Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mandatory subjects until 18 a terrible idea

143 replies

Mysteriousflo · 21/09/2023 20:29

Thinking back to my school years, a key part of the excitement of going to sixth form was the ability to choose what I wanted to study.

I chose based on what I enjoyed and what would help me into the degree I wanted.

Focusing on a handful of key subjects was something that suited me and, if it didn’t, I could’ve made the choice to do the IB.

I believe having that choice was a key part of my success in my exams which set me up for my degree, career and where I am now professionally.

Why oh why does Sunak think mandating English and maths until 18 is a good idea?

It feels really regressive and like a terrible idea to me - AIBU?

Have I got this totally wrong and actually it’s a big vote winner?!

OP posts:
SnowflakeCity · 22/09/2023 15:43

Brightandshining · 22/09/2023 14:00

Agree. Its absolutely ridiculous.
Some kids will be fine but there are others who are particularly talented at the arts or at the sciences but are hopeless at the other... as long as they have achieved basic literacy and numeracy they should be able to pursue their actual gifts as they pass 16.
Really pissed me off as a more arts inclined person that even at gcse level I couldn't take music, art and drama.. in fact I could only choose one. Because you had to do endless subjects you weren't really that interested in.
I think its appalling to take up kids time with that at A level as well. Once again its just massive devaluing of the arts tbh... because English is basically useful even if you are an engineer or scientist but maths at an advanced level is of absolutely no real use to a dancer for example. As long as they have the basics of maths down theres no need to force it further on people and take up time they could be doing a subject they are actually engaged by.

I dont actually think there are many people who are 'hopeless' at maths and English though. Definitely some people that find some subjects easier than others but that doesnt mean they cant learn it. The vast majority of people with enough time and good teaching can get up to a decent standard. It's about the culture that surrounds learning mostly, no learning is pointless.

Just to add as well basic literacy and numeracy is a really low bar. Surely you want more for your kids than basic literacy?

x2boys · 22/09/2023 15:31

Dulra · 22/09/2023 13:49

There are options for those that are less academic such as leaving cert applied but they would include literacy and numeracy these are seen as basic skills that you need to get on in life no matter what you end up doing.

As pointed out by other posters the majority of education systems across the world have mandatory subjects up to 18 which in general include numeracy and literacy. The UK education is not rated as a great system and I don't think it is good for any society to have young people leaving school without a basic grasp of maths or English. I also don't think it is beneficial to have to specialise so young

So not dis similar to the english systen then where it is already mandatory for all 16_18,year olds to keep.doing maths and Ennglish at GCSE untill they get at least a grade four? ,As well as whatever course they do post 16 ,there are lots of choices other than Alevels

LadyEloise1 · 22/09/2023 15:25

mellongoose · 21/09/2023 21:09

I think it's a great idea. Similar to the international standard of baccalaureate. If it's good enough for children overseas, why not here 🤷‍♀️

Similar to the Irish system too.
Entry to universities is based on the points they get in their 6 best subjects.

thebellagio · 22/09/2023 14:16

Definitely agree economics should be brought in

When I set up my business, I didn't really know an awful lot about the accounting side of things (thats what I pay my accountant for!) but to teach kids how to read a balance sheet, how to tell the difference between profit/turnover, even teaching them how to use software like Quickbooks would again be a valuable lesson because many of them could easily go self-employed at a young age.

Plus definitely teach them functional daily maths - how to work out compound interest, how to know what the base interest rate could mean for mortgages/savings, how to read an energy bill - all those things that many adults struggle with - as shown by the posts on MN every single day

essentially, my view is if you're going to bring in compulsory lessons to 18, they need to be information relevant to ALL

EasternStandard · 22/09/2023 14:12

Critical thinking, English, debate, language sounds good

I’d love to see economics brought more into school curriculum for part of the maths

Hotsaucegal · 22/09/2023 14:12

I wonder if instituting an British baccalaureate is to appeal more to EU students for university as there has been a significant drop in applications since Brexit. Lots of British universities do not have a good understanding of qualifications from other countries (I.e. non A level) and often make unrealistic offers? Wonder if Sunak has realised that this is making the Uk university market increasingly less attractive and hurting their bottomline which in turn is affecting higher education for home students. making uk leaving qualifications more comparable to other EU ones might resolve this issue…

thebellagio · 22/09/2023 14:09

I think what others have said- it should be about English language, not English lit to 18

That way, you can learn how to apply critical thinking skills, how to write a CV and cover letter, how to get your point across in a polite (yet firm) manner, how language changes - when to use colloquialisms and when to be more formal - all of that would be valuable in the workplace

In my role as a copywriter it's about learning when to use different tones of voice, how to communicate with different groups - when to use jargon/when not - those are valuable transferrable skills that could be explored further

Notpooryet · 22/09/2023 14:06

MintJulia · 21/09/2023 20:41

My DS can't wait to give up English. He's perfectly literate, reads endlessly, but finds the dissection of texts takes the joy out of reading.

He'll get a 5 at English GCSE, but 8s & 9s in maths and three sciences, which he'll take for a'level.

Making him study English for another two years would just irritate him.

But English doesn't have to be about dissecting texts. They could change the syllabus post 16 into two streams one use of English one more academic.

Brightandshining · 22/09/2023 14:03

And I mean could this not just be part of 'general studies'? I remember in my school we started out doing 5 AS levels of which general studies had to be one and it contained segments on politics and economics etc... then the other 4 we could choose. We could drop general studies after AS if we wanted or continue it to A level.

Iamnotastick · 22/09/2023 14:01

I think they should instead teach maths and English on a more practical level.

Maths - How tax works, bank accounts, interest rates, credit cards, teh dangers of klarna,
English: How to construct an email, CV etc. I can spot a CV from an under 20 year old a mile off based on their email to me.

Brightandshining · 22/09/2023 14:00

Agree. Its absolutely ridiculous.
Some kids will be fine but there are others who are particularly talented at the arts or at the sciences but are hopeless at the other... as long as they have achieved basic literacy and numeracy they should be able to pursue their actual gifts as they pass 16.
Really pissed me off as a more arts inclined person that even at gcse level I couldn't take music, art and drama.. in fact I could only choose one. Because you had to do endless subjects you weren't really that interested in.
I think its appalling to take up kids time with that at A level as well. Once again its just massive devaluing of the arts tbh... because English is basically useful even if you are an engineer or scientist but maths at an advanced level is of absolutely no real use to a dancer for example. As long as they have the basics of maths down theres no need to force it further on people and take up time they could be doing a subject they are actually engaged by.

noblegiraffe · 22/09/2023 13:57

Suggesting that English schools can realistically implement a curriculum overhaul is like suggesting that those schools currently closed due to RAAC could organise a full scale production of Hamilton.

The infrastructure, capacity and resources needed are so far removed from what is available that it is batshit to suggest it.

Runnersandtoms · 22/09/2023 13:53

I also agree that there are much more useful skills than the ones taught in GCSE maths and English, and a focus on skills that are actually useful in life would be better than the deeply theoretical maths that is currently taught, and the endless analysis of texts in English.

Dulra · 22/09/2023 13:49

x2boys · 22/09/2023 12:12

What happens with your less academic students ?
Mums net tends to focus on everybody doing A levels in a school.sixth form
When actually many schools only go.up.to.year eleven and GCSE,s
Post 16 there are lots of options including A levels .

There are options for those that are less academic such as leaving cert applied but they would include literacy and numeracy these are seen as basic skills that you need to get on in life no matter what you end up doing.

As pointed out by other posters the majority of education systems across the world have mandatory subjects up to 18 which in general include numeracy and literacy. The UK education is not rated as a great system and I don't think it is good for any society to have young people leaving school without a basic grasp of maths or English. I also don't think it is beneficial to have to specialise so young

x2boys · 22/09/2023 13:46

Runnersandtoms · 22/09/2023 13:40

Making sure everyone has a decent grasp of English and Maths before leaving school is not the worst idea in the end. However, for a large proportion who pass GCSE they already have a decent grasp of both and don't need to continue to get a more advanced knowledge unless it is relevant for their future career. For those who don't pass, continuing to retake and fail GCSE is utterly pointless and it would be much better to encourage these students to take functional skills maths and English to get the skills they actually need for life.

I don't disagree with that ,my son has never been academic ,he was also very unwell in February in intensive care so missed a full.half term of his,year 11_#subsequently he's having to re do maths and English ,at college ,I think functional.skills in maths and English would suit him far better ,but currently the system is GCSE ,maths and English untill.a student gets at least a grade four

BlooDeBloop · 22/09/2023 13:45

Passerillage · 22/09/2023 11:51

I do think that there is room on the syllabus for a "real world applied maths" course, for less academically inclined students, focused on household budgets, interest rates, debt, taxes, SME business accounting, Excel, main accounting softwares used (Quickbooks/Xero etc.), conversions and measurements. Apply it to real life circumstances that young people handle, so that they can fluently price up a project, do year end accounts, write a script in Excel, instantly spot discrepancies and so on.

God, offer it to more academically inclined students too!

Completely agree. So many adults and students run up debts - it's almost inevitable in this day and age - everyone needs to understand APR. There are so many individual businesses too that basic accountancy like you say is essential imo. Other things like what is VAT, what is a limited business. So totally relevant to large sections of our workforce, both white and blue collar.

Runnersandtoms · 22/09/2023 13:40

Making sure everyone has a decent grasp of English and Maths before leaving school is not the worst idea in the end. However, for a large proportion who pass GCSE they already have a decent grasp of both and don't need to continue to get a more advanced knowledge unless it is relevant for their future career. For those who don't pass, continuing to retake and fail GCSE is utterly pointless and it would be much better to encourage these students to take functional skills maths and English to get the skills they actually need for life.

Natsku · 22/09/2023 13:38

The British education system narrows far too young, its not good for people to stop doing something as essential to life as maths at age 16, even those who aren't academic.

For instance I'm at vocational college in Finland, as an adult. If I want to get the full vocational qualification I need to study mothertongue (either Finnish or Swedish), the other language (so Swedish if mother tongue is Finnish), a foreign language (generally English), maths, physics, chemistry, art, social studies and work-related studies. Its only a few study points for each so you're not studying all of them the whole time but it makes sure basic skills are up to scratch.

GasPanic · 22/09/2023 13:35

For me two reasons why you don't reach level at 16. One is you are not able to, the other is you don't care or want to.

Making it mandatory and forcing people who don't care or want to is stupid. it's hard enough teaching kids under 16, let alone a bunch of 18 year old who don't want to be there. And who is going to make them turn up ?

Similarly if you are not able to you would probably be better off at least getting special needs teaching, or focussing on a career that you could do rather than continuing to bang your head against the wall with stuff you can't.

I think kids need to have it drummed into them that education doesn't stop at 16 and that it should be something you can come back to at any point, whether you continue after 16 and go onto university, or decide to go out into the real world for a couple of years, realise that mundane employment isn't for you and come back to qualify on your terms.

The message should be that if you want to come back and learn at any age the door is open. Because kids at 16-18 years old aren't always in the best position to decide on their educational needs, but that may change as they get only a few years older.

BlooDeBloop · 22/09/2023 13:35

I heard this on the radio and although I agree that expanding the a levels is a great idea, I'm far from sold on the maths/English question. I know an extremely bright science post-grad who struggled with maths. She is French and the bac includes a maths element - she gritted her teeth and finally scraped a pass. The legacy is she's no better at maths for the experience but the bad memory lives on.

Each child is different. Some will embrace the extra subjects (I would have), others will be gutted and might put them off learning entirely. The prescriptiveness in education needs to stop.

NotAMug · 22/09/2023 13:25

I don't really think even the maths/English GCSEs are necessarily something every child should have in the format that they are. Everyone should have to pass a functional maths/English exam in Y10/11 but the GCSEs are more suited to those having an interest in them at A level. The functional exams should be the minimum requirement for A levels (unless maths or English is relevant for that particular a level). Science I'm not sure about, it's probably fine as it is as its generally not a requirement for A levels to pass anyway.

fussychica · 22/09/2023 13:25

My DS was educated in Spain and undertook a Bachillerato. He had the choice of 4 study streams Arts, Science, Humanities or Social Sciences. 2 of the 4 continued the study of Maths and 10 subjects are covered in each stream. The Bachillerato is designed that way because they know that a large number of students wouldn't carry on and go to university if they had to study maths. It offers the opportunity to study a far broader range of subjects to give you the widest choice of courses at University.
I think we could learn a lot from the way other countries operate their post 16 offering.
Sunak's vision will just stop a large number of young people from wanting to study if they have to continue with maths but with the constant focus on STEM and the demise of arts degrees perhaps that's what he wants.

EasternStandard · 22/09/2023 13:11

It is a very narrow focus compared to what many other countries are used to

WitcheryDivine · 22/09/2023 13:09

I don't really mind if people have to study Maths to 18, the problem comes if they then have to pass an exam in it in order to get on with their lives afterwards.

The IB (which I did) is bloody hard work for anyone with a weak spot in any subject, not many people realise that if you do really badly at any of the subjects you fail THE ENTIRE DIPLOMA leaving you with nothing after two years. So many of my friends would have left college with no qualifications as they were unable to really get their heads round maths, English or a foreign language, despite being really talented in other areas. Thank god they could all do A levels instead.

Something like this could just leave more students on the exams scrapheap. IMO the only people who advocate that kind of system are either true all-rounders or those who lack any kind of empathy. Should the future teacher or journalist or physio leave school without a higher qualification because they find one area hard?

EliflurtleTripanInfinite · 22/09/2023 13:04

I expect like any system of education it would suit some and not others. We've always had something more like IB here. Depending on the state it's 5-6 subjects at our A level equivalent, including English or English and maths, with 4 electives. Maths and English are very streamed at that level. There are also vocational paths too, but they're done through an alternative provision. I can imagine the crys of horror if out children were restricted to only 3 subjects. For me I would have found that really restrictive, others would probably have benefited from a more focused education.