Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there is a sub-class of people in our society

342 replies

bluewanda · 21/09/2023 21:27

Baby boy died in 'filthy' home with 'traces of cocaine in his system'

https://mol.im/a/12545263

What the hell is wrong with these people. How the fuck can they subject an innocent baby to such a horrific life?! These children should be removed at birth because they don’t stand a chance. It is so utterly depressing.

Baby boy died in 'filthy' home with 'traces of cocaine in his system'

Little Grant John Storey-Delaney died while in his baby bouncer at his Rochdale home. He was found 'turning grey' by his mother Sophie Riley with a blanket over his face

https://mol.im/a/12545263

OP posts:
SequentialAnalyst · 22/09/2023 21:51

When I was in my 20s and 30s, governments routinely blamed the behaviour of young male adolescents on the fact that their mothers went out to work.

I shit you not. And then they blamed and guilt-tripped working mothers.

And then they said single parents had to put their children in nursery, so they could go out and earn a pittance, instead of relying on benefits of quite modest amounts, and having to lose, or pay for and claim back, the free prescriptions that were among the few perks of living on benefit. That must have been heartbreaking for many.

Nor could anyone claim for childcare costs provided by the child's own grandparent.

No year's maternity leave back then either - I was entitled to 2 weeks when I gave birth.

And then they made it so that, for economic reasons two parent families had little choice but to have both partners working to keep a roof over their heads Hmm

Ex-professional CAB worker in the NE here, so I know of what I speak.

bluewanda · 22/09/2023 21:49

I knew a generally very sweet, intelligent woman who, in her thirties, has had all five of her children removed as babies. She's a heroin addict with a controlling boyfriend.

And thank fuck for that. I honestly feel relieved reading your post. There’s no way anyone who’s “very sweet” would end up having five kids removed IMO. I’m glad they’re presumably in a more stable place now but it’s tragic they had to be subjected to that in the first place.

OP posts:
bluewanda · 22/09/2023 21:45

The poor little boy everyone on here is wailing and rending their clothes over would grow up to be one of these "sub human" people you all hate.

Yes, that little kid didn’t stand a chance in hell, thanks to the family and the home he was born into. Perhaps it would have been better to remove him at birth.

Well, I say “perhaps” but it absolutely would, as clearly staying with his parents was the worst possible outcome.

OP posts:
bluewanda · 22/09/2023 21:37

The truth is that any one of us or any one of our children could lose jobs, fall victim to addiction, to a violent relationship etc.

Sure. But that doesn’t mean you end up with a dead baby.

OP posts:
Coveescapee · 22/09/2023 20:53

lordloveadog · 22/09/2023 20:28

I want to pay taxes so that social work is well funded and employs people with the time and competence to remove babies like this poor mite from clearly unfit parents. And a care system that actually takes care of children. And mental health services. And drug rehab - it's almost impossible to get into now.

Even with all these things, some people will still be useless. But without them there is no chance. I can't do this myself - I rely on collective action through the state. But that seems to be collapsing.

It's unrealistic to reflect the state to do all those things effectively. As another poster said in the past there were much closer communities and the wider family nearby that all offered support. Additionally drugs have become effectively decrimalised and all lifestyles are supposed to be equally valid. But my main point is the state is extremely inefficient at providing support previously provided by wider networks and always will be however much money is put in.

AliOlis · 22/09/2023 20:28

Coveescapee · 22/09/2023 20:00

@Pollyputhekettleon your posts are definitely the most informative and interesting on here. Ignore the flak.

Agree.

lordloveadog · 22/09/2023 20:28

I want to pay taxes so that social work is well funded and employs people with the time and competence to remove babies like this poor mite from clearly unfit parents. And a care system that actually takes care of children. And mental health services. And drug rehab - it's almost impossible to get into now.

Even with all these things, some people will still be useless. But without them there is no chance. I can't do this myself - I rely on collective action through the state. But that seems to be collapsing.

Coveescapee · 22/09/2023 20:00

@Pollyputhekettleon your posts are definitely the most informative and interesting on here. Ignore the flak.

Pollyputhekettleon · 22/09/2023 19:24

@TheGhostofLoganRoy Swearing, shouting, name calling and misrepresenting what I've said aren't arguments.

TheGhostofLoganRoy · 22/09/2023 19:16

Pollyputhekettleon · 22/09/2023 19:02

Your 'likely' is doing an awful lot of work there you know. If he did grow up to be, say, a Jon Venables, yes, those hideous middle class mums would have hated and demonized him. Because of his actual behaviour. No hypocrisy involved.

'Supporting' child abuse survivors does not mean condoning everything they may ever do in life. Since many child abusers are themselves survivors of child abuse, caring about child abuse involves sometimes 'supporting' them by taking their children into care and/or putting them in jail.

Just stop.

You obviously have an agenda to try to demonise abused kids or kids from backgrounds you feel don't deserve to exist.

Between your hysterical rantings about eugenics and advocating for abused kids and people with low IQ to be forcibly sterilised, your poorly understood ignorance about genetics, your insistence on conflating child abuse with low IQ, your repeated personal attacks on other posters, and now your utterly bizarre insistence on shoehorning Jon Venables into the discussion as much as possible, it's very obvious that there's not just an agenda, but a complete sociopathic lack of empathy or common decency at play.

The fact you hear "abused baby" and your mind automatically goes to "Jon Venables" says everything we need to know about you.

Obviously the 0.00000000000000000001% of abused kids who are torturing and murdering toddlers by the time they're 10 don't deserve sympathy. The vast, vast majority of abused kids/kids from chaotic backgrounds do not grow up to torture and murder toddlers ffs.

No one is talking about Jon Venables, we're talking about the thousands of traumatised children who are intelligent and kind and would never hurt anyone, but who are demonised and thrown away like rubbish due to stigma, or because they act out in harmless ways, or because they don't conform to middle class standards of behaviour because they've never been taught that.

I was completely demonised and treated like human garbage and told I was a sub-human whore (by EVERYONE) from the time I was 12. And oh look, I went on to do a PhD and publish a best seller, and I'd pit my IQ against yours any day.

And still I have to deal with hostility and resentment every single day from mediocre middle class people who are bitter that "street trash" KICKED THEIR ARSES and accomplished so much more than them. And it feels fucking brilliant.

So take your "I read half a Daily Mail article about genetics once" bigoted witterings about eugenics and child murderers elsewhere.

Pollyputhekettleon · 22/09/2023 19:02

TheGhostofLoganRoy · 22/09/2023 18:41

Babies grow into children. That's kinda the point.

It's hypocritical to be all sympathy and tears when we all know if this baby hadn't died, in a few short years he would likely have been the kind of child Middle Class Mumsnet hates and demonises.

Either you support child abuse survivors or you don't. If your support and sympathy is conditional on someone being a helpless baby, then you don't actually care about child abuse.

Your 'likely' is doing an awful lot of work there you know. If he did grow up to be, say, a Jon Venables, yes, those hideous middle class mums would have hated and demonized him. Because of his actual behaviour. No hypocrisy involved.

'Supporting' child abuse survivors does not mean condoning everything they may ever do in life. Since many child abusers are themselves survivors of child abuse, caring about child abuse involves sometimes 'supporting' them by taking their children into care and/or putting them in jail.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 22/09/2023 18:52

Pollyputhekettleon · 22/09/2023 16:51

I'm surprised and heartened that it took almost 12 hours for the 'so you're saying' and holocaust shrieking to start. There's hope for humanity yet.

Nah, it was fucking obvious sooner than that.

Ithh · 22/09/2023 18:51

She should have had the baby taken off her at birth.

Lolasgame · 22/09/2023 18:48

@TheGhostofLoganRoy
Same. It’s very easy for some of these I’m alright jacks, to sit in their middle class ivory towers judging things they know nothing about. Other than reading the skewed perspective of certain nasty tabloids. I like to think life will humble them somehow, if not in this life then the next.

TheGhostofLoganRoy · 22/09/2023 18:41

Babies grow into children. That's kinda the point.

It's hypocritical to be all sympathy and tears when we all know if this baby hadn't died, in a few short years he would likely have been the kind of child Middle Class Mumsnet hates and demonises.

Either you support child abuse survivors or you don't. If your support and sympathy is conditional on someone being a helpless baby, then you don't actually care about child abuse.

Pollyputhekettleon · 22/09/2023 18:38

TheGhostofLoganRoy · 22/09/2023 18:34

I grew up in an environment that is exactly like this, one most MNers would consider "subclass."

I have a high IQ, fought like crazy for the right to go to school (it took until I was 23 to be allowed to sit GCSEs), went to university and then post-graduate school, and now have a decent job. No one would ever guess my background from looking at me.

But the damage and the ongoing damage is immense, and I deal with the stigma and need to keep secrets every single day. It's just suffocating and people think if you're from that kind of background, that you're a non-human. What happened to this baby is a horrific tragedy but he's only getting sympathy because he's a baby. If he'd grown up to be a mouthy traumatised 12-year-old skipping school and hanging around parks drinking, how much sympathy would there be for him then?

It's perfectly appropriate that people have more sympathy for a baby than a 12 year old. 12 year olds, whatever their background etc, have some degree of free will, babies have none. 12 year olds can cause problems for other people in society (including babies...), babies do not. That's why Jamie Bulger's killers did serve some time in prison for their actions, but not as much as an adult would have.

TheGhostofLoganRoy · 22/09/2023 18:34

I grew up in an environment that is exactly like this, one most MNers would consider "subclass."

I have a high IQ, fought like crazy for the right to go to school (it took until I was 23 to be allowed to sit GCSEs), went to university and then post-graduate school, and now have a decent job. No one would ever guess my background from looking at me.

But the damage and the ongoing damage is immense, and I deal with the stigma and need to keep secrets every single day. It's just suffocating and people think if you're from that kind of background, that you're a non-human. What happened to this baby is a horrific tragedy but he's only getting sympathy because he's a baby. If he'd grown up to be a mouthy traumatised 12-year-old skipping school and hanging around parks drinking, how much sympathy would there be for him then?

Zebedee55 · 22/09/2023 18:29

i worked in Child Protection for a number of years, seeing all sorts of abuse/issues.

I would say that, as adults, everyone has the choice as to how they parent. It's not always easy, but the choice is there.

If they can't parent properly, then those babies need to be removed, at an early age, to give them a chance of normality.

No point in cascading it down to another to another generation.🙄

Pollyputhekettleon · 22/09/2023 18:28

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 22/09/2023 18:08

It does look a lot like you are advocating eugenics though.

How things look to you is, as the kids say, 'a you problem'. You've been programmed to automatically associate the kinds of words I've used with the term eugenics and with negative emotions. That's all. I've already clearly said that I don't support eugenics. I'm not bothered about getting into that debate with those who do support it because firstly they have a legitimate point, secondly they have enough people shrieking at them, and thirdly there's absolutely no prospect of it happening because those people have no power. They're essentially just letting off steam, which I perfectly understand.

AgnesX · 22/09/2023 18:21

WeeOrcadian · 21/09/2023 21:44

Or...... And hear me out..... The parents were vile, scuzzy, disgusting excuses for human beings?

Shit like this isn't just the responsibility of authorities - people like this shouldn't be allowed to procreate. SS or not - the responsibility lies with the 'parents'

Quite agree, I'm fed up of the excuses that are invariably made.

Sigh As always it's a shit storm where the underlying causes are complex from the parental backgrounds onwards.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 22/09/2023 18:08

Pollyputhekettleon · 22/09/2023 16:51

I'm surprised and heartened that it took almost 12 hours for the 'so you're saying' and holocaust shrieking to start. There's hope for humanity yet.

It does look a lot like you are advocating eugenics though.

CampsieGlamper · 22/09/2023 18:05

The bar is set too low. It's a sweet idea to maximise the idea that it's right to keep the child with the parent as the default.

Ideally there should be more state support, more state intervention and more state scrutiny of those receiving state money. I believe this is the model in Scandinavia.

Pollyputhekettleon · 22/09/2023 17:50

@Bobbotgegrinch

I don't believe anyone is arguing that simply having those genes makes you a member of the subclass. For all I know I could have genes predisposing me to heroin addition, but because I've never tried the stuff, no one is including me in the subclass.

What is true is that some behavioural traits are better for people and for society than others, in a given environment. A genetic predisposition to alcoholism is a bad thing for anyone in a western country to have. It's completely neutral in value if you're a strict Muslim living in Saudi because you're not having any anyway. These are value judgments, of course, but they're largely uncontroversial.

Other similar value judgments are certainly more controversial. Higher neuroticism, for example, is a bad thing for the individual's mental health but has benefits also. Their children may be overprotected but they're unlikely to die of neglect. They'll probably work hard at their job motivated by fear of making a mistake.

It follows that value judgments about the genetics underlying such traits are also possible and inevitable, and disputable too.

Your personal experience makes sense, but it fits perfectly with what I've said. I don't happen to know what the breakdown is of genes vs environment when it comes to predisposition to alcoholism but that will vary by individual anyway. It's not one gene, and environments vary hugely.

I agree that someone genetically predisposed to anger/violence is more likely to engage in violence themselves if their childhood environment included it. But that's simply another way of saying that behaviours are the result of a combination of genes and environment!

I'm not arguing that anyone is doomed by their genes. No personality trait, for example, is 100% genetically heritable. And I believe we do all have free will, albeit often very little, which is not measurable by psychology or in any other way and is entirely separate from both genetics and environment.

I refuse to use the language of 'othering' because I despise the philosophy that produced that concept so I won't address that point. People's genes, all of our genes, are both part of our problems and part of our strengths.

Bobbotgegrinch · 22/09/2023 17:31

Pollyputhekettleon · 22/09/2023 17:05

Addictions, personalities and intelligence are different things. You're aware that intelligence is highly genetically heritable. You understand that there are genetic predispositions to addiction. Yet you haven't come across the fact that personality traits are also highly genetically heritable?

I'm not entirely clear on what you're arguing, but intelligence and propensity to addiction alone have huge impacts on people's behaviours. Although I'm not sure why you singled those two out.

Some people are more prone to criminal behaviours than others, partly for genetic reasons. As I said already, I know that triggers strong negative emotions in people and causes them to start cursing and swearing and all that. It's still true though.

Interestingly, I don't know if you're aware that accepting that intelligence is 1) measurable at all and 2) 'largely genetic' is considered in many circles to be 'frankly fucking disgusting', eugenicist and verging on fascist. I'm not sure you understand the implications of those statements.

OK, I think we're talking at cross purposes slightly here.

My issue isn't that the idea that certain personality traits, or intelligence levels, or predispositions to addictions have a basis in genetics. My issue is that there are people on this thread who think that having those genetics makes you a "worse" person. Makes you a subclass, or subhuman. That's the opinion that I'm finding abhorrent.

To use a personal example, I have a problem with alcohol. There may be a genetic component to this, my Dads relationship with it isn't great, and my Grandad was a full blown alcoholic.

But a far bigger reason for my issue with it is that I was born to very young parents who weren't really ready to give up their friends and social lives, so as a child I spent huge parts of my weekend down the rugby club, or the pub. As a result I learnt that I really liked the pub, it was full of people I knew and liked, it felt warm and safe and fun.

I grew up, started drinking and that warm and safe feeling transferred to the beer itself. I had a kid and stopped going to the pub, but drank at home instead. So, my child isn't going to have that feeling about the pub, but maybe I've normalised drinking too much at home for her instead.

Had my parents been avid hikers or film goers instead, would I still have an alcohol problem? Maybe, but it seems a lot less likely.

Or a more generic example, let's say two people are genetically predisposed to anger. One of them grows up in a household with domestic abuse, one doesn't. Which one is going to think it's normal or acceptable to hit his wife.

I'm not denying that genetics play a part in who you are, I'm just opposed to the viewpoint that certain people are doomed or should be classed as "other" because of those genetics.
Plenty of people are screwed over because of who their parents are, but it's not the genes they passed on that are the problem.

Pinkfluff76 · 22/09/2023 17:09

Yes a sub class who shouldn’t breed. Disgusting vile selfish people. It’s heartbreaking. That poor baby