Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

YouTube jumped too soon and no UK Parliament are wading in!

59 replies

MetaverseMavis · 21/09/2023 12:09

No matter what my personal thoughts are about RB, I feel very uncomfortable with this trial by the media. YouTube has taken it too far by deciding he has violated their T&Cs and removed his channel. Now UK Parliament want his Rumble channel down.

Why is Parliament getting involved today? what are they scared of, I'm not a conspiracy theorist but this is absurd.

I seem to remember the media accusing Cliff Richard - turns out he was innocent.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FOJN · 21/09/2023 20:32

Begsthequestion · 21/09/2023 20:00

You want the CJS to protect rapists even more than it already does???

Why don't you just go ahead and say you think rape shouldn't be punished or prevented at all.

Is that really what you think the poster means or is it a mechanism by which you think you can shame people into silence?

The media is not the criminal justice system and for an MP to try to prevent someone earning on the basis of what's presented in the media is unreasonable when Brand has not been charged with anything yet.

CantThinkOfANameAtAll · 21/09/2023 20:27

Pix56 · 21/09/2023 15:51

No one got charged or convicted for stealing my car 3 years ago. I take it that I shouldn't have claimed on the insurance since no crime was committed? 🙄

Now you are being silly. It would be you going round the town telling everyone that neighbour Mr Jones stole it and he needs to lose his job immediately as he's a criminal despite no police charges or even a police interview. Gosh...🙄

Begsthequestion · 21/09/2023 20:00

TheBabylonian · 21/09/2023 15:12

Trial by media is disgusting and should be outlawed.

You want the CJS to protect rapists even more than it already does???

Why don't you just go ahead and say you think rape shouldn't be punished or prevented at all.

FeigningConcern · 21/09/2023 17:30

Worldgonecrazy · 21/09/2023 13:09

The phrase used is ‘We are concerned that he may be able to profit from his content on the platform.’

It is political overreach.

I don’t like Russel Brand and have never found him funny or attractive, but a Government committee sending such a letter is wrong.

Absolutely. It's completely inappropriate and quite worrying that the government would overstep in this way.

FOJN · 21/09/2023 16:48

cakehoover123 · 21/09/2023 16:12

@pinksunglasses I think you're confused.

The Committee's letters don't have anything to do with the criminal justice system. They don't have any bearing on any criminal case.

The Committee is writing to C4 and the BBC about their internal investigations into management processes. It's appropriate for the C4 and BBC to carry out management investigations, and it's appropriate for Parliament to be interested in those, because C4 and the BBC are publicly owned. Nothing to do with the criminal justice system.

Ditto the letter to TikTok. The Committee are asking about TikTok's monetisation policies, and asking about its procedures to protect victims. DCMS regulates the media in the UK, the Committee scrutinises DCMS, and these are questions about how the media is operating. Again, these are management issues, not criminal justice issues.

And nobody is being blocked from anything.

Does that help explain things?

Edited

This is the letter Caroline Dinenage sent to Rumble. It is not a simple enquiry about it's policies.

The letter specifically asks if Rumble intends to join YouTube in suspending Brands ability to generate income on the platform. The letter says that they are concerned about his ability to generate income from content he created and in that sentence they do not specify the nature of the content they are concerned about.

Asking what Rumble are doing to protect the welfare of victims assumes guilt. We are all free to speculate about that on the basis of the evidence presented in newspapers but it's disingenuous to claim that the same speculation from an elected representative is merely a "management issue" and therefore appropriate.

YouTube jumped too soon and no UK Parliament are wading in!
pinksunglasses · 21/09/2023 16:34

cakehoover123 · 21/09/2023 16:12

@pinksunglasses I think you're confused.

The Committee's letters don't have anything to do with the criminal justice system. They don't have any bearing on any criminal case.

The Committee is writing to C4 and the BBC about their internal investigations into management processes. It's appropriate for the C4 and BBC to carry out management investigations, and it's appropriate for Parliament to be interested in those, because C4 and the BBC are publicly owned. Nothing to do with the criminal justice system.

Ditto the letter to TikTok. The Committee are asking about TikTok's monetisation policies, and asking about its procedures to protect victims. DCMS regulates the media in the UK, the Committee scrutinises DCMS, and these are questions about how the media is operating. Again, these are management issues, not criminal justice issues.

And nobody is being blocked from anything.

Does that help explain things?

Edited

😁 No, not confused but thank you all the same.

I suppose it comes down to whether you believe they are simply asking or ‘expressing a concern’ knowing that a letter with a House of Commons stamp will often have ensure those concerns are taken quite seriously. My opinion is that the letters are heavy with subtext and I’ll be interested to see how it proceeds.

I also find it interesting that the same committee sent a letter to The Sun with regards to the Huw Edwards reporting and the tone was actually quite scolding:

‘Given the concerns that have been reported about inaccuracies, changing narratives and lack of engagement with some of the parties involved in the case of Mr Edwards, we would also be interested to understand what was done to verify this specific story and what, if any, reviews or discussions are ongoing about The Sun’s procedures and reporting in this case and any wider lessons to be learned.’

They are essentially wading into different cases with little consistency and I really believe that all government committees, individual MPs and cabinet members should be both mindful of their positions and upholding the justice system. All of their interventions would be valid if he had actually been charged with anything - that is the key thing here.

xILikeJamx · 21/09/2023 16:28

If someone goes into a pub and causes trouble, they get kicked out. If they come back another day and cause trouble again, they'll get kicked out and barred. It's a private business and they can choose to serve or not serve an individual at their discretion (discrimination laws notwithstanding).

Brand is causing trouble for YouTube and they're reacting in the same way.

cakehoover123 · 21/09/2023 16:12

@pinksunglasses I think you're confused.

The Committee's letters don't have anything to do with the criminal justice system. They don't have any bearing on any criminal case.

The Committee is writing to C4 and the BBC about their internal investigations into management processes. It's appropriate for the C4 and BBC to carry out management investigations, and it's appropriate for Parliament to be interested in those, because C4 and the BBC are publicly owned. Nothing to do with the criminal justice system.

Ditto the letter to TikTok. The Committee are asking about TikTok's monetisation policies, and asking about its procedures to protect victims. DCMS regulates the media in the UK, the Committee scrutinises DCMS, and these are questions about how the media is operating. Again, these are management issues, not criminal justice issues.

And nobody is being blocked from anything.

Does that help explain things?

IncomingTraffic · 21/09/2023 16:09

He’s been on tik tok comparing himself to Jesus apparently.

FOJN · 21/09/2023 15:57

Whataretheodds · 21/09/2023 15:18

There is a principle in British law that one should not profit from one's crimes.

Apart from a brief clip of him refuting the accusations made against him I not aware that he has made any content referring to the accusations so I don't see how that principle would apply.

Pix56 · 21/09/2023 15:51

CantThinkOfANameAtAll · 21/09/2023 15:23

He hasn't been charged. Therefore no crimes 🙄

No one got charged or convicted for stealing my car 3 years ago. I take it that I shouldn't have claimed on the insurance since no crime was committed? 🙄

sadaboutmycat · 21/09/2023 15:41

FOJN · 21/09/2023 12:21

I don't think they have asked for his channel to be taken down but they want Rumble to demonetise the channel.

YouTube continue to profit from his income even though they have demonetised it.

I think he's probably guilty as accused but I don't think the UK government should be getting involved in something that is not a criminal case yet.

The press are free to report on this story but I think the government intervening could call the possibility of a fair trial into question.

You've said what I think but more eloquently than I could!

IncomingTraffic · 21/09/2023 15:39

Maybe the select committee need to know if brand is/can make money out of this, and what SM companies are doing about influential people using them as a platform to undermine people who challenge them as part of the process of figuring out if there is a problem, and if parliament should be doing something about it.

CantThinkOfANameAtAll · 21/09/2023 15:23

Whataretheodds · 21/09/2023 15:18

There is a principle in British law that one should not profit from one's crimes.

He hasn't been charged. Therefore no crimes 🙄

pinksunglasses · 21/09/2023 15:22

cakehoover123 · 21/09/2023 14:58

@pinksunglasses totally disagree.

If a colleague is "aggressive and disrespectful" towards women while at work (as Brand's behaviour has been described), that's not a criminal offence - but it's unprofessional behaviour that should be dealt with by HR.

If a colleague repeatedly sexually assaults people at work, in a way that is an "open secret" (as Brand's behaviour has also been described), would you want to share an office with them until someone wins a criminal case? Would you want junior team members to do so?

Management and criminal convictions are different things. Would you want to be told "your colleague doesn't have a criminal conviction, so we won't take any management action"?

The BBC and C4 are publicly-owned broadcasters. It's appropriate for Parliament to look into how much management knew about his behaviour, and what they did in response.

@IncomingTraffic totally agree!

You don’t appear to have read my post properly.

I said:

‘Tesco would be entitled to do so (suspend or sack) depending on their own policies but the government should be upholding the justice system!’

Private companies should have robust policies for employees, including process should somebody be accused of a crime.

Parliament, however, do not get to decide how the justice system and due process should apply to each individual accused person because the law is supposed to apply to all of us equally.

If MPs feel that blocking income streams or censoring social media accounts of accused persons should be part of that process, they can lobby for that to be debated in parliament. As it stands, that’s not how it works and therefore they are over the line.

It’s no good emoting about hypothetical situations in which I might find myself sharing a desk with a prolific rapist because of course I would want to raise hell. Just as I would if it were my daughter or sister. But that is why the justice system is supposed to be unbiased.

And I’d rather not set a precedent for public shaming and misuse of power even if that means some people don’t have quite as bad a time before their trial as I’d like them to. Because in my heart, I know that if it was my son, my daughter, my husband or myself being accused of something - I would want them to be treated fairly.

Wariness about the justice system and it’s proper application is not because I care about Russell Brand or any one individual, it’s because the justice system either protects all of us or none of us.

Also, this approach means that even if this case were to get to trial - there is absolutely no way to ensure an unbiased jury now. Which is problematic in itself.

Whataretheodds · 21/09/2023 15:18

There is a principle in British law that one should not profit from one's crimes.

Whataretheodds · 21/09/2023 15:18

MetaverseMavis · 21/09/2023 12:32

Do we stop anyone with a SA allegation against them - made by the media, from working immediately whilst they await a police investigation, possible charge and eventually a trial?

No. Just him.

If we did, half of our media and government would be hanging around jobless.

Can you think of a comparable case of a famous bame making money from media appearances while multiple substantial, detailer and substantial allegations of criminal conduct are made against them?

I can't think of a recent example where there hasn't been a call for them to be demonetised. When politicians were accused of less serious crimes and not suspended without pay there was outcry.

TheBabylonian · 21/09/2023 15:12

Trial by media is disgusting and should be outlawed.

Gothambutnotahamster · 21/09/2023 15:03

FOJN · 21/09/2023 12:21

I don't think they have asked for his channel to be taken down but they want Rumble to demonetise the channel.

YouTube continue to profit from his income even though they have demonetised it.

I think he's probably guilty as accused but I don't think the UK government should be getting involved in something that is not a criminal case yet.

The press are free to report on this story but I think the government intervening could call the possibility of a fair trial into question.

Completely agree.

cakehoover123 · 21/09/2023 14:58

@pinksunglasses totally disagree.

If a colleague is "aggressive and disrespectful" towards women while at work (as Brand's behaviour has been described), that's not a criminal offence - but it's unprofessional behaviour that should be dealt with by HR.

If a colleague repeatedly sexually assaults people at work, in a way that is an "open secret" (as Brand's behaviour has also been described), would you want to share an office with them until someone wins a criminal case? Would you want junior team members to do so?

Management and criminal convictions are different things. Would you want to be told "your colleague doesn't have a criminal conviction, so we won't take any management action"?

The BBC and C4 are publicly-owned broadcasters. It's appropriate for Parliament to look into how much management knew about his behaviour, and what they did in response.

@IncomingTraffic totally agree!

MetaverseMavis · 21/09/2023 14:41

Cancel culture has gone too far. The government have overstepped the mark by getting involved. SA accusations are a regular (sadly) occurrence, and this doesn't happen to everyone accused of SA, most carry on until trial before losing anything.

OP posts:
BlooDeBloop · 21/09/2023 13:47

If you had eyes and interest to see many YouTube channels during COVID times were taken down without scrutiny. It seemed obvious to me the government was asking the company to do so. But I was a conspiracy theorist for thinking so 🙄. It was shocking to me but obviously there was little coverage at the time and little public interest. Today's news shows just how they do it - a polite 'request' is sent. There'll be arm wresting behind the scenes I expect. Most will come into line: YouTube already have, they know their place.

With RB, what we are seeing are unproven allegations being used to bring down a person. They aren't satisfied with a 'never work on the BBC again'. They want to see him bankrupted, with a broken marriage, on the streets, on drugs. They want to COMPLETELY destroy him. Is that justified even if the allegations are true?

Thisistyresome · 21/09/2023 13:32

Naunet · 21/09/2023 13:18

Explain to me why it’s ok for YouTube to cancel women’s channels for knowing not what biological sex is, but outrageous for a millionaire male accused of rape? YouTube is a private platform, they can do what they want.

Has anyone on here said it is ok for YouTube to target women discussing the reality around biological sex?

Looks like people object to a company gaining dominant market share and then appointing it self arbiter of truth particularly with ambiguous rules. There needs to be clear standard, any targeting of women discussing reality regarding sex highlights the need for better standards.

Mulhollandmagoo · 21/09/2023 13:30

I think YouTube are well within their rights, as they are a private company - so they could demonitise anyone whenever they want for no reason what-so-ever, and to be fair, until he is proven innocent, he shouldn't be able to make money off this very large amount of exposure he is getting right now, as it is in bad taste.

I think its overstepping from the government to be getting involved, people get accused of rape every day and they don't get involved, so in that respect he is being unfairly treated.

It is similar in effect to someone being suspended from their job, if one of my colleagues was being investigated for multiple rapes, we would have to suspend them until the investigation was compete.

IncomingTraffic · 21/09/2023 13:29

You don't think that the above, under a House of Commons letterhead, implies a clear directive to TikTok? It’s not a neutral stance!

Absolutely nothing about it compels tik tok to do anything.

I would not be surprised if they come back saying that they will not comment on individual tik tok members and with information about their acceptable use policy and moderation procedures.

They’re writing to a multinational corporation, not an individual. I sincerely doubt tik tok will give much of a shit about the letter.

Swipe left for the next trending thread