Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do our souls know when we're going to pass away?

160 replies

SwiftieGrainger · 20/09/2023 22:45

Please, please do not read on if you find themes of loss or bereavement triggering. This is hopefully intended to be light hearted as a thread. I'm just wondering if anyone believes we subconsciously know when we or people close to us are going to pass away?

I am not hugely superstitious and I have no real view or opinion on the afterlife that makes me more susceptible to taking on such beliefs but I think I do. I was at work and for absolutely no reason at all as I heated up my pasta, I felt the need to call my dad's uncle. We rarely speak- he's an absolutely wonderful old man, but I have never called him in my life. I just did it without any real thought and I could not tell you why. It was lovely, just a light hearted chat that I found time for in my day but hugely unlike me. He peacefully passed away in his sleep the next day and I'm so glad I called. I'm also really glad that somehow the phone call happened when I'm usually so busy at work I don't even respond to texts. It's made me really happy tbh to know he knew I was thinking of him before he went, has anyone else had similar experiences?

Yabu - death is random and we can't know it on a cellular level
Yanbu - this is a common phenomenon

OP posts:
CaroleSinger · 21/09/2023 07:17

I knew my mum was going. I actually phoned the family that afternoon to let them know I was staying with her because she was going to go that night. I had only been there an hour that night when she went. I can't explain it but yes, sometimes you do know.

SproutLady · 21/09/2023 07:10

@Mothership4two I had a very similar experience—a hangover-like episode, shivering and feeling very sick, but without any physical cause—I hadn’t been drinking and didn’t have food poisoning. I was lying on the bathroom floor at five am in my dressing gown when my mum rang to tell me my dad had died from a heart attack. It had happened around the time I’d woken up feeling very unwell. I’d had a long chat with my dad on the phone the night before, and I’ve always felt it was another form of communication that we don’t understand.

Gerrataere · 21/09/2023 07:09

I’ve seen the TikTok videos and heard a few stories like the op but I’m still not sure if it’s all just coincidence with conformation bias when it happens.

A few years ago I saw a friends dad out and about and something just came over me, ‘he’s going to die soon’. He wasn’t old or ill. This happened about 3 times in a space of a month. He dropped dead very soon after the last time I saw him. But, whilst not knowingly ill he was certainly not in the healthiest shape and I think my overactive brain just put two and two together and happened to see an unhealthy person was likely to have a massive heart attack. If it hadn’t happened I’d have just put it down to intrusive thoughts.

Sugarfree23 · 21/09/2023 06:53

Here is another odd one.

I didn't tell anyone that I was in labour. Called my mum at 8am to say I'd had my baby and all was good. She replied I should have called earlier she'd been awake since 4.30 am something woke her but she didn't know what and she couldn't get back to sleep. That's when I gave birth!

Could be coincidence but always strikes me as a weird thing like she just knew.

CurlewKate · 21/09/2023 06:48

Bear in mind all the times we've thought about someone and they haven't died......

Sleepyteach · 21/09/2023 06:42

There is a woman who sometimes pops up on TikTok and my Facebook reels, Nurse Hadley, who is a hospice nurse in the US who talks about this sort of stuff and has written a book on it. I really like listening to her, she is trying to change the way we think about grief and dying and I’ve found some of the things she says really helpful.

budgetingnovice1993 · 21/09/2023 06:37

MarsandMercury · 20/09/2023 23:05

I think it's just confirmation bias. You are ignoring all the times you rang a loved one on a whim and they didn't die next day! I've had that feeling multiple times about my ageing and poorly parents - must call them - that sudden feeling of being desperate to speak now, despite being busy. So far, touch wood, they are very much still with us!

The op said she does not usually call great uncle. Never called him prior to that occasion.

Mo819 · 21/09/2023 06:36

As a nurse who worked in palliative care for part of my career I can tell tell you people do some strange things when they are nearing death ie giving things away asking to people at strange hours. They deffinatly know . As a nurse you sence even smell when death is close.
In my personal life I knew when my nana and when my mum were dying and managed to be with them both just in time it was an overwhelming sence of I just had to get to them.

PieonaBarm · 21/09/2023 06:35

My Mum knew. I was getting married in 4 months and she told my Dad "to have a good wedding" the week before she died, she was poorly but we expected her to see the wedding, she was out driving herself around in the car the day she died.

My dog also used to refuse to sit on her knee. They absolutely idolised each other but it was comical how he wouldn't do it (he wasn't a cuddly dog) and it really annoyed her because it was all she wanted. Again, about a week before she died she asked me to take him round and he sat on her knee and they watched TV together. I knew then she wouldn't see me get married and that her death was imminent. DDog has gone now too and I comfort myself with the feeling that they're together and she's feeding him all the crap she used to shovel down his throat, which, of course, he accepted quite willingly!

Wazzzzzuuuuuuup · 21/09/2023 06:34

When I was a teenager a family member had cancer and was unwell. I hadn't seen her for many weeks and no one had told me (or even knew?) she was getting towards the end of her life.

I was late home from a friend's house and knew my mum would be cross. This was in the 90s before mobile phones.

However, as my bus was going past the area where my relative lived, I just felt compelled to get off. I went to her house and my uncle let me in. She was in bed asleep and died while I was there having a cup of tea.

It was the strangest thing, and I don't know why I felt I had to go

madnessitellyou · 21/09/2023 06:24

I read a lot about this after my dad died. I think it was my way of trying to process what had happened.

One thing I read was that sometimes, the person might get very stressed about needing to make contact with others. The week before he died, dad suddenly decided they needed a new landline phone. They really didn't, but he was absolutely insistent. I humoured him and bought him one that never ended up getting installed. Who knows.

The last time I spoke to my dad he kept on saying "I'm glad my girls (me and mum) are here." I knew at this point. He died 48 hours later.

NoMor · 21/09/2023 06:23

I've had things like this happen and absolutely believe it's confirmation bias and until someone explains what a soul is, I don't believe humans have one. The explanations I've heard usually describe a consciousness, that comes from the brain and dies with us.

I do think a lot of people know when they're dying because it becomes obvious when the doctors are telling you you're going to die, you're extremely old, your body isn't really working anymore, your heart rate slows right down, etc. but I don't believe other people 'sense' it.

patsy999 · 21/09/2023 06:16

When my dad was in hospital, dying with cancer.
I went outside for a ciggie and heard a voice in my head, saying go back to your sister, who was sitting with him.
Just as i got back to his room. He squeezed my hand, then died.

dippyflippy · 21/09/2023 06:04

I have known a few times that people were going to die. Creepiest one was a young pet in perfectly good health, suddenly thought "wouldn't it be weird if he died tomorrow", the next day I went downstairs and pet had died in the night. People say I must have picked up on pet being poorly, but he was eating fine, drinking fine, playing, using the toilet fine etc.

Squirrelsnut · 21/09/2023 05:55

Not a personal experience, but I remember reading in Ian Curtis' biography that both his mum and aunt (or possibly grandma) had vivid dreams about him the night he killed himself.

Mothership4two · 21/09/2023 03:59

Anecdotally cats and dogs are supposed to know when they are close to death and will go off to die alone if they can. Out 23 year old cat did this, having not moved from a few square metres where she had based herself for days, she suddenly got up walked to the back door, went out and was walking down to the bottom of the garden. I thought she was confused so picked her up and she died in my arms. So if animals know on some level why not humans? We are animals too.

I have felt physically unwell when close relatives have died - like having a really bad hangover. I can remember feeling so bad at work once that I lay down in the back of my car during my lunch hour only to find out later that my grandad had died out of the blue (heart attack). I had never crashed out in my car before or since..

DoesMaryNotDrive · 21/09/2023 03:43

I’ve never really thought about it but similar happened with my dad.

My dad was diagnosed with a very aggressive cancer and was given just 6 months to live.

He lived out his remaining months at home, with my mum, my siblings and I.

I think we were in denial for most of his remaining life and we pretended he was going to get better.

Towards the very end he couldn’t speak and his eyes stayed closed, but the nurse said he could hear us.

We were a big family and we also had Macmillan nurses so dad was never left alone. One night I stayed up to talk to him, to tell him what a great childhood he gave us, how much I loved him and how much I would miss him. The morning he had passed away.

I’m not sure why I chose that night, but it was comforting to think my dad heard he was loved before he passed.

Homefry · 21/09/2023 03:40

This happened to me once. Said goodbye to a relative and started crying uncontrollably at the doorstep, just felt inexplicably emotionally overwhelmed. It was so strange.

Said relative became ill shortly after this and died of cancer some months later, i never saw them again after the doorstep incident. Was a very beautiful soul so it was very sad when she died.

USaYwHatNow · 21/09/2023 03:39

@Daffidale yep, it's got a name, 'sense of impending doom' we call it in maternity care, and if a woman tells us that, we believe her!!

Shrinkray · 21/09/2023 03:28

I have had similar experiences a few times. A beloved uncle who was still relatively young and healthy called our house one Christmas Eve. I had an overwhelming urge to speak to him and was told no because we were eating dinner and we'd see him at New Year. He died a few days later. My father was going to visit my Grandma and suddenl I desperately wanted see her and begged to go but wasn't allowed and she died the next day. Then once I had a call from my mother's phone and started crying and when I picked it up before he spoke I said "hello <step father's name>, aunt <X> is dead isn't she?". He's never called me from my mother's phone before or since, and my aunt hadn't been ill. I have no idea how I could have known.

PriOn1 · 21/09/2023 03:28

I saw my grandad the day before he died and knew he was going to die. Two other relatives were discussing who should visit the next day, and I said to my dad (out of their hearing) that they didn’t need to. He looked at me with interest and said “do you think not?” and I replied no.

I was a young adult and it was the only time I think I’ve visited anyone who was close to death. It seems quite uncanny now, because I actually felt strongly enough to tell my dad what I was thinking.

So I don’t know about the distance thing (though we know so little about what actually happens when people die that I wouldn’t rule anything out) but certainly we do sometimes pick up on the fact that someone is about to die, even if we’re not sure what it was we picked up on.

Roselilly36 · 21/09/2023 02:38

One of my biggest regrets was not calling my elderly auntie, the night before she died unexpectedly, I felt compelled to call her. But I was tired, been working that day, then sorting out getting my boys to bed, and just run out of time. I thought I would call her in the morning, as it was late. She died during the night, aneurysm. So wished I had called her.

Firefly89 · 21/09/2023 02:25

I’m not a big believer but after working in a nursing home, a lot (not all) of the residents know when they are about to pass away and the more experienced nurses and carers seem to be able to sense it.
one I also remember was having a chat with a resident about my pregnancy and she told me ‘if she makes it’ but she didn’t say in a horrible way just a factual and sad way. The resident died the next day and I had a miscarriage a few days later. I think she knew. It was so out of character for her to say something like that.

Chocolatepopcorn · 21/09/2023 01:54

No idea but lucky him passing away peacefully in his sleep. Hope we're all as lucky.

9GreenBottles · 21/09/2023 01:42

My Mum’s friend was convinced that my Mum knew she was going to die as the day before she died, Mum was insistent that her friend took a kitchen stool from her flat which she wanted her to have. Mum didn’t want to wait till the next day in daylight but made her very slight 75 year old friend walk along the road in the dark carrying this big blue stool.

Mum has been ill but was on the mend and her death was unexpected.

Swipe left for the next trending thread