, including of course the prenatal environment, where a lot of harm is already done in many cases. It's a correlation that dogma insists is a cause.

In other words, child abuse and criminal behaviour share many similar underlying behavioural and therefore partly genetic causes. Children removed at birth from abusive parents remain more likely, statistically, to become child abusers or criminals themselves.

Actual experts know this, it's not even arguable in 2023, but pure environmentalism is a fanatical dogma, and not coincidentally it pays a lot of salaries. Most social policy is built on it and has been for a long time.

Many people will get upset about the above. Anyone reacting with - 'but I was abused and I turned out fine', 'but my parent was a criminal and I'm not', or shrieking about eugenics and concentration camps - statistics is taught incredibly badly at school but this is basic stuff and I think most people can follow it if they can set aside their emotions long enough to try. I won't be explaining.

@Pollyputhekettleon Interesting that you think genetics could well come into play-

Even with animals ( Horses, Dogs) it’s known that good temperament passes on to the offspring- or otherwise.

The apple doesn’t fall far from the tree.
Many years ago there was a “ Problem family “ where I was growing up
Googling I’m 2023 shows same family in local press but moved down a couple of generations.

Nature or nurture?

jlpth · 22/09/2023 11:56

Our society is broken. We don’t tackle problems and it snowballs into this.

Lovepeaceunderstanding · 22/09/2023 11:53

PickledFox · 21/09/2023 22:09

I don't think it's as simple as a "subclass". The mother most likely had a dreadful upbringing herself hence why she ended up the way she did. It's just a very very sad situation but I really don't think your label is appropriate here. It sounds a bit of a snobby term tbh.

@PickledFox ”Sub” = under. There are some people unfortunately who operate outside accepted societal norms. They don’t expect to take responsibility for themselves, their children or animals. They may feel no obligation to consider how they impact others. They may feel no obligation to act within the law. They certainly do not feel an obligation to bring up their children as decent, contributing members of society and so the problem grows.
I do not believe we do enough to stop the cycle of dependency and antisocial behaviour that engulfs some families. Let me be clear these are not those who find themselves struggling or those on benefits, they are a growing underclass and a cancer in society.

bombastix · 22/09/2023 11:46

The key things are moving away, being able to access education, and having insight into your circumstances.

Many people cannot do it. The mental strength needed is massive. If you have a low IQ, are excluded from school, never go, or live in an area where this culture is normalized (violence, early pregnancy, casual use of drugs, family splits or casual step parenting, early sexual experience, no transport, a home filthy so no one sees except dealers or abusers) the odds are stacked against you.

I have met people who survived violent homes though all were scarred. I have met people who survived sexual abuse and poverty and moved on. But they all left where they came from. They cut off their parents. And they did not live in the circumstances like this case describes (which is not so unusual).

Chickenkeev · 22/09/2023 11:29

MrsSkylerWhite · 22/09/2023 11:21

MyHornCanPierceTheSky · Yesterday 23:05

Most of us on this thread will have been lucky in that we had stable homes, parents who were invested in us, and who were in turn lucky enough not to have serious mental health issues or addictions”

I didn’t. I lived with violence and chaos until I became a young adult and left. I made a good life for myself because I knew the way I was brought up was wrong. Our children were raised with love.

Everyone has a choice.

You've done well but it's not a given that everyone else will. Upbringing is a huge thing for people and many don't come out the better side of a bad one through no fault of their own.

MrsSkylerWhite · 22/09/2023 11:21

MyHornCanPierceTheSky · Yesterday 23:05

Most of us on this thread will have been lucky in that we had stable homes, parents who were invested in us, and who were in turn lucky enough not to have serious mental health issues or addictions”

I didn’t. I lived with violence and chaos until I became a young adult and left. I made a good life for myself because I knew the way I was brought up was wrong. Our children were raised with love.

Everyone has a choice.

Bemyclementine · 22/09/2023 11:05

In reference to my first reply, Of course the parents are to blame. They shouldn't have ever had another child. Reading the article though, it's clear there was no joint working going on with the various professionals that could have protected this baby.

Chickenkeev · 22/09/2023 11:02

Bobbotgegrinch · 22/09/2023 09:10

No, they're human, just like you.

They've probably had a spectacularly shitty childhood themselves, may have been born addicted to alcohol or drugs, had their psychological development completely buggered up by abusive parenting.

Does any of that excuse that behaviour, no. But it does go some way to explaining it.

And it may make you feel better to "other" these people, but it doesn't help. If you'd lived their life, you may have acted exactly the same.

Thank you for this, i couldn't put my similar thoughts into words properly. It is silly to ignore these peoples backgrounds, to ignore is to continue the cycle of abuse. It might feel a bit wrong to treat them with humanity but that's exactly what's needed to avoid this in future.

Bubbles254 · 22/09/2023 10:55

The notion of a sub class in Britain has been around at least since the victorian period. Look at the Charles Booth maps of London in the 1890s, he described the lowest class as viscous, semi criminal, shown in black on his maps
https://booth.lse.ac.uk/map/17/-0.1324/51.5167/100/0

Map | Charles Booth's London

Search or navigate Charles Booth's poverty map to discover rich or poor areas of late Victorian London and reveal a modern underlay map.

https://booth.lse.ac.uk/map/17/-0.1324/51.5167/100/0

Everyonesliverlovesparvo · 22/09/2023 10:50

Investment in social workers so they have fewer families on their caseload, better training, support and pay for said SWs to produce and retain skilled practitioners
Likewise HCPs like health visitors, midwives.

decent reasonably priced child care to enable parents to work and contribute, to break the cycle of poverty. Opportunities to gain qualifications post school.
Proper intensive support for these troubled ‘families’.

parental education opportunities like Surestart with access to health visitors, psychologists, mentors to keep a track of these types of parents, a legal system that ensures timely intervention

more investment in schools, SEN support as most of these ‘parents’ themselves have learning difficulties and fall through the net, never had decent role models etc

All this requires money. It’s easier to other these people rather than to see their existence as a societal failing which needs huge long term intervention.

Lwrenagain · 22/09/2023 10:44

@BMW6 having a low IQ or intellectual disability does not make you bad.
It means life will be a constant struggle.

Often because of people's shitty views, such as the one you've just displayed.

BertieBotts · 22/09/2023 10:34

CCTVcity · 22/09/2023 00:33

Lol I had a moment there where I thought you were an ai bot breaking into sentience. There’s been some weird posts tonight all over.

If you are… well life’s complicated.
If your not.. that’s a lot of questions

No, I'm not an AI. I've been on here about 15 years, definitely had this name over ten years if you want to Advanced Search me, I don't mind.

I fully admit to being a bleeding heart softy. But I'm also interested in the logic behind different beliefs and the idea that people can be separated into categories of "good" and "bad" is particularly fascinating because people seem so very sure that it is possible, but when you press for details nobody can draw a sharp line in between the two and that's the bit I am curious about.

Honestly this is probably not the thread for it. I'll leave it and start a general thread another time that isn't linked to any specific case.

Fallingthroughclouds · 22/09/2023 10:32

BMW6 · 22/09/2023 10:02

People are not born shit people

Wrong. People are born with really low IQ, psychopathy, just plain BAD.

Sure nurture plays its part, but nature is at the front of our genetic makeup.

You can be made into a shit person, but of course you can be born a shit person in the first place.

Are you putting people with a low IQ in the same bracket as psychopaths?

BMW6 · 22/09/2023 10:02

People are not born shit people

Wrong. People are born with really low IQ, psychopathy, just plain BAD.

Sure nurture plays its part, but nature is at the front of our genetic makeup.

You can be made into a shit person, but of course you can be born a shit person in the first place.

KimberleyClark · 22/09/2023 09:23

WeeOrcadian · 21/09/2023 21:44

Or...... And hear me out..... The parents were vile, scuzzy, disgusting excuses for human beings?

Shit like this isn't just the responsibility of authorities - people like this shouldn't be allowed to procreate. SS or not - the responsibility lies with the 'parents'

Quite often it’s the only thing of value they feel they CAN do. I’m not excusing them. But it’s easy to say “shouldn’t be allowed to procreate”, not so easy to rebuild society from the bottom up. This goes all the way back to Thatcher and her mantra “there is no such thing as society”. Which basically means “take care of yourself because nobody else matters”.

CollagenQueen · 22/09/2023 09:14

I was a Special Constable for 5 years. I can't even begin to get across to "normal" people, how awful a certain section of society is. Nothing prepared me for it. In those 5 years, I only went in to 2 houses that I would say were "normal". The rest were filthy hovels. Despite the occupants not working, they never ever cleaned. So most surfaces were black with grime. Faeces smeared on the walls. People sleeping on filthy mattresses. The children were not clothed properly and often hungry. Drug addiction was rife. The houses STANK. The first time I went in to a home like this, I was so shocked and thought it was a one off. But no. Every home after that was the same. The people didn't wash, despite having running water. They wouldn't change their clothes for weeks. That's assuming they actually got dressed in the morning.

I tried to tell my Mum how bad it was, and she would reply "Oh dear, sounds bad", but honestly, unless you have seen it with your own eyes, you can't comprehend the depravity.

I think it's a mix of not being raised properly, parents having zero expectations of their children, no one in the family ever working, no money, drug use, alcohol addiction, everyone in your circle being the same (so it's normalised), committing crime because you have no money, getting depressed because you have nothing, turning to drugs and alcohol to try and forget.

If you're born in to a normal family with loving parents, access to resources and enough money to get a decent start in life, you really are lucky. None of us knows how our lives would be, had we been born in to abject poverty or to drug addicted parents. Would we be the Richard Branson, who broke the mould? Maybe, but probably not. Having a normal start in life is an absolute godsend.

Obviously the above had nothing to do with this case. I don't even know where to begin with that!

Bobbotgegrinch · 22/09/2023 09:10

No, they're human, just like you.

They've probably had a spectacularly shitty childhood themselves, may have been born addicted to alcohol or drugs, had their psychological development completely buggered up by abusive parenting.

Does any of that excuse that behaviour, no. But it does go some way to explaining it.

And it may make you feel better to "other" these people, but it doesn't help. If you'd lived their life, you may have acted exactly the same.

Mistressanne · 22/09/2023 08:59

Surely anyone with dc who is a drug user and has drugs in the house is putting the dc at risk and yet so many celebrities are up there doing it.

What the op really means is drug addicts without someone to care for their dc and clean their homes and run their lives whilst they’re off their head on drugs, they are sub human.
The rich and famous either don’t get caught or are tragic and get admitted to rehab by their agents.

Dolores87 · 22/09/2023 08:45

AliOlis · 21/09/2023 21:50

Can you expand on why this is an example of "social failure"? Not just scumbag parents who shouldn't be allowed to breed?

People are not born shit people. Obviously they have turned into awful people but babies don't become awful people alone.

The article says that social services had taken her other children. So this is a social services failure for a start as they should have had heavy social services supervision from the get go and the baby should have been removed based on the state of their house.

But it's also an issue of addiction, likely generational trauma, likely poverty, poor mental health. So many areas of social failing contribute to situations like this.

Locutus2000 · 22/09/2023 08:39

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Flickersy · 22/09/2023 08:08

TodayInahurry · 22/09/2023 08:04

No one made the parents buy and take drugs. Too many people on MN make excuses for drug taking

Your argument is ridiculously facile and you have no understanding of addiction and how some people struggle with it.

Had this little boy survived and grown up with an addiction (thanks to the traces of drugs already in his system at 4 months old), would you say "but no-one made him take the drugs".

Children can be born with addictions thanks to drug use in pregnancy. When they grow up into "scumbags", are you going to be sat there saying "oh but nobody made them take it, it was all their own choice".

TodayInahurry · 22/09/2023 08:04

No one made the parents buy and take drugs. Too many people on MN make excuses for drug taking

Dacadactyl · 22/09/2023 07:44

Ponoka7 · 22/09/2023 02:10

I think that more than likely fault will be found in the original decision to put the baby on a CIN plan rather than CP.
Another issue is that the systems aren't joined. Health isn't joined with SS. That was another Tory contract given out that wasn't fit for purpose. Had the systems been joined then the Mother's MH would have been known by the SWs. Had the right questions been asked when writing up the pre birth plan, there would have been enough to put the baby on a CP plan, or even removal. The lack of joined up working was a factor in Baby Ps death, yet here we are sixteen years later. The parents in this case stopped engaging with everyone at two months in. It was then up to the professionals to save this child's life.

At an ICPC, mum's MH would've been discussed. There would be midwives/health visitors invited, potentially mum/dads G.P too. If MH services were involved with mum/dad, a representative of that service would also have been invited. Same for if a drug/alcohol service are involved, then they're invite too.

The problem comes if there are no services involved at the time, they won't have a full picture, but the SW report should mention the state of the house etc. Depends how crafty the parents are too and whether they appear to be doing everything right at the time of the ICPC.

Pollyputhekettleon · 22/09/2023 07:41

BertieBotts · 21/09/2023 23:43

Many experts have pointed out that, if we could eliminate child abuse, we'd get close to eliminating crime. There have never been sufficient resources to eliminate child abuse.

Food for thought.

They're ignoring behavioural genetics as always. All behaviours are partly genetic in cause, to varying degrees. Genetic susceptibility to alcoholism, or addition to any drug, for example, is heritable. The children of two alcoholics, adopted at birth to a non alcoholic family, remain more likely than others to become alcoholics themselves.

The same applies to all the behaviours, personality traits, and IQ, that underlie different criminal behaviour as well as child abuse. Risk-taking, for example, disagreeableness, low IQ, impulsiveness, low conscientiousness, inability to empathize, mental health problems, personality disorders. That's one of the reasons why there is a correlation between suffering child abuse growing up and criminality in later life. Environment is the other, including of course the prenatal environment, where a lot of harm is already done in many cases. It's a correlation that dogma insists is a cause.

In other words, child abuse and criminal behaviour share many similar underlying behavioural and therefore partly genetic causes. Children removed at birth from abusive parents remain more likely, statistically, to become child abusers or criminals themselves.

Actual experts know this, it's not even arguable in 2023, but pure environmentalism is a fanatical dogma, and not coincidentally it pays a lot of salaries. Most social policy is built on it and has been for a long time.

Many people will get upset about the above. Anyone reacting with - 'but I was abused and I turned out fine', 'but my parent was a criminal and I'm not', or shrieking about eugenics and concentration camps - statistics is taught incredibly badly at school but this is basic stuff and I think most people can follow it if they can set aside their emotions long enough to try. I won't be explaining.

Janieforever · 22/09/2023 07:34

As much as I agree the responsibility is with the parents, I do also think society has a responsibility, we have support services in place, social services, police, care system, and people like these parents will always exist.

These people were known to be a risk, a huge risk, it wasn’t some surprise as the parents presented as people who presented as capable. As such, I think that social services failed in their responsibility

that little baby didn’t even have a bed. Nothing to support their little head. They had class a’s in their system. They will have been over heated, and much more we don’t know about.

social services knew that baby was at risk. Even basic checks were clearly not done.