Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

teacher DH needs to leave his job.

106 replies

greenteaandchai · 21/09/2023 20:08

DH is a Maths teacher (A Level). A very good one. He is head of something and many other things I can't remember, he's also SLT.

DH HATES his job. Every day is the anger, the stress, the cries of how much he 'can't do it anymore'.

DH also privately tutors, in fact, he has built such a reputation that he runs a successful company doing it. He earns more privately tutoring than his teacher salary. It helps that I am an accountant so I can do his finances easily.

I've produced cash flows, projections, financial models. I've proved he can quit. I have proved his business could be a massive success. I also have said, if you quit then you can always apply for another job if this fails, there's enough of them. I also earn more than double DH so we can easily survive on my salary.

Up until recently he'd say 'I want to quit' and I'd say 'are you sure? really?' and i'd console, I was the therapist, the ear, the teacher, but all just got angry responses of 'you don't get it'. So now I am saying QUIT. Stop moaning or quit.

AIBU to say that he can easily survive without this job right now and he needs to sort his mental health out? At the moment he is juggling everything well enough but with a lot of stress and occasional mood swings. However, we are TTC and I am clear that he can't juggle when/if we are successful because he is never home at the moment.

Would like to get opinions.

YABU - teaching is security, do it, keep it up
YANBU - do the other business idea, sort your mental health out.

Would be very interested to hear from teachers who have left the profession too.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Doingmybest12 · 23/09/2023 15:43

I feel a bit cross with him. How can he do all of this well, of course he's going to be stressed and knackered and bad tempered. Absolutely ridiculous. He needs to decide which he wants to concentrate on. I don't feel sorry about his situation at all.

DarkWingDuck · 23/09/2023 15:03

It might not just be about the money. Jobs that are more of a calling like healthcare, teaching, forces etc they sell you a dream of being helpful and useful in society. You get caught up in being a teacher rather than having a job as a teacher. It becomes part of your personality. When you start you can’t ever see yourself leaving, your job is you and your life. It’s hard to admit that the job has ground you down, it’s hard to admit you can’t do it any longer. Even though you cry everyday and say you can’t do it- you can’t walk away. It gets you like an abusive relationship In some ways.

Perhaps have a chat about what waking away would bring up for him and go from there.

mayorofcasterbridge · 23/09/2023 12:59

He’s greedy. There are ways and means to make his life easier and all he wants to do is moan! Doesn’t sound like he will ever be content!

How about ditching the management stuff and sticking to teaching for a start? It’s not as if there’s a massive amount of marking in Maths! Plus manage the side hustle through the employees and take less of the load on himself?

Work is tough for many of us not just teachers!

This situation will not be sustainable when you have children.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 23/09/2023 12:44

greenteaandchai · 23/09/2023 11:28

For those confused by DH’s hours. He is mid thirties, he works every single day of the week. Over 100 hours a week. He is NEVER home. That’s not an exaggeration. He gets in, sleeps.

He refuses to rely on my income. He is very proud and believes he should be matching my salary which is part of the issue tbh. I’ve told him we’re a team etc but it’s his mindset.

This sounds insane.

If you're planning to have a baby with him, then he needs to be home at least some of the time- he can't be out of the house all day every day of the week. His child(ren) will never see him.

I think it might be time for a conversation about how children change your life in various ways, and one of them is that he doesn't need to be working all hours to earn money that isn't really needed right now. He shouldn't be effectively working two (busy/stressful) jobs and never seeing his child.

I'd basically tell him he needs to pick one and drop the other, for now at least. That it doesn't matter how much he earns- he needs to be present for family life.

I'd imagine only working one job would be a significant improvement to his quality of life!

At the moment, if he left a maths teacher/head of maths role, he could easily find another role in a few years if the tutoring side of things didn't work out or wasn't providing a reliable income stream.

I think the only thing I would consider if he left teaching is his pension- the TPS is a good pension scheme and you may struggle to match it with a private pension. Of course, if he ends up dead from overwork in his 30s/40s/50s, then he won't see the benefits anyway.

cardibach · 23/09/2023 12:43

greenteaandchai · 23/09/2023 11:24

He charges more than £30 an hour. Much more. He is an ex exam writer so it helps too. He’s amazing. He runs group classes, has lots of private students. He makes six figures through the business (a limited company)

And is also SLT in a school and some other responsibility you can’t remember? He’s not doing something properly then. No SLT member I know has time to tutor. Or have a family life. He should just chuck the school job. Why is it even a discussion?

Mumof118 · 23/09/2023 12:42

Three weeks into the term and I’m exhausted. I’ve already been monitored. Next week will be evaluated. My books have been scrutinised and scrutiny will now take place every 5-6 weeks. I explained to my husband that it feels like I go to work on Monday morning and finish on Friday afternoon. I feel like I work constantly.

I am looking to leave. I got 82% A*-C pass rate for one of my GCSE classes, 78% for the other and 75% A -C for my A level class and this is in a deprived school with a much lower overall pass rate, so I know I will be missed from the profession. My 25 ish years teaching do actually count for a lot.

But I say if your husband can comfortably leave, leave. Teaching sucks the life from you these days. And it’s not the kids fault either.

Mummy08m · 23/09/2023 12:41

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 23/09/2023 12:34

If you're employed under STPCD, schools can't force you to work on your days off, and if you agree to, you can ask to be paid for it. See the advice here: https://neu.org.uk/advice/your-rights-work/contracts-and-working-hours/workload-and-working-time/directed-time/directed-time-faq

I agree there are downsides to teaching part time, but most teachers can't be forced to work additional days.

I agree. I've worked 3 days pw for several years now and only extremely rarely do I have to take any work home, I'm talking like 3 times a year maximum.

I'm at an independent school so, yes, I am expected in for parents evenings and full inset days but they are usually on my days in, and anyway I only teach 3 year groups so that's 3 parents evenings a year. The most I've ever had to come in on my days off is about 2 days a year.

My salary is maybe 35-40k-ish for 3 days a week as I'm high up in the payscale from teaching so long. It's quite good salary for what is basically a very easy gig, no extra responsibilities, just subject teaching.

If I were op's dh I'd swap to part time just to keep that extra security. Parents usually want practising teachers for tutors anyway.

I agree that 4 days pw is a mug's game, I did that for a while. 2, 2.5 or 3 days pw are ideal.

Gorgeouscombes · 23/09/2023 12:34

@cardibach in London a level maths tutoring can be a great deal more than. £60!

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 23/09/2023 12:34

FarmerJoe · 21/09/2023 21:03

People suggesting he goes parttime I guess have never been a part time teacher. The same amount of work just less pay!

You have to go in on you"off days" because of meetings, parents evening, open evenings, inset days etc. Same amount of planning but maybe not teaching a duplicate class so no benefit really dropping that class.

Still tied into all the "other stuff" that teachers do.

Teaching is a hard job - it is awful job if you are not enjoying it.

Life is too short - leave, breath and see that there is life outside of the school

Ex teacher left teaching and have flourished mentally and physically since leaving teaching.

If you're employed under STPCD, schools can't force you to work on your days off, and if you agree to, you can ask to be paid for it. See the advice here: https://neu.org.uk/advice/your-rights-work/contracts-and-working-hours/workload-and-working-time/directed-time/directed-time-faq

I agree there are downsides to teaching part time, but most teachers can't be forced to work additional days.

Netcam · 23/09/2023 12:29

There is loads of GCSE Maths tutoring work around, he would always have work. I tutor GCSE Maths and I am sure I could fill my days if I wanted to and I don't even tutor A level. I used to be a secondary school teacher and I would never return to the classroom.

tokennamechange · 23/09/2023 12:23

if you are in your late twenties and he is presumably a similar age and you're earning at least 200k between you (sounds like quite a bit more) then surely he understands that you're probably in a better financial position than something like 97% of your peers, or even people much older? It's not a case of 'surviving', even if he didn't work at all your income would still be triple the average UK household income.

Why is he so worried about a bad year, or something disastrous happening? It doesn't sound healthy at all. Thousands of teachers would kill to be in his position, with a financially solvent and supportive partner, but they can't because their £33k wage is literally supporting the whole family and they don't have any fall back. I honestly don't get his reasoning.

JFDIYOLO · 23/09/2023 12:01

From your figures, compared to what so many of us here have, you are RAKING in the £s.

greenteaandchai · 23/09/2023 11:56

JaneIntheBox · 23/09/2023 11:55

The key thing here is that even if the business is 'destroyed' he can always go back to teaching, as @dinmin has stated.
So really. This is a zero risk plan... something that I rarely say...!

Also where do you live? How are you doing on things like a mortgage?

Edited

DH is reading this thread (why I created it). LOOK DH LOOK. POINT PROVEN ;)

He's not currently with me because guess what? he's at school, working!

OP posts:
JaneIntheBox · 23/09/2023 11:55

greenteaandchai · 23/09/2023 11:32

I’ve purposefully been vague as I think anyone in our area can identify us. He does more than privately tutor - we have 5 employees (part time), I help out, we have passive income streams, online platforms etc, but it’s relatively new.

this wasn’t meant to be a critique of if my numbers are right. They are. But likewise, a bad year could destroy the business.

The key thing here is that even if the business is 'destroyed' he can always go back to teaching, as @dinmin has stated.
So really. This is a zero risk plan... something that I rarely say...!

Also where do you live? How are you doing on things like a mortgage?

greenteaandchai · 23/09/2023 11:54

ConnieTucker · 23/09/2023 07:22

He is earning more as a side hustle tutor than SLT?! Wow. He is either storming that side hustle or vastly underpaid slt. I know primary slt would be much of a step up from ups3, but high school should be well into £60k. And you earn double? Id have left teaching in a heart beat.

it isnt the money keeping him. Is it the job defining him?

He's on slightly less than 60k with the new payrise. He would have to take on more responsibility for the next pay band which would kill him.

I earn a stable low six figures and I am 29. We can survive. I think DH is getting obsessed with proving himself as a success.

We aren't flashy. My car is 16 years old, DH's 12. We eat out a fair amount but simple foods. We don't have kids yet. We like holidays, but who doesn't. Part of the reason we spend so much on travel is 1) we have to go in school holidays and 2) we're escaping the humdrum of normal life. But now he works on holiday too because he can't stop. I don't think it's a life.

OP posts:
dinmin · 23/09/2023 11:36

Haven’t RTFT but quit. The business sounds viable and he will always have the option to do supply if really worried.

and then if he wants to go back to something more similar to his SLT/teaching job in future he could try private school, online school or working for a MAT as a subject lead

ThornInMySide84 · 23/09/2023 11:35

@greenteaandchai My main concern is… does he space to tutor my DS?! Desperately looking for a very good further maths gcse tutor!!

Cupofteafortwo · 23/09/2023 11:34

Whitestick · 23/09/2023 11:31

He has such good earning potential, and as a couple you are absolutely fine for money, so I have a lot less sympathy for him than I have for someone desperate to leave but really reliant on the money and security.
He needs to do something or stop complaining about it.

Agree with this

Whitestick · 23/09/2023 11:33

Sorry Op I obviously cross posted with your last post

greenteaandchai · 23/09/2023 11:32

I’ve purposefully been vague as I think anyone in our area can identify us. He does more than privately tutor - we have 5 employees (part time), I help out, we have passive income streams, online platforms etc, but it’s relatively new.

this wasn’t meant to be a critique of if my numbers are right. They are. But likewise, a bad year could destroy the business.

OP posts:
Whitestick · 23/09/2023 11:31

He has such good earning potential, and as a couple you are absolutely fine for money, so I have a lot less sympathy for him than I have for someone desperate to leave but really reliant on the money and security.
He needs to do something or stop complaining about it.

greenteaandchai · 23/09/2023 11:28

Cosyblankets · 23/09/2023 11:26

What's he waiting for then?
How does he fit it all in?

I’m extremely concerned he will drop dead. Extremely.

OP posts:
greenteaandchai · 23/09/2023 11:28

For those confused by DH’s hours. He is mid thirties, he works every single day of the week. Over 100 hours a week. He is NEVER home. That’s not an exaggeration. He gets in, sleeps.

He refuses to rely on my income. He is very proud and believes he should be matching my salary which is part of the issue tbh. I’ve told him we’re a team etc but it’s his mindset.

OP posts:
Cosyblankets · 23/09/2023 11:26

greenteaandchai · 23/09/2023 11:24

He charges more than £30 an hour. Much more. He is an ex exam writer so it helps too. He’s amazing. He runs group classes, has lots of private students. He makes six figures through the business (a limited company)

What's he waiting for then?
How does he fit it all in?

greenteaandchai · 23/09/2023 11:26

FarmerJoe · 21/09/2023 21:03

People suggesting he goes parttime I guess have never been a part time teacher. The same amount of work just less pay!

You have to go in on you"off days" because of meetings, parents evening, open evenings, inset days etc. Same amount of planning but maybe not teaching a duplicate class so no benefit really dropping that class.

Still tied into all the "other stuff" that teachers do.

Teaching is a hard job - it is awful job if you are not enjoying it.

Life is too short - leave, breath and see that there is life outside of the school

Ex teacher left teaching and have flourished mentally and physically since leaving teaching.

Yes DH said it wouldn’t be worth it

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread