Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To complain about treatment during smear test?

56 replies

IfIHadAHeart · 21/09/2023 19:50

I have never had a smear test, until today. I’m at least 12 years past when I should have had my first, but as a victim of SA I’ve never been able to bring myself to go. I’ve recently had some symptoms that meant I’ve had to bite the bullet, and so this morning off I went…

I explained to the nurse that I was anxious, and she did a good job of putting my mind at rest. Initially once she started it wasn’t too bad and I was just thinking how foolish I’d been putting it off for so long. But she couldn’t find my cervix even after a few minutes of (admittedly quite gentle) trying. She disappeared behind the curtain and the next thing I hear the treatment room door open and she walks off down the corridor leaving only a paper curtain between me and a busy queue of people waiting for their covid jabs.

she returns with another nurse and is explaining to the nurse (not to me) that she can’t locate my cervix. Nurse No2 picks up a speculum and shoves it quite roughly inside with no warning and without having said a word to me. She then tries a different size, then back to the first. It’s becoming quite painful. She pulls it out then in again repeatedly. No lubricant, and I think by this time any natural lubrication has gone (sorry TMI!) Eventually I ask her to stop, to which she replies “If we can’t do it today you’ll only have to come back”. I need the test and I knew if I left I’d never go back, so I silently let her carry on. Eventually it’s done. I dress, leave, and by the time I get back to my car I’m crying.

I’m not sure if I’m being dramatic, and I’m sure a smear test is never particularly pleasant, but it’s really upset me. It’s the fact that No2 didn’t feel it necessary to speak to me or explain what she was doing. Or show any awareness I was uncomfortable and in pain.

WIBU to complain to the surgery? Or is this just normal?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ReadingSoManyThreads · 22/09/2023 00:39

Absolutely complain, that's not ok.

301963Laurie · 22/09/2023 00:12

This is the reason I have refused a smear for about 10 years! Treated shockingly,very painful and unsuccessful! Am 60 now so just hoping the risk of cervical cancer is lower …I am a registered nurse as well but cannot face that ordeal again 😕

IntheSnowySnowyMountains · 22/09/2023 00:06

I had a similar experience - no SA but the nurse couldn't find my cervix and was trying for ages. It was very painful. I think it took 3 appointments in the end to get a sample (the last one with the GP most experienced in women's health).

I have since moved abroad and see a gynae for my check ups. It's like night and day. She knows exactly what she's doing and it's over in less than 30 seconds. Sometimes the actual smear taking is uncomfortable but that is really only two seconds. I highly recommend getting referred if you can (sounds like you need it anyway if you might have an issue).

Artichokepiglet · 21/09/2023 23:18

YANBU. When I had my first smear test it hurt so much that I asked the nurse to stop, and she said 'I'll keep going because if I don't get it done today you'll have to go through this all again'. It seemed to take forever, like minutes of her scraping away, and when she pulled the swab out I was horrified to see that it was dripping in blood. 'That's normal' she told me, 'if you don't bleed it means I haven't got enough cells'. I seriously debated not going when my next smear test came up but I did and it was nothing like that first experience - so quick and no bleeding. They have been fine ever since and I now think that first nurse might have actually been trying to hurt me?

Callipygion · 21/09/2023 22:56

Im not going back either after an horrendously painful experience which left me bleeding for nearly a week after. The nurse that time said to ask for the smallest speculum in future, so I did on my next one only to get tutted at and the eye roll. I don’t know if she did get it, but it was still really painful (not merely uncomfortable) so I’m never going back.

Gillyyy · 21/09/2023 22:46

Definitely complain. Hope you’re ok, that sounds awful. I have endometriosis and dread going for my smear test. I always ask for the smallest speculum and for them to go slowly and stop if I need to. We shouldn’t have to ask for them to look after us properly.

EvilElsa · 21/09/2023 22:39

I'm absolutely fucking sick of women getting treated like shit during medical treatments, labour and birth. I've heard so many stories of awful treatment, limited pain relief, aggression, bullying. When I had DD my breastfeeding "help" consisted of a midwife grabbing my breast so hard that I had finger shaped purple bruising.
Please do complain. Hope you are OK.

hellywelly3 · 21/09/2023 22:33

I wish I’d complained last time. She said she needed a light but said she couldn’t be bothered to look for one as she didn’t know where they were. I said I was in no hurry if she wanted to go look but she said no. I couldn’t sit down comfortably for a few days and bleed afterwards. I debated for a couple of weeks then the pandemic happened and I thought I’d leave it. But I due again and I’m reluctant to book.
Defiantly complain wish I had

Daniki · 21/09/2023 22:18

Defo complain! That's a horrendous way to carry on, you're in such a vulnerable position (even without the SA taken into account) that to be respected and treated with dignity is the absolute bare minimum! Hope you're ok

weebleswobblebuttheydontfalldown · 21/09/2023 22:16

Firstly, well done for getting your smear, they are definitely not my fave thing!!
I always have this issue and had an experience like yours a few years ago (although, think yours sounded a bit worse tbh). I had one the other day and same thing happened, couldn't find cervix - ugh! However the lovely nurse was fantastic- warned me before she was going to insert anything and tried a few tricks and finally it worked! She was very lovely and I felt like I was in good hands.

There is no excuse for the way they dealt with you, I've had similar when I was in labour and shouted at by a registrar when she was breaking my waters!! I was in a lot of pain and she was very unsympathetic when I was at my most vulnerable!! As were you when having a smear. I would definitely complain if you feel able.

Abfab63 · 21/09/2023 22:09

Erm no definitely not normal. Especially leaving the door open!

Had a few smears over the years and all have been absolutely fine, no pain at all. However most recent one was awfully painful and rough and I was absolutely fuming afterwards as it's just carelessness.

They might have been rushed but it's still no excuse as it might put you off going back again. It is possible to have a pain free smear so sorry this has happened.

Whapples · 21/09/2023 21:51

I’m so sorry this happened to you, that’s awful. Definitely complain. I wish I had after I went last year. The nurse was really rough and didn’t stop when I asked (just said that she was almost done). She didn’t even ask if I was okay despite me crying before it finished and continuing to cry and we left. My partner was there and he tried to advocate on my behalf but was just horrified as she didn’t even respond to him saying that I was in pain.

I really hope all your results are okay so you don’t have to go again any time soon. I would advise an advocate in the future too - my partner may not have been able to do anything but I’m glad he witnessed the behaviour too!

justanothermanicmonday1 · 21/09/2023 21:48

I have recently had my second baby, and any time they've wanted to examine me they ask permission every single time.

Surely they should have known that. It should be standard practice?

I've never had a smear test either for other reasons. However as I have just had another baby, I need to bite the bullet for them.

I hope you're ok xx

GoryBory · 21/09/2023 21:43

Some smear tests can be uncomfortable but there’s absolutely no need to not have any manners.

Obviously nurse 2 has smear experience to do it so there’s no excuse for no bedside manner.

My nurse has always talked me through each step.

I’m sorry you had such a crap experience, especially after a 12 year wait.

batfink39 · 21/09/2023 21:42

I agree, it didn't uphold your dignity & nurses should be well aware of trauma informed practise. I'd send an email to the practise. I'm sorry your first experience wasn't a positive one & I hope it doesn't put you off going again in future. Well done for getting it done- hope you treated yourself to something afterwards x

Takentomybed · 21/09/2023 21:41

I'm so sorry to hear you had that experience. If you feel able please do complain. And don't worry about getting anyone into trouble. You were treated poorly.
I've never spoken about this, apart from to my partner, but I was examined very roughly many years ago by a female doctor, so much so I was crying. She then totally minimised my discomfort and said it was because I was nervous about it so not relaxed enough.
I've never been for a smear test since. I really felt violated and wish I had complained.

LovingMyLiver · 21/09/2023 21:32

Being a woman is really bloody hard. I hope you're okay OP xx

WillowCraft · 21/09/2023 21:30

If you have symptoms a smear is not the right thing - you need a GP appointment.

They should have asked if you had symptoms before they started though. If they didn't that is another thing to complain about. The way you were treated is not normal, it is not acceptable, it sounds most unpleasant and they need to do better.

FictionalCharacter · 21/09/2023 21:25

Complain strongly, don’t let them get away with this.
Nurse 2 treated you as though you weren’t a sentient human. Too many HCPs do this.
Nurse 2 should not have left the door open when you were on the couch exposed. She should have shut the door.

disappointed101 · 21/09/2023 21:24

So sorry you went through this. I had a bad experience about 6 years ago where the nurse was so rough poking around. It took me a good 6 months to book my following smear. I explained to the new nurse and it was like night and day. It was soooo much better. I honestly felt violated and wish I had complained. Please do make a complaint.

MagickSTEM · 21/09/2023 21:21

Yes, do complain.

Next time, tell the nurse that you had a horrendous experience with the last one, that it’s hard to find and that you might need the smallest speculum. That should make it a lot easier.

I hate having a smear.

Prescottdanni123 · 21/09/2023 21:15

Was this a GP surgery? If so, next time, I'd ask to be referred to outpatients department at a local hospital. They have many tricks up their sleeve for doing smears and normally have a special chair for you to sit so you are upright, which makes it easier.

scoobydoo1971 · 21/09/2023 21:08
  1. Make a complaint to PALS to prevent this happening to others. I had cervical treatment once off an awful doctor who told me I was being dramatic, and I told him if he kept hurting me I would shove that speculum in him, 2. Go to a sexual health clinic and arrange a smear through their service. They are much more skilled at dealing with female anatomy. My cervix is hard to find due to low bicornuate uterus, and tilted/ twisted uterus. I have found better service from those who do these tests in specialist centres of care. 3. I appreciate your history makes this a difficult procedure. However, many cervix related diseases are prevented or treated by early screening, so don't let nurses lacking clinical skills put you off.
nocoolnamesleft · 21/09/2023 20:38

user1846385927482658 · 21/09/2023 20:36

Please make a GP.appointment. If you have symptoms you need a GP appointment and a different pathway.

Smear tests are NOT for investigating symptoms, they're a screening tool for asymptomatic patients.

Absolutely agree with this.

I'm sorry you had a bad experience. The first nurse should have closed the door so you felt less exposed, the second should definitely have spoken with you.

JoeMaplin · 21/09/2023 20:37

I’m so sorry you had this experience, it sounds very unprofessional and unkind. Just wanted to say, if you have any symptoms a smear test is not a diagnostic test. Please, please , if you have any symptoms, go and see your GP. You can always explain in the econsult beforehand about the SA if you feel able.

Hugs (9 months post total hysterectomy here)