Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there is a sub-class of people in our society

342 replies

bluewanda · 21/09/2023 21:27

Baby boy died in 'filthy' home with 'traces of cocaine in his system'

https://mol.im/a/12545263

What the hell is wrong with these people. How the fuck can they subject an innocent baby to such a horrific life?! These children should be removed at birth because they don’t stand a chance. It is so utterly depressing.

Baby boy died in 'filthy' home with 'traces of cocaine in his system'

Little Grant John Storey-Delaney died while in his baby bouncer at his Rochdale home. He was found 'turning grey' by his mother Sophie Riley with a blanket over his face

https://mol.im/a/12545263

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SequentialAnalyst · 23/09/2023 21:41

@MyHornCanPierceTheSky is this the 5 minute argument, or the 10 minute argument? Either way, your time's up.

Miri13 · 23/09/2023 18:57

Totally agree with this comment.

Lolasgame · 23/09/2023 18:36

@Goodornot

Maggie Thatcher did irreversible damage from the 70s onwards. A lot of the damage she did cannot be turned around by any labour government.

Zebedee55 · 23/09/2023 17:33

Some parents should never be parents. They just don't operate on the same levels as most.

It's gone on forever though, and I'm not sure anything much changes this. 🙁

bombastix · 23/09/2023 17:30

This stuff is beyond Labour and Conservatives; it's a multiple generation problem if drugs, violence and sexual abuse. Baby P is worth noting because the family background is frightening; you need to see that these things don't just appear. It's woven into the hopelessness of its existence in these houses, which don't get normal people visiting at all, but instead alcoholics, drug addicts, dealers, sexual offenders and paedophiles. These are places with very little attention and so what you get is basically criminal neglect of children. It's not like a single abusive incident, or a man becoming violent, it's all the time.

Goodornot · 23/09/2023 17:04

Pumpkinpie1 · 23/09/2023 16:57

This is another victim of conservative politics. This country has been going downhill since 2010. They took away surestart , support for disabled kids , education , the nhs , decent housing, jobs and hope . This is what you get voting for these incompetent scroungers death and despair .

Baby P and Victoria Climbie lived under Labour governments and were victims of Blair and Brown's governments.

Pumpkinpie1 · 23/09/2023 16:58

And no blooming ticket offices

Pumpkinpie1 · 23/09/2023 16:57

This is another victim of conservative politics. This country has been going downhill since 2010. They took away surestart , support for disabled kids , education , the nhs , decent housing, jobs and hope . This is what you get voting for these incompetent scroungers death and despair .

MyHornCanPierceTheSky · 23/09/2023 16:56

So @SequentialAnalyst no ones ever to blame for their actions?
Am pretty sure there's people who you blame for things. You think current government are ok doing what they do as that's what their circles have always done?

SequentialAnalyst · 23/09/2023 16:53

I do not blame people. I try very hard not to judge people. I understand their experience due to my own life experience.

Huge respect to @TheGhostofLoganRoy for escaping the cycle Smile

MyHornCanPierceTheSky · 23/09/2023 16:53

I absolutely agree with @bluewanda. Do you blame all criminal acts on the parents?

MyHornCanPierceTheSky · 23/09/2023 16:49

You're bizarrely determined to pass the blame for his death to everyone else. Why? OK his parents may have been disadvantaged, but they are alive.

SequentialAnalyst · 23/09/2023 16:48

For clarity, it's not me blaming the parents. @bluewanda is the one doing that, and I disagree with her.

SequentialAnalyst · 23/09/2023 16:26

MyHornCanPierceTheSky · 23/09/2023 15:25

In this? Baby Grant's parents given that their parents didn't cause their deaths?

But they did bring up, in two separate families of their own, their own children, who in turn became the parents of Baby Grant. There is a high probability that Baby Grant's grandparents were as disadvantaged as their offspring.

MyHornCanPierceTheSky · 23/09/2023 15:25

SequentialAnalyst · 22/09/2023 23:26

ie the parents of the mother, and the parents of the father, and the parents of the child?

In this? Baby Grant's parents given that their parents didn't cause their deaths?

Lolasgame · 23/09/2023 15:03

@Ponoka7

THIS ☝️

Ponoka7 · 23/09/2023 14:47

oakleaffy · 23/09/2023 07:31

Well done for having the nous and determination to free yourself from a far from ideal childhood.

Children who had loving, safe and stable childhoods are at a massive advantage.

It sets them up for life- Gives such a secure foundation, compared to a child who has suffered loss and abuse at an early age.

It’s a lottery as to what family one is born into.

Good point regarding this infant. Had he been a teen, involved in petty theft, County lines, there would be zero sympathy for him by the world generally.

If baby P had have lived, he'd be being called sub human on this thread, because there's no way he wouldn't have been exceptionally damaged.

Ponoka7 · 23/09/2023 14:46

bluewanda · 22/09/2023 22:03

You can talk about plans and thresholds all you like, but ultimately no one is to blame but the parents themselves.

Yes but having mental health issues doesn't make you sub class. People who have children removed aren't sub class. They are usually people who have had a completely chaotic background and then have other factors come into their life. You claim to care about the baby, but you don't, or you'd take on board the issues people have and the need for good child protection. It's on all of us to call for good CP that works. You just want to demonize one group of people and not save the children of those people.

oakleaffy · 23/09/2023 07:31

TheGhostofLoganRoy · 22/09/2023 18:34

I grew up in an environment that is exactly like this, one most MNers would consider "subclass."

I have a high IQ, fought like crazy for the right to go to school (it took until I was 23 to be allowed to sit GCSEs), went to university and then post-graduate school, and now have a decent job. No one would ever guess my background from looking at me.

But the damage and the ongoing damage is immense, and I deal with the stigma and need to keep secrets every single day. It's just suffocating and people think if you're from that kind of background, that you're a non-human. What happened to this baby is a horrific tragedy but he's only getting sympathy because he's a baby. If he'd grown up to be a mouthy traumatised 12-year-old skipping school and hanging around parks drinking, how much sympathy would there be for him then?

Well done for having the nous and determination to free yourself from a far from ideal childhood.

Children who had loving, safe and stable childhoods are at a massive advantage.

It sets them up for life- Gives such a secure foundation, compared to a child who has suffered loss and abuse at an early age.

It’s a lottery as to what family one is born into.

Good point regarding this infant. Had he been a teen, involved in petty theft, County lines, there would be zero sympathy for him by the world generally.

TheGhostofLoganRoy · 23/09/2023 00:56

One of the subjects of my joint honours BSc was in biology (with a focus on genetics), and my first MSc was in anthropology of oppression, and my second MSc was in social policy and mental health care. One of the things that's most crucial to understand when studying any kind of science - and this is why I don't believe that Polly has ever studied genetics - is that science is never neutral, and is always prone to political and other forms of bias. Actual scientists, even science students, are taught from day one of the dangers of applying scientific research to ideology.

Which is to say, all the existing body of research into genetic traits, epigenetics, concepts such as "is there a gene for criminality", nature vs nurture; all this research is very much in its infancy, and has limited application to politics or real world social policy.

Genetics and other concepts from the biological sciences have been abused all throughout modern scientific history to oppress people. For example, there was a very famous case in the 1800s where a scientist illegally collected hundreds of skulls and measured them, and provided "scientific proof" that black people had smaller crania than white people, and were therefore scientifically less intelligent and more brutish. During slavery, there was a great deal of "scientific research" done with the intention of providing scientific proof that black people are inherently inferior and thus need to be controlled by white people: science with a clear agenda to support and justify slavery.

in my first term as an undergrad, my tutor assigned the book called 'The Bell Curve.' This is a non-peer reviewed "scientific" work exploring the alleged link between race and intelligence, which was extremely controversial and widely accused of being racist. My tutor taught this book in the context of how both biology and anthropology have historically been used to justify oppression of minorities. Yet it was a published "science" book and to a lot of people, that makes it the Gospel.

(I actually wrote my MSc thesis on how scientific research has historically been used to justify oppression of women - think things like "hysteria", wandering wombs, etc. Mumsnet tends to be very pro-feminist, and I wonder how different the response would be if posters were using "science" to demonise women, rather than demonising people from low socioeconomic backgrounds.)

The research on the nature versus nurture debate is still in infancy, anyone confidently stating that everything is genetic, that there's a gene for being a child abuser, that babies born to abusive parents are doomed even if they're removed from their abusive homes in infancy and adopted by loving families because they've already inherited the child abuser gene - I'm sorry but there just is no substantial body of peer-reviewed evidence to be able to state any of that as fact, and anyone claiming otherwise either has an agenda, or has never taken a genetics class. Anyone with even a small amount of genetic knowledge knows that genetics is highly complex; there are rarely single genes that govern behaviour but many different genes working and influencing each other. The punnet square genetics we all learned at GCSE level is highly over-simplified; the reality is that even something as seemingly straight forward as eye colour is controlled by many different genes.

I've read a few peer-reviewed journal articles on the CDH13 gene (which controls neural connectivity) and the MAOA gene (which is related to dopamine) - these are the two genes proudly declared by the tabloid press to be the "crime genes." In reality, dopamine production is very very complex and is linked with Tourette's Syndrome and schizophrenia, as well as conditions like Parkinsons and tic disorders, to name but a few. That's why L-Dopa was such an astonishing discovery. (And dopamine production is linked with physical injury or disfunction of the basal ganglia; the relationship between genetics and neuroanatomy is not yet all that well understood.)

Even if we had solid evidence that there was a gene for child abuse (which we don't, and no actual geneticist would ever claim otherwise), it's clearly dangerous to base social policy on lab work. One of Polly's posts upthread, for example, suggests that babies born to abusive homes are more likely to grow up to be abusers since they have the gene for child abuse, regardless of whether they are removed from the abusive home in infancy or not. That actually isn't true and there's no statistically evidence to support it - there is no large scale study of babies removed from abusive homes in infancy which studied those babies into adulthood. That's a very worrying application of poorly understood junk science, since it would be very easy to twist that into "well those babies are doomed because they have bad genes anyway, so why bother to remove them from abusive homes" and once again, exploit science as a way to justify oppression.

Please, please go to PubMed or JStor and actually read peer reviewed studies yourself if you're interested, don't just blindly believe everything you read online.

You can perhaps start here:

Mountaineer0009 · 23/09/2023 00:15

for some of the specific topics people are saying has anyone actually researched their history to see the topics go back even as far a plato, and in modern times america got there before germany did etc

TheGhostofLoganRoy · 22/09/2023 23:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Pollyputhekettleon · 22/09/2023 23:52

@TheGhostofLoganRoy I won't be responding to you.

TheGhostofLoganRoy · 22/09/2023 23:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

SequentialAnalyst · 22/09/2023 23:26

ie the parents of the mother, and the parents of the father, and the parents of the child?

Swipe left for the next trending thread