Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New Tenants Coming Around

160 replies

Belladonna90 · 21/09/2023 15:26

Not sure if it’s the stress of moving that has made me feel extra sensitive and unreasonable… so please give me a steer!
DP and I are moving into our first home together in two weeks. I’ve given notice on my rental and estate agency did a day of viewings and new tenants have been found. Estate Agent got in touch to see whether new tenants can come around on Saturday to take measurements for their furniture. Feel slightly annoyed by this as I’m in the midst of packing and there are random piles/ boxes everywhere and last thing I want is strangers manouvering around my stuff. The new tenants also know that I’m still living in the property and it’s not empty. Am I being AIBU if I refuse? Thanks all 💕

OP posts:
TrailingLoellia · 23/09/2023 11:26

Lucanus · 23/09/2023 09:44

I said these random people COULD do that. I didn't say they WOULD do it because they are tenants. Nothing to do with their social status as you implied. Total reach on your part.

Incidentally I noticed you also accused the OP of "being a bit of a twat" for refusing access. Maybe look to your own attitude before accusing others.

At least I am judging people based on something they have actually done and not some fear of what they might do. I also don’t believe your protestations that their being tenants had nothing to do with your comments as to their likelihood of being “complete CFs who take half an hour or more. Could move things, break stuff, steal something..”

Belladonna90 · 23/09/2023 09:46

Yeah Fair enough…. Especially if they were burnt before. I guess I keep reverting to how I have behaved when I was viewing rentals in the past. Anytime it was still being occupied by tenants I wouldn’t feel comfortable opening their fridge or asking to come round again to take measurements.

OP posts:
Lucanus · 23/09/2023 09:44

TrailingLoellia · 23/09/2023 09:35

You most certainly did say this about the incoming tenants:
No guarantee they won't be complete CFs who take half an hour or more. Could move things, break stuff, steal something..

I said these random people COULD do that. I didn't say they WOULD do it because they are tenants. Nothing to do with their social status as you implied. Total reach on your part.

Incidentally I noticed you also accused the OP of "being a bit of a twat" for refusing access. Maybe look to your own attitude before accusing others.

TrailingLoellia · 23/09/2023 09:37

LoudAndSqueaky · 23/09/2023 09:32

It's not being a doormat if you do something that you don't mind doing. It honestly wouldn't bother me to let someone look around the house as long as it was at a time that worked for me.

OP, you mentioned that some prospective tenents had obviously opened your fridge and some cupboard doors. I don't think that's surprising as those things are part of the rental.

Most tenants do check kitchen cupboards for signs of rodent and roach infestations. When 1/3rd of private rentals are below standards it is the smart thing to do.

TrailingLoellia · 23/09/2023 09:35

Lucanus · 23/09/2023 09:30

What a ridiculous comment, I said no such thing. OP doesn't know these people and has absolutely no reason to allow them into her home which she is paying for. Nothing to do with them being tenants. She has already been more than obliging in allowing viewings, no reason at all to give up her time for a second viewing.

You most certainly did say this about the incoming tenants:
No guarantee they won't be complete CFs who take half an hour or more. Could move things, break stuff, steal something..

LoudAndSqueaky · 23/09/2023 09:32

It's not being a doormat if you do something that you don't mind doing. It honestly wouldn't bother me to let someone look around the house as long as it was at a time that worked for me.

OP, you mentioned that some prospective tenents had obviously opened your fridge and some cupboard doors. I don't think that's surprising as those things are part of the rental.

Lucanus · 23/09/2023 09:30

TrailingLoellia · 23/09/2023 09:03

What lovely view you have of tenants being cheeky fucker clumsy thieves, not at all a bit of classism in it at all.

What a ridiculous comment, I said no such thing. OP doesn't know these people and has absolutely no reason to allow them into her home which she is paying for. Nothing to do with them being tenants. She has already been more than obliging in allowing viewings, no reason at all to give up her time for a second viewing.

Everywednesday · 23/09/2023 09:18

This shouldn't be an issue because decent landlords leave at least a few days gap between tenancies to get the property checked over and sort out anything that needs doing.
Last time tenants moved out of a property we own ancient Chinese takeaway had to be chipped off the polished wood bedroom floor. I wouldn't expect new tenants to have to deal with that on moving day.

TrailingLoellia · 23/09/2023 09:10

NoSquirrels · 22/09/2023 15:09

Pretty sure there’s a lot of people who haven’t rented in years and years then, and have no idea of the law and tenancy agreement terms. Everyone here saying ‘be nice’ etc or ‘imagine if it was you’ - most renters just don’t get to go back for ‘measuring up’, it’s not a thing. What’s more usual is that a property is shown to tenants when it’s already vacant. The LL sucks up the inconvenience (and cost) of the void period - not expects the outgoing tenant to do them a favour.

The OP really owes nobody anything and it’s not about whether they’re ‘nice’ or not.

It is true most rental properties are shown vacant, but it is also true that most tenants do request a second viewing to do measurements once they know they have secured that property. The need to do measurements doesn’t evaporate if there is a sitting tenant, and it is not uncommon for tenants to request a quick 10-15mins to run around and do measurements. So it is ‘a thing’ even if you haven’t personally done it. As I said my relative has been an estate agent and letting agent for 16yrs so they’ve seen far more sets of tenants as have their colleagues at the estate agent offices than you possibly could have.

The sitting tenant does have the right to refuse access, but that is not really permission to be a bit of a twat.

TrailingLoellia · 23/09/2023 09:03

Lucanus · 22/09/2023 12:14

So many people on this thread sound like complete doormats. As for saying "it's only 10 minutes" - how do you know? No guarantee they won't be complete CFs who take half an hour or more. Could move things, break stuff, steal something - OP doesn't know these people, why would she want them traipsing through her house?

OP has already said no - very unreasonable of the agent to keep pestering her about it.

What lovely view you have of tenants being cheeky fucker clumsy thieves, not at all a bit of classism in it at all.

Perihelion · 22/09/2023 21:44

In Scotland when buying houses, it's standard practice that once an offer is accepted, the buyer doesn't get back in the house till the sale is completed. None of this measuring up visiting.

londonrach · 22/09/2023 21:27

Deposit back every single time....we started to refuse access to anything but maintenance after I found an EA in my underwear drawer...we rented three other places after that...always said no to viewings...full deposit returned each time when we choose to leave and tbh last landlord was amazing and best landlord we ever had.

londonrach · 22/09/2023 21:24

You don't have to allow access ever even if in contact...the agent lucky to allowed them to do a viewing...say sorry they packing and need quiet enjoyment of your home.

DoubleTequilaSunrise · 22/09/2023 21:18

’m n what universe do you have to measure or see space to order a child’s crib?

maybe not crib, but sadly the UK (and possibly other countries I don't know the details of) have our ridiculous "box rooms" which are often too small to fit an actual single bed in. How is that even legal is anyone's guess but there you go.

Just because you never felt the need to do a quick visit before moving day, it doesn't mean other people are not doing it, or at least asking! it's not an outrageous or alien concept. It happens.

Belladonna90 · 22/09/2023 20:47

You sound like a really decent landlord!

OP posts:
pikkumyy77 · 22/09/2023 19:18

Wouldyouguess · 22/09/2023 15:13

If you have zero furniture then yes, it is extremely difficult to sleep on the floor and have no food Id say (no fridge, no hob),especially if people have kids, would you have a 10mo on the floor?
If it only takes 10 minutes to let someone in, it's kinda bitchy and petty to say no to that.

I’m n what universe do you have to measure or see space to order a child’s crib? The hysteria over the notion that the renters need to see and measure the space is just bizarre to me. And I have rented many times before—always unfurnished. Admittedly ive been in a house for the last 27 years but we even rented in between houses and didn’t need to measure. We just jammed in our furniture as we could.

Even if you imagine the scenario where these tenants are moving with no furniture and need to order so what? They can order the bare necessities without measuring and wait for bigger items until later. If they have a poor little wee ten month old or toddler the crib or bed is a standard size snd measurements will not make the given space smaller or larger. They rented the place and have to expect to make do.

Ragwort · 22/09/2023 19:03

I think if you'd made it clearer at the beginning of this thread that you work in A & E and therefore are a busy surgeon/nurse/anaesthetist/porter or whatever the replies would be very different. It's obviously difficult for you to get time off at short notice and your work commitments can clearly over run.

People who work locally or WFH may have (understandably) different expectations.

Cherrysoup · 22/09/2023 17:51

No, EA is being an arse. I don’t think it’s normal to have new tenants come round again once the tenancy has been agreed. As a landlord, I totally expect gaps between tenants, how else can I check the property, make good and issues and ensure it’s properly clean for the next person? I hate disturbing my tenants, they only see me if they want something.

zingally · 22/09/2023 16:39

I'm also a renter, and pretty chill over most things "renting", but I'd say no to this.

"Hi lettings agent person, no, it wouldn't be convenient to have people coming round to measure up with all my own possessions still in-situ. I am in the process of packing and making my own arrangements, so would appreciate the continued quiet enjoyment of my property until the move-out date previous discussed."

OrangesLemonsLimes · 22/09/2023 16:24

Congrats on moving in together OP. Exciting times!

I would probably facilitate it for ten minutes even though I wouldn’t feel obliged to. The tenants are probably quite excited and want to make plans.

I wouldn’t offer to take measurements in case I messed it up 😃

SamphiretheTervosaurReturneth · 22/09/2023 16:15

Womencanlift · 22/09/2023 13:06

For the renters who are firm in not working with the landlord/EA, I wonder how many deposit deductions are made on things that may have just been overlooked in situations like this

Being petty and also goodwill works both ways

The time where I want to stay on the landlords good side is the time when I am just about to get my deposit back

Never. For over a decade now. Deposit protection is a real thing and petty deductions because an agent is annoyed can't happen.

OP is perfectly entitled to say no.

New tenant and agent are perfectly entitled to ask.

The only thing unreasonable so far is the repeat request and trying to push OP into agreeing.

That is the absolute top and bottom of it.

starfishmummy · 22/09/2023 16:10

Belladonna90 · 22/09/2023 13:26

Again thanks everyone so much on how you would approach this. The biggest inconvenience for me is the fact that the estate agency don’t have a key so I have to be at there to let them in which is hard to arrange during working hours. I allowed them two days to conduct viewings even ensuring I had fresh flowers in vases so it looked as presentable as possible! When I got home after the second day of viewing I noticed kitchen cabinet doors were opened and my fridge was not fully closed which means prospective tenants had opened these. I don’t know maybe it’s just me but I would never of dreamed of opening cabinets if tenants were living in situ especially a fridge! My annoyance is that when I explicitly said no that she came back again.

I wonder if the viewers knew you were still living there. I mean they would after they opened the fridge but maybe not beforehand.

Belladonna90 · 22/09/2023 15:43

Everytime I open this thread there is a different perspective so thank you again everyone. Just to add some context, it is a standard two bed new build in the South East. Two large double bedrooms upstairs. Galley kitchen and dining/sitting room which is a big square. Landlord has installed blinds in all the rooms so don’t think they want to come around to measure for curtains etc. all white goods provided by the landlord.

OP posts:
BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 22/09/2023 15:41

For those saying "I'd have no issue with it" - great. Doesn't mean the OP isnt allowed to have an issue with it.

NoSquirrels · 22/09/2023 15:33

Again, the OP doesn't HAVE to do anything, but nothing wrong with being "nice" either. It's more pleasant when the people before you are nice.

We’re just answering the AIBU question posed from different perspectives, I think. I’m answering ‘AIBU to refuse’ from a tenant POV. You’re answering it from a ‘be nice’ POV.

Yes, it’s ‘nice to be nice’ - of course there’s nothing wrong with that. But it’s not ‘nice to be nice’ if it’s genuinely an inconvenience, which it seems it is to the OP. In pure tenancy terms, the OP is NBU to refuse the request.

Nobody is right or wrong.