Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for a head count as to how many mumsnetters don’t believe that climate change is caused by human activity?

236 replies

workingtowards · 21/09/2023 13:13

There was a thread on MN many years ago, when a good proportion thought climate change was just weather/natural, so it would be interesting to know if views have changed.

YANBU: Yes human activity is causing climate change
YABU: No climate change is natural and there’s nothing we can do about it

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Laiste · 21/09/2023 13:48

That is far more important than the Non judgemental classes beating up the developed world in praise of the "noble savage'.

What does this mean? Please and thank you. Genuinely. I've read it 5 times and i don't understand.

GasPanic · 21/09/2023 13:47

Conferenceblues · 21/09/2023 13:36

But the year without a summer wasn’t climate change in an ongoing sense - it was intense and brief climate change caused by volcanic activity. Then the disruption from the eruption cleared and things went back to normal. That’s not what’s happening now.

Because it wasn't big enough, or long enough duration.

If we had a VEI 8 eruption (Tambora was VEI 7 I think), or a continuous process of volcanic eruption (for example Deccan Traps), it could change the climate for a much longer period. There's no guarantee this won't happen tomorrow, or maybe nothing will happen for another 100,000 years.

There is no such thing as "normal" in terms of climate. It's changed throughout the Earths history and will continue to change, on top of any effects that we may cause.

Climate has also changed "naturally", rapidly and permanently in the past due to things like meteorite strikes/asteroid impacts. It can happen pretty much instantaneously, and there is nothing we can do to stop it. But generally these events are very improbable, the chances of them happening in maybe the next 1000 years is pretty low, whereas the probability that humans may have a rapid and significant effect on climate in the next 1000 years if our activities continue is far higher.

CampsieGlamper · 21/09/2023 13:44

Does it matter if it is all or part of not due to humans? Climate change is happening and has been happening since the start of "climate".

What matters is if humans can have an effect on it, and how humans and countries can live with it. That is far more important than the Non judgemental classes beating up the developed world in praise of the "noble savage'.

Conferenceblues · 21/09/2023 13:43

EasternStandard · 21/09/2023 13:40

Isn’t there a scientific take on this?

A consensus that’s it’s to do with humans

I thought that had been suggested

Anyway I’d say the acceleration is human related

Yes, there is. As quoted earlier, 97% of scientists working in this area believe in man-made climate change

Conferenceblues · 21/09/2023 13:42

Laiste · 21/09/2023 13:38

I mean … I guess. It kind of sucks for all the other species though. How is it karma for them? It’s not some sort of divine retribution, it’s just fucking things up.

I suppose it depends weather you look at it from a moral point of view. I'm not saying we shouldn't try to avoid changing the climate by the way. I do do my bit. I recycle, no flying, walk as much as poss. ect I take it all on board.

But the ice age made certain species die out. Answer: but that was nature.
WE are 'nature' too though aren't we? We evolved here and I think we'll kill ourselves off.

Of course, extinction is inevitable, and generally the more evolved a species is the quicker it dies out. But the mass extinction wave we’re in now isn’t natural or karma, it’s because of human activity and it’s happening way faster than ice-age led extinctions and it’s happening all over the world. We may make ourselves extinct but I think we have a better chance of surviving us than the vast majority of other species.

BillStickersWillBeProsocuted · 21/09/2023 13:41

Natural climate change at it's fastest in the last 20000 changed the temperature by about 1 degree every 1000 years. It’s been much slower for the last 10000 or so years. Until we started burning fossil fuels. Since then its risen by 1 degree in 100 years, so we've accelerated it by at least 10x - and it's only going up rather than fluctuating.

EasternStandard · 21/09/2023 13:40

Isn’t there a scientific take on this?

A consensus that’s it’s to do with humans

I thought that had been suggested

Anyway I’d say the acceleration is human related

Laiste · 21/09/2023 13:38

I mean … I guess. It kind of sucks for all the other species though. How is it karma for them? It’s not some sort of divine retribution, it’s just fucking things up.

I suppose it depends weather you look at it from a moral point of view. I'm not saying we shouldn't try to avoid changing the climate by the way. I do do my bit. I recycle, no flying, walk as much as poss. ect I take it all on board.

But the ice age made certain species die out. Answer: but that was nature.
WE are 'nature' too though aren't we? We evolved here and I think we'll kill ourselves off.

Stripeypyjamas · 21/09/2023 13:37

I think the rapid increase is definitely caused by us but we have very little power to do anything about it ... until the right man sets to make money out of it, that's the only way we will see change.

Bored1000 · 21/09/2023 13:37

I think mainly natural, has been happening for millions of years, ice age etc

It might be slightly aggravated by human behaviour though

BorgQueen · 21/09/2023 13:36

Plastic is a bigger enviromental problem than Humans affecting the climate.
We are all ingesting microplastics, it’s killing marine life.

Why isn’t banning plastic top of the agenda?

Conferenceblues · 21/09/2023 13:36

GasPanic · 21/09/2023 13:31

Look up the "year without a summer".

Climate change can happen "naturally" very quickly as well.

But the year without a summer wasn’t climate change in an ongoing sense - it was intense and brief climate change caused by volcanic activity. Then the disruption from the eruption cleared and things went back to normal. That’s not what’s happening now.

LemonQuiche · 21/09/2023 13:35

Its both.

The climate changes naturally and would do if humans didn’t exist. However, human activity is definitely contributing to climate change.

TooOldForThisNonsense · 21/09/2023 13:35

I think it is both. Climate change does occur but human activity has accelerated it. Ultimately does it matter? What happens is trying to mitigate it as best we can which is clearly down to humans.

Ohyournotwearingadress · 21/09/2023 13:33

Not voting as I think it’s a mix of both. Huge environmental disasters like volcanic eruptions in my opinion spew much much more but I do think it’s time for us to help BUT by us I mean the whole world.

I get really frustrated at the things we in uk are expected to be doing when the US and China pollute soooooo much.

Conferenceblues · 21/09/2023 13:33

Laiste · 21/09/2023 13:27

accelerated climate is not good for anything on the planet

Or maybe in a weird way it's karma/evolution/natures way to despatch of humans quicker?

I mean … I guess. It kind of sucks for all the other species though. How is it karma for them? It’s not some sort of divine retribution, it’s just fucking things up.

londonrach · 21/09/2023 13:33

Abit of both!

Laiste · 21/09/2023 13:32

But it’s not just affecting us it affects lots of other species detrimentally too

Yes, i don't disagree.

Conferenceblues · 21/09/2023 13:31

Wtf? 23% of people don’t agree with that humans are driving climate change. This makes me despair.

There are 7 billion humans consuming and pumping out fossil fuels. I don’t understand how anyone could think that’s not influencing the climate. Of course climate changes naturally but very slowly - what’s happening now is is on a completely different scale.

Cathyt90 · 21/09/2023 13:31

Historical climate change took millions of years. Since the industrial revolution we have compressed climate change into decades. There is more energy in the climate system than it can naturally balance, and ecosystems cannot adapt this quickly. There is consensus amongst world scientists on this. But still the narrative that 'it's natural' is trotted out by sceptics and those who have bought the wilful misdirection of the fossil fuel industry.

GasPanic · 21/09/2023 13:31

Treebark · 21/09/2023 13:27

It's the rate of climate change that is the issue. I don't know why people can't see this - changes which took thousands of years when driven by natural processes are now happening much quicker because of human activity.

That's the bit no one ever seems to grasp. Yes change is natural. Very fast change is not natural and is driven by human activity.

HTH

Look up the "year without a summer".

Climate change can happen "naturally" very quickly as well.

Laiste · 21/09/2023 13:31

We came, we fucked it up for ourselves, we died off pretty quick, planet returns to it's normal ebb and flow being hit by meteors every few million years ect.

We're a short episode in Earths story. We've only been here a blink of an eye. It will outlive us.

CurlewKate · 21/09/2023 13:30

I'm not an expert. So I will go with 97% of the scientific community and say yes, climate change is man made.

Afternoonteaandicecream · 21/09/2023 13:29

Or maybe in a weird way it's karma/evolution/natures way to despatch of humans quicker?

But it’s not just affecting us it affects lots of other species detrimentally too

BillStickersWillBeProsocuted · 21/09/2023 13:29

I think this illustrates really well the difference between natural fluctuations in the earths temperature and what's happened in the last 100 years or so

https://xkcd.com/1732/

Earth Temperature Timeline

https://xkcd.com/1732

Swipe left for the next trending thread