Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To call my neighbour selfish

457 replies

Fedupandgrumpy1 · 21/09/2023 19:36

We live in a quiet street with about 10 houses in. I have mobility issues and also struggle with my MH. It's important for me to have as much sleep as possible so I tend to go to bed at 10.30pm and don't get up until about 11am.

Very recently a family moved in next door. They have 3 children who are lovely and not a problem. But their mother annoys me and I feel she is being selfish. She works strange hours and most days leaves the house to go to work at 4.30am. She drives an old car and the doors creaks when she opens it. She then normally sits in the car with it running for 5 mins before driving off. The father is fine.

I have spoken to her and told her about my health issues and have asked her to consider changing her working hours, replace her car or to park her car in a road away from the house. She said she was sorry that she disturbs me but she cannot change her working hours due to the nature of her job. She said they can't afford to replace the car and as its an old car she has to warm it up before going anywhere. She admits the door creaks and said that oiling is didn't help. She is not willing to park away from home and she doesn't think its safe to walk on her own early in the morning with no streetlights.

She is making me more poorly. I am now having to sleep a bit in the afternoon due go being disturbed and as a result am missing out on me time.

What can I do about it? I'm fed up of her selfish behaviour.

OP posts:
fairydust11 · 21/09/2023 23:10

Justkeepingplatesspinning · 21/09/2023 22:59

I too have a disability and part of it is that I have sleep problems, even with meds to help. So I understand some of the challenges you're facing, @Fedupandgrumpy1 Even so, I'm amazed that you think it reasonable to give your neighbour three options and to essentially tell her she's got to choose one of them. She has option 4 too, which is to continue to go about her business which she's absolutely entitled to do.
My neighbour used to leave at 4.30am for work. It took a couple of weeks for me to get used to the dog being let into the garden, doors closing, car starting. Then I slept through it. It would never have occurred to me to ask him to swap shifts or not let the dog into the garden etc. It's part of living on a street with other houses.
I think you need to move bedroom if you can do so you're not overlooking where your neighbour's car is. If not, then thick curtains to block noise, white noise on your phone, ear plugs, whatever you need to do, essentially simply accepting that you're going to wake up for probably 10ish minutes as she leaves for work and training yourself to fall back asleep once she's gone, are what's needed. You don't say how long this has been going on for but I don't think you've given yourself time to get used to the background sounds.
And, quite honestly, you owe your poor neighbour a bunch of flowers and a huge apology. She has a right to go about her business without harassment and your demands aren't far off that.

I completely agree with this.
The only person being unreasonable is you op.
I can’t believe you don’t wear ear plugs but expect your neighbour to either change her working hours, buy a new car or park away from the house!
Heres a suggestion for you, why don’t you move rooms, or even house if you don’t want to wear ear plugs.

iminvestednow · 21/09/2023 23:08

like others have said, there is no way this could be real, no one with an ounce of self awareness could possibly suggest someone change their work hours to suit someone’s entitled lifestyle. You get disability payments specifically to give you extra money to make sure you can afford to make adaptions so you can cope with normal things that others wouldn’t be bothered by. This might include spending money on extra soundproofing or triple glazing. You cannot expect you neighbours to be quiet for the 12hrs you need to sleep! This must be a wind up!

Dora33 · 21/09/2023 23:06

You seem to think your neighbour should make work & expenses changes to suit you but you won't consider wearing ear plugs because you don't like them.
Your neighbour is having to get up very early for work & driving an old car and you think she should be able to buy a new car. Unfortunately many people can't afford to buy new cars.
If inwas your neighbour, I would be avoiding any discussions with you in the future.

Expecting the neighbour to park away from her driveway and walk in the dark to it at 4.30am is unacceptable.
Move your bedroom to a room at the back of your house maybe.

Redglitter · 21/09/2023 23:06

Coulditreallybe · 21/09/2023 22:26

are you neurodivergent @Fedupandgrumpy1 ?

No just an entitled CF

Juicyj1993 · 21/09/2023 23:02

YABVU she has to go to work and you cannot expect her to change her working hours/make a major purchase/put herself in potential danger, for someone who is not her responsibility/is able to sleep in the afternoon/could find their own solution.

Also if you are getting up at 11am, even if she left for work at a more 'normal' time like 8am she would disturb you. Realistically she wouldn't be able to leave for work until atleast 11am (and and make sure she is back by 1030pm) which would limit her options considerably.

isitshe · 21/09/2023 22:59

wildeatheart · 21/09/2023 22:48

Someone please tell me this bullshit is a joke??

Yeah, after reading this reply:

Fedupandgrumpy1 · Today 20:13

I don't have the money to buy her a new car. Mine is on the mobility scheme so I don't even have my own car but appreciate that the scheme helps me. I do know that I wouldn't be able to afford a car myself so I know its not easy, but she does work so should have some spare money.

It sounds like somebody bored and on the wind-up

Justkeepingplatesspinning · 21/09/2023 22:59

I too have a disability and part of it is that I have sleep problems, even with meds to help. So I understand some of the challenges you're facing, @Fedupandgrumpy1 Even so, I'm amazed that you think it reasonable to give your neighbour three options and to essentially tell her she's got to choose one of them. She has option 4 too, which is to continue to go about her business which she's absolutely entitled to do.
My neighbour used to leave at 4.30am for work. It took a couple of weeks for me to get used to the dog being let into the garden, doors closing, car starting. Then I slept through it. It would never have occurred to me to ask him to swap shifts or not let the dog into the garden etc. It's part of living on a street with other houses.
I think you need to move bedroom if you can do so you're not overlooking where your neighbour's car is. If not, then thick curtains to block noise, white noise on your phone, ear plugs, whatever you need to do, essentially simply accepting that you're going to wake up for probably 10ish minutes as she leaves for work and training yourself to fall back asleep once she's gone, are what's needed. You don't say how long this has been going on for but I don't think you've given yourself time to get used to the background sounds.
And, quite honestly, you owe your poor neighbour a bunch of flowers and a huge apology. She has a right to go about her business without harassment and your demands aren't far off that.

Mademetoxic · 21/09/2023 22:58

Troll maybe?

This post is actually really amusing, surely it cannot be real 😂

Twistyemily · 21/09/2023 22:58

How about fitting another layer of double glazing? There must be other noises that disturb you if you usually ned to sleep until quite late in the morning. Maybe some DIY secondary glazing? Can you change bedroom?
I voted YABU because you are asking too much of your neighbour, but it's a real problem for you so worth seeing if there is anything you can do.

isitshe · 21/09/2023 22:57

OP I can't believe you actually said She is making me more poorly.

I really feel for her, just moved house with 3 kids to what may be a new area for them, having to get up at silly-o'clock to work varying shifts only to discover she's got a very unreasonable neighbour making batshit requests.
Asking her to park her car in a road away from the house would have been bad enough on its own but seriously, changing her working hours? replace her car?
In what universe would either of those things be reasonable?
Bonkers.

Petimrose · 21/09/2023 22:56

Can't help but think this has been written by the woman with the car and grossly exaggerated and embellished

Waffle78 · 21/09/2023 22:54

You can't expect her to change her working hours. Get some ear plugs and take some kalms so you stay asleep longer.

Firawla · 21/09/2023 22:53

Sounds like you’re the selfish one - you are being ridiculous and so detached from reality if this is true

Nanny0gg · 21/09/2023 22:51

Fedupandgrumpy1 · 21/09/2023 20:13

I don't have the money to buy her a new car. Mine is on the mobility scheme so I don't even have my own car but appreciate that the scheme helps me. I do know that I wouldn't be able to afford a car myself so I know its not easy, but she does work so should have some spare money.

I don't know what world you live in but it isn't the real one!

You have no idea what calls she has on her income!

OP - who do you live with? Do you have any friends or family around? Have you said any of this to them?

CuriouslyMinded · 21/09/2023 22:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

@Prinnny this made me chuckle! 🤣

wildeatheart · 21/09/2023 22:48

Someone please tell me this bullshit is a joke??

FarEast · 21/09/2023 22:45

I'm not sure what a reverse is but I am being serious. I don't choose to be poorly, but she can choose her job.

Good lord! No you didn’t choose to be chronically I’ll, but why does that mean your neighbour can choose her job? Maybe you’ve never worked so you don’t understand about working. She’s getting up at a godawful hour, and paying her taxes.

You are very unreasonable and selfish, to boot.

Hidiho · 21/09/2023 22:38

Well, here's me thinking my alcoholic jobless ndn causing noisy havoc to our entire cul-de-sac every other night was tough. But, your neighbours car door creaking when she goes off to earn an honest living at that ungodly hour - well, what an utter bitch she is! 🙄

Jesus wept

I get chronic illness and the need for decent sleep - I'm one of those people. But I can't expect my neighbours lives to revolve around me.

I honestly cannot quite believe you demanded she buy a new car and change her hours because her car door creaks and she has to warm it up for 5 mins.

Be thankful you're not having to get up at that time yourself to earn low earnings (to the extent you can't just go out and buy a new car on a neighbours demand!) and keep your kids fed and a roof over their heads.

Get a grip OP. Or go and move out into to the rural sticks where you don't have any neighbours. Just be sure to put a big sign up outside demanding the wildlife change their routines and not wake you up before 11am with their selfish noises!

Pallisers · 21/09/2023 22:38

OP, she isn't being selfish and your requests of her were unreasonable.

That said, they only moved in recently. You WILL get used to the noise and will sleep through it. It will be like when people go on holidays to the countryside and bird/animal noises keep them awake - if you lived there you wouldn't notice.

I lived in an apartment once where trash was collected 3 times a week including one recycling day. On trash days the trucks came by stopping and starting from about 4.30 on. On recycling day, people would come by to go through the recycling for cans that had money back on them - that started around 3.30 followed by the trucks.

First week we were "oh my god". Within a month we didn't even notice the noise.

SemperIdem · 21/09/2023 22:37

Now in fairness, I can empathise with you over the car idling before she goes about her day. It drives me to the absolute brink when people just sit with their cars idling.

There’s not much that can actually be done though.

purdypuma · 21/09/2023 22:34

I don't think you have any idea how ridiculous you sound! I know the answer I'd be giving if you suggested any of those to me.

Your neighbour has to earn a living, she probably doesn't wish to start that early but if that's what it takes to put food on the table then so be it.

Do you plan on buying her a less creaky car? Not everybody has the means to make such a major purchase & she might prefer to spend her money otherwise, not that its any of your business.

Please do not expect to put another female to put her personal safety at risk so that you can get a bit more sleep.

Invest in some earplugs & accept that she lives differently to you. Otherwise move.

F1ymetothetoon · 21/09/2023 22:32

Here for the deletion message cos no way is this real

Oioicaptain · 21/09/2023 22:28

Good attempt, but not good enough.

Tangelablue · 21/09/2023 22:27

I think some posters are being a little harsh. As they have children I would imagine these shifts work well for them to help juggle childcare. The job is likely not well paid so i doubt they are stashing thousands away.
Have you thought about bringing your bedtime forward to 16.00 so you can get 12 hours uninterrupted sleep?
Can you gift them a can of wd40? Or lend then your car?
Sending thoughts and prayers x

Coulditreallybe · 21/09/2023 22:26

are you neurodivergent @Fedupandgrumpy1 ?