Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To require a friend to wear a mask in house when she has a cold?

211 replies

Saboblue · 21/09/2023 13:26

I found out from another friend that she’d been slagging me off for making her wear a mask when she had a cold in my house. When she came round I simply said I’d rather not get a cold and asked her to put on the mask and opened the windows. She was very understanding and put the mask on. I thought nothing of it until I found out she was slagging me off about it when she seemed fine to put it on at the time. I’m pissed off about it because what have I said wrong? Why would I want your virus? Put a mask on when you’re ill and in someone’s house!!

OP posts:
DottyLottieLou · 22/09/2023 09:26

I have been told the opposite by doctors. On their own viruses are too small but viruses travel in droplets which can't get through surgical masks. I'd seriously worry about doctors who don't know this.

DottyLottieLou · 22/09/2023 09:21

You can't avoid a cold. Give your immune system a work out or you'll be coming down with everything going.

MariaVT65 · 22/09/2023 08:57

DameWhiskers · 22/09/2023 08:21

@Everanewbie

If facemasks had the same efficacy as condoms, maybe. Personally I still wouldn't wear one because 1. my immune system needs the stimulation and 2. well I hate them so much that I'd have cold or covid any day of the week.

But I realise not everyone has the same health or attitude to risk that I have. You brought condoms into it, wearing a facemask is like using a fishnet condom.

I recognise that there are different types of face masks. Some work. Enter than others. But a blanket "they don't work" is silly - masks do work. If you don't to wear one, that's fine, but stop spreading misinformation.

In particle terms, masks halt all but the tiniest of particles from getting in (or out) of the mask. Oxygen is tiny; it can move freely, but the Covid virion is stopped as it's far too large (on its own or whether it's carried within a respiratory droplet). Surgical masks are generally 95-98% effective when worn correctly in this regard.

A few of us in the thread have mentioned that we’ve been informed by doctors and scientists that masks don’t protect from viruses, as viruses are still too small to be shielded by a mask.

DameWhiskers · 22/09/2023 08:21

@Everanewbie

If facemasks had the same efficacy as condoms, maybe. Personally I still wouldn't wear one because 1. my immune system needs the stimulation and 2. well I hate them so much that I'd have cold or covid any day of the week.

But I realise not everyone has the same health or attitude to risk that I have. You brought condoms into it, wearing a facemask is like using a fishnet condom.

I recognise that there are different types of face masks. Some work. Enter than others. But a blanket "they don't work" is silly - masks do work. If you don't to wear one, that's fine, but stop spreading misinformation.

In particle terms, masks halt all but the tiniest of particles from getting in (or out) of the mask. Oxygen is tiny; it can move freely, but the Covid virion is stopped as it's far too large (on its own or whether it's carried within a respiratory droplet). Surgical masks are generally 95-98% effective when worn correctly in this regard.

To require a friend to wear a mask in house when she has a cold?
LlynTegid · 22/09/2023 08:11

If you have a cold, maybe the best thing is to not visit? Explain why politely.

Tessisme · 22/09/2023 08:09

If you don't want to risk catching someone's cold, then cancel the meet-up.

Posters keep repeating versions of this. If the guest doesn't tell you they have something contagious, where is the choice to cancel? Do you turn them away at the door based on what shade of red their hooter is? I would like to know in advance if someone is coming to my house to cough and sneeze all over me. Just fecking tell me and I'll decide whether I want your company.

A few years ago, some family members turned up to stay at our house with what they called a cold. They had been staying elsewhere and picked it up there. The people they were staying with offered to let them remain rather than infect us, but no, they didn't wanted to spoil their holiday. So they arrived, with rucksacks, snotty nosed and coughing. A few days later DS1 was on antibiotics and a week after that DP was in hospital with pericarditis and AF, brought about by this 'cold'. So I have no qualms now about telling someone to bugger off and take their germs with them. But I'd prefer to do it by phone call or text, rather than on my doorstep. I do obviously understand that any of us can pick up germs anywhere, but it is very inconsiderate to knowingly bring them into someone's house, thereby increasing their risk.

Dymaxion · 22/09/2023 07:50

If you are immunocompromised then I would have postponed the visit until I was better, but I suppose that massively reduces the drama opportunity !

eastegg · 22/09/2023 07:34

Guiltridden12345 · 21/09/2023 14:18

Sorry this was mid pandemic and no masks! The oldies thought fuck it and preferred normality with risk than a meeting of masks.

Presumably if it was unknowingly, none of you had symptoms? That would reduce the chance of spread, so it’s a different situation. Doesn’t prove it was luck rather than mask which protected the pp.

boobot1 · 22/09/2023 07:19

I think your ridiculous! Covid has really screwed up peoples rational thought processes.

BusyBees1234 · 22/09/2023 07:09

If you're that concerned you should have asked her not to come over

Kwasi · 22/09/2023 07:06

If the pandemic hadn’t happened, would you have thought to ask her to call in at a pharmacy en route to your house to buy a mask?

Vegemiteandhoneyontoast · 21/09/2023 18:05

Everanewbie · 21/09/2023 13:31

Would you have done this pre-March 2020?

A lot of people will find this to be extreme hypochondria but others will say its sensible and back you.

Its your home and you are free to make your own rules, but friend is free to tell people that she thinks you're batty.

I'd say that I am skeptical of the benefits of masks, as they are designed to prevent wound contamination and protect the wearer from blood splatters, and nothing to do with respiratory viruses. So yes, YABU to insist on a mask and maybe if you were that worried, you should have met outside or not at all?

I would like to have done it pre-2020, that's for sure. Some years ago, we invited a 'friend' for dinner and it was only once he was sat at the table with a drink in front of him that he told us he was just starting a stinker of a cold. OH caught it and was quite unwell but because we're both self-employed and get no sick pay, he carried on going to work. He works on his own outside so at least didn't spread it himself. The friend works for a company so took the week off and told us he spent most of it sleeping. We called him Salary Man for a while.

margotrose · 21/09/2023 17:58

HateLongCovid · 21/09/2023 16:01

Everyone saying "Oh it's only a cold". Isn't that what everyone reckons Covid often feels like now? Who is to say she hadn't got Covid which can still make many people seriously ill and even be fatal.My daughter is only young and was seriously ill last time she had covid and is now very poorly with Long Covid. I wouldn't want anyone visiting my house with a cold that could turn out to be Covid, thank you very much. Oh but I'm just over reacting wanting to keep my child safe.

If you don't want to risk catching someone's cold, then cancel the meet-up.

Making them wear a piece of fabric over their mouth and nose won't make their presence any less risky.

readbooksdrinktea · 21/09/2023 17:52

People should stay away from other people's houses when they're ill.

Tribblesarelovely · 21/09/2023 17:50

Annaishere · 21/09/2023 13:38

I wear a mask if I have respiratory symptoms and need to go to someone’s house. And wear one if visiting people with colds. I don’t think you’re unreasonable I would ask the same of people

Unless you don’t touch any surfaces at all , wearing a mask is a waste of time.

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 21/09/2023 17:43

Wtf

jlpth · 21/09/2023 17:33

SunRainStorm · 21/09/2023 17:21

I think she's a twat to show up at your house with a cold.

I can't fucking stand people who take their illnesses on tour, throwing their germs around like confetti and then moaning that other people haven't been hospitable to them.

If you're sick, stay home. No one wants what you've got.

OP, it's your house. If she had a problem with the mask she should have said so at the time or taken herself home.

Indeed.

tiredofthenoise · 21/09/2023 17:22

I hate having a cold and would hope people would stay away if they're contagious, but it simply wouldn't occur to me to ask a guest to wear a mask. Either invite them in and accept you may catch the cold or ask them to stay out of the house. Maybe take a walk together instead?

SunRainStorm · 21/09/2023 17:21

I think she's a twat to show up at your house with a cold.

I can't fucking stand people who take their illnesses on tour, throwing their germs around like confetti and then moaning that other people haven't been hospitable to them.

If you're sick, stay home. No one wants what you've got.

OP, it's your house. If she had a problem with the mask she should have said so at the time or taken herself home.

Callyem · 21/09/2023 17:20

When you say 'slagged you off' do you mean she mentioned it in a 'can you believe...' kind of way or actually made nasty remarks about you?

I think I'd have complied at the time (out of surprise more than anything) but had a little laugh about it later.

GoryBory · 21/09/2023 17:19

Crazyjanes · 21/09/2023 16:09

I would have been understanding in the moment too but probably giggled about you to a friend after.

So you’re too cowardly to speak up for yourself but would happily bitch about your ‘friend’ behind their back?

It doesn’t matter whether it’s putting on a mask, taking off your shoes or only sitting on a certain chair.

If you have a problem with it, say it at the time.

Don’t be fake and slag them off to someone else.

Hufflemuff · 21/09/2023 17:17

Oh for goodness sake... either have her over or don't with a cold. Putting on a mask is just pathetic. Even if my BEST friend requested this of me I'd call them a lemon and say ill be back when the cold has passed.

Mumof118 · 21/09/2023 17:13

Humans have been catching colds forever and it’s what gives us our immunity. If you really didn’t want her cold, you should have said ‘let’s wait until you’re feeling a little better’, not still have her over and ask her to wear a (useless) mask. I’d probably have been polite to your face, but told others about the request too. It’s bonkers to be honest.

Mysonwontwash · 21/09/2023 16:58

We probably wouldn’t be friends. I tend to avoid neurotic people 😁
Obviously if someone in your home was severely compromised and I had no choice but to enter with a cold I would with no question but mask wearing over the sniffles is just weird.

Hbh17 · 21/09/2023 16:51

Not sure whether this is hypochondria or paranoia, especially as masks don't work. We all get colds, although fewer as we get older - they're annoying, but not a big deal, and you're just as likely to catch one in a shop or on a bus/train. It would be nice, OP, if you could be more welcoming to your friends.