Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mandatory subjects until 18 a terrible idea

143 replies

Mysteriousflo · 21/09/2023 20:29

Thinking back to my school years, a key part of the excitement of going to sixth form was the ability to choose what I wanted to study.

I chose based on what I enjoyed and what would help me into the degree I wanted.

Focusing on a handful of key subjects was something that suited me and, if it didn’t, I could’ve made the choice to do the IB.

I believe having that choice was a key part of my success in my exams which set me up for my degree, career and where I am now professionally.

Why oh why does Sunak think mandating English and maths until 18 is a good idea?

It feels really regressive and like a terrible idea to me - AIBU?

Have I got this totally wrong and actually it’s a big vote winner?!

OP posts:
Lydiala · 22/09/2023 12:40

No need to panic. Reforms of this level take loads of time to develop and implement. Rishi Sunak has barely a year left as PM - nowhere near enough time to push this through.

MissSeventies · 22/09/2023 12:38

I think we are too quick to see the grass greener on the other side, or, indeed, in another country. I feel for A-level students too. It is almost 20 years since I sat mine, I did 4 plus Advanced Extensions (if anyone even remembers them) and every year both then and since come results day there are pieces and pundits out there saying that the students aren't as smart as yesteryear or that the system in other countries is better. The UK system will be 'fixed' and the qualifications worth something just as soon as we change them. The system in other countries may not be better, just different.

In my personal experience I did not enjoy maths, I got an A at GCSE but had to work three times as hard to get that as to get an A in other subjects. I would hate to think of having had to struggle on for another two years.

A Levels are intended to be specialist, in other coutries they are doing 6/7 subjects, but are they going into them in the same depth? My partner did A levels in England and then a medical degree at an Irish University, 7 year course, the first year was all science, all of which he had already covered at A-level.

thebellagio · 22/09/2023 12:31

But surely the funding should be better put into primary education so that kids have the right foundations in place so that by the time they reach 16 they are competent in those areas? As a PP said, if 12 years of education has failed them by that point a further 2 years isn’t really doing anything is it?

pointythings · 22/09/2023 12:28

I don't think it's necessarily a terrible idea, but I am not sure maths should be included. Everyone should have functional everyday maths skills, but GCSE maths already sits beyond that and isn't useful to many people.

I grew up in the Dutch system and whatever qualifications you did, English and Dutch were mandatory. This was combined language and literature for both, so broader than for example the A level literature spec. Something like that could work. I also did 8 subjects, not 3 or 4 (which meant I could drop my worst from the end result). The course I did in French and German was far more challenging than the UK equivalent A levels so you wouldn't necessarily l8se the depth by widening the range.

Okisenough · 22/09/2023 12:28

This is nonsense and just another pointless announcement from a Government desperate to find some sort of policy that will win them some support. I have no issues with reforming A-levels but surely right now they should concentrate on fixing the buildings and coming to an agreement with striking teachers before they start meddling.

BCCoach · 22/09/2023 12:28

Dixiechickonhols · 22/09/2023 12:13

I’d also agree on the how will they fit it in point. My dc is yr 13 and it’s very full on. 3 A levels and EPQ. Uni applications far more involved than my day - full day open days to visit, some subjects need additional tests passing (law/medicine) work experience and supra curricular - additional reading, podcasts, taster sessions. Plus life stuff like Learning to drive and pt jobs to hopefully save a bit for uni as most won’t get a full maintenance loan.
If they drop content from A levels as less time then knock on implications for degree study of some subjects.

My understanding are the plans would be to scrap A-levels altogether and replace with a bacc-style system. This is what most countries have rather than having 15 year olds specialise in only 3 subjects.

Lemonyyy · 22/09/2023 12:27

i would have hated being made to do maths in 6th form. I had an A at GCSE and was perfectly competent but I hated it and giving it up really changed how I felt about school.

I think there’s an argument for non assessed targeted support such as essay writing skills, referencing, public speaking etc. from English and statistics skills etc. from maths but if he literally means continuing with an advanced curriculum for people who struggle with or loathe a subject, all that’s going to do is turn people of further education. Although as a PP said perhaps that’s the point of this!

Oliotya · 22/09/2023 12:22

I think it would be a really good idea for teenagers to continue developing a broader range of skills. 16 is too young to narrow learning as we do now. A very mathematically minded child scraping a GCSE pass in English, would arguably really benefit from continuing a bit longer and vice-versa. However it should really all be less academic nonsense and more real life applications, skills they will actually use.

BCCoach · 22/09/2023 12:19

You should tell (pretty much) every other developed country they're doing it wrong then.

x2boys · 22/09/2023 12:18

Passerillage · 22/09/2023 12:13

Certainly if a bricklayer wants to progress in his or her career, they're going to need maths! Of all jobs it seems to require a lot of very important calculations.

Again where did I say they don't know maths??
Maybe some posters could do with going back to.school and doing some comprehension lessons 🙄

x2boys · 22/09/2023 12:16

WelcomeToLagos · 22/09/2023 12:08

Do you honestly think bricklayers don’t know maths?

Where did I say brick layers didn't know maths?????
My point was if you read it properly why would a brick layer need to study Maths, if they have already passed their GCSE ?????
The thing about mandatory,is that it means everyone post 16 not just those studying A levels !!!!

Passerillage · 22/09/2023 12:13

Certainly if a bricklayer wants to progress in his or her career, they're going to need maths! Of all jobs it seems to require a lot of very important calculations.

Dixiechickonhols · 22/09/2023 12:13

I’d also agree on the how will they fit it in point. My dc is yr 13 and it’s very full on. 3 A levels and EPQ. Uni applications far more involved than my day - full day open days to visit, some subjects need additional tests passing (law/medicine) work experience and supra curricular - additional reading, podcasts, taster sessions. Plus life stuff like Learning to drive and pt jobs to hopefully save a bit for uni as most won’t get a full maintenance loan.
If they drop content from A levels as less time then knock on implications for degree study of some subjects.

x2boys · 22/09/2023 12:12

Diorama1 · 22/09/2023 12:07

I am Irish and only discovered last month that children in England dont have do Maths or English past 16 and generally only do 3 subjects for A levels. We generally to 7 subjects including mandatory Irish, English and Maths.

Looking at the past paper, the ordinary level (lower) maths paper includes working out rates and percentages for house increases, areas of garden, commission rates, how to work out insurance costs - all very practical stuff. The English paper focuses on social issues, opinion pieces, how to express your views, comprehension of articles/posters etc. I cant see how any of that cant help a person in their daily life.

Edited

What happens with your less academic students ?
Mums net tends to focus on everybody doing A levels in a school.sixth form
When actually many schools only go.up.to.year eleven and GCSE,s
Post 16 there are lots of options including A levels .

WelcomeToLagos · 22/09/2023 12:08

x2boys · 22/09/2023 11:30

I.was the person who mentioned brick laying and hairdressing ,but I did actually ask why would they need to.carry on studying English and maths if they had already achieved a grade four?
There is already a system in place for students to carry on studying English and maths until they get a grade four .

Do you honestly think bricklayers don’t know maths?

Diorama1 · 22/09/2023 12:07

I am Irish and only discovered last month that children in England dont have do Maths or English past 16 and generally only do 3 subjects for A levels. We generally to 7 subjects including mandatory Irish, English and Maths.

Looking at the past paper, the ordinary level (lower) maths paper includes working out rates and percentages for house increases, areas of garden, commission rates, how to work out insurance costs - all very practical stuff. The English paper focuses on social issues, opinion pieces, how to express your views, comprehension of articles/posters etc. I cant see how any of that cant help a person in their daily life.

Squirrelsnut · 22/09/2023 12:07

It's a crap idea, and, as a PP said, two years of reluctant, begrudging 'study' as an almost-adult isn't going to rectify much. 16 year olds need to select their preferred areas of study if it's to be a valuable experience.

WelcomeToLagos · 22/09/2023 12:05

Mysteriousflo · 21/09/2023 20:29

Thinking back to my school years, a key part of the excitement of going to sixth form was the ability to choose what I wanted to study.

I chose based on what I enjoyed and what would help me into the degree I wanted.

Focusing on a handful of key subjects was something that suited me and, if it didn’t, I could’ve made the choice to do the IB.

I believe having that choice was a key part of my success in my exams which set me up for my degree, career and where I am now professionally.

Why oh why does Sunak think mandating English and maths until 18 is a good idea?

It feels really regressive and like a terrible idea to me - AIBU?

Have I got this totally wrong and actually it’s a big vote winner?!

I think you are hopelessly wrong. There is huge value in breadth of education as well as depth.

Just because a specific system wouldn’t have suited you personally, doesn’t mean it’s worthless.

MadamWhiteleigh · 22/09/2023 12:02

I was good at English but terrible at maths and scraped a C in my GCSE. I went on to do a law degree and then a masters and being shit at maths has not affected my life in anyway. But at 16, having to pass maths to carry on was miserable and soul-destroying.

x2boys · 22/09/2023 11:59

Passerillage · 22/09/2023 11:51

I do think that there is room on the syllabus for a "real world applied maths" course, for less academically inclined students, focused on household budgets, interest rates, debt, taxes, SME business accounting, Excel, main accounting softwares used (Quickbooks/Xero etc.), conversions and measurements. Apply it to real life circumstances that young people handle, so that they can fluently price up a project, do year end accounts, write a script in Excel, instantly spot discrepancies and so on.

God, offer it to more academically inclined students too!

Less academic students already have to.study English and Maths until.they get a grade four ,maybe functional.skills would be better for my less academic son but it should be either or not both.

Passerillage · 22/09/2023 11:52

I can confidently say that I have never used cos, sin or tan since 1995.

Passerillage · 22/09/2023 11:51

I do think that there is room on the syllabus for a "real world applied maths" course, for less academically inclined students, focused on household budgets, interest rates, debt, taxes, SME business accounting, Excel, main accounting softwares used (Quickbooks/Xero etc.), conversions and measurements. Apply it to real life circumstances that young people handle, so that they can fluently price up a project, do year end accounts, write a script in Excel, instantly spot discrepancies and so on.

God, offer it to more academically inclined students too!

TheLuckyOnes · 22/09/2023 11:50

I'm Irish, and Irish, English and Maths have generally been mandatory for our A-level equivalent (closer to IB, six or seven subjects, usually). Having taught at universities in Ireland and the UK, I think it's valuable. Specialising too soon narrows options, and leaves great gaping holes in general knowledge and basic abilities.

Dixiechickonhols · 22/09/2023 11:46

Complete overhaul of maths syllabus would be better.
I hated maths at school, I was an A grade student stressing if I’d get a C in maths as I was so desperate to avoid resit. I got a B and announced to my dad I was never doing maths again and he laughed (he had accounts job) but it was true I’ve never used what was in maths gcse - quadratic equations?!
I was actually good at science got highest score in school in Chemistry gcse but was totally put off science A levels by thought of having to do maths.

Whataretheodds · 22/09/2023 11:46

OP, having to choose just 3 or 4 A level subjects narrowed down my choices significantly at 16.
How could I have just chosen the IB? Would have required a move overseas or transfer to private school.