Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for a head count as to how many mumsnetters don’t believe that climate change is caused by human activity?

236 replies

workingtowards · 21/09/2023 13:13

There was a thread on MN many years ago, when a good proportion thought climate change was just weather/natural, so it would be interesting to know if views have changed.

YANBU: Yes human activity is causing climate change
YABU: No climate change is natural and there’s nothing we can do about it

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
foolsgolddigger · 21/09/2023 22:49

I follow the scientific consensus as that is the rational position, but retain a healthy degree of skepticism.
What I find weird is that there is very little research into and discussion of possible benefits of climate change.

Oioicaptain · 21/09/2023 22:42

Laist is absolutely correct. Both statements are true.

There have been many natural weather phenomenons over millions of years. However, it has only been comparitivly 'recently' that we have entered the 'goldilocks zone' where weather conditions have stabilized and enabled the human race and life to flourish. Now, human activity has caused the scales to tip again out of that stable zone.

Antinori86 · 21/09/2023 22:16

I do indeed, well done.

But I agree, I think he is straightforwardly oblivious/insulated and straightforwardly nasty. No matter how mild mannered he appears.

Papyrophile · 21/09/2023 22:13

Sez you @Antinori86 . I won't vote for him, but I do think he holds his beliefs straightforwardly.

Antinori86 · 21/09/2023 22:01

Rishi genuinely doesn't care if the world burns, as long as his tired, fractious, entitled party of none of the talents wins the next election.

He knows that he and his family have enough wealth to insulate themselves from the very real and current (let alone future) impacts of climate change in the way ordinary people do not.

He is a nasty little man heading up a nasty little party.

Papyrophile · 21/09/2023 21:58

I have one DC, and they're currently adamant that there will never be a GC.

SpringViolet · 21/09/2023 21:55

Let’s face it the only way we’re going to solve this issue is by reducing the amount of us humans. There is way too many of us consuming, polluting, using energy to continuously improve our lifestyles (which is not a bad thing but too much is needed).

In planetary terms, we’re pretty much like a plague of locusts!

Single child families might be a way to go? Impossible to enforce though as we don’t want to end up with a dystopian nightmare with forced abortion, hidden children etc. Education wouldn’t work. Financial incentives for sterilisation after the first child? Still pretty unpalatable to most but I guess we need to balance it with having a planet able to sustain fewer people or none at all.

If the 8 billion people on the planet now were replaced by 4 billion and those 4 billion replaced by 2 billion and so on would it work? Obviously the figures would be out for a couple of hundred years due to age ranges of current population.

<ho hum, I have 4DC but I’ve already told them that they should only have 1DC each!>

Papyrophile · 21/09/2023 21:46

A delay is sensible. Most of the EU has set 2035 as the big cut off deadline for ICE cars.

From a rural person, there needs to be a balance. We don't have much public transport. Most of it doesn't go anywhere you need to visit, especially if you have a timed appointment, so it's irrelevant to everyday life. It stops after 5.00 pm, and the routes don't prioritise the supermarket run.

For us, it takes 35-40 minutes to drive to the hospital. Double that for public transport. So no, public transport can never deliver an acceptable level of service at an affordable cost outside a metropolitan area.

ShipSpace · 21/09/2023 21:46

Of course we are. As a species, we are.

If the worst comes to the worst and we cannot achieve the communication and collaboration needed to find ways to survive, then as a species, we do not have the capability to continue.

verdantverdure · 21/09/2023 21:41

ShipSpace · 21/09/2023 21:35

In the face of extinction a species does what it can, within the realms of it’s capabilities, to survive.

Humans will do the same.

And if the species can survive, it will. If it can’t, it can’t. Other species will survive and the circle of life will continue.

Does it though?

Cos we're not.

ShipSpace · 21/09/2023 21:35

In the face of extinction a species does what it can, within the realms of it’s capabilities, to survive.

Humans will do the same.

And if the species can survive, it will. If it can’t, it can’t. Other species will survive and the circle of life will continue.

PaperWalkAndTalk · 21/09/2023 21:30

Climate change is real and man-made and thinking that delaying a ban on petrol cars until 2035 is sensible does not make me a climate-change denier.

Papyrophile · 21/09/2023 21:29

So @verdantverdure, if you and I (and millions like us) refrain from environmentally unsound misbehaviour, which I/we do strive for, where does the pressure come from in the developing world? I think most (much) of the Northern Hemisphere and the nicer temperate parts of the Southern Hemisphere are on board with you. But in between there are millions of people suddenly equipped with smartphones and facebook who have seen the life in better governed areas, and would prefer to move. That moves the goalposts, big time.

Boyonthenres · 21/09/2023 21:28

Parky04 · 21/09/2023 21:15

I'm not a climate change denier, I just don't give a toss. Net Zero bollocks should be scrapped instead of delayed!

Why do you not give a toss? Are you in your senior years? Without young family? Just curious as to why you care so little

MiniBossFromAus · 21/09/2023 21:27

Parky04 · 21/09/2023 21:15

I'm not a climate change denier, I just don't give a toss. Net Zero bollocks should be scrapped instead of delayed!

Do you have a child/ren?

Boyonthenres · 21/09/2023 21:27

Libertass · 21/09/2023 21:25

Our climate has always changed. The Romans grew grapes in the north of England, which is just about possible today. The Victorians skated & held ‘frost fairs’ on the frozen solid Thames, which is completely unthinkable today. And that’s just the U.K.

Is our climate getting warmer? Yes, of course it is. Everyone can see that and to attempt to deny it would be ridiculous.

Is that evident warming solely or mainly as a result of human activity, rather than the natural cycles of the planet? And can any changes we make now affect that rate of warming in any significant way? Those are completely different questions, and ones to which I have yet to be convinced that the answers are yes & yes. So I am both sceptical and open minded on the subject.

Literally 97% of scientists globally agree that the warming is man made, what exactly would convince you?

We surely have to at least try to slow it down ?

Libertass · 21/09/2023 21:25

Our climate has always changed. The Romans grew grapes in the north of England, which is just about possible today. The Victorians skated & held ‘frost fairs’ on the frozen solid Thames, which is completely unthinkable today. And that’s just the U.K.

Is our climate getting warmer? Yes, of course it is. Everyone can see that and to attempt to deny it would be ridiculous.

Is that evident warming solely or mainly as a result of human activity, rather than the natural cycles of the planet? And can any changes we make now affect that rate of warming in any significant way? Those are completely different questions, and ones to which I have yet to be convinced that the answers are yes & yes. So I am both sceptical and open minded on the subject.

verdantverdure · 21/09/2023 21:18

Papyrophile · 21/09/2023 21:09

It's an interesting question. But from our local environment, which was from 1750 - 1850, one of the most intensively industrialised/mined parts of the world, and which is now a SSSI and a protected AONB, I would put my money on the ability of the planet to recover, and also, on the ingenuity of humanity to repair the damage.

The planet will be fine.

It has survived worse than us.

But how much suffering do you want to inflict on our children, on future generations and on us for the rest of our lives?

It's just not sensible to make our home unliveable is it?

It's car up on bricks, sofa on the front lawn, taking a shit on your own lawn on steroids

Parky04 · 21/09/2023 21:15

CalistoNoSolo · 21/09/2023 20:47

Holy shit. I had no idea there were so many climate change deniers on MN. Wow.

I'm not a climate change denier, I just don't give a toss. Net Zero bollocks should be scrapped instead of delayed!

Boyonthenres · 21/09/2023 21:13

IslaWinds · 21/09/2023 21:09

Climate change does happen naturally and humans are also affecting the climate on top of the natural cycles.

It’s sort of like climate change is a little fire and we have just dumped a barrel of petrol on it to make a massive bonfire.

The natural climate change can cause all manner of natural disasters. For example the flood in Libya wasn’t the first flood to hit the north coast of Africa as there are records of historic floods from thousands of years ago that have literally sunk cities beneath the sea- which under sea archaeologists have been excavating. Great Britain got cut off from mainland Europe by a tsunami sinking Doggerland beneath the sea. Sea levels have fallen and risen. Deserts have expanded and contracted. The western hemisphere has the El Niño cycle. Natural climate change has also caused species to go extinct- even before humans existed the fate of 97% of species was extinction at some point in time.

Human activity creating emissions has acted as an overlay on all this in the direction of making the planet warmer than it naturally should be. Trying to reverse that is really to save ourselves as there are enough species that can happily continue to exist if we end up going extinct through our own foolishness.

Very good post. 6th extinction and all that

Boyonthenres · 21/09/2023 21:12

Papyrophile · 21/09/2023 21:09

It's an interesting question. But from our local environment, which was from 1750 - 1850, one of the most intensively industrialised/mined parts of the world, and which is now a SSSI and a protected AONB, I would put my money on the ability of the planet to recover, and also, on the ingenuity of humanity to repair the damage.

Not with 8 billion people marching towards 10 billion by 2050 we won't. We don't stand a hope.

Not a single leader on the world stage leading by example, we're totally fooked

Boyonthenres · 21/09/2023 21:10

Begsthequestion · 21/09/2023 20:50

Depending on where the jet stream shifts to long term, it could be pissing rain here all the time, with constant flooding. Or just continue to get more unpredictable on a daily basis, making it very very hard to grow food.

Yes it could be but give me floods over drought and fires any day. Of course that's like choosing between poo and vomit but at least we can hopefully develop better ways of using all that excess water to our advantage both in terms of food production and energy. I know if we're completely under water then that's a moot point but that won't happen instantly.

Hey, I'm one of the gloomiest environmental doomers you'll ever come across but I keep myself sane ish over it by trying to channel the odd positive thought.

IslaWinds · 21/09/2023 21:09

Climate change does happen naturally and humans are also affecting the climate on top of the natural cycles.

It’s sort of like climate change is a little fire and we have just dumped a barrel of petrol on it to make a massive bonfire.

The natural climate change can cause all manner of natural disasters. For example the flood in Libya wasn’t the first flood to hit the north coast of Africa as there are records of historic floods from thousands of years ago that have literally sunk cities beneath the sea- which under sea archaeologists have been excavating. Great Britain got cut off from mainland Europe by a tsunami sinking Doggerland beneath the sea. Sea levels have fallen and risen. Deserts have expanded and contracted. The western hemisphere has the El Niño cycle. Natural climate change has also caused species to go extinct- even before humans existed the fate of 97% of species was extinction at some point in time.

Human activity creating emissions has acted as an overlay on all this in the direction of making the planet warmer than it naturally should be. Trying to reverse that is really to save ourselves as there are enough species that can happily continue to exist if we end up going extinct through our own foolishness.

Papyrophile · 21/09/2023 21:09

It's an interesting question. But from our local environment, which was from 1750 - 1850, one of the most intensively industrialised/mined parts of the world, and which is now a SSSI and a protected AONB, I would put my money on the ability of the planet to recover, and also, on the ingenuity of humanity to repair the damage.

Boyonthenres · 21/09/2023 21:06

MiniBossFromAus · 21/09/2023 20:44

Britain may be cool. It will also be under water.

Yes, it will be eventually, everyone will move to the epicentre 🥺

Swipe left for the next trending thread