Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

teacher DH needs to leave his job.

106 replies

greenteaandchai · 21/09/2023 20:08

DH is a Maths teacher (A Level). A very good one. He is head of something and many other things I can't remember, he's also SLT.

DH HATES his job. Every day is the anger, the stress, the cries of how much he 'can't do it anymore'.

DH also privately tutors, in fact, he has built such a reputation that he runs a successful company doing it. He earns more privately tutoring than his teacher salary. It helps that I am an accountant so I can do his finances easily.

I've produced cash flows, projections, financial models. I've proved he can quit. I have proved his business could be a massive success. I also have said, if you quit then you can always apply for another job if this fails, there's enough of them. I also earn more than double DH so we can easily survive on my salary.

Up until recently he'd say 'I want to quit' and I'd say 'are you sure? really?' and i'd console, I was the therapist, the ear, the teacher, but all just got angry responses of 'you don't get it'. So now I am saying QUIT. Stop moaning or quit.

AIBU to say that he can easily survive without this job right now and he needs to sort his mental health out? At the moment he is juggling everything well enough but with a lot of stress and occasional mood swings. However, we are TTC and I am clear that he can't juggle when/if we are successful because he is never home at the moment.

Would like to get opinions.

YABU - teaching is security, do it, keep it up
YANBU - do the other business idea, sort your mental health out.

Would be very interested to hear from teachers who have left the profession too.

OP posts:
greenteaandchai · 23/09/2023 11:24

cardibach · 21/09/2023 20:27

He earns more privately tutoring than his teacher salary.
Sorry @greenteaandchai this isn’t possible. The lowest SLT pay is £47k. At £30 an hour for A level tutoring that’s 30 students per week, every week, all year. Even if he does the tutoring in groups it’s not possible.

He charges more than £30 an hour. Much more. He is an ex exam writer so it helps too. He’s amazing. He runs group classes, has lots of private students. He makes six figures through the business (a limited company)

OP posts:
AllProperTeaIsTheft · 23/09/2023 08:26

Doing an already stressful and all-consuming SLT job and adding enough tutoring to earn more than your salary is insane, if not actually impossible. I can't imagine anyone actually doing that unless they had some kind of monumentally terrible financial problem and desperately needed more money than their good SLT salary paid. Of course he's stressed out of his mind- who wouldn't be, with that workload. He could ditch the job and just do tutoring, but he could also ditch the tutoring and do the job without the additional workload. That would be more secure, with the benefits of security, sick pay, pension etc.

FUPAgirl · 23/09/2023 08:23

If ne needs to earn a 'full time' salary then tutoring really won't work. He will busiest when you are home from work, you won't see each other. Would he not be better retraining into a whole new industry? Or what about stopping the current tutoring, would that not improve his work life balance?

Lots of people complain about their jobs, especially teachers, sometimes its just letting off steam. I wouldn't pressure him to jump ship.

cuddlebear · 23/09/2023 08:22

I was HOD and to be honest it nearly killed me.

I started teaching because I loved it, believed in transforming students, felt so good about my job. I ended up a wrung out disheveled mess. Drinking, fat, medicated for anxiety. By the time I had dealt with all the stupid futile admin and reporting, I had barely any energy left for teaching.

It was my 18 year old son who pointed out to me that I could just leave. I didn’t have to spend another day shaking with rage at the latest demand from SLT. So I did.

I took a year off and did hourly paid lecturing for different FE colleges, and eventually got my MH back to the point where I applied for a FT job in my profession, but where I also have responsibilities for training.

I get stressed and busy sometimes but overall, it’s an absolute doss compared to teaching. Sometimes you just can’t see how bad things are until you’re out of it.

I hope things work out for you both.

cardibach · 23/09/2023 08:11

Twentypastfour · 23/09/2023 07:45

I have friends who use tutors and I’m told they pay about £70 an hour these days.

I have teacher friends who say otherwise. In fact I am a teacher who does on and off tutoring and I say otherwise. Sometimes maybe. I don’t know why though. But that would still mean 15 students per week every week including holidays to match even the lowest SLT salary, and he has other responsibilities. Just doesn’t seem possible.

tttigress · 23/09/2023 08:08

I worked with someone that was a former maths teacher, he moved into I.T. for similar reasons.

He said when a maths teaching position is advertised, only 1 or 2 people are good enough to be interviewed.

Where as for PE or English there are many more suitable candidates.

I'm sure if your husband quits he will be able to get another job without problems.

pompomdaisy · 23/09/2023 07:57

DH was a secondary school teacher too. He now works in FE and loves it. Your hubby could do that two days a week if he wants some security. It won't be anywhere near as well paid as secondary but what price a life?

Totaly · 23/09/2023 07:55

I moved into a different sector 6 months ago, pay is higher. I’ve just secured a company training role with a pay rise. Companies are crying out for trainers. I do 9/5 flexible working - time for the toilet - and tea. I’ve been on two holidays this year so far, have others planned. It’s so much cheaper!
I have also dropped DD off at Uni, winner!
I can buy more holiday and work extra paid overtime (double)

I’m surprised by how many transferable skills there are in the workplace.

Redbrickrebel · 23/09/2023 07:53

It doesn't matter what the particular job is, if it is causing ill health and negatively impacting home life and relationships, a change is needed.

On this occasion it's teaching, but it could also be retail, office work, health care etc.

It is easy to say this from the sidelines, as I know the 'money trap ' is a real thing, but you can't simply whinge and be unhappy. You have to do something about it.

Twentypastfour · 23/09/2023 07:45

cardibach · 21/09/2023 20:27

He earns more privately tutoring than his teacher salary.
Sorry @greenteaandchai this isn’t possible. The lowest SLT pay is £47k. At £30 an hour for A level tutoring that’s 30 students per week, every week, all year. Even if he does the tutoring in groups it’s not possible.

I have friends who use tutors and I’m told they pay about £70 an hour these days.

Aishah231 · 23/09/2023 07:40

I'm sorry OP but if you're husband is earning more tutoring than being SLT the reason in he's stressed at work is because he's completely neglecting his duties at school. He should quit his job and just focus on his tutoring.

DisquietintheRanks · 23/09/2023 07:37

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 21/09/2023 20:30

There's something not right here. How on earth would someone with a ft senior teaching job have time to tutor at all (in term time), never mind tutor enough to make more money than his SLT salary?! It's not possible!

This in spades .

CelestialSausage · 23/09/2023 07:33

he could do a half way thing for a year or two first …. Drop responsibilities and go part time. There are loads of home ed children and adults who need maths qualifications so he would be pretty busy. If he gave his notice now, he could could start part time working Christmas time. There will be other driven staff keen to take on his school responsibilities.

ConnieTucker · 23/09/2023 07:22

He is earning more as a side hustle tutor than SLT?! Wow. He is either storming that side hustle or vastly underpaid slt. I know primary slt would be much of a step up from ups3, but high school should be well into £60k. And you earn double? Id have left teaching in a heart beat.

it isnt the money keeping him. Is it the job defining him?

Werewolfnotswearwolf · 23/09/2023 07:21

My thoughts exactly! Probably half the reason he’s stressed is that he’s working two full time jobs??
I’m SLT too, it’s very stressful and very hard work but my god, there’s no way I’m tutoring on top of it!!

Teateaandmoretea · 23/09/2023 07:20

Yanbu at all. Staying in a job you hate and makes you miserable but you don’t actually need to do is irrational. Is it a fear of people thinking he’s a failure?

Mummyoflittledragon · 23/09/2023 07:16

Takoneko · 23/09/2023 06:35

If he’s angry then quitting his job is g going to solve that. He has an SLT job on SLT salary and, from the sounds of it, an all or mostly A Level timetable with the SLT reduction in contact hours. He also has enough spare time to do a significant amount of private tutoring. The issue isn’t his job. He clearly seeks out additional work and stress for himself.

He can quit if he wants but I’d be really surprised if in the long term it’s financially better to just private tutor. You need to consider the pension too and if you are TTC don’t underestimate the financial value of a parent who works school hours term time only. Private tutoring mostly involves working when children are not at school. It’s evenings and weekends. Is that what you all want from family life when you’ve got small school-aged children of your own?

Do you even want children with an angry, stressy man? There’s nothing to say changing his job will change his anger.

All very good points. You’ll feel like you’re on your own op.

Takoneko · 23/09/2023 06:35

If he’s angry then quitting his job is g going to solve that. He has an SLT job on SLT salary and, from the sounds of it, an all or mostly A Level timetable with the SLT reduction in contact hours. He also has enough spare time to do a significant amount of private tutoring. The issue isn’t his job. He clearly seeks out additional work and stress for himself.

He can quit if he wants but I’d be really surprised if in the long term it’s financially better to just private tutor. You need to consider the pension too and if you are TTC don’t underestimate the financial value of a parent who works school hours term time only. Private tutoring mostly involves working when children are not at school. It’s evenings and weekends. Is that what you all want from family life when you’ve got small school-aged children of your own?

Do you even want children with an angry, stressy man? There’s nothing to say changing his job will change his anger.

Rachlis · 23/09/2023 06:25

Teaching is an awful profession for mental health at the moment. I wouldn’t return after children for this reason.

MargotBamborough · 23/09/2023 06:23

Have you factored his pension into your financial calculations?

Mummy08m · 23/09/2023 06:19

If I were op I'd focus only on how dh's ways affect mine. Focus on the outcome you need rather than the means you think he should use

Eg - you are often angry at me and that makes me unhappy and affecting our TTC. I need to you stop being angry at home. You say that your anger is due to work stress so my suggestion is that you reduce your workload/quit your job but if you can find another way to stop being angry at home, that would be equally fine.

Put the ball in his court, let him have agency over it.

So for him it's not "my wife is pressuring me to quit my entire hard earned career", it's "my wife no longer wants to endure my anger, how do I fix this."

Mummy08m · 23/09/2023 06:12

Just to reiterate when I say - definitely not condoning op's dh getting angry at home. If he's getting angry at op (and/or any kids if they have some already) then that's even potentially abusive and needs addressing.

I'm just not convinced that quitting his career would be an automatic quick-fix for his emotional dysregulation.

Nugg · 23/09/2023 06:11

YANBU he needs to quit at least for 6 months and see how life looks/he feels. You're right he can go back if he needs to

Mummy08m · 23/09/2023 06:07

Hankunamatata · 21/09/2023 22:45

Does he actually want to quit or just he just need an offload of emotional build up at the end of the day and a sympathetic ear?

I agree with this, it's why I voted yabu.

I'm a teacher and genuinely love my job, in an independent school, it's an easy gig.

But I do like to moan sometimes to dh, tbf not like op's husband more like anecdotes of how unreasonable SLT/parents etc can be and I sometimes even make dh laugh and he helps me laugh it off.

I'd much prefer my dh helps me laugh about my gripes than insisted "why don't you just quit so you can stop moaning at me".

Obviously it's not ok that op's dh brings anger home. Anger is not really ok in the home imo. But I'm also unconvinced that quitting his whole successful career would make him less angry.

(I'm a huge fan of working part time though so I'd recommend that to anyone.)

ittakes2 · 22/09/2023 14:38

We pay £50 an hour for A level maths tutors in our area - but how on earth does he earn more from tutoring than teaching? This man must be working so much he's prob exhausted with little free time.