Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for a head count as to how many mumsnetters don’t believe that climate change is caused by human activity?

236 replies

workingtowards · 21/09/2023 13:13

There was a thread on MN many years ago, when a good proportion thought climate change was just weather/natural, so it would be interesting to know if views have changed.

YANBU: Yes human activity is causing climate change
YABU: No climate change is natural and there’s nothing we can do about it

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
madamreign · 22/09/2023 18:49

Of course it is.

Doesn't matter whether we believe in it or not. It's science, not the tooth fairy.

LlynTegid · 22/09/2023 18:47

Whether you believe it is caused by human activity, the actions we take can reduce dependence on energy from dictatorships, and price volatility to an extent.

verdantverdure · 22/09/2023 18:45

From Oxfam’s Dress For The World You Want campaign

To ask for a head count as to how many mumsnetters don’t believe that climate change is caused by human activity?
Spambod · 22/09/2023 16:09

There has always been a strong ebb and flow. It was warmer and we were connected to mainland Europe via Doggerland. Then it froze, then warmed up again. These fluctuations are in very recent history (1000's of years)

I think it is a crucial question, how much of natural and inevitable climate change do human activities contribute to. If its 80% then we have a moderate chance of some success through innovation and initiatives (not sure how we engage the big players India and China though). If its 20% then we need to shift the focus to coping and living with climate change like air quality, cooling systems etc. Work with the problem rather than eliminate it.

verdantverdure · 22/09/2023 16:01

Middlelanehogger · 22/09/2023 13:09

Where are the options for...

It's a mix of both

It's natural but we should be doing something about it anyway, e.g. carbon capture to ensure it stays within human-livable temperatures

It's man-made but there's nothing we can do about it, or nothing we can do about it that wouldn't cause worse problems

It's man-made and we can do something about it, but the current specific policy proposals on the table aren't appropriate

...

I hate how facile this "debate" becomes. Just a stupid exercise in "look at those dumb people who don't believe in Science".

The facts are the facts and muddying the waters with a lot of stuff that doesn't align with the facts is a disinformation technique.

verdantverdure · 22/09/2023 15:58

Private jets are responsible for MORE greenhouse gas emissions in the past three years than Uganda, a country with a population of 46 MILLION.

(I don't have time to join in properly today. Just lob in a nugget or two Grin)

Middlelanehogger · 22/09/2023 13:09

Where are the options for...

It's a mix of both

It's natural but we should be doing something about it anyway, e.g. carbon capture to ensure it stays within human-livable temperatures

It's man-made but there's nothing we can do about it, or nothing we can do about it that wouldn't cause worse problems

It's man-made and we can do something about it, but the current specific policy proposals on the table aren't appropriate

...

I hate how facile this "debate" becomes. Just a stupid exercise in "look at those dumb people who don't believe in Science".

verdantverdure · 22/09/2023 13:02

The Office of Budgie Responsibility:

To ask for a head count as to how many mumsnetters don’t believe that climate change is caused by human activity?
To ask for a head count as to how many mumsnetters don’t believe that climate change is caused by human activity?
MrsSkylerWhite · 22/09/2023 10:34

Both

Boyonthenres · 22/09/2023 10:33

Fifireee · 22/09/2023 04:25

Oh god I voted the wrong way. Bloody insomnia. Of course it’s caused by human activity.

You can go back and change your vote 😊

Boyonthenres · 22/09/2023 10:32

ShipSpace · 22/09/2023 01:11

Of course we need to intervene.

If we want the human species to survive in this location, we need to intervene.

But if humans can’t successfully do this as a species, then the species won’t survive.

Maybe selfishness is the flaw in the human species that means we won’t survive.

Agree, we need to drastically intervene to level it let alone reverse it. We don't have the leaders to enact this, it's a perfect storm. The next 50 years are going to be 'interesting'

CalistoNoSolo · 22/09/2023 07:35

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

SheerLucks · 22/09/2023 04:44

CurlewKate · 21/09/2023 13:30

I'm not an expert. So I will go with 97% of the scientific community and say yes, climate change is man made.

This.

I'm quite shocked that I got this far into the thread before an intelligent comment was made.

urbanbuddha · 22/09/2023 04:36

ShipSpace · 22/09/2023 01:11

Of course we need to intervene.

If we want the human species to survive in this location, we need to intervene.

But if humans can’t successfully do this as a species, then the species won’t survive.

Maybe selfishness is the flaw in the human species that means we won’t survive.

This.

Fifireee · 22/09/2023 04:25

Oh god I voted the wrong way. Bloody insomnia. Of course it’s caused by human activity.

aurynne · 22/09/2023 04:02

ShipSpace · 21/09/2023 14:59

Human beings are natural, no?

So if the activities of the dominant species on a planet are resulting in climate changes on that planet, then that is natural change, yes?

Which negates your question, I think.

Ok, so by your own argument, if I go and stab you to death you've just died of natural causes, right?

ShipSpace · 22/09/2023 01:11

Of course we need to intervene.

If we want the human species to survive in this location, we need to intervene.

But if humans can’t successfully do this as a species, then the species won’t survive.

Maybe selfishness is the flaw in the human species that means we won’t survive.

CCTVcity · 22/09/2023 01:04

I do think we probably do need to intervene. We are like a bus about to drive off a pier. Half the bus is arguing about which direction to drive. Hopefully they figure it out and we do t go plunging. It’s looking pretty inevitable to me so I am putting on life jackets and pre smashing some windows 🤣

ShipSpace · 22/09/2023 00:36

But we don’t “have to intervene” do we?

As a species, we’ll do what we can to survive.

If this means we decide to import trees and this works for us, then great. The species wins.

If large areas of the planet become uninhabitable to humans, how is that any different to today? The species will adapt or die.

If humans spend all their resources arguing amongst themselves and fail to make the adaptations needed to survive, then the species will die. Just like any species that fails to adapt to a new environment.

CCTVcity · 22/09/2023 00:11

ShipSpace · 21/09/2023 23:54

“We will have to import and replant”

I’m not sure why there is this belief that humans are somehow above nature.

Where were the humans “importing and replanting” after the last ice age? Or after the asteroid hit the dinosaurs?

We will not have to import and replant. Life will find a way, as it always has done.

All species (including humans) will adapt and survive as far as possible. Some species will not be able to survive and will die out. Others will thrive and will adapt further until new species develop.

I don’t know why we think humans are exempt from this somehow.

An ice age would be preferential for nature. It’s kind of like a pause on the soil and the seed bank. When things warm up then it defrosts and has another chance.

Warming causes desertification. Soils literally die to a dust and the seed banks not going to survive that. Sure in U.K. we are like woo, mangoes and orange trees. But in half the world it’s going to be death zone like Saharan desert.

The earth also used to be a lot more stuck together. Things could move around a bit better. Now there’s a lot of sea. It’s unlikely we will get enough fluke survivor seeds crossing the ocean to repopulate out entire tree population. We only have 15 U.K. native tree species. So yes we will have to intervene. Because survival of the fittest and evolution is something which takes 1000s of years. Not 10s.

I don’t think humans are exempt. Even in a fucked event am sure some would survive absolutely. I would rather not have to live through a fucked event.

Regardless of what we do I don’t think we can reverse climate change. Our industry’s taking a hedge your bets approach. We can see it changing. It’s happening! We are trying to do our best to prepare for that.

sleepwouldbenice · 22/09/2023 00:02

verdantverdure · 21/09/2023 14:22

We're doing climate deniers a favour really aren't we?

If we do what needs to be done and prevent climate change getting dramatically worse the climate change deniers can bang on like they did about Y2K that it was all a big hoax and they knew nothing bad was going to happen .

They love a bit of that. Grin

Yep
Like to ozone layer action
And like actions and vaccines for covid

Deniers delight

ShipSpace · 21/09/2023 23:54

CCTVcity · 21/09/2023 23:04

I went to a tree talk the other day about picking species for the future. Because obviously trees don’t grow over night. I will be honest it was pretty alarming. And I am someone who is usually quite chill about the resilience of nature.

Pretty much all the native U.K. trees are goners. You can see that if you look outside. All the trees are fucked. There’s dead/dying trees all over the place, you might think it’s because it’s autumn but it’s bloody not yet! We just had the only two weeks of heat this summer and we have had an extremely mild and wet summer. It’s been perfect for trees. Yet so many are struggling from last summers heat wave and the cold frosts we had last winter.

We will have to import and replant. Problem is we don’t even know which way it’s going to go. We are assuming heat, but not necessarily. There’s a school of thought that the Gulf Stream might just collapse imminently. If that happens then it’s a mini ice age for U.K not heat!

“We will have to import and replant”

I’m not sure why there is this belief that humans are somehow above nature.

Where were the humans “importing and replanting” after the last ice age? Or after the asteroid hit the dinosaurs?

We will not have to import and replant. Life will find a way, as it always has done.

All species (including humans) will adapt and survive as far as possible. Some species will not be able to survive and will die out. Others will thrive and will adapt further until new species develop.

I don’t know why we think humans are exempt from this somehow.

Thatladdo · 21/09/2023 23:35

I think the reality is we arent going to stop this accelerated climate change because the main (accellerating) offenders arent going to stop, reducing our already reducing footprint is futile.
We would be better served preparing to mitigate as best we can.
Face the reality.

CCTVcity · 21/09/2023 23:04

IsleofDen · 21/09/2023 13:53

I think we have exacerbated climate change and we should take responsibility for that, but we didn’t create it.

I also hate the “save the planet” rhetoric. The planet will be fine, life will survive, or return. It’s humanity that needs to save itself from extinction.

I went to a tree talk the other day about picking species for the future. Because obviously trees don’t grow over night. I will be honest it was pretty alarming. And I am someone who is usually quite chill about the resilience of nature.

Pretty much all the native U.K. trees are goners. You can see that if you look outside. All the trees are fucked. There’s dead/dying trees all over the place, you might think it’s because it’s autumn but it’s bloody not yet! We just had the only two weeks of heat this summer and we have had an extremely mild and wet summer. It’s been perfect for trees. Yet so many are struggling from last summers heat wave and the cold frosts we had last winter.

We will have to import and replant. Problem is we don’t even know which way it’s going to go. We are assuming heat, but not necessarily. There’s a school of thought that the Gulf Stream might just collapse imminently. If that happens then it’s a mini ice age for U.K not heat!

Mountaineer0009 · 21/09/2023 23:04

Laiste · 21/09/2023 13:23

I believe both these things are true:

  • Our behaviour has an affect on the planets climate.
  • The climate has changed in the past long before humans were around.

I don't think either negates the other.

plus dont the ice cores prove that the earth was warming and cooling years before humans ?