Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

YouTube jumped too soon and no UK Parliament are wading in!

59 replies

MetaverseMavis · 21/09/2023 12:09

No matter what my personal thoughts are about RB, I feel very uncomfortable with this trial by the media. YouTube has taken it too far by deciding he has violated their T&Cs and removed his channel. Now UK Parliament want his Rumble channel down.

Why is Parliament getting involved today? what are they scared of, I'm not a conspiracy theorist but this is absurd.

I seem to remember the media accusing Cliff Richard - turns out he was innocent.

OP posts:
pinksunglasses · 21/09/2023 13:19

IncomingTraffic · 21/09/2023 13:05

It seems to me that, alongside basic comprehension issues, there are quite a lot of people with no understanding of how parliament and government work in this country.

Edited

Parliament is a different entity, yes. Dame Caroline Dineage, the signee, is an MP. MPs have their own code of conduct which includes very specific rules about how their position and influence should be used.

For example -

‘Objectivity

Holders of public office must act and take decisions impartially, fairly and on merit, using the best evidence and without discrimination or bias.’

I would say that this action directly contradicts that. Elected officials, such as MPs, should be upholding due process. And if they don’t like the current system, they are in a prime position to fight for change.

pinguins · 21/09/2023 13:19

tolerable · 21/09/2023 13:09

Given bbc and ch4 and times ALL harboured details of an alleged rapist and left said alleged rapist to roam free(and potentially continue this behaviour)then dropped it as "the biggest story of the year" maybe they should be demonised too

If the allegations are proven true, and we're demonetising things, the production companies and channels that profited from RB's work at the time the crimes took place should give those profits to the victims. Why should they be able to profit from this? Why should anyone?

But that's a conversation to have once the criminal investigation has concluded.

Naunet · 21/09/2023 13:18

MetaverseMavis · 21/09/2023 12:09

No matter what my personal thoughts are about RB, I feel very uncomfortable with this trial by the media. YouTube has taken it too far by deciding he has violated their T&Cs and removed his channel. Now UK Parliament want his Rumble channel down.

Why is Parliament getting involved today? what are they scared of, I'm not a conspiracy theorist but this is absurd.

I seem to remember the media accusing Cliff Richard - turns out he was innocent.

Explain to me why it’s ok for YouTube to cancel women’s channels for knowing not what biological sex is, but outrageous for a millionaire male accused of rape? YouTube is a private platform, they can do what they want.

CantThinkOfANameAtAll · 21/09/2023 13:14

I don’t feel comfortable with such a gross overstep. The government can’t be allowed to promote punishment for people who as of yet haven’t been charged or convicted of anything!

^^ This. I don't like any kind of witch hunt and too many are being allowed to happen with zero checks.

pinguins · 21/09/2023 13:10

Yeah there is literally no reason for the UK government to involve themselves in this situation. It should be a police investigation of the historic crimes of a media personality.

This isn't even trial by media, the government have literally targeted a citizen. Did they do this to Andrew Tate, another UK citizen? Did they do this to literally anyone else at all? Rose West still has a bank account and is able to make money, FFS, and she was proven to sexually abuse, torture and murder 12 women with her husband.

This whole thing is terrible but I give this thread an hour.

tolerable · 21/09/2023 13:09

Given bbc and ch4 and times ALL harboured details of an alleged rapist and left said alleged rapist to roam free(and potentially continue this behaviour)then dropped it as "the biggest story of the year" maybe they should be demonised too

Worldgonecrazy · 21/09/2023 13:09

The phrase used is ‘We are concerned that he may be able to profit from his content on the platform.’

It is political overreach.

I don’t like Russel Brand and have never found him funny or attractive, but a Government committee sending such a letter is wrong.

Givemepickles · 21/09/2023 13:08

It's nothing to do with the Government and they should stay out of it. Think of all the people involved in writing that letter to Rumble. This is why our taxes are so high. Government have forgotten what their job is and continuously overstep.

pinksunglasses · 21/09/2023 13:08

IncomingTraffic · 21/09/2023 13:02

That letter doesn’t even ask tik tok to demonitise brand.

The committee asks two things:

  1. if tik tok will confirm whether brand is able to monitise content in which he seeks to discredit his accusers.
  2. what are tik tok doing to prevent content creators using their platform to undermine the welfare of others.

It’s not a conspiracy. At most brand is an example (he isn’t the only person making money out of using SM to bully people) and the CMS committee are looking at how social media platforms can be used by people to further harm people who may have objected to their conduct.

It doesn’t say ‘please stop letting brand make money off this stuff’.

‘We would be grateful if you could confirm whether Mr Brand is able to monetise his TikTok posts, including his videos relating to the serious accusations against him, and what the platform is doing to ensure that creators are not able to use the platform to undermine the welfare of victims of inappropriate and potentially illegal behaviour.’

You don't think that the above, under a House of Commons letterhead, implies a clear directive to TikTok? It’s not a neutral stance!

IncomingTraffic · 21/09/2023 13:05

It seems to me that, alongside basic comprehension issues, there are quite a lot of people with no understanding of how parliament and government work in this country.

pinksunglasses · 21/09/2023 13:04

cakehoover123 · 21/09/2023 12:58

The Select Committee aren't finding Brand "guilty" or "not guilty" of anything. They're just writing to four media companies:

  • To TikTok to understand if Brand is still monetising his posts
  • To C4 and the BBC to ask for updates on their internal investigations
  • To GBNews to remind them about their duty to cover the story impartially.

I think it's reasonable the Committee do this.

Firstly, traffic to Brand's TikToks will have gone up over the past week, because of the allegations. This is an issue beyond just Brand - if he's monetising TikToks by being a notorious sexual abuser, that creates monetary incentives for other creators to do the same thing (think Andrew Tate). That's not something we want to incentivise.

And secondly, certainly the Committee should be asking questions about the corporate culture and investigations at C4 and the BBC. Both those organisations gave Brand a public platform for years, despite it apparently being well-known that he wasn't safe around female staffers.

Nope. If criminal charges are filed and he’s found guilty after being questioned in court, it would then be appropriate for an inquiry into how corporate culture might have enabled him and how it could be prevented in future.

It is in all of our interests that the law and the justice system is upheld. It’s not about Russell Brand, it’s about the precedent it sets. Protecting due process protects us all.

IncomingTraffic · 21/09/2023 13:02

That letter doesn’t even ask tik tok to demonitise brand.

The committee asks two things:

  1. if tik tok will confirm whether brand is able to monitise content in which he seeks to discredit his accusers.
  2. what are tik tok doing to prevent content creators using their platform to undermine the welfare of others.

It’s not a conspiracy. At most brand is an example (he isn’t the only person making money out of using SM to bully people) and the CMS committee are looking at how social media platforms can be used by people to further harm people who may have objected to their conduct.

It doesn’t say ‘please stop letting brand make money off this stuff’.

cakehoover123 · 21/09/2023 12:58

The Select Committee aren't finding Brand "guilty" or "not guilty" of anything. They're just writing to four media companies:

  • To TikTok to understand if Brand is still monetising his posts
  • To C4 and the BBC to ask for updates on their internal investigations
  • To GBNews to remind them about their duty to cover the story impartially.

I think it's reasonable the Committee do this.

Firstly, traffic to Brand's TikToks will have gone up over the past week, because of the allegations. This is an issue beyond just Brand - if he's monetising TikToks by being a notorious sexual abuser, that creates monetary incentives for other creators to do the same thing (think Andrew Tate). That's not something we want to incentivise.

And secondly, certainly the Committee should be asking questions about the corporate culture and investigations at C4 and the BBC. Both those organisations gave Brand a public platform for years, despite it apparently being well-known that he wasn't safe around female staffers.

pinksunglasses · 21/09/2023 12:54

Islandsadness · 21/09/2023 12:51

It's not DCMS.

There is a difference between parliament and government which many on this thread need to learn!

Yeah, the government are supposedly accountable to parliament. Making parliament our most powerful and significant institution, so it’s still incredibly inappropriate.

MetaverseMavis · 21/09/2023 12:53

pinksunglasses · 21/09/2023 12:49

I’m not sure people are understanding. See the link below -

https://committees.parliament.uk/publications/41488/documents/204326/default/

Parliament are asking TikTok & Rumble to demonetise his videos. It’s not about Russell Brand specifically, I suspect he’s guilty but it’s a really dangerous precedent for the government to involve themselves in cutting off income streams of people who as of yet have not been charged with anything!

It’s irrelevant how much money the person has etc. If Kevin working in Tesco was accused of a crime but not yet charged or convicted of anything, the government writing to Tesco and asking for him to be sacked would be incredibly inappropriate. Tesco would be entitled to do so depending on their own policies but the government should be upholding the justice system!

I don’t feel comfortable with such a gross overstep. The government can’t be allowed to promote punishment for people who as of yet haven’t been charged or convicted of anything!

This is what I was trying to articulate. Thank you @pinksunglasses for being more eloquent than I can ever be

OP posts:
Islandsadness · 21/09/2023 12:51

Worldgonecrazy · 21/09/2023 12:42

I think that the letter sent by DCMS is political overreach and plays into the hands of those who believe RB is being targeted because of his beliefs.

The pedant in me is also horrified by the use of ‘Dear Firstname”

https://committees.parliament.uk/publications/41488/documents/204326/default/

It's not DCMS.

There is a difference between parliament and government which many on this thread need to learn!

IncomingTraffic · 21/09/2023 12:51

Oh good. Another ‘I’m not a conspiracy theorist but it’s definitely a conspiracy against Russell brand’ thread.

short answer: there is no conspiracy against brand. He isn’t actually an important person. No government fears him.

pinksunglasses · 21/09/2023 12:49

I’m not sure people are understanding. See the link below -

https://committees.parliament.uk/publications/41488/documents/204326/default/

Parliament are asking TikTok & Rumble to demonetise his videos. It’s not about Russell Brand specifically, I suspect he’s guilty but it’s a really dangerous precedent for the government to involve themselves in cutting off income streams of people who as of yet have not been charged with anything!

It’s irrelevant how much money the person has etc. If Kevin working in Tesco was accused of a crime but not yet charged or convicted of anything, the government writing to Tesco and asking for him to be sacked would be incredibly inappropriate. Tesco would be entitled to do so depending on their own policies but the government should be upholding the justice system!

I don’t feel comfortable with such a gross overstep. The government can’t be allowed to promote punishment for people who as of yet haven’t been charged or convicted of anything!

Thisistyresome · 21/09/2023 12:47

StoneWashJeansWithAMatchingJacket · 21/09/2023 12:32

The accusations against RB have an awful lot of weight behind them compared to the ones against cliff Richard. Anyway CR was never found to be “innocent” as far as I remember. I thought the charges were dropped/withdrawn due to insufficient evidence. Not the same thing as being innocent, whether he is or not.

Tbh the less exposure Russell Brand gets the better imo. Odious bastard.

A number of the historic allegations against the likes of CR were not "we couldn't find evidence" but actually the claims were not possible given the other evidence (certain people were not in the same physical location at the same time, etc.).

It is not a court finding "innocent" which really only happens with convictions of the accuser like Carl Beach or Jemma Beale. That is not to say obvious false accusations where the accused wad clearly innocent should not be described as such.

There were a number of accusations where it turned out at trial the accused was innocent (evidence showed it not to be possible), many involving teachers facing decades old accusations.

FOJN · 21/09/2023 12:44

I think that the letter sent by DCMS is political overreach and plays into the hands of those who believe RB is being targeted because of his beliefs.

Absolutely and it's giving other YouTube channels of the same "genre" plenty of conspiracy material.

Worldgonecrazy · 21/09/2023 12:42

I think that the letter sent by DCMS is political overreach and plays into the hands of those who believe RB is being targeted because of his beliefs.

The pedant in me is also horrified by the use of ‘Dear Firstname”

https://committees.parliament.uk/publications/41488/documents/204326/default/

YouTube jumped too soon and no UK Parliament are wading in!
DameWhiskers · 21/09/2023 12:37

You OK, Mavis? You realise he's hardly penniless?

Thisistyresome · 21/09/2023 12:37

A member of parliament asking a company to do something is not parliament asking. Just as it is not the government asking. If a Parliamentary Committee Chair writes to a US based company saying “do this” I suspect the undertone of the response will be “who are you?”

This is a police matter now and politicians should be keeping clear. Politicians have a habit of polluting investigations and should know that. The chances of finding something at this time line is very low but no one should want a politician getting involved and making it worse.

FOJN · 21/09/2023 12:37

I think some posters are not aware that Dame Caroline Dinenage, Chair of the Culture, Media and Sports Committee has written to the CEO of Rumble asking them to demonetise RB's channel.

One more time for those not aware of the most recent developments.

Rumble have refused.

YouTube made the decision without government intervention.

minipeony · 21/09/2023 12:36

CinnamonBear · 21/09/2023 12:34

It's a private company not a public utility. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Exactly. It's like Tesco deciding not to stock a product.