Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Huge fall out with parents involving DC - am I wrong?

364 replies

Chocpot1986 · 21/09/2023 15:08

Hi all,

Will try and keep it as brief as possible but need an outside outlook on this.

Last week was at my parents with my 3YO DS. He had a massive meltdown when it was time to go home, screaming and crying, getting himself in a state. However just before going home my Mum had got a game out to play with him so naturally he was reluctant to go when it was time. My Dad idolises my DC but doesn’t have a lot of patience when he starts to become a handful. My Dad started swearing a bit and getting annoyed which I asked him not to do. I was very calm and didn’t say much whilst my DS sat on my lap. My DS is still screaming and crying. We were upstairs at this point then moved downstairs. My Dad wanted my DS to put his shoes on so he could walk him to our car (their normal routine when we leave) but DS didn’t want to at that point. My Dad proceeded to be handsy with DS and get him by the arm and pull him towards the sofa - at which point I went berserk and told my Dad to stop it and that he will not do that to my son. Me and my DB used to get a few wallops as kids but I don’t want that for my son. My Mum entered the room and instead of defending me says “well DS shouldn’t be behaving like this”. My Dad did apologise straight away but I was too livid to acknowledge it because he then tells me “you’re too soft”. My Mum is sitting on the sofa trying to comfort my son, starts to cry telling me I have upset her. This made me burst into tears and get very cross whilst asking her what on earth have I done? and we then left the house whilst my DC is sobbing and so am I. My Mum does have a tendency to be a cow at times but still blame the other person. More than once in an argument she is wrong but can’t acknowledge it.

Anyway fast forward a week and I have heard absolutely nothing from them. No message, phone call, knock on the door nothing. Radio silence and it has completely hurt me. I can’t comprehend how you could see your child so upset, know you are the cause and not give it a day, then get in touch? They have both always said if there were a falling out between us they would sort it out, come knock on the door blah blah but yet….zilch.

Generally they are good parents. Had our ups and downs over the years and have butted heads more than once but had a good upbringing overall and a good enough relationship with them now.

What do I do? Continue to leave it or is life too short for this and get in touch with them? I just feel I am not in the wrong here and for once I don’t want to back down from what I am feeling.

Please no nasty replies.
Thanks for reading.

OP posts:
Poppyseed14 · 21/09/2023 16:19

feralunderclass · 21/09/2023 16:16

Gosh that was exhausting to read, worrying that adults cannot regulate themselves and this is a "huge" fallout. You were in the wrong, when he started tantrumming you should have lifted him straight into the car.
My dsis and her DH ascribe to the 'gentle hands' parenting, and their ds goes berserk every time he doesn't get his own way. They both try to 'talk him down' and this drives my DM mad (because it doesn't work) to the extent she isn't keen on having them over.

@feralunderclass your Dsis sounds exhausting 😔

Mischance · 21/09/2023 16:19

A G parent slapped a child of a close relative. They took the child away from the situation. Radio silence for a while, then they contacted saying "We do not hit our children and do not allow anyone else to do so." They came back with a bit of a grovel (at least from Gmother) and no problem since.

You need to draw your lines. Your parents clearly have no concept of what a small person can deal with - under no circumstances should they be criticising your parenting and definitely not in front of the child.

Do not leave your child with them on their own - you must always be there.

Chocpot1986 · 21/09/2023 16:18

Some of you on here have made me feel like I wish I never posted 😔I wish you were able to talk on here rather than typing. So you could get a better feel of the situation and the person.

OP posts:
BelindaBears · 21/09/2023 16:17

GeneralLevy · 21/09/2023 16:16

I’m going to disagree with many posters. I think it’s fine to have a hard line no stance on physical chastising. My dad would wallop me, and it had an impact he’ll never acknowledge. I’m meant to just accept it whilst he is untouchable.
Whilst I can’t change it for me and I’ve let go I will not allow any even trickle of a start of that behaviour towards my child. It starts somewhere and my dad had to learn it was a zero tolerance.
He did in time accept it with my eldest and hasn’t touched my younger ones in anyway I say no to. He got over himself and found other ways to communicate, and accepts now they are lovely well behaved children.
Personally I’d let them stew a bit and keep myself busy. When there’s a natural time for contact don’t rehash it, but if brought up calmly repeat it’s unacceptable in short phrases.

Then you calmly remove your child from that situation and don’t bring them back, you don’t get into a stand up shouting match with him and escalate the situation.

Hungryfrogs23 · 21/09/2023 16:16

MariePaperRoses · 21/09/2023 16:12

You all sound very dramatic. The child will pick up on that.

The moment the child went into a tantrum you should have gathered your things, stuck the kid under your arm and left, calling out 'See you soon!' to your parents and then off you go go your car.

That shows the child the tantrum is unacceptable behaviour and you're going home.

Dithering at your parents as you have now seen leads to everyone getting upset.

Yup, this.

Once they are full tantrum, dithering with them on your knee, moving pointlessly around the house will achieve nothing but aggravate the situation. Pick them up, yell "see you later" and get on with leaving.

feralunderclass · 21/09/2023 16:16

Gosh that was exhausting to read, worrying that adults cannot regulate themselves and this is a "huge" fallout. You were in the wrong, when he started tantrumming you should have lifted him straight into the car.
My dsis and her DH ascribe to the 'gentle hands' parenting, and their ds goes berserk every time he doesn't get his own way. They both try to 'talk him down' and this drives my DM mad (because it doesn't work) to the extent she isn't keen on having them over.

GeneralLevy · 21/09/2023 16:16

I’m going to disagree with many posters. I think it’s fine to have a hard line no stance on physical chastising. My dad would wallop me, and it had an impact he’ll never acknowledge. I’m meant to just accept it whilst he is untouchable.
Whilst I can’t change it for me and I’ve let go I will not allow any even trickle of a start of that behaviour towards my child. It starts somewhere and my dad had to learn it was a zero tolerance.
He did in time accept it with my eldest and hasn’t touched my younger ones in anyway I say no to. He got over himself and found other ways to communicate, and accepts now they are lovely well behaved children.
Personally I’d let them stew a bit and keep myself busy. When there’s a natural time for contact don’t rehash it, but if brought up calmly repeat it’s unacceptable in short phrases.

Chocpot1986 · 21/09/2023 16:16

There is a lot I could say for further context but it is a lot and long! I wanted to avoid that in the first place as people were bound to tell me it was too much. I appreciate the posters who have been sensitive and offered helpful kind words

OP posts:
Luckingfovely · 21/09/2023 16:15

Oh come on - two grown women crying because you asked your Dad not to do something is clearly ridiculous.

Either you're mad drama llamas - or this is a result of childhood trauma, which is then very sad. But you need to do something about it so that you're not causing huge scenes in front of your young child, I gently suggest.

butterpuffed · 21/09/2023 16:14

You were all in the wrong , you and your mum for crying , your dad for getting hold of your son , all because your DS was having a tantrum, which is normal behaviour for a 3year old .

Your mum may be thinking the same as you , wondering why you haven't been in touch , you're both being stubborn .

MyHornCanPierceTheSky · 21/09/2023 16:13

astarsheis · 21/09/2023 16:01

When he started playing you should just put him in the car and gone home. Why let him go through all the drama and it would have shown him that he can't get away with playing up like that.
All a bit too dramatic in front of a 3 year old.

This,and finding the big change from your 'going beserk' to 'actually i was being firm' odd. They're polar opposite!

Iwasafool · 21/09/2023 16:12

Your dad apologised. You didn't even acknowledge his apology. I think it is your turn.

MariePaperRoses · 21/09/2023 16:12

You all sound very dramatic. The child will pick up on that.

The moment the child went into a tantrum you should have gathered your things, stuck the kid under your arm and left, calling out 'See you soon!' to your parents and then off you go go your car.

That shows the child the tantrum is unacceptable behaviour and you're going home.

Dithering at your parents as you have now seen leads to everyone getting upset.

NewName122 · 21/09/2023 16:11

Yabu OP probably due to the trauma of your dad hitting you as a child, It all sounds very dramatic and unnecessary though.

Keroppi · 21/09/2023 16:10

I think you should have just your son up and went to the car - many a time I've had to employ "the rugby hold"!

there's a way of doing it firmly but kindly - repeated countdowns, warnings "we've got two mins left, one min, let's set a timer, when the timer goes off we have to go in the car, lets race with granddad and see whos fastest" but if the child is that far gone into tantrum and distraction etc doesn't work then you just pick up and put in car.

I think just go over and say "well it was all a bit charged last week, next time when he's having tantrums let's give him three warnings and then just quickly leave whilst ignoring the screaming as best as we can, no need for anything more, toddlers are hard ha ha quick subject change.." and move on

do you trust them to have him alone? are you worried abt your dad using physical punishment with your son? maybe this incident triggered you hence the high emotions

GeorgiaGirl52 · 21/09/2023 16:09

Your child is having a screaming tantrum because he doesn't want to go home. Instead of putting him in the car you sit down and comfort him on your lap. He continues to tantrum. Your father tries to help by putting on his shoes - so you can get him to the car. You yell at your father.
There are many people who are not comfortable sitting through a toddler tantrum. I have had to listen to other people's children in grocery stores, restaurants, and movie theaters. I don't hate children and I think they should be allowed to go places. I also believe that parents have the right to be as permissive as they choose. But perhaps next time put him and his shoes briskly in the car and let him tantrum with you in the car instead of letting him upset your parents?

BelindaBears · 21/09/2023 16:08

There sounds like a huge amount of drama from all the adults concerned - you and both your parents. Your DC is behaving age appropriately because they’re 3, the rest of you are not. Swearing, shouting at each other, and crying - none of these are acceptable behaviours to be showing in front of a child IMO.

Iwasafool · 21/09/2023 16:08

Zimunya · 21/09/2023 15:19

I'm not defending your DF at all - roughness / violence towards a young child isn't acceptable, and you were 100% correct to step in and stop it. However, this statement - I can’t comprehend how you could see your child so upset, know you are the cause and not give it a day, then get in touch? - is very one-sided. Your Mum was also crying when you left. Perhaps she feels the same way? Maybe she is waiting for you to get in touch?

That's what I thought.

TripleDaisySummer · 21/09/2023 16:05

Wow - I am shocked that a normal toddler reaction sparked such extreme emotional responses in 3 adults.

This - 3 year old have tantrums I'm also surprised you don't have strategies for managing your parents by now -as well oh no Mum we're leaving in 5 minutes have to do game next time - or done a quick game and a count down to leaving - a firm Dad please leave this to me.

I'd pick up the phone - see if they take the call they may well be waiting for you to calm down and make the first move rather than upset you further.

You also might want to think about meeting in future in a more neutral location park/ indoor play area so you have a bit more control over the situation - it's always harder work in someone else's house.

Theunamedcat · 21/09/2023 16:05

I think I would leave them to simmer your mom crying was the height of manipulation

If your dad gets "handsy" like this in front of you how does he act when your not around?

Why was your mom getting a game out just before you were leaving?

Why couldn't you just scoop up ds and put him in the car Why is the shoe routine important

You crying did not help tbf you should be able to rein it in (although when my pfb cut her lip accidentally I did nearly pass out at the sight of her bleeding so I can on occasion overreact myself 😂)

CheshireCat1 · 21/09/2023 16:04

I’d contact them, tell them that your son loves seeing them and you don’t want the incident to affect any future contact. Set any boundaries for future visits and draw a line under it. If you’d just swooped your child up and put him in your car at the start of this episode it wouldn’t have escalated.

Viviennemary · 21/09/2023 16:03

Your DS was badly behaved and you seemed to do nothing. That can be quite frustrating for onlookers. But your Dad shouldn't have interfered. Both in the wrong. .

LizzieSiddal · 21/09/2023 16:03

Agree with others that that was a whole lot of drama!
However as a granny I can see it from your parents point of view. We have a nearly 3 year old Granddaughter and sometimes when she’s been here for a while (we look after her all day once a week) we’ve have enough, are knackered and just want some peace and quiet and our house back. We have to bit our tongues quite a bit because I want to say things like “Just tell her she’s doing X, you give her too many choices, she’s too young to be making those decisions, she’s confused etc). Maybe your mum and dad had just had enough that day?! (I’ve been there!)

astarsheis · 21/09/2023 16:01

When he started playing you should just put him in the car and gone home. Why let him go through all the drama and it would have shown him that he can't get away with playing up like that.
All a bit too dramatic in front of a 3 year old.

museumum · 21/09/2023 16:00

All three adults lost their cool in different ways there, not a good demonstration to the 3 year old. I think you need to sit down with your parents and talk to them about how you will all handle him being tantrummy in future. You need to all agree.
Personally, I would often put shoes onto my 3yr old myself and carry him from a situation rather than waiting until he was ready to do it himself, I know other parents believe differently. You need to speak calmly to your father about your approach, not 'go berserk' at him.
You and your mum both ending up in tears is way over the top and you both need to talk about how to stay calm if ds is tantrumming.

Swipe left for the next trending thread