Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there is a sub-class of people in our society

342 replies

bluewanda · 21/09/2023 21:27

Baby boy died in 'filthy' home with 'traces of cocaine in his system'

https://mol.im/a/12545263

What the hell is wrong with these people. How the fuck can they subject an innocent baby to such a horrific life?! These children should be removed at birth because they don’t stand a chance. It is so utterly depressing.

Baby boy died in 'filthy' home with 'traces of cocaine in his system'

Little Grant John Storey-Delaney died while in his baby bouncer at his Rochdale home. He was found 'turning grey' by his mother Sophie Riley with a blanket over his face

https://mol.im/a/12545263

OP posts:
Pollyputhekettleon · 22/09/2023 17:05

Bobbotgegrinch · 22/09/2023 16:55

Absolute bollocks. Yes, there are genetic predisposition a to things like addiction, and obviously intelligence level is largely genetic, but the impact on your personality is miniscule compared to how much of it comes from your background and the way you're treated in your early years.

It's about what you perceive is normal. If every house you see growing up is filthy, then you're not going to put a high priority on cleanliness yourself.

If you grew up with your parents shouting and swearing at you in the street, then that's the model you're likely to follow when parenting your own kids.

If your Dad used to kick the shit out of you when drunk, then you're less likely to leave when your husband starts doing the same.

None of that is nature, it's not stuff that magically applies to you the moment you are conceived.

It's nurture, it's your normal, it's how you see the people around you behave.

The idea that some people are genetically "worse" than others is frankly fucking disgusting.

Addictions, personalities and intelligence are different things. You're aware that intelligence is highly genetically heritable. You understand that there are genetic predispositions to addiction. Yet you haven't come across the fact that personality traits are also highly genetically heritable?

I'm not entirely clear on what you're arguing, but intelligence and propensity to addiction alone have huge impacts on people's behaviours. Although I'm not sure why you singled those two out.

Some people are more prone to criminal behaviours than others, partly for genetic reasons. As I said already, I know that triggers strong negative emotions in people and causes them to start cursing and swearing and all that. It's still true though.

Interestingly, I don't know if you're aware that accepting that intelligence is 1) measurable at all and 2) 'largely genetic' is considered in many circles to be 'frankly fucking disgusting', eugenicist and verging on fascist. I'm not sure you understand the implications of those statements.

Xtraincome · 22/09/2023 17:05

I do get tired of the government cuts/SS blame all the time when a child dies at the hands of gross negligence/abuse from the parents. The parents stand as the culprits in every way here. Their upbringing and social status have no relevance, they are an underclass of feral vile humans.

There is an amazing, yet gut wrenching scene in Law and Order:SVU when Whoopi Goldbergs character verbally rinses the prosecution when she's being pulled up on fixing a care record after the death of a child under SS. It has stayed with me and is playing in my head as I read through the replies.

That poor baby.

Bobbotgegrinch · 22/09/2023 16:55

Pollyputhekettleon · 22/09/2023 16:44

Your genes are a large part of the reason you act the way you do. It's simply not the case that these people's behaviour is 100% caused by 'problems in society' - i.e. the environment.

It is 'ingrained' in them in the sense that they had a genetic predisposition to such behaviours and/or were already so damaged at birth they were predisposed to such behaviours. No one has said that 'if they had been brought up differently they'd still be scum.' What a ridiculous thing to claim.

Absolute bollocks. Yes, there are genetic predisposition a to things like addiction, and obviously intelligence level is largely genetic, but the impact on your personality is miniscule compared to how much of it comes from your background and the way you're treated in your early years.

It's about what you perceive is normal. If every house you see growing up is filthy, then you're not going to put a high priority on cleanliness yourself.

If you grew up with your parents shouting and swearing at you in the street, then that's the model you're likely to follow when parenting your own kids.

If your Dad used to kick the shit out of you when drunk, then you're less likely to leave when your husband starts doing the same.

None of that is nature, it's not stuff that magically applies to you the moment you are conceived.

It's nurture, it's your normal, it's how you see the people around you behave.

The idea that some people are genetically "worse" than others is frankly fucking disgusting.

Dacadactyl · 22/09/2023 16:55

To all those who think investment in services is the way to achieve greater equality and try to break these cycles, I would like to ask a question.

When these services have been on offer, do you think they are actually utilised by the people who need them? I can tell you, they're not. You can't force people to engage. That's the problem.

Under Labour, the Sure Start centres came into being. The support on offer wasn't properly targeted AT ALL. The end result was a load of mums went to these groups who didn't really need them, because they were free. Only one mum who came religiously would have fit the mould of "needing support". She was 17 with 2 kids and when she was ready to work, childcare was provided for her (no problem with this)

On a couple of occasions, a problem family near us were ferried to and from these groups by a paid for taxi, but mum never engaged with the groups (or her kids)

The vast, vast majority of the mums at the groups knew how to parent appropriately already.

The only way investment in services works is if people are FORCED to engage. How you do that, I don't know. But hoping they'll change because there are services on offer, just doesnt work.

Pollyputhekettleon · 22/09/2023 16:51

NeverDropYourMooncup · 22/09/2023 16:46

So you are justifying removing the rights of women from puberty on the basis of their parents' situation? Because they inevitably have bad genetics and need to be erased from the gene pool prior to having a child themselves, as they are predestined to be murderers, low intellect, criminals, a waste of benefits, housing, food and life?

I don't give a fuck about your petty digs and casual misogyny. You're advocating for another holocaust.

I'm surprised and heartened that it took almost 12 hours for the 'so you're saying' and holocaust shrieking to start. There's hope for humanity yet.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 22/09/2023 16:46

Pollyputhekettleon · 22/09/2023 07:41

They're ignoring behavioural genetics as always. All behaviours are partly genetic in cause, to varying degrees. Genetic susceptibility to alcoholism, or addition to any drug, for example, is heritable. The children of two alcoholics, adopted at birth to a non alcoholic family, remain more likely than others to become alcoholics themselves.

The same applies to all the behaviours, personality traits, and IQ, that underlie different criminal behaviour as well as child abuse. Risk-taking, for example, disagreeableness, low IQ, impulsiveness, low conscientiousness, inability to empathize, mental health problems, personality disorders. That's one of the reasons why there is a correlation between suffering child abuse growing up and criminality in later life. Environment is the other, including of course the prenatal environment, where a lot of harm is already done in many cases. It's a correlation that dogma insists is a cause.

In other words, child abuse and criminal behaviour share many similar underlying behavioural and therefore partly genetic causes. Children removed at birth from abusive parents remain more likely, statistically, to become child abusers or criminals themselves.

Actual experts know this, it's not even arguable in 2023, but pure environmentalism is a fanatical dogma, and not coincidentally it pays a lot of salaries. Most social policy is built on it and has been for a long time.

Many people will get upset about the above. Anyone reacting with - 'but I was abused and I turned out fine', 'but my parent was a criminal and I'm not', or shrieking about eugenics and concentration camps - statistics is taught incredibly badly at school but this is basic stuff and I think most people can follow it if they can set aside their emotions long enough to try. I won't be explaining.

So you are justifying removing the rights of women from puberty on the basis of their parents' situation? Because they inevitably have bad genetics and need to be erased from the gene pool prior to having a child themselves, as they are predestined to be murderers, low intellect, criminals, a waste of benefits, housing, food and life?

I don't give a fuck about your petty digs and casual misogyny. You're advocating for another holocaust.

Pollyputhekettleon · 22/09/2023 16:44

Bobbotgegrinch · 22/09/2023 13:05

Exactly. Othering people, calling them subhuman or a subclass is just a way to ignore the problems in society that cause people to act this way. It's a way to say "These people are different, it's ingrained in them" and that if they'd been brought up differently, they'd still be scum.

It's just not true. It's a generational issue, and one that won't be solved quickly, but is something we all need to work at, by reporting abuse when we spot it, by voting for a government that will spend money on the right services, by parenting our own kids in ways that will let them grow up to be well adjusted adults. These people are human, they are a part of our society, and when a tragedy like this happens, it's because we as a society have failed this child.

Your genes are a large part of the reason you act the way you do. It's simply not the case that these people's behaviour is 100% caused by 'problems in society' - i.e. the environment.

It is 'ingrained' in them in the sense that they had a genetic predisposition to such behaviours and/or were already so damaged at birth they were predisposed to such behaviours. No one has said that 'if they had been brought up differently they'd still be scum.' What a ridiculous thing to claim.

MyHornCanPierceTheSky · 22/09/2023 16:43

Ponoka7 · 22/09/2023 15:56

From what I've read the Mum's MH plummeted around that two month mark. She only shared it with the GP. That didn't trigger a SS referral. It was noted on the GP system, though. The lack of CP plan meant little engagement with services and little attempts by the SWs. There will be criticism of all those involved.

So there wasn't any other checks or home visits?
The mother must have known the other services etc out there given all the input that would have occurred prior to her other children being removed.

TheThingIsYeah · 22/09/2023 16:37

Is this one of those stories where the local MP offers 'Thoughts and prayer for little XXXXX" via their twitter page, and the local council announces "Lessons will be learned", only for the same thing to happen 3 months later?

Pollyputhekettleon · 22/09/2023 16:27

SemperIdem · 22/09/2023 12:50

@Pollyputhekettleon

Epi-genetics is a fascinating topic!

Sure. But not if it's used as a diversion from discussing genetics, or a way to sneak dogmatic environmentalism back in through the back door.

Pollyputhekettleon · 22/09/2023 16:26

@oakleaffy It's always both nature and nurture. In differing proportions depending on the behaviour we're talking about.

Ponoka7 · 22/09/2023 15:56

Dacadactyl · 22/09/2023 07:44

At an ICPC, mum's MH would've been discussed. There would be midwives/health visitors invited, potentially mum/dads G.P too. If MH services were involved with mum/dad, a representative of that service would also have been invited. Same for if a drug/alcohol service are involved, then they're invite too.

The problem comes if there are no services involved at the time, they won't have a full picture, but the SW report should mention the state of the house etc. Depends how crafty the parents are too and whether they appear to be doing everything right at the time of the ICPC.

From what I've read the Mum's MH plummeted around that two month mark. She only shared it with the GP. That didn't trigger a SS referral. It was noted on the GP system, though. The lack of CP plan meant little engagement with services and little attempts by the SWs. There will be criticism of all those involved.

HelpaFriend85 · 22/09/2023 15:28

I was intrigued by another poster who said that having children is one thing they can do and achieve hence why it’s important.

We grew up in an area of deprivation but did not historically come from such deep deprivation, my mum would say it was sad how the girls and boys of my age would just follow their parents. Into smoking, drinking and then teen pregnancies.

Chickenkeev · 22/09/2023 15:11

Greysofa · 22/09/2023 13:44

There’s no accountability, and until poor parents are made to take accountability, the cycle will never be broken. People constantly look to blame others for their shortcomings, rather than accepting them and looking to change. How often do we read on here about kids being excluded from school for bad behaviour, but it’s the schools fault! I work with these families and the lack of accountability goes from the smallest things such as arriving late for a meeting to the big things as child abuse. Yes, generational trauma and the cyclical nature of this plays a part, but until these parents take accountability and recognise that maybe they don’t have the skills and ability to parent, this will continue.

They don't realise they don't have the skills. They've had no role models.

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 22/09/2023 14:56

MrsSkylerWhite · 22/09/2023 11:21

MyHornCanPierceTheSky · Yesterday 23:05

Most of us on this thread will have been lucky in that we had stable homes, parents who were invested in us, and who were in turn lucky enough not to have serious mental health issues or addictions”

I didn’t. I lived with violence and chaos until I became a young adult and left. I made a good life for myself because I knew the way I was brought up was wrong. Our children were raised with love.

Everyone has a choice.

Not everyone is the same. People respond differently to trauma. Some shrug it off. Some react against it. Some replicate it. Some are just broken by it. I am not seeking to denigrate your achievements by saying, not everyone who we t through what you went through COULD do what you did. People are built differently.

You say you knew it was wrong; what gave you that awareness? It took me until university, where I met a very wide range of people with "normal" families, to realise that my (non-abusive but dysfunctional) childhood was not "normal" (or within the range of). It messed with my head! You know what you know and most kids normalise it because it's all they know (until they see something that contradixts that belief. What was it for you?

Whatafustercluck · 22/09/2023 14:39

BMW6 · 22/09/2023 10:02

People are not born shit people

Wrong. People are born with really low IQ, psychopathy, just plain BAD.

Sure nurture plays its part, but nature is at the front of our genetic makeup.

You can be made into a shit person, but of course you can be born a shit person in the first place.

Nobody knows if people are born with psychopathy. Most psychopaths have either a history of some kind of brain trauma or a horrendous childhood that meant their neurological pathways did not develop normally. Most agree that genes may predispose someone to psychopathy, but there is usually a trigger that unleashes it. This makes me think that nurture is the most important factor.

In the story in the original post, it says the mother was known to social services for mental health problems. There is nothing in the story to suggest there was deliberate abuse involved. Severe mental health problems, as seems to be the case here, leads to addiction which leads to neglect. Mental health never receives the funding and support it should do and sadly these cases will go on happening while this continues.

It's all terribly sad.

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 22/09/2023 14:20

OneNameTwoNameThreeName · 21/09/2023 23:03

You say you feel terrible for the poor little baby (and children like him) who didn’t even have a chance. Me too. But at what point do you feel he would have had a chance and is thus fully responsible with zero excuses to be made for what happens in the next generation?

If a baby born to addict parents, neglected from birth, likely with predisposition to mental health problems, possibly a low IQ. Somehow survives the abuse, the parents who don’t give a shit if they go to school or not or how and with whom they spend their free time, exposed to alcohol and drugs in pre teens, no role models in life (yes perhaps teachers/people on tv etc, but not anyone ‘like them’ and in their world. Abusive relationships modelled left right and centre. This kid makes it to 18. Somehow. Fair chance has exactly zero GCSEs. Drinks. Possibly drugs. May already have kids. Likely in very unhealthy relationship. Friends all from similarly chaotic circumstances with similarly chaotic current lives…

So at what point did the poor baby who never had a chance become despicable scum that you feel is accountable for not just pulling themselves up by their bootstraps, getting a job, being a productive member of society, stop drinking/drugs (that they may have been addicted to since literal childhood), knowing not to expose themselves/their kids/their partner to alcohol/drugs/abusive relationships, etc etc?

Edited

This is the only post worth reading. Answer THIS question, OP. Not all survivors of abuse/neglect are abusers, but i'd say a good proportion of abusers are survivors of abuse and neglect - in the sense they made it out alive, but obviously a derilect childhood isn't a great basis for a functioning adult.

It's like child-on-child sexual abuse - in the VAST majority of cases, the child who is abusive/inappropriate is themselves the victim of abuse elsewhere and acting out. Is that child s hideous abuser or a helpless victim? Or both? The answer, as always, is COMPLICATED which nobody likes. Much easier to be able to have hero's and villains, angels and monsters.

This poor child will never have a chance now to see what he could have made of the piss poor hand he was dealt. But if he had lived, at what point on his journey from adorable, unfortunate baby to troubled adult would you lot wash your hands of him?

AliOlis · 22/09/2023 14:10

Coyoacan · 22/09/2023 14:04

We need to know the causes and what measures society can take to minimize horrible cases like that. But unfortunately if upping benefits for poor families were found to cut down on such neglect, I believe a lot of people here would be up in arms

You know exactly where an increase in benefits would have been spent in this particular case. There's no reason to suspect extra money would reduce neglect in any other cases either, neglect isn't simply a lack of material resources.

Coyoacan · 22/09/2023 14:04

We need to know the causes and what measures society can take to minimize horrible cases like that. But unfortunately if upping benefits for poor families were found to cut down on such neglect, I believe a lot of people here would be up in arms

Greysofa · 22/09/2023 13:44

There’s no accountability, and until poor parents are made to take accountability, the cycle will never be broken. People constantly look to blame others for their shortcomings, rather than accepting them and looking to change. How often do we read on here about kids being excluded from school for bad behaviour, but it’s the schools fault! I work with these families and the lack of accountability goes from the smallest things such as arriving late for a meeting to the big things as child abuse. Yes, generational trauma and the cyclical nature of this plays a part, but until these parents take accountability and recognise that maybe they don’t have the skills and ability to parent, this will continue.

Chickenkeev · 22/09/2023 13:15

GreyNomad · 22/09/2023 13:13

The country is a mess.
Brexit, Covid, austerity, tory government fucking everything up... things are going to pot all over the place.
It's pretty obvious that this is going to put considerable additional strain on the most vulnerable in society, who probably don't cope well with life even in "good" times. I think we're seeing evidence of this all over the news with the awful things people are doing.

But to be honest I don't disagree with the OP - these people are the fucking lowest if the low, and I don't really give a shit about the "circumstances" that led them to kill their innocent child. It's an utter disgrace and my heart breaks for every story like this I hear. IMO some people are beyond help and honestly the world would be better place without them in it.

All very well and good, but if you don't investigate why they are like that, how will you stop it happening again?

GreyNomad · 22/09/2023 13:13

The country is a mess.
Brexit, Covid, austerity, tory government fucking everything up... things are going to pot all over the place.
It's pretty obvious that this is going to put considerable additional strain on the most vulnerable in society, who probably don't cope well with life even in "good" times. I think we're seeing evidence of this all over the news with the awful things people are doing.

But to be honest I don't disagree with the OP - these people are the fucking lowest if the low, and I don't really give a shit about the "circumstances" that led them to kill their innocent child. It's an utter disgrace and my heart breaks for every story like this I hear. IMO some people are beyond help and honestly the world would be better place without them in it.

Chickenkeev · 22/09/2023 13:10

Bobbotgegrinch · 22/09/2023 13:05

Exactly. Othering people, calling them subhuman or a subclass is just a way to ignore the problems in society that cause people to act this way. It's a way to say "These people are different, it's ingrained in them" and that if they'd been brought up differently, they'd still be scum.

It's just not true. It's a generational issue, and one that won't be solved quickly, but is something we all need to work at, by reporting abuse when we spot it, by voting for a government that will spend money on the right services, by parenting our own kids in ways that will let them grow up to be well adjusted adults. These people are human, they are a part of our society, and when a tragedy like this happens, it's because we as a society have failed this child.

I heard an interview with Gabor Mate re intergenerational trauma and so much of it rang true. It was a lightbulb moment for me. It's a terrible thing to dismiss people without considering the 'why'.

Bobbotgegrinch · 22/09/2023 13:05

Chickenkeev · 22/09/2023 11:02

Thank you for this, i couldn't put my similar thoughts into words properly. It is silly to ignore these peoples backgrounds, to ignore is to continue the cycle of abuse. It might feel a bit wrong to treat them with humanity but that's exactly what's needed to avoid this in future.

Exactly. Othering people, calling them subhuman or a subclass is just a way to ignore the problems in society that cause people to act this way. It's a way to say "These people are different, it's ingrained in them" and that if they'd been brought up differently, they'd still be scum.

It's just not true. It's a generational issue, and one that won't be solved quickly, but is something we all need to work at, by reporting abuse when we spot it, by voting for a government that will spend money on the right services, by parenting our own kids in ways that will let them grow up to be well adjusted adults. These people are human, they are a part of our society, and when a tragedy like this happens, it's because we as a society have failed this child.

SemperIdem · 22/09/2023 12:50

@Pollyputhekettleon

Epi-genetics is a fascinating topic!

Swipe left for the next trending thread