Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for a head count as to how many mumsnetters don’t believe that climate change is caused by human activity?

236 replies

workingtowards · 21/09/2023 13:13

There was a thread on MN many years ago, when a good proportion thought climate change was just weather/natural, so it would be interesting to know if views have changed.

YANBU: Yes human activity is causing climate change
YABU: No climate change is natural and there’s nothing we can do about it

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
verdantverdure · 23/09/2023 03:15

Another nugget from me:

China’s emissions often come up in these discussions but when you think about it a chunk of their emissions are really our emissions because they’re doing our manufacturing for us.

We “export” a huge chunk of our emissions to China, through them making stuff for us, because we hardly make anything, then blame China for their emissions and claim that ours are lower than they actually are.

Ditto for places like Bangladesh where our cheap clothes are often made.

Our territorial (within our borders) emissions are lower than the emissions we are responsible for because of our demand for stuff.

Those emissions get blamed on the country of manufacture, but really the responsibility lies with the country with the demand.

Middlelanehogger · 22/09/2023 23:37

"Do you believe in climate change" is such a worthless faith-test. The only interesting question should be what should we do about it, whether anthropogenic or natural - and on that question intelligent minds may differ.

ClifftopView · 22/09/2023 23:29

I think it's a mix of both. The earth is having a warming period (and will have a cooling period again in future). It's what the earth does and always has done. I also believe that human activity is making the warming happen faster and to a greater degree.

Twillow · 22/09/2023 22:46

Treebark · 21/09/2023 13:27

It's the rate of climate change that is the issue. I don't know why people can't see this - changes which took thousands of years when driven by natural processes are now happening much quicker because of human activity.

That's the bit no one ever seems to grasp. Yes change is natural. Very fast change is not natural and is driven by human activity.

HTH

Thank god for this post. I was losing the will...

ShipSpace · 22/09/2023 22:46

Well, this has gone weird now

Papyrophile · 22/09/2023 22:42

I would disagree but you are free to make that judgement!

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 22/09/2023 22:35

Papyrophile · 22/09/2023 22:28

What is a planet, unless some species wrestles it into a useful environment to nurture a culture?

Saturn is perfectly majestic with no culture

Papyrophile · 22/09/2023 22:33

@Theunamedcat , to whom was your comment directed?

IslaWinds · 22/09/2023 22:32

workingtowards · 22/09/2023 22:23

@Islawinds This is aibu. The voting options are only ever yes or no. It is still interesting to see what proportion of people still click yabu. If you want to start a more subtle binary voting thread, please do.

Edited

Yes it is AIBU, but your choices were not worded as well as they could be in my opinion. I haven’t voted because neither choice is sufficiently accurate.

Theunamedcat · 22/09/2023 22:31

That's an overly simplistic view

Papyrophile · 22/09/2023 22:30

Please tell me the value of Jupiter's moons. I would be interested, except that we have already deduced they are uninhabitable for our species or actually, any mammalian species.

Papyrophile · 22/09/2023 22:28

What is a planet, unless some species wrestles it into a useful environment to nurture a culture?

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 22/09/2023 22:25

Doodar · 22/09/2023 20:56

I don’t believe it at all, we’ve been here for such a short period of time. It’s all natural. Great money making exercise though.

OK, so what do you think has caused the unprecedentedly rapid rise in atmospheric CO2 which happens to overlap exactly with industrialisation and the burning of fossil fuels, those fossil fuels being the remnants of plant life which back in the Cambrian period absorbed huge amounts of carbon from the atmosphere, which through burning binds with oxygen to form CO2, which hangs around a long time in the atmosphere ?

Papyrophile · 22/09/2023 22:25

Which is where you end up when you suggest a world without humans.

Papyrophile · 22/09/2023 22:23

I don't really fancy living in a world without humans.

workingtowards · 22/09/2023 22:23

@Islawinds This is aibu. The voting options are only ever yes or no. It is still interesting to see what proportion of people still click yabu. If you want to start a more subtle binary voting thread, please do.

OP posts:
Papyrophile · 22/09/2023 22:19

So all the art and science that humans have created in 18,000 years has absolutely no value to you @hattie43?

I have a theory that you can be team history or team natural history. I am team history that celebrates the genius of humanity, the highest aspiring creature ever to walk the earth.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 22/09/2023 22:17

I follow the scientific consensus as that is the rational position, but retain a healthy degree of skepticism

A balanced and sensible approach to take, especially as scientists have a long record of allying themselves with whatever's fashionable or will secure the most funding and recognition
This doesn't necessarily mean their conclusions are wrong, but all the same it's worth bearing in mind

After all, in global terms it wasn't long ago that the "consensus" was that the world was flat and the sun went around the earth

Sunsnet · 22/09/2023 21:49

hattie43 · 21/09/2023 14:02

I think it's natural evolution and it's the human race time to die out , like the dinosaurs. I don't think anything we do will alter the passage of nature and nor should it .
The human race is evil .

That's not how evolution works or how the dinosaurs were wiped out and we can't alter nature, whatever that means, but we do have an effect on it as we are part of it.

No idea what evil is.

CurlewKate · 22/09/2023 21:12

"Just a stupid exercise in "look at those dumb people who don't believe in Science"
Why would anyone want to look at them?

Doodar · 22/09/2023 20:56

I don’t believe it at all, we’ve been here for such a short period of time. It’s all natural. Great money making exercise though.

IslaWinds · 22/09/2023 20:49

MadderthanMorris · 22/09/2023 20:46

Those saying that it's "a bit of both - humans have some effect but the climate has always changed regardless", can you point out to me where any scientist anywhere ever has claimed that the climate DOESN'T change regardless? Because if not, this is just a ridiculous strawman.

The vast majority of scientific experts who have actually studied the subject have concluded that human actions have created a large and accelerating increase in global heating, which will soon become - or is already becoming - irreversible. The last thing we need is to humour those who think Donald Trump is a better source of wisdom than the scientific community by acknowledging irrelevant and bleeding obvious points that noone ever denied anyway.

No one is doing a strawman. The reason some of us are saying both is because the OP asked the question with a binary of choose human or natural as the cause of climate change to vote. The OP either doesn’t know climate change is both natural and anthropogenic or forgot when she set up the voting.

MadderthanMorris · 22/09/2023 20:46

Those saying that it's "a bit of both - humans have some effect but the climate has always changed regardless", can you point out to me where any scientist anywhere ever has claimed that the climate DOESN'T change regardless? Because if not, this is just a ridiculous strawman.

The vast majority of scientific experts who have actually studied the subject have concluded that human actions have created a large and accelerating increase in global heating, which will soon become - or is already becoming - irreversible. The last thing we need is to humour those who think Donald Trump is a better source of wisdom than the scientific community by acknowledging irrelevant and bleeding obvious points that noone ever denied anyway.

MadderthanMorris · 22/09/2023 20:35

SheerLucks · 22/09/2023 04:44

This.

I'm quite shocked that I got this far into the thread before an intelligent comment was made.

New to Mumsnet, are we?

PrrrplePineapple · 22/09/2023 18:51

I think we're responsible for the acceleration of the current global warming trend we're seeing, but as others have said, the planet naturally warms and cools so we're not causing anything new per se beyond accelerating a natural process.