Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Birthday coming up - already know I’ll be disappointed

186 replies

TastyCheeseYum · 21/09/2023 10:38

My birthday is coming up and I already know DH will forget. I mentioned it’s not going to be a great day anyway as he’ll be at work all day then it’s football in the evening. He just said “oh, we can do something another time instead”. Tried to hide my disappointment but don’t think it worked.

Question is, AIBU to want to do something nice on the day when DH is home from work? I’ll be with DD all day while he’s at work (she’s 18mo so doesn’t get the concept of birthdays yet).

Guess I’m just getting fed up of being the lowest priority in the household even though I’m the one making all the decisions, keeping the house tidy, etc.

Sorry, rant over lol 🫠

OP posts:
Iaintsadwhenugotobed · 24/09/2023 18:40

I’m so sorry you’re going through that OP. It’s horrible being the one who seems to be overlooked all the time. I would say definitely tell him and if he doesn’t want to change his plans then plan your own day out with friends
he is being unreasonable I would expect him to drop his plans for the one day of the year that is about you. It’s an annual thing he knew about it he should be planning ahead.
Xx

catgirl1976 · 24/09/2023 18:35

Mine is on Monday.

I’ve moved it to Saturday as Monday is my first day back at work after a period of illness, I’m still a bit poorly and it’s right before payday.

I’ve told DH to get me cards from him and DS and that is like a massage but to just make me a voucher with DS and I’ll book one after I get paid and I’ve booked for all of us to go out for a nice meal on Saturday.

so maybe move your birthday to the weekend and be really clear about how you would like to spend it or, arrange things yourself. No it’s not romantic and surprising etc but it means you won’t be disappointed and you’ll spend it as you wanted. If the surprise and romance elements really matter to you then you need to talk to your DH and explain this. Possibly using crayons and diagrams if he’s like a lot of men

happy birthday though

Winnipeg23 · 24/09/2023 18:32

Do something with people who do care and don't bother with his birthday. Card and happy birthday dear.
Lots of people don't bother that much. Ones not right and ones not wrong. But make it work for u.
Don't be sad.

Maybe ask him if there is another day he can think of when he would like to come up with something to treat you too🤣 don't be disappointed if he doesn't come up with anything.
If he on the whole is a good husband, just accept it and reciprocate.
If he's generally totally selfish and unhelpful... hmmm

DoughBallss · 24/09/2023 18:31

If your husband won’t celebrate with you then sod him! Make plans, tell him you have plans and need him to have DD…problem solved :)

Ass hole move from him though it’s one day a year, I’d be fuming.

Screamingabdabz · 24/09/2023 18:24

HobbyHorse30 · 24/09/2023 17:47

There are a lot of low bar responses here. Why should you plan your own celebration or have it on a day that’s not your birthday, and be grateful for the ‘luxury’ of <check notes> a hot dinner?

I usually plan my own birthday because then I can do exactly as I’d like, but my basic expectation is that my husband would make an effort to treat my birthday as an occasion if I hadn’t made it clear what I’d like to do. Just as I’d do for him.

Exactly! It’s still a bit sad and sorry to have a party for one or ‘arrange your own birthday’ while your beloved soul mate and father of your children sits on his arse enjoying his footy not giving a solitary shit about doing anything special or making any kind of effort.

The best birthday celebration you could have on your own is to make an appointment with a divorce lawyer and dump his useless arse.

Buffs · 24/09/2023 18:20

If you want something nice, organize it yourself.

Judecb · 24/09/2023 18:18

Get a couple of girlfriends over and celebrate whilst he's at football and once your daughter is in bed. Make if clear to your husband that she's his responsibility when he gets in, so you can have some time to yourself. That would have been a great present to self when my kids were young! 😁

PrinceHaz · 24/09/2023 18:16

I would look at this in the round. When you’re old and grey, will you look back with pride and happiness at the decades of joy you’ve had, or will you feel bitter about your years wasted with a lazy, inconsiderate arse.

PrinceHaz · 24/09/2023 18:14

It’s so, so unpleasant of him not to put the football on hold for your birthday. He is telling you very clearly that your birthday is not as important as his football.
To the people who say the birthday celebration can be moved, of course it can but that would be with agreement by both parties, not because one can’t be arsed and the other one is going to have to lump it.

Retiredfromearlyyears · 24/09/2023 18:10

Oh dear! This is a bit of a red flag! He comes home and watches footie on the t.v. meanwhile you have to wait to have your birthday acknowledged. He could afford a cake ,card and a couple of hours away from his bloomin' football. Speak up!

IsItThough · 24/09/2023 17:59

@HobbyHorse30 I reckon people are just being pragmatic - I certainly was.
Having to insist in the couple of days remaining that your husband sorts out something fancy and changes his plans/assumptions is going to make it feel like an obligation, not a joy. There's a longer term convo on why it matters to be had though.

In our house it's a household policy of making a fuss of everyone's birthdays, too, because why not, life is short and you've got to have some enjoyment....

HobbyHorse30 · 24/09/2023 17:47

There are a lot of low bar responses here. Why should you plan your own celebration or have it on a day that’s not your birthday, and be grateful for the ‘luxury’ of <check notes> a hot dinner?

I usually plan my own birthday because then I can do exactly as I’d like, but my basic expectation is that my husband would make an effort to treat my birthday as an occasion if I hadn’t made it clear what I’d like to do. Just as I’d do for him.

BluebellsForest · 24/09/2023 17:13

Calling someone goady is hardly an attack, FFS.

Sorry for derailing, OP. I hope you're able to update with how you're working things out.

category12 · 24/09/2023 17:07

BluebellsForest · 24/09/2023 17:03

I disagree when a poster is repeatedly attempting to undermine and dismiss an OP who has said how sidelined she already feels, @category12.

Edited

Attack the ideas not the person.

BluebellsForest · 24/09/2023 17:03

I disagree when a poster is repeatedly attempting to undermine and dismiss an OP who has said how sidelined she already feels, @category12.

category12 · 24/09/2023 16:57

BluebellsForest · 24/09/2023 16:46

Hair-trigger modding, @category12

Edited

It was a pointless personal attack. I reported it. The mods agreed and took it down. Meh. It wasn't bringing anything interesting to the discussion.

I've had posts of mine taken down in the past. I care not.

BluebellsForest · 24/09/2023 16:46

Hair-trigger modding, @category12

IsItThough · 24/09/2023 16:46

I think you should

  1. plan for you and DD to do something lovely - go for a really nice lunch out either on your own or with friends
  2. tell your useless DH that you find his attitude very hurtful and that you would like your birthday to be acknowledged, on the day itself (- bare minimum he can organise a takeaway/dinner, flowers and a card; and get home in time to sort bedtime with DD whilst you go to the gym/have a nap/have a bath) OR go out with your mates and he can look after his child.
Bobsledgirl · 24/09/2023 16:40

I hate a fuss so not bothered by birthdays but if you want it a certain way….tell him
what you want. Waiting and hoping that he’ll give you a brilliant birthday will end in disappointment unless you take control.

category12 · 24/09/2023 16:37

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Nah, that was me. It was just a personal attack and had no value as a post.

BluebellsForest · 24/09/2023 16:35

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

category12 · 24/09/2023 16:23

UsingChangeofName · 24/09/2023 16:05

I mean this as a genuine remark not a goady one, you should consider have higher expectations of your partner / husband.

As an aside, my husband played football for a couple of years in the evenings and it was a bit of fun for a group of over 35s. They weren’t under the illusion they were Manchester United, it was perfectly fine and normal for somebody to not be able to make it some weeks if they had a higher priority family occasion.

Which is fine if that is the way it has been set on / the conditions on which he joined.
Personally I think it is really important to ringfence some time each week to do something for yourself. Whether it is a sport or a book club or a choir or meeting a mate to play pool or to learn how to paint or to go rock climbing or to do meditation. It doesn't matter what it is that clears your head, but if you work and have family responsibilities, then, IMHO it is good to prioritise that space.
A lot of posters on MN froth because the word 'football' is mentioned. If it were anything else the dh were doing, then there wouldn't be half the angst. It isn't saying that the match is more important than the birthday, it is saying "If we go for a meal on the Thursday, then we can do both, whereas if we go for the meal on the Wednesday, the other activity doesn't happen".

It's nothing to do with being a man or being a woman, it's to do with communication and a bit of common sense.

But this guy is just watching football on the telly at home. He's not going out to practice or support a club, he's not letting anyone down by not watching, he's not ringfencing time with friends or whatever.

It's a couple of hours of telly that he's prioritising over his partner's birthday.

He could (despite ilovesooty's protestations 😂) watch it on catch up later in the evening. Or (to appease ilovesooty) he could fit something nice for her around the match. Or he could, instead of saying "we can do something another time instead", have made actual plans for what they'll do to celebrate another night. Instead he's been vague and dismissive and OP knows from experience he'll forget (can't be arsed).

UsingChangeofName · 24/09/2023 16:05

I mean this as a genuine remark not a goady one, you should consider have higher expectations of your partner / husband.

As an aside, my husband played football for a couple of years in the evenings and it was a bit of fun for a group of over 35s. They weren’t under the illusion they were Manchester United, it was perfectly fine and normal for somebody to not be able to make it some weeks if they had a higher priority family occasion.

Which is fine if that is the way it has been set on / the conditions on which he joined.
Personally I think it is really important to ringfence some time each week to do something for yourself. Whether it is a sport or a book club or a choir or meeting a mate to play pool or to learn how to paint or to go rock climbing or to do meditation. It doesn't matter what it is that clears your head, but if you work and have family responsibilities, then, IMHO it is good to prioritise that space.
A lot of posters on MN froth because the word 'football' is mentioned. If it were anything else the dh were doing, then there wouldn't be half the angst. It isn't saying that the match is more important than the birthday, it is saying "If we go for a meal on the Thursday, then we can do both, whereas if we go for the meal on the Wednesday, the other activity doesn't happen".

It's nothing to do with being a man or being a woman, it's to do with communication and a bit of common sense.

DangerousAlchemy · 24/09/2023 09:28

If OPs DH is choosing to watch his team play on TV rather than doing something nice for her birthday then that is totally shit! I plan my own birthdays now as my DH is usually working etc or playing footy. Or I book a weekend away with friends. My DH also can't see the point of birthdays! When kids are v young it's important couples make an effort though as life seems hard enough with young kids without husbands making us feel more depressed than normal with their lack of interest. Book a spa weekend away with a friend or your Mum & dump your DC on him for the weekend. That's what I'd do. My DH has been playing football every Sat afternoon & gone from the house 1- 6pm for 20 years 🙈 & it is annoying tbh. Plus coaching our DS team Saturday mornings til 10-11.30 plus DS matches on Sundays. I make my own plans most weekends tbh so I don't feel (too) resentful & I did choose to marry a man who was obsessed with sport so I should have realised I guess.

Thementalloadisreal · 23/09/2023 22:30

ilovesooty · 23/09/2023 18:25

And I've said that as an avid sports fan, I don't think recording and watching later is a viable alternative.

The date of the birthday might be static but I don't think the celebration has to be.

The date of the birthday might be static but I don't think the celebration has to be.

Surely you only get to make that choice for your own birthday, not someone else’s