Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for a head count as to how many mumsnetters don’t believe that climate change is caused by human activity?

236 replies

workingtowards · 21/09/2023 13:13

There was a thread on MN many years ago, when a good proportion thought climate change was just weather/natural, so it would be interesting to know if views have changed.

YANBU: Yes human activity is causing climate change
YABU: No climate change is natural and there’s nothing we can do about it

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Hurrydash · 24/09/2023 18:29

workingtowards · 24/09/2023 13:38

The ice core samples from East Antarctica provide us with a record of CO2 levels in the atmosphere over the past 800,000 years compared to the present day.

It is not clear from the text what the red line on the graph shows.
If it is temperature let's all breath a sigh of relief the temperature now is lower than many spikes over the last 800,000 years.
Either way if the world's age was a 24 hour clock 800,000 years is about 15 seconds - if my maths hasn't failed me!

workingtowards · 24/09/2023 13:38

The ice core samples from East Antarctica provide us with a record of CO2 levels in the atmosphere over the past 800,000 years compared to the present day.

To ask for a head count as to how many mumsnetters don’t believe that climate change is caused by human activity?
OP posts:
Puzzledandpissedoff · 24/09/2023 11:57

Excellent post, @Hurrydash, especially about the infinitesimal time mankind's been here and the assumptions that we know it all

For me this is where the arrogance comes in, as if we're the only thing that's mattered to the planet or ever will. I wouldn't mind, but when you dig into things so much is done on "modelling" - in other words largely guesses, except such comments aren't always welcome because of what you accurately described as the 1984 thing

Hurrydash · 24/09/2023 01:27

12moose · 23/09/2023 18:07

I believe it is mainly caused by human activity. However, I also think that we fail to assess the issue as we do all other issues. That is, weighing up the pros and cons. The fact is, there are many, many more human deaths caused by cold weather, so an overall warming of the planet will actually increase human mortality rather than decrease it.
Also, cheap energy such as that taken from fossil fuels has done more good than harm. Cheap fuel resources have lifted millions of people out of poverty, and brought huge wealth to developing countries.
I also find it curious how people who are staunchly against the use of fossil fuels tend to be anti-capitalist, so it's uncleear how much of it is informed by science and how much is political. Ie. Seeing human consumption and innovation as inherently bad, and fossil fuels being a convenient mask for their hatred of humans in general.

Broadly agree apart from the comment climate change is caused mostly by humans.
Massive climate changes over 4,5 billion years on this planet. Humans not around for most of it.
No one has a clear understanding of the impacts on climate of e.g. sunspots, the earths's 'wobble', deep sea tranches, volcanoes, ash clouds and on and on.
Scientists are too scared to own up to this as the 'scientific' community has largely become a 1984 state - if you disagree/challenge you're cancelled.
Climate change will continue for billions of years after humans are extinct - likely causes; pandemic, asteroid and of course nuclear war.
Having hotter summers big danger - nah not really.
Chill out and get a tan. Much better than gluing yourself to a road!!

IslaWinds · 23/09/2023 18:20

verdantverdure · 23/09/2023 18:15

@IslaWinds During the colonial years when we were "the workshop of the world" that China is now we outsourced a lot of our emissions to other territories so our total responsibility is even bigger than calculated.

And so is our obligation to take responsibility for it.

We are taking responsibility….how can you even say we are not?!

Im a bit confused, you are saying that anything we import and consume we are responsible for, not the country that manufactured it and sold it to us. (Which I agree with)

But now you are saying everything we manufactured when we were the “workshop of the world” and then sold all around the world for other countries to consume we are also responsible for?

That seems a double standard.

verdantverdure · 23/09/2023 18:15

@IslaWinds During the colonial years when we were "the workshop of the world" that China is now we outsourced a lot of our emissions to other territories so our total responsibility is even bigger than calculated.

And so is our obligation to take responsibility for it.

verdantverdure · 23/09/2023 18:10

*Have you done many things such as stop flying, upgrade to heat pump, no car or EV etc

Not calling you out but you obviously care. Does it translate to your life as well? What type of stuff have you embraced @EasternStandard.

Reduced consumption mainly. I haven't been buying clothes this year, I cook from scratch mostly, I'm aware of air miles, I recycle, I don't buy plastic bottles ever, I buy a takeaway coffee rarely. I bought reusable period pads, I don't fly, we're down to one car, and it's a little one, we moved to somewhere I can walk everywhere including to work, I work from home a lot, I'm a vegetarian trying to go vegan. The kids wear each other's hand me downs as much as possible.

We went non open plan to create a snug we can heat and insulate easier than a big open plan barn. We don't have gas. We don't have a log burner, We don't have central heating at the moment.

The extra we're paying on our mortgage every month (Thanks Tories!) has taken away our budget to save for an EV, heating, and a grey water system for our baths and showers to flush the loo, but we'll get there.

I support businesses and politicians who help us get to Net Zero and minimise my interaction with those who don't.

I use my local farm shop and my fill your own container shop.

I try and do my bit basically.

I've got probably 40-50 more years in whatever hellscape we create and my kids could have 90 or more.

So I learn the facts and I do my bit.

Fimofriend · 23/09/2023 18:08

YANBU.

12moose · 23/09/2023 18:07

I believe it is mainly caused by human activity. However, I also think that we fail to assess the issue as we do all other issues. That is, weighing up the pros and cons. The fact is, there are many, many more human deaths caused by cold weather, so an overall warming of the planet will actually increase human mortality rather than decrease it.
Also, cheap energy such as that taken from fossil fuels has done more good than harm. Cheap fuel resources have lifted millions of people out of poverty, and brought huge wealth to developing countries.
I also find it curious how people who are staunchly against the use of fossil fuels tend to be anti-capitalist, so it's uncleear how much of it is informed by science and how much is political. Ie. Seeing human consumption and innovation as inherently bad, and fossil fuels being a convenient mask for their hatred of humans in general.

IslaWinds · 23/09/2023 18:02

verdantverdure · 23/09/2023 17:40

Countries have a responsibility for their cumulative historical global emissions that got us to this point.

The US is responsible for 20.3% of historical territorial emissions. China is second, with 11.4%,followed by Russia 6.9%, Brazil 4.5%,and Indonesia 4.1%, Germany is sixth on 3.5%, India 7th on 3.4%, and the U.K. is the 8th largest cumulative CO2 emitter globally with 3%.

The UK's isn't to do with forest fires or deforestation. It's primarily fossil fuel reliance.

And it doesn't count the emissions outsourcing we did throughout colonialism. (For example, in India.)

Or flights.

And then there's per capita.

The U.K. is a relatively small country with a relatively small population but 7th in the world for cumulative territorial emissions is punching well above our weight.

We had a 150yr head start, so of course we’d be punching above our weight for cumulative CO2 emissions dating from 1750.

To ask for a head count as to how many mumsnetters don’t believe that climate change is caused by human activity?
derxa · 23/09/2023 17:46

And just as vegans and vegetarians help mitigate the effects of meat eating on the planet, those of us who do more will mitigate the effects of those who do less.
The Chinese are increasing their meat and milk production at a prodigious rate
https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.aar8534

Lavender14 · 23/09/2023 17:42

Both are true in part but human behavior is definitely causing issues at a faster and more problematic rate. But I do also think it's big companies that cause the biggest issues compared to individual people.

verdantverdure · 23/09/2023 17:40

IslaWinds · 23/09/2023 16:54

We “export” a huge chunk of our emissions to China

The emissions we “export” to everyone else, not just China, are 30% of our total consumption based emissions, which accounts for 0.4% of global emissions.

Countries have a responsibility for their cumulative historical global emissions that got us to this point.

The US is responsible for 20.3% of historical territorial emissions. China is second, with 11.4%,followed by Russia 6.9%, Brazil 4.5%,and Indonesia 4.1%, Germany is sixth on 3.5%, India 7th on 3.4%, and the U.K. is the 8th largest cumulative CO2 emitter globally with 3%.

The UK's isn't to do with forest fires or deforestation. It's primarily fossil fuel reliance.

And it doesn't count the emissions outsourcing we did throughout colonialism. (For example, in India.)

Or flights.

And then there's per capita.

The U.K. is a relatively small country with a relatively small population but 7th in the world for cumulative territorial emissions is punching well above our weight.

IslaWinds · 23/09/2023 17:36

And then when you add in the super baddies, well China is practically just like us!

To ask for a head count as to how many mumsnetters don’t believe that climate change is caused by human activity?
MariePaperRoses · 23/09/2023 17:33

sarahh96 · 21/09/2023 13:19

Climate change is a natural evolution of the planet. Nothing to do with us. The planet will continue to evolve long after we've gone.

This.

IslaWinds · 23/09/2023 17:32

Following on, so looking at per capita China vs U.K., China looks like a baddie don’t they? But they really aren’t once you add in a few real CO2 baddies.

To ask for a head count as to how many mumsnetters don’t believe that climate change is caused by human activity?
IslaWinds · 23/09/2023 17:28

Just for informational purposes as China is so much more populous than the U.K., that the usual fairest way to measure how a country is doing with CO2 measures is to look at CO2 per capita. Unfortunately, this website divides total annual CO2 by total population. To adjust for consumption based, we have to reduce China’s by 8% and increase ours by 30%

8 x 0.92= 7.36t per capita China consumption
5.2 x 1.3= 6.76t per capita U.K. consumption

So U.K. and China- we still consume less per person. Another issue is that while we are actively cutting, China is on an upward trend. Even after you reduce the chunk of their emissions used on items they manufacture for the rest of the world, it’s clear their own consumption means each person in China consumes more than each person in the U.K.

To ask for a head count as to how many mumsnetters don’t believe that climate change is caused by human activity?
EasternStandard · 23/09/2023 17:15

verdantverdure · 23/09/2023 03:15

Another nugget from me:

China’s emissions often come up in these discussions but when you think about it a chunk of their emissions are really our emissions because they’re doing our manufacturing for us.

We “export” a huge chunk of our emissions to China, through them making stuff for us, because we hardly make anything, then blame China for their emissions and claim that ours are lower than they actually are.

Ditto for places like Bangladesh where our cheap clothes are often made.

Our territorial (within our borders) emissions are lower than the emissions we are responsible for because of our demand for stuff.

Those emissions get blamed on the country of manufacture, but really the responsibility lies with the country with the demand.

Have you done many things such as stop flying, upgrade to heat pump, no car or EV etc

Not calling you out but you obviously care. Does it translate to your life as well? What type of stuff have you embraced

IslaWinds · 23/09/2023 17:13

verdantverdure · 23/09/2023 17:06

Sorry, it took me to a pay wall. Can you briefly summarise what was in the article?

verdantverdure · 23/09/2023 17:06

Free to read in the FT today.

www.ft.com/content/8e05cf9f-9fed-4257-adbb-5df062e28af1

EasternStandard · 23/09/2023 17:05

I’ve seen some polls on and most feel like we’re not doing enough

Oth holidays are popular, and consumption generally

So maybe people feel like it’s something someone else solves or pays for

We’re at the abstract it’s not going to hurt (financially) stage.

IslaWinds · 23/09/2023 16:54

We “export” a huge chunk of our emissions to China

The emissions we “export” to everyone else, not just China, are 30% of our total consumption based emissions, which accounts for 0.4% of global emissions.

IslaWinds · 23/09/2023 16:49

verdantverdure · 23/09/2023 03:15

Another nugget from me:

China’s emissions often come up in these discussions but when you think about it a chunk of their emissions are really our emissions because they’re doing our manufacturing for us.

We “export” a huge chunk of our emissions to China, through them making stuff for us, because we hardly make anything, then blame China for their emissions and claim that ours are lower than they actually are.

Ditto for places like Bangladesh where our cheap clothes are often made.

Our territorial (within our borders) emissions are lower than the emissions we are responsible for because of our demand for stuff.

Those emissions get blamed on the country of manufacture, but really the responsibility lies with the country with the demand.

CO2 emissions are measured both ways.
There is the production based emissions which measures all the emissions we do within our borders including whatever we manufacture to sell & export to other countries is counted against us.
Then there is the consumption based emissions which measures all the emissions we do within our borders but then adds the emissions of everything we import, while subtracting the emissions of everything we export (those are added to the countries importing our products)

UK production based emissions are 327m or 0.9% of global emissions
UK consumption based emissions are 465m 1.3%of global emissions

China production based emissions are 10.96bn tonnes or 29.5% of global emissions
China consumption based emissions are 10.03bn tonnes or 27% of global emissions

So it is very clear that 92% of China’s emissions are on energy and products they consume.

a chunk of their emissions are really our emissions because they’re doing our manufacturing for us
This chunk is 8% of their emissions for everything they manufacture and export to everyone else in the world- not just us.

(all figures are 2020 figures because the website doesn’t have any later figures for consumption based CO2 emissions)

To ask for a head count as to how many mumsnetters don’t believe that climate change is caused by human activity?
Hurrydash · 23/09/2023 10:51

The earth is 4.5 billion years old and the climate has been changing for all of that time. People have been around for only a fraction of those years.
It therefore doesn't add up to attribute climate change solely to human activity.
However, does human activity impact the environment?
Of course it does.
The debate needed is how much do we need to mitigate this, and how best to do it.
I suggest the knee jerk reactions that negatively impact the poorer in society most - green levies, ULEZ and the like are not socially fair or acceptable solutions.

GarlicGrace · 23/09/2023 03:55

Yet another "both". The planet's still coming out of an ice age. But humans started evolving during a period of repeated glaciations: it's never been really hot during our species' time and we didn't evolve to deal with the conditions of a 'greenhouse' epoch.

Therefore it's pretty stupid of us to speed up the warming process, as we are.