Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ex accused of rape. DD wants to move in with him

178 replies

Overreactingmom · 21/09/2023 10:01

I don’t even know where to begin everything is such a mess.

I have a child (DD12) with Ex. Recently discovered he has 2 separate rape allegations pending (different women, both 18+). He has court early Jan. He also has a record for assaulting me.

ex has a new gf with 2 young girls. SS said he couldn’t live with them anymore as he was an ‘indirect risk’ and they were worried about his drinking/driving/behaviour.

I only found any of this out because ex told me about 1 allegation, the rest came from speaking to SS and the courts.

So they advised (only advised so not set rules) no overnights, for him not to drive her anywhere himself but otherwise keep contact as long as I don’t see any red flags and she can call me if needed.

so for the first time in years he’s been more consistent seeing my DD and has seen her 5 weeks in a row. She is now asking for sleepovers, to live there every other week FT and staying she wants to live there when she is 16. he also wants to take her abroad in Dec which he has never done before even for a weekend.

I am actually heartbroken that she wants to live there as I’ve raised her without much input from him at all. (Never done a school run, night waking, drs appt, etc). It feels like a betrayal from my child (IABU there I know). DD knows he’s been accused of ‘assault’ but assumed fighting in a pub etc so she doesn’t know the real reason. I’m

he speaks to me like shit, comments on my appearance, speaks badly about me in-front of DD and comments on my weight.

I don’t know what to do. How to go forward. I don’t even know if he’s going to be around after court happens. I am going to court to hear details as I need to know if he is guilty or not.

Please be kind. I am so upset and torn right now.

OP posts:
leopardprintismyfavourite · 21/09/2023 14:56

His girlfriend cannot be deemed responsible - she’s knowingly having her children around him.

The social services investigation for her children will read something along the lines of ‘he is of a medium/high risk to the children in a domestic setting’

this means that in effect, around your child on his own he may well be fine. But in the context of a relationship, he is volatile. And that means that those children are more likely to witness something as a result or get caught in the crossfire.

So ask yourself, why is your child in the exact same situation, any different to hers?

Social services are well known for sitting on the fence. If you take her into protective custody, withhold contact from her dad unless in a supervised contact centre, you will at least have removed that element of harm.

Social services don’t have the law on their side to do that as she is not being abused directly and they’re saying that they aren’t living together - and believe it or not that’s the only version of the truth they need to make that assessment.

You have to do it, and in court to some extent if you withhold contact completely you will be vilified. But allowing her to go to him, says to a court ‘I think it’s safe for them to all be around each other’ which puts you in a state of culpability if something happens.

I went through this process. It’s shit, I won’t lie. But it stopped the unwanted behaviour. The abuser moved onto someone else who they left for dead in front of a child.

Abusers rarely change after the age of 30. Protect your daughter. Get legal advice. File an urgent order to remove his parental responsibility.

MsFogi · 21/09/2023 14:53

He's doing this so he can raise it in mitigation at his trial - don't send my client down at all/for too long, look at what an amazing and involved dad he is and his poor daughter will suffer if you deprive her of her dad by sending him to prison for raping women...

Gnomegnomegnome · 21/09/2023 14:52

CoveredWindows · 21/09/2023 14:48

It’s advisory at the moment. However, if you allow it you may well find the decision removed from you, with SS become involved. I’d be very clear that she cannot go there, and leave it to him to go to court if he wishes to see her

This. I would tell dd that although it’s only advisory at the moment that she could end up losing both of you if you allowed this.

Nothing seems fair when you are 12 and of course it’s mums fault!

I don’t know if I would tell her that he’s been accused of two counts of rape but I would make sure that she knows that it’s very serious allegations regarding his behaviour towards females.

CoveredWindows · 21/09/2023 14:48

It’s advisory at the moment. However, if you allow it you may well find the decision removed from you, with SS become involved. I’d be very clear that she cannot go there, and leave it to him to go to court if he wishes to see her

whynotwhatknot · 21/09/2023 14:48

shes not a responsible adult shes not meant to be there

CClaire · 21/09/2023 14:46

I would tell her [a 12yo’s version] of exactly what’s going on and that your job has always been to keep her safe and always will be. Pull him up when he talks to you like sh!t as well. What a scumbag.

QOD · 21/09/2023 14:43

if he is still living with the girlfriend and her kids, you need to speak to SS

Tryingmybestadhd · 21/09/2023 14:33

You need to contact SS again , to get more advice and to report him living with minors . You should also speak with the school , ask if they can get your daughter some counselling . I also wonder if a meeting with her and a police liaison or someone similar and explain to her the charges against her father .
you be red to start moving now regarding hun wanting to travel and out a full stop to it . If she has a passport hide it and contact the home office regarding a risk if kidnap

DoughnutDreams · 21/09/2023 14:31

Overreactingmom · 21/09/2023 14:18

Thank you everyone, I have up til this point followed SS’s advice every step of the way. It has been more difficult than expected as court was postponed so this has been going on since around March.

I have emailed the courts to see if I can access bail conditions. I am debating on the advice of telling her more, she is a fairly grown up 12 but quite an emotional child still.

part of the advice from SS was that he had to have a responsible adult there when she sees him so it is supervised to an extent. This has been the gf who communicating and facilitating the contact.

Obviously I don’t plan on acting on her wishes of overnights etc I just needed an outlet. I think I will call SS again to get some updated advice given the sudden interest and ask for it in writing to help back me up with her.

His gf cannot be deemed a responsible adult for supervised contact, as she is failing to follow SS advice and protect her own children.

Overreactingmom · 21/09/2023 14:18

Thank you everyone, I have up til this point followed SS’s advice every step of the way. It has been more difficult than expected as court was postponed so this has been going on since around March.

I have emailed the courts to see if I can access bail conditions. I am debating on the advice of telling her more, she is a fairly grown up 12 but quite an emotional child still.

part of the advice from SS was that he had to have a responsible adult there when she sees him so it is supervised to an extent. This has been the gf who communicating and facilitating the contact.

Obviously I don’t plan on acting on her wishes of overnights etc I just needed an outlet. I think I will call SS again to get some updated advice given the sudden interest and ask for it in writing to help back me up with her.

OP posts:
Mirabai · 21/09/2023 14:14

I don’t really understand why you’re “torn” OP. SS won’t let him live with gf’s children why would yours be any different?

He’s lovebombing her now because she’s approaching puberty and is of more interest to him. He wants to show the court and SS he’s a “good dad”- which will give him more access to teenage girls long term. It’s win win.

PoshPineapple · 21/09/2023 14:13

Oh gosh, I'm so sorry - this must be an impossible situation for you.

The only thing I've thought of (and apologies if it's already been raised, I skimmed through the replies)...I'm assuming he was arrested at some point? If that's the case, he'll have bail conditions pending a court hearing. Can you possibly access these? I know that social services sometimes (but definitely not always) are privy to them but it would be interesting to see if and how they match up to what social services are suggesting.

I agree with the majority on here though, I think it's time for gentle honesty with your DD. She'll find out the truth at some point, especially if he is found guilty - it will be published in the press and likely be the local gossip for a while. Much better that she knows the reality beforehand and you can discuss between you how to deal with any potential outcome.

Edited because my fat fingers did all sorts of random stuff first time around!

babyproblems · 21/09/2023 14:10

I agree he is abusing both of you.
you move forward by reducing his presence in your lives as much as you can.

By allowing him all these privileges with your DD you are giving him way too much control. I would reduce his involvement as much as you can and I would push for zero contact, reinforced by court if at all possible. When your DD is older you can tell her the real reasons he is dangerous.

you’re a great mother. Sending love xxxxx

RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway · 21/09/2023 14:09

Overreactingmom · 21/09/2023 10:07

Yes she does know SS said no overnights but because it’s just advisory she thinks (as he has said to her) that we don’t have to follow it and that SS are being over the top and so am I.

he is also still living with the gf and her 2 children.

Sounds like her dad and his GF are using her as a babysitter for the GF's two.

heyathere · 21/09/2023 14:05

heyathere · 21/09/2023 14:02

I think you have to tell her the truth (gently, appropriately, maybe research how to do this, follow up with lots of support for her, ensure she has access to other support if needed) or she will grow up believing you are purposely obstructing/undermining their relationship.

Or worse, get rebellious and put herself in danger as a teen by going over to his house unsupervised whether day or night.

The assault is confirmed and familiarity breeds contempt in this sort of people – I've no doubt that while he may be sweet to her now, he'll start treating her the way he treated you if she moves in.

He already is by being abusive to you in front of her – honestly not to guilt trip you because it's hard decisions all round, but you're teaching her a terrible message that it's OK for girls/women to be treated like trash. She'll prob find a boyfriend/partner like him.

heyathere · 21/09/2023 14:02

I think you have to tell her the truth (gently, appropriately, maybe research how to do this, follow up with lots of support for her, ensure she has access to other support if needed) or she will grow up believing you are purposely obstructing/undermining their relationship.

LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 21/09/2023 14:00

Sorry - I was slow to post my answer and can see other people are also suspicious of his motives!

LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 21/09/2023 13:59

He is abusing you (and using her to do so).

Am I being too suspicious in thinking that he might also be trying to make himself look like a devoted family man who is trusted with his daughter ? Even his estranged wife trusts him! (There is always: 'But your honour, a prison sentence would be a sentence for this innocent little girl who depends on me' ) His new interest in her is notable.

I agree that she needs to know the truth before she completely falls for him in the heroic-dad image he is presenting to her.

It will be in the papers and at school if in court.

If you talk to her about his treatment of girls/women , at least she will be looking out for trouble when with him. Even if she refuses to believe you now, she might be protected by understanding any future wrong-doing from him when she sees it (rather than feeling any wrong-doing by him is her fault and a secret).

Is it possible to get SS to explain to her why they advise as they do?

This might be better than you explaining (as he can tell her that you hate him etc.). You could then add to this by talking through why you trust them and agree with them? You might be able to lead her to this conclusion herself.

Mble · 21/09/2023 13:55

I thought exactly the same as @GoingDownLikeBHS

GoingDownLikeBHS · 21/09/2023 13:47

Not RTFT just OP's posts, but has anyone else said that he's encouraging the DD to live with him so as to use this in his favour in court? His solicitor has probably told him to present as a committed family man with PR over young DD, which will go in his favour if it comes to sentencing.

oakleaffy · 21/09/2023 13:44

@Overreactingmom Tell your daughter the truth.
It’s horrible for you both, your daughter needs truth and honesty.

Namechange800 · 21/09/2023 13:44

The other issue with this in addition to what everyone else has said is that no doubt your daughter would want to have friends over to stay, and this is not a man who should be having unsupervised access with any teenage girl. Imagine if you were the parents of another child, and this wasn’t disclosed, and they went to stay over and something happened

Whilst social services have given you advice, that was presumably based on the fact that she wasn’t actually seeing him that much since that advice was given, it looks like things are vamped up, and it is quite concerning that he is asking her to live with him and encouraging that. I suggest (family lawyer) that you call children services tell them been going on and asked for updated advice. In my view, your daughter shouldn’t be going overnight until the rape case has been dealt with. If he’s convicted he will go to prison anyway. if he’s not convicted then you can tell your daughter, you can review things then.

JFDIYOLO · 21/09/2023 13:40

I would tell her the truth.

Finding an age appropriate way to describe rape will be the challenge, but she needs to understand why your duty is to protect her.

Poundfoolishpennywise · 21/09/2023 13:32

You have had some good advice on this thread but I would not tell her about what he has been accused of. He hasn’t been found guilty yet (? apologies if I have missed something) but also this information is in no way appropriate to tell a 12 year old girl who clearly loves her Dad. I was told something much less serious about mine when I was 15 and the knowledge of it nearly triggered an eating disorder. She is still a child, barely into secondary school.

Morewineplease10 · 21/09/2023 13:28

I think unfortunately you have to tell your DD. Which is shit, she's still young, but he's put you in this situation, noone else.

He's a rapist. Of course you must do everything possible to protect your DD.

And yes, I know he's not been convicted, but two allegations?!

And tell SS of his living situation...