Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New Tenants Coming Around

160 replies

Belladonna90 · 21/09/2023 15:26

Not sure if it’s the stress of moving that has made me feel extra sensitive and unreasonable… so please give me a steer!
DP and I are moving into our first home together in two weeks. I’ve given notice on my rental and estate agency did a day of viewings and new tenants have been found. Estate Agent got in touch to see whether new tenants can come around on Saturday to take measurements for their furniture. Feel slightly annoyed by this as I’m in the midst of packing and there are random piles/ boxes everywhere and last thing I want is strangers manouvering around my stuff. The new tenants also know that I’m still living in the property and it’s not empty. Am I being AIBU if I refuse? Thanks all 💕

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WasIBad · 26/09/2023 21:54

God this would annoy me! PLEASE don't give in to either demand. Like a pp said - they can have all the access they want when you've moved out. Just because you're moving out doesn't mean that you have to give in to their intrusive demands.

"Dear EA,

As I've said several times now, it's best for us if there are no more visits between now and <moving out date>. This includes having the locks changed. I hope that's clear now.

Regards,
OP"

CardamomGarden · 26/09/2023 21:31

Once you’re into citing your legal rights, you know you’re dealing either with cowboys or idiots. At the last place I rented, a neighbour told me there were viewings while I was at work (I had been told nothing let alone asked, so this came as a surprise) and when I rang the agent they defiantly said they’d continue whether I agreed or not.

‘NO YOU WON’T BECAUSE IT IS AGAINST THE LAW’ was the only thing they finally understood - it was clear they had no prior understanding or familiarity with specific laws. Terrifying!

pikkumyy77 · 26/09/2023 12:01

Belladonna90 · 25/09/2023 21:53

Thank you for this!
Quoting a law is the last thing I want to be doing as I always felt it might come across a bit harsh. It seems though that it might be the only way for them to leave me alone. EA’s like this really give the whole industry a bad name. I really feel sorry for any vulnerable tenants out there.

Stop being so british! Quote the damn law. They would if the positions were reversed.

Belladonna90 · 26/09/2023 09:38

Thank you for this!

OP posts:
Belladonna90 · 25/09/2023 21:53

Thank you for this!
Quoting a law is the last thing I want to be doing as I always felt it might come across a bit harsh. It seems though that it might be the only way for them to leave me alone. EA’s like this really give the whole industry a bad name. I really feel sorry for any vulnerable tenants out there.

OP posts:
GingembreThe · 25/09/2023 17:11

It's normal for letting agents to hold a set of keys for emergency access. They should have security measures though, such as signing the keys in and out, and they should be security keys that can't be copied. I suspect that the manager has only just realised that they don't have a spare set, which is why they want to change the locks. Or, worse, they have lost them...

It's up to you whether you want to agree to the locksmith and the new tenants coming round. Remind the letting agent of your statutory right to quiet enjoyment, that you have been helpful in allowing viewings previously and explain why it is inconvenient (the nature of you job, you are busy with professional exams and moving house). I would also state that you will not allow access to the property when you are not there because it would invalidate your insurance policy. I imagine that will be their next suggestion if you allow the locks to be changed.

That said, isn't the easiest solution to offer to spend 10 minutes taking a few measurements for the tenants with the disclaimer that you cannot guarantee that they are accurate? It would probably take less time than replying to all their emails.

Newestname002 · 25/09/2023 16:38

Write back and tell them to stop harassing you - that they are interfering with your legal "right to quiet enjoyment" of your home.

They cannot just change the locks whilst you are legally in situ. I suspect the issue with keys is that they're aiming to let the new tenants by what is still your home.

They need to give you reasonable notice for agreed maintenance issues (eg emergency tradesmen) and cannot just let people into your home for non/emergencies such as measuring up. 🌹

Rakszasa · 25/09/2023 16:31

By now I'd be complaining, that's rediculous.

Travis1 · 25/09/2023 16:30

I’d send a shitty email back saying you’ve already said no, you will not be shifting on this and any works can be carried out once you leave citing your right to quiet enjoyment of the property as the current paying tennant

SomeCatFromJapan · 25/09/2023 16:24

Just email them back and say they'll have all the access they need once you move out. Contrary to what people are saying here, you do not need to grant them access - it's hardly essential maintenance or a safety issue. And they can't withhold your deposit, as previously discussed, so they have literally no leverage at this point.

Belladonna90 · 25/09/2023 16:10

Update everyone!
EA emailed AGAIN asking what day and time would suit this week?

She also said that they have asked a LockSmith to get in touch to arrange changing my locks. I find it really strange that they want to change the locks whilst I’m in situ. They said they want to have a key to the property. Are they trying to be intimidating? This is really stressing me out when I can do without their emails at this time. Thanks everyone as always

OP posts:
humpty74 · 25/09/2023 10:22

TrailingLoellia · 25/09/2023 09:28

You're the only person on this thread that I've seen making any comment indicating that tenants should be looked at as poor and untrustworthy. Which is pretty hilarious by the way, have you seen how much rent costs?

Dear me, I have quoted Lucanus so many times on multiple posts calling out their anti-tenant view that you actually think their view is my view.

Please go back and re-read the conversation in quote history and you will see it is Lucanus who thinks that and I am the one objecting to it. Ta.

I did read the thread, you're accusing everyone who wouldn't want to let someone they don't know make a repeat visit into their home at an inconvenient time of saying they hate all tenant scum and would never let "lower class, poor untrustworthy" tenants cross their threshold.
The bit in quote marks is what you said, not anyone else...

you know if you unload that chip off your shoulder you might be able to stretch and reach a bit further...

dear me indeed 😂

Frabbits · 25/09/2023 10:17

If the property is unfurnished I think YABU to deny access, for the sake of what will only be 30 minutes of your time.

pizzaHeart · 25/09/2023 10:13

This question is coming up regularly on MN and the general consensus is that unfortunately you have to provide access to the house for viewings ( this essentially counts as a viewing). You can expect 24 hour notice and you being present but that’s about it. That’s why EA is coming back to you all the time she is just doing it politely.
I don’t think that tenants are unreasonable, you just don’t know their circumstances, they probably think that you are very unreasonable not knowing when you are at work or not however in reality you have a specific job circumstances, the same might apply to them.

I didn’t read the whole thread but surely someone reminded you already about your deposit which you probably would want back .

TrailingLoellia · 25/09/2023 09:28

humpty74 · 25/09/2023 09:07

They are unknown people, you have no idea about them. Someone being allowed to rent a property, while obviously a wonderful character reference (not sure why they don't use that instead of enhanced DBS for working with kids- perhaps you should contact your MP to suggest it?) does not mean I would want them in my property when it is inconvenient to me and I am trying to pack. (I don't know them, therefore they are a complete random to me, regardless of the estate agent thinking they're alright to live in a house after putting a hefty deposit down. Why do they take deposits after all their references by the way? surely passing references should be enough to confirm they won't damage the property?)

I would say exactly the same if they were buying the property from the landlord. It has literally nothing to do with them being tenants and everything to do with them being unknown people and it being my home still, not theirs yet.

You're the only person on this thread that I've seen making any comment indicating that tenants should be looked at as poor and untrustworthy. Which is pretty hilarious by the way, have you seen how much rent costs?

You're the only person on this thread that I've seen making any comment indicating that tenants should be looked at as poor and untrustworthy. Which is pretty hilarious by the way, have you seen how much rent costs?

Dear me, I have quoted Lucanus so many times on multiple posts calling out their anti-tenant view that you actually think their view is my view.

Please go back and re-read the conversation in quote history and you will see it is Lucanus who thinks that and I am the one objecting to it. Ta.

RedHelenB · 25/09/2023 09:10

Belladonna90 · 21/09/2023 16:02

Phew! Thought it was just me! Buying a house can totally get but rental?!?!?! There was many times I had to place sheets over windows until curtains arrived etc

So why not do them a good turn and let them measure up. I think yabu its no big deal

humpty74 · 25/09/2023 09:07

TrailingLoellia · 24/09/2023 21:48

The new tenants are not complete randoms. They would not have been offered the tenancy if they had not passed referencing which is quite thorough. They also would not have access to wander around alone. The letting agent will be with them and the OP can also be present.

The OP has the right to say no, but comments about new tenants being complete randoms who could be cheeky fuckers that take a half hour or more and could move, break or steal things is scaremongering and in line with how tenants are looked down on as lower class, poor and untrustworthy.

They are unknown people, you have no idea about them. Someone being allowed to rent a property, while obviously a wonderful character reference (not sure why they don't use that instead of enhanced DBS for working with kids- perhaps you should contact your MP to suggest it?) does not mean I would want them in my property when it is inconvenient to me and I am trying to pack. (I don't know them, therefore they are a complete random to me, regardless of the estate agent thinking they're alright to live in a house after putting a hefty deposit down. Why do they take deposits after all their references by the way? surely passing references should be enough to confirm they won't damage the property?)

I would say exactly the same if they were buying the property from the landlord. It has literally nothing to do with them being tenants and everything to do with them being unknown people and it being my home still, not theirs yet.

You're the only person on this thread that I've seen making any comment indicating that tenants should be looked at as poor and untrustworthy. Which is pretty hilarious by the way, have you seen how much rent costs?

TrailingLoellia · 24/09/2023 21:48

humpty74 · 23/09/2023 11:38

They're complete randoms, they could do that (which I wouldn't want in my home) or they could not (but I also wouldn't want them in my home. It's my home, not theirs!). I don't think it's a comment on them being tenants or otherwise, it's a comment on having no idea who they are and them wanting access to someone else's home.

OP should just say no and not elaborate, I've learned not to get into debates or give reasons, it makes people think you're stating your blockers and are willing to negotiate. "No, not possible, sorry!" And if they come back take 24h to reply, apologise for the delay saying you're very busy and reiterate that the answer is no. You don't have to tell them why.

The new tenants are not complete randoms. They would not have been offered the tenancy if they had not passed referencing which is quite thorough. They also would not have access to wander around alone. The letting agent will be with them and the OP can also be present.

The OP has the right to say no, but comments about new tenants being complete randoms who could be cheeky fuckers that take a half hour or more and could move, break or steal things is scaremongering and in line with how tenants are looked down on as lower class, poor and untrustworthy.

TrailingLoellia · 24/09/2023 21:41

Lucanus · 23/09/2023 12:04

Believe what you want. I'm not 'judging' the new tenants 🙄 If anyone is showing contempt for tenants here it's you and your insistence that when the letting agent says 'jump', OP should say 'how high?' and agree to all their demands, no matter how inconvenient for her.

I’ve been quoting what you said about the incoming tenants verbatim “complete CFs who take half an hour or more. Could move things, break stuff, steal something..” is what you wrote.

But your response to me calling you out on this biased anti-tenant comment is to double down and accuse me of showing contempt for the new tenants by making up something I never said much less insisted on:
“when the letting agent says 'jump', OP should say 'how high?' and agree to all their demands, no matter how inconvenient for her.” - this never happened. You made it up.

Nice one.

pikkumyy77 · 23/09/2023 12:14

Yes, this situation pits Tenant against Tenant so those of us defending OP are definitionally not “anti tenant” or despising tenants because of class bias or something.

Also to the poster who responded to me: I have rented many times and not needed to get in to measure. My response way upthread was to the poster who was disaster mongering with the tear jerking story of little baby-sleeps-on-the-floor because daddy and mummy couldn’t get in to measure.

Lucanus · 23/09/2023 12:04

TrailingLoellia · 23/09/2023 11:26

At least I am judging people based on something they have actually done and not some fear of what they might do. I also don’t believe your protestations that their being tenants had nothing to do with your comments as to their likelihood of being “complete CFs who take half an hour or more. Could move things, break stuff, steal something..”

Believe what you want. I'm not 'judging' the new tenants 🙄 If anyone is showing contempt for tenants here it's you and your insistence that when the letting agent says 'jump', OP should say 'how high?' and agree to all their demands, no matter how inconvenient for her.

gogomoto · 23/09/2023 11:48

I've viewed myself and facilitated others to view, being helpful is good (obviously fitted around your work timetable, wouldn't suggest otherwise)

gogomoto · 23/09/2023 11:44

I'd let them visit, they won't care if you have packing boxes everywhere, they just want to make sure furniture will fit, no big deal.

SomeCatFromJapan · 23/09/2023 11:44

We very kindly facilitated the estate agents, viewers etc when we were due to move out of our rental and the landlady decided to sell. She then decided, two weeks before we were due to move out, that she wanted to change estate agents and send the new lot round to redo the pictures - the place was a half-packed mess of boxes by that point. So we told them they could wait until we were gone and she, and they, had the cheek to sound unhappy about it.

No good deed goes unpunished, as OP is finding out.

humpty74 · 23/09/2023 11:38

TrailingLoellia · 23/09/2023 11:26

At least I am judging people based on something they have actually done and not some fear of what they might do. I also don’t believe your protestations that their being tenants had nothing to do with your comments as to their likelihood of being “complete CFs who take half an hour or more. Could move things, break stuff, steal something..”

They're complete randoms, they could do that (which I wouldn't want in my home) or they could not (but I also wouldn't want them in my home. It's my home, not theirs!). I don't think it's a comment on them being tenants or otherwise, it's a comment on having no idea who they are and them wanting access to someone else's home.

OP should just say no and not elaborate, I've learned not to get into debates or give reasons, it makes people think you're stating your blockers and are willing to negotiate. "No, not possible, sorry!" And if they come back take 24h to reply, apologise for the delay saying you're very busy and reiterate that the answer is no. You don't have to tell them why.

Swipe left for the next trending thread