Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Childless dog owners at kids park

334 replies

Canisaysomething · 21/09/2023 09:43

My DCs school has a children’s park right outside. There is no fence around it and nowhere does it say “dogs not allowed”. Dog owners with children at the school let their dogs walk about the play area and this isn’t normally a problem at all.

Here is my AIBU. There’s become an increasing number of childless dog owners going to the park before and after school to let their dogs “socialise” with the children using the park. I had to ask a dog owner the other day to call their dog away from my child trying to use the swing and was shouted at by the owner who said “she’s just excited and trying to play”. The dog at one point chased after my child who got scared and upset.

Here’s my AIBU. Who was right? Me or the dog owner?

There were no signs saying “no dogs” but aren’t dogs meant to be trained NOT to bother strangers? Especially children in parks.

OP posts:
Alstroemeria123 · 21/09/2023 16:52

Are you seriously arguing that what most people would recognise as a children’s play area isn’t for children because there are no signs?

I’m starting to understand why my bag of cashews said “contains nuts” now.

TheCupboardUnderTheStairsAtTheMojoDojoCasaHouse · 21/09/2023 16:47

Oliotya · 21/09/2023 15:55

A lack of facilities for training dogs doesn't entitle them to use children's facilities. There are no public dog agility courses because dogs aren't people. Public facilities are for people, not pets. People play tennis. People play rugby. Dogs are not people. You want more dog facilities, go and campaign for it, but you can't just help yourself to children's facilities.

The facilities in question aren't specifically designated for children - they aren't fenced off, and there are no signs saying "children only" or "no dogs". They are for everyone.

Agility is a sport for humans as much as it is for dogs. Tennis involves humans and a racket. Volleyball involves humans and a ball. Agility involves humans and a dog. It's all just different kit for different sports.

Next you'll say that there shouldn't be bridleways because horses are pets, and horseriding has nothing to do with humans Hmm

Asiatoyork · 21/09/2023 16:25

There's a park not too far from me that has one! It's a lovely little green space. Tennis courts, bowls club. Really good playground no dogs!), dog agility area. Small allotment area for community use, a field/sports area and a community run café. More councils could do this

I feel bad now because I was being sarcastic and your reply is lovely! You don’t live near the Imperial War Museum do you?!

I can see the fun of a few little dog obstacles dotted about for sure :)

CwmYoy · 21/09/2023 15:56

TheCupboardUnderTheStairsAtTheMojoDojoCasaHouse · 21/09/2023 15:48

There really aren't that many agility clubs out there - and they are always miles from anywhere and completely inaccessible on public transport. They're also expensive.

Agility clubs teach competitive agility, which is an entirely different skill to search and rescue.

Expense, travelling miles and weekly commitments to an agility club just doesn't suit the pet dog owner who wants an engaging interlude in their dog walk.

This idea makes about as much sense as telling someone whose child wants to go up climbing frames and down slides that they should join the local rock climbing club and start scaling the cliffs in the countryside an hour away.

There isn't a single public dog agility course in my county or the neighbouring counties. There's a few in London, so it's clearly possible, but we're nowhere near London.

There are facilities in my local parks for all sorts of sports - tennis, rugby, cricket, football, even volleyball and softball. Why not agility? Humans are just as involved in agility as they are in tennis, they go around the course with the dog.

Finally, dog's paws are no muddier than human shoes. We're talking about dogs balancing on the stepping log things for instance - their feet only go where human feet go.

Why are you comparing dogs with children? Not the same thing at all.

Dog owners seem to think their dogs matter as much as children. They don't. They do not belong in children's play parks - why you seem to think they do smacks of the ludicrous entitlement of many dog owners.

Keep your dogs away from children's play parks. If you can't find anywhere else to train the dog that's just tough.

Oliotya · 21/09/2023 15:55

TheCupboardUnderTheStairsAtTheMojoDojoCasaHouse · 21/09/2023 15:48

There really aren't that many agility clubs out there - and they are always miles from anywhere and completely inaccessible on public transport. They're also expensive.

Agility clubs teach competitive agility, which is an entirely different skill to search and rescue.

Expense, travelling miles and weekly commitments to an agility club just doesn't suit the pet dog owner who wants an engaging interlude in their dog walk.

This idea makes about as much sense as telling someone whose child wants to go up climbing frames and down slides that they should join the local rock climbing club and start scaling the cliffs in the countryside an hour away.

There isn't a single public dog agility course in my county or the neighbouring counties. There's a few in London, so it's clearly possible, but we're nowhere near London.

There are facilities in my local parks for all sorts of sports - tennis, rugby, cricket, football, even volleyball and softball. Why not agility? Humans are just as involved in agility as they are in tennis, they go around the course with the dog.

Finally, dog's paws are no muddier than human shoes. We're talking about dogs balancing on the stepping log things for instance - their feet only go where human feet go.

A lack of facilities for training dogs doesn't entitle them to use children's facilities. There are no public dog agility courses because dogs aren't people. Public facilities are for people, not pets. People play tennis. People play rugby. Dogs are not people. You want more dog facilities, go and campaign for it, but you can't just help yourself to children's facilities.

Baffled1989 · 21/09/2023 15:50

I assume because they’ve no children with them. She didn’t say parentless , don’t start!

Baffled1989 · 21/09/2023 15:49

There doesn’t need to be A responsible owner does not let their dogs near children unattended let alone chase one!

Speaking as a dog owner with a 2 yr old.

TheCupboardUnderTheStairsAtTheMojoDojoCasaHouse · 21/09/2023 15:48

CwmYoy · 21/09/2023 15:11

So next time you hear on the news that someone is missing (elderly person or a child) or we are sending in rescue teams to an desaster zone, the dog finding people might well have started training on a children's playground.

Inadequate training facilities for rescue dogs is not a good enough reason to let them trample their muddy paws all over children's play equipment. There are plenty of dog agility clubs. Take them there.

There really aren't that many agility clubs out there - and they are always miles from anywhere and completely inaccessible on public transport. They're also expensive.

Agility clubs teach competitive agility, which is an entirely different skill to search and rescue.

Expense, travelling miles and weekly commitments to an agility club just doesn't suit the pet dog owner who wants an engaging interlude in their dog walk.

This idea makes about as much sense as telling someone whose child wants to go up climbing frames and down slides that they should join the local rock climbing club and start scaling the cliffs in the countryside an hour away.

There isn't a single public dog agility course in my county or the neighbouring counties. There's a few in London, so it's clearly possible, but we're nowhere near London.

There are facilities in my local parks for all sorts of sports - tennis, rugby, cricket, football, even volleyball and softball. Why not agility? Humans are just as involved in agility as they are in tennis, they go around the course with the dog.

Finally, dog's paws are no muddier than human shoes. We're talking about dogs balancing on the stepping log things for instance - their feet only go where human feet go.

6 (Public) Dog Agility Trails in London - The Londog

Looking for things to do with your dog in London? All about 5 dog agility trails in North, East, South and West London parks you can visit for free!

https://thelondog.com/dog-agility-trails-london/

GeneralLevy · 21/09/2023 15:30

Ylvamoon · 21/09/2023 14:51

On a serious note, I actually train one of my dogs at a children's playground....
She's going to be a search & rescue dog.

The truth is, my dog as well as many others wouldn't have made the grade in terms of fitness & agility if it wasn't for the wobbly bridges, slides and balancing beams.

The search & rescue team in my county is entirely run by volunteers. The dogs training course is also paid by volunteers.
So unless a dog is super fit among other things, they won't be considered.
Plus, we have space/ funding for 5 search & rescue dogs.... the Woking team has 3 dogs plus mine in training.

So next time you hear on the news that someone is missing (elderly person or a child) or we are sending in rescue teams to an desaster zone, the dog finding people might well have started training on a children's playground.

This is just so vanishingly unlikely to be the case isn’t it though, it’s rather irrelevant.
Plus, even if you train search and rescue dogs, I’d still consider it pretty stupid at 3:30pm outside a school. I’d hope highly trained people had some awareness of more appropriate timing

LakieLady · 21/09/2023 15:26

Taketurn · 21/09/2023 13:37

No way???? People do that??

When I got my first Lakeland puppy, my then DH was working at a school.

He got permission to take the puppy into to the infants' school so we could socialise the dog with children. I also used to make a point of taking DPup out for a walk at the time the children were going to school and coming home, so he was socialised with them, and did the same with the second puppy.

It's the responsible thing to do if you haven't got DCs or know anyone with young DCs. Dogs need to be exposed to as many things as possible when they're very young, they're more likely to fearful or aggressive if you don't. And that causes no end of problems later on.

Mine had been on trains, buses, busy boot fairs, pubs, the stables where my friend had her horse, all sorts of places before they were 6 months old.

Cosyblankets · 21/09/2023 15:13

Taketurn · 21/09/2023 13:37

No way???? People do that??

It depends what they want the dog to do.
Getting them used to ignoring the kids is exactly what they need. So maybe walk past at busy times rather than hang around.
Wanting the dog to greet everyone is not fine.

CwmYoy · 21/09/2023 15:11

So next time you hear on the news that someone is missing (elderly person or a child) or we are sending in rescue teams to an desaster zone, the dog finding people might well have started training on a children's playground.

Inadequate training facilities for rescue dogs is not a good enough reason to let them trample their muddy paws all over children's play equipment. There are plenty of dog agility clubs. Take them there.

Oliotya · 21/09/2023 15:08

Ylvamoon · 21/09/2023 15:05

Only until some vulnerable in your family goes missing.

My point was that it shouldn't be necessary. Training working dogs should be possible without using children's facilities. Dogs in play areas shouldn't have to be the solution.

Ylvamoon · 21/09/2023 15:05

Oliotya · 21/09/2023 15:02

A lack of adequate funding and facilities still doesn't mean a children's play area is an appropriate place to train a dog.

Only until some vulnerable in your family goes missing.

Oliotya · 21/09/2023 15:02

Ylvamoon · 21/09/2023 14:51

On a serious note, I actually train one of my dogs at a children's playground....
She's going to be a search & rescue dog.

The truth is, my dog as well as many others wouldn't have made the grade in terms of fitness & agility if it wasn't for the wobbly bridges, slides and balancing beams.

The search & rescue team in my county is entirely run by volunteers. The dogs training course is also paid by volunteers.
So unless a dog is super fit among other things, they won't be considered.
Plus, we have space/ funding for 5 search & rescue dogs.... the Woking team has 3 dogs plus mine in training.

So next time you hear on the news that someone is missing (elderly person or a child) or we are sending in rescue teams to an desaster zone, the dog finding people might well have started training on a children's playground.

A lack of adequate funding and facilities still doesn't mean a children's play area is an appropriate place to train a dog.

Kokapetl · 21/09/2023 14:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Lachimolala · 21/09/2023 14:55

KimberleyClark · 21/09/2023 11:18

Dictionary definition of childless

childless
/ˈtʃʌɪl(d)lɪs/

adjective
adjective: childless

  1. not having any children.
  2. "a childless couple"

It literally means what it says above. Using it to mean unaccompanied by children is bound to lead to confusion.

Only if you’re particularly dim.

Kokapetl · 21/09/2023 14:55

GoryBory · 21/09/2023 13:52

Grapes, raisins, dark chocolate and things sweetened with Xylitol are all potential after school snacks for humans but poisonous for dogs. And children do drop food...

Just saying😉

These are more likely to give the dog diarrhoea.
Not the best idea for a dog in a child’s park.

It's another reason why the two shouldn't mix. It's a risk for dogs in addition to being hit by swings etc.

Ylvamoon · 21/09/2023 14:51

PurpIe · 21/09/2023 14:04

The fact that there are people on here stating that unless a playpark is specifically signposted as only for children (human children, not your 🤮🤮 "fur baby") and not dogs is very concerning. OF COURSE a playpark is not for dogs. Nor is it for naked kids scraping their exposed anus along the slide, sitting in swings, or pissing on the playframes. So please keep your snappy, pissing, happy mutt menace away.

Days were great when dog people kept their dogs in their own homes save for a short walk around the block twice a day. Now they expect us to tolerate dogs in children's playparks, restaurants, supermarkets, the cinema.

On a serious note, I actually train one of my dogs at a children's playground....
She's going to be a search & rescue dog.

The truth is, my dog as well as many others wouldn't have made the grade in terms of fitness & agility if it wasn't for the wobbly bridges, slides and balancing beams.

The search & rescue team in my county is entirely run by volunteers. The dogs training course is also paid by volunteers.
So unless a dog is super fit among other things, they won't be considered.
Plus, we have space/ funding for 5 search & rescue dogs.... the Woking team has 3 dogs plus mine in training.

So next time you hear on the news that someone is missing (elderly person or a child) or we are sending in rescue teams to an desaster zone, the dog finding people might well have started training on a children's playground.

bombastix · 21/09/2023 14:50

These people are utter twats. They should be discouraged and told of their twatiness firmly.

Years ago had to tell a man off for bringing his husky to do this and that he should leave as he would be responsible for his dog hurting any child. I don't actually think he had considered that at all. It was all for the dog. Idiotic

Oliotya · 21/09/2023 14:47

TheCupboardUnderTheStairsAtTheMojoDojoCasaHouse · 21/09/2023 14:08

We decided that home education was right for us as a family.

Dogs are allowed in some libraries e.g.
https://www.edinburgh.gov.uk/using-library/dog-friendly-libraries

Councils are increasingly opening up open air swimming pools at the end of the summer season to dogs e.g.

https://thelondog.com/6-dog-swim-days-at-lidos-outdoor-pools-in-uk/

https://chippylido.co.uk/the-lido-dog-swim-2023/

https://www.bracknellnews.co.uk/news/national/23779038.golden-retrievers-take-lido-dog-swimming-month-begins/

I pick up after my dog, so there is never anything for anyone to step in.

The play equipment in my local area is open, unfenced, without any signs about dogs (there's a separate fenced off area, which is no dogs, and we don't go in that part). If dogs were meant to be excluded from that area, they would have been. When we go to the park there are usually no children around.

There's something supremely entitled in thinking that childfree people should pay for your lifestyle choice, but we shouldn't be allowed to use the facilities provided to your lifestyle choice, even at times when you don't want to use them.

If you've read Aesop's Fables, you may be familiar with The Dog in the Manger - or in this case - The Parent Not Currently In The Playground.

We don't all get to do whatever we want with public facilities just because we can. That's immense entitlement. Children's play equipment is not for dogs.

emiily93 · 21/09/2023 14:46

Ohambassador · 21/09/2023 09:49

There’s become an increasing number of childless dog owners going to the park before and after school to let their dogs “socialise” with the children using the park.

I doubt this very much. I imagine just the one you’ve come across

It's happening in my local parks also

GoryBory · 21/09/2023 14:44

Thewizardbinbag · 21/09/2023 13:55

I’ve had dogs all my life. But if someone’s untrained dog starts chasing my kid, then you’re damn right that it’s getting kicked off.

Not my job to train someone else’s dog or try to approach it as I would a dog which has been trained when it hasn’t been and is chasing my kid. Don’t want your dog kicked then keep it away from my kids.

Do not kick a dog.

Not only is it abusive but it’s also a great way to make it attack you/your child.

Serendipitoushedgehog · 21/09/2023 14:43

I think the set up of the playground isn't helping here. In the centre of our our village/estate there's a big green field area, with a small fenced of playground area clearly labelled as no dogs and only children under 12. There's also a skate park and a basketball net. So there's a safe place for young children to use play equipment, but also plenty of space for dogs to exercise and socialise. Could you write to the parish council and suggest they review the area?

The childless thing is unhelpful. Recreation spaces should ideally suit everyone. If there's not a specific space for teenagers they will hang around on the play equipment because there's no where else for them to go. If there's not a fenced off area where dogs can't go, then dogs will go everywhere.

It should be possible to have tax-funded recreation facilities that cater for everyone. I don't think it's unreasonable to want a space where little kids can play without being approached by dogs. But I don't think it's unreasonable for dogs to be running round either.

GeneralLevy · 21/09/2023 14:37

TheCupboardUnderTheStairsAtTheMojoDojoCasaHouse · 21/09/2023 14:08

We decided that home education was right for us as a family.

Dogs are allowed in some libraries e.g.
https://www.edinburgh.gov.uk/using-library/dog-friendly-libraries

Councils are increasingly opening up open air swimming pools at the end of the summer season to dogs e.g.

https://thelondog.com/6-dog-swim-days-at-lidos-outdoor-pools-in-uk/

https://chippylido.co.uk/the-lido-dog-swim-2023/

https://www.bracknellnews.co.uk/news/national/23779038.golden-retrievers-take-lido-dog-swimming-month-begins/

I pick up after my dog, so there is never anything for anyone to step in.

The play equipment in my local area is open, unfenced, without any signs about dogs (there's a separate fenced off area, which is no dogs, and we don't go in that part). If dogs were meant to be excluded from that area, they would have been. When we go to the park there are usually no children around.

There's something supremely entitled in thinking that childfree people should pay for your lifestyle choice, but we shouldn't be allowed to use the facilities provided to your lifestyle choice, even at times when you don't want to use them.

If you've read Aesop's Fables, you may be familiar with The Dog in the Manger - or in this case - The Parent Not Currently In The Playground.

Oh dear, you’ve confused common sense with entitlement.
Not all facilities are yours or for you. You don’t take a dog in a play park. Like don’t rock up in the garden of a council care home with your child or start breaking into school playgrounds at weekends. You don’t get to Use everything simply because it exists.
I used to wonder why so much is invested in signs stating the obvious.