Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for a head count as to how many mumsnetters don’t believe that climate change is caused by human activity?

236 replies

workingtowards · 21/09/2023 13:13

There was a thread on MN many years ago, when a good proportion thought climate change was just weather/natural, so it would be interesting to know if views have changed.

YANBU: Yes human activity is causing climate change
YABU: No climate change is natural and there’s nothing we can do about it

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Hellokittymania · 21/09/2023 14:35

I live in a part of Greece that was affected by wildfires in July, and then a flood a few weeks ago. Both were terrible. In fact, on 27 July, the worst fire in all of Greece was in my area, it led to an ammunition, warehouse explosion, but apart from a report on the BBC, which did show this, guess what everything else was talking about, the fires in the tourist hotspots.

in the videos from the floods, which have been on social media, people who don’t live in Greece, or commenting along the lines of, that’s a Manchester… Summer in the UK… Etc. Really stupid things to say. I have lived in the UK, and I have also lived in Greece, and anyone who thinks that the weather this summer is “normal“ she’ll think again. This was not normal, many people were not prepared for a flood of this scale, it has never happened before. I am amazed with the comments people can come out with…

Laiste · 21/09/2023 14:34

@verdantverdure 😂 You certainly wont get a thankyou

But seriously - when i look at the massive pollution caused by industry i wonder what difference me using my net bag for apples in Tesco really has.

I know ''if everyone does their bit then this and this will happen ...'' ect ect. But - can the little people really drive change with our spending habits alone? As i said earlier, we can buy less literal cheap tat from china, but the microchips which run cars, phones, laptops - no one is going to stop buying them.

Also, look at the amount of people who'll say yes, they're worried about the climate and want an electric car, but rip out 'dated' kitchens for new ones as soon as they move house. Or buy a shit tonne of laminate flooring rather than put up with a worn carpet. Or buy loads of plastic camping equipment and drive a big 4x4 to france a couple of times a year and be smug they're not flying.

verdantverdure · 21/09/2023 14:28

We don't have time to mess about do we @Boyonthenres?

Boyonthenres · 21/09/2023 14:26

verdantverdure · 21/09/2023 14:20

Climate can't be like Brexit.

We can't let the people who don't understand how any of it works and haven't tried to, but inexplicably think they know better than the experts stop us doing the necessary.

We don't have time to indulge them.

We have to do what needs to be done and save them whether they like it or not.

I SO agree with this

verdantverdure · 21/09/2023 14:26

verdantverdure · 21/09/2023 14:22

We're doing climate deniers a favour really aren't we?

If we do what needs to be done and prevent climate change getting dramatically worse the climate change deniers can bang on like they did about Y2K that it was all a big hoax and they knew nothing bad was going to happen .

They love a bit of that. Grin

Like when climate deniers say global warming isn't real because we're not having a heatwave where they are today.

They love a bit of that.

verdantverdure · 21/09/2023 14:22

We're doing climate deniers a favour really aren't we?

If we do what needs to be done and prevent climate change getting dramatically worse the climate change deniers can bang on like they did about Y2K that it was all a big hoax and they knew nothing bad was going to happen .

They love a bit of that. Grin

loverofpants · 21/09/2023 14:20

Climate change is a natural phenomenon and has always happened. Anthropogenic climate change is the accelerating change seen since the 1800s and post industrialisation. The key is the word "change" - it doesn't mean heating up necessarily. However the world is heating up at the fastest rate it ever has been and the impacts, both environmental and societal, are huge.

verdantverdure · 21/09/2023 14:20

Climate can't be like Brexit.

We can't let the people who don't understand how any of it works and haven't tried to, but inexplicably think they know better than the experts stop us doing the necessary.

We don't have time to indulge them.

We have to do what needs to be done and save them whether they like it or not.

Laiste · 21/09/2023 14:18

The chinese import issue - microchips for example. How will it stop?

How many of you/us are willing or able to not buy a replacement laptop, PC, tablet or phone until there's a guarantee that the parts are all made here?
That's a loooooong way off.

verdantverdure · 21/09/2023 14:16

There's nothing you can do with denialists.

The facts have been established for fifty years.

My mum's friend doesn't believe in climate change and says she doesn't care anyway because she'll be dead before it all happens.

She also complained bitterly about how hot she was in her retirement flat last summer during the record breaking heatwaves and about how someone should sort it out.

Littlechickenleg · 21/09/2023 14:15

I tend not to believe what they say tbh. On the 60s and 70s we were told we were going to enter an ice age. Now they say its heating up.
I think as a species we are culpable for lots of negative impact on the environment, such as pollution and destruction of habitat. But I think the earth as a whole, has it's cycle which, apart from meteor strikes and pole reversal, is not affected by us.
Just my opinion.

InYourHeadZombieeeaeaeaea · 21/09/2023 14:15

Climate change is natural phenomena but we are considerably speeding our cycle up.

Lakeyloo · 21/09/2023 14:14

I think both.... it's evolution and the world has been through these cycles for millions of years, but I think we are accelerating it. You can't keep taking out of the earth and spewing the wrong stuff back into it without something giving.

verdantverdure · 21/09/2023 14:13

Yes climate change is man-made.

Yes it's real.

Yes it's going to fuck us all over if we don't get to Net Zero sharpish.

No, banning things that don't exist such as a "meat tax" and "compulsory car sharing" wont help any of us.

Or our children.

verdantverdure · 21/09/2023 14:10

I think like we need more memes that say something like

"Wild fires after record breaking heatwaves...COINCIDENCE????!!!!"

Laiste · 21/09/2023 14:10

hattie43 · 21/09/2023 14:02

I think it's natural evolution and it's the human race time to die out , like the dinosaurs. I don't think anything we do will alter the passage of nature and nor should it .
The human race is evil .

Although i agree with your first sentence i don't agree about the 'evil' bit. But then i'm not religious and don't really hold with the concept of evil as such.

We evolved here on earth just like all the other animals. We right now are a product of the earth, if you like, just as much as a tiger or a dinosaur. Ultimately will save ourselves (and fewer other species will die out as a result) or not.

Crunchingleaf · 21/09/2023 14:08

We have to consume less.

Thing is I don’t think leaving Climate Change can be slowed down solely by public buy in. Many will never but in and others will only do what is easy for them. Yet many multinational corporations are out there doing what they like and making more money then ever. We don’t need cheap tat from China. We should not be importing beef from places like Brazil who are destroying the Amazon rainforest to make way for cows. It’s seems like the plan in many parts of developed world is to reduce emissions but continue living a consumerist lifestyle by raising emissions elsewhere.

Climate change isn’t the only problem we are facing we have problems with biodiversity and we are probably all being poisoned by micro plastics.

Boyonthenres · 21/09/2023 14:06

EasternStandard · 21/09/2023 13:40

Isn’t there a scientific take on this?

A consensus that’s it’s to do with humans

I thought that had been suggested

Anyway I’d say the acceleration is human related

Suggested? 97% of all scientists globally agree that the current rapid warming is human led.

Boyonthenres · 21/09/2023 14:04

Conferenceblues · 21/09/2023 13:31

Wtf? 23% of people don’t agree with that humans are driving climate change. This makes me despair.

There are 7 billion humans consuming and pumping out fossil fuels. I don’t understand how anyone could think that’s not influencing the climate. Of course climate changes naturally but very slowly - what’s happening now is is on a completely different scale.

Totally agree, like what will it take for people to see it?? I completely despair, I find it so hard to comprehend the wilful obtuseness of some posters

hattie43 · 21/09/2023 14:02

I think it's natural evolution and it's the human race time to die out , like the dinosaurs. I don't think anything we do will alter the passage of nature and nor should it .
The human race is evil .

TheLeadbetterLife · 21/09/2023 13:54

Ohyournotwearingadress · 21/09/2023 13:33

Not voting as I think it’s a mix of both. Huge environmental disasters like volcanic eruptions in my opinion spew much much more but I do think it’s time for us to help BUT by us I mean the whole world.

I get really frustrated at the things we in uk are expected to be doing when the US and China pollute soooooo much.

China pollutes sooooo much making stuff for the rest of the world. Everything from the microchips in our phones to the plastic tat in our Christmas stockings. It’s our pollution as much as, possibly more than, it is theirs.

We have to consume less.

Conferenceblues · 21/09/2023 13:54

GasPanic · 21/09/2023 13:47

Because it wasn't big enough, or long enough duration.

If we had a VEI 8 eruption (Tambora was VEI 7 I think), or a continuous process of volcanic eruption (for example Deccan Traps), it could change the climate for a much longer period. There's no guarantee this won't happen tomorrow, or maybe nothing will happen for another 100,000 years.

There is no such thing as "normal" in terms of climate. It's changed throughout the Earths history and will continue to change, on top of any effects that we may cause.

Climate has also changed "naturally", rapidly and permanently in the past due to things like meteorite strikes/asteroid impacts. It can happen pretty much instantaneously, and there is nothing we can do to stop it. But generally these events are very improbable, the chances of them happening in maybe the next 1000 years is pretty low, whereas the probability that humans may have a rapid and significant effect on climate in the next 1000 years if our activities continue is far higher.

Well of course if there was a massive volcanic eruption of the scale that would be disastrous. I don’t see what relevance that has to what’s being discussed now though. The year without a summer was brought up to demonstrate that extreme climate change doesn’t have to be human-driven. Well sure - but the current climate change we’re experiencing can’t be explained by natural events like volcanos, so that’s not an argument that what we’re currently going through isn’t human driven.

We can’t (or probably can’t) protect ourselves from very unlikely but possible disasters like massive volcanic activity or asteroids, but we could protect ourselves from the human-driven changes we are seeing now.

IsleofDen · 21/09/2023 13:53

I think we have exacerbated climate change and we should take responsibility for that, but we didn’t create it.

I also hate the “save the planet” rhetoric. The planet will be fine, life will survive, or return. It’s humanity that needs to save itself from extinction.

Laiste · 21/09/2023 13:52

@Conferenceblues yes, the thought of the amount of species we take with us (dead) makes me sad, but not us dying out. That doesn't make me sad. It probably should!

I do believe the planet will go on after us.

BlueVinca · 21/09/2023 13:50

CurlewKate · 21/09/2023 13:30

I'm not an expert. So I will go with 97% of the scientific community and say yes, climate change is man made.

Me too