Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do our souls know when we're going to pass away?

160 replies

SwiftieGrainger · 20/09/2023 22:45

Please, please do not read on if you find themes of loss or bereavement triggering. This is hopefully intended to be light hearted as a thread. I'm just wondering if anyone believes we subconsciously know when we or people close to us are going to pass away?

I am not hugely superstitious and I have no real view or opinion on the afterlife that makes me more susceptible to taking on such beliefs but I think I do. I was at work and for absolutely no reason at all as I heated up my pasta, I felt the need to call my dad's uncle. We rarely speak- he's an absolutely wonderful old man, but I have never called him in my life. I just did it without any real thought and I could not tell you why. It was lovely, just a light hearted chat that I found time for in my day but hugely unlike me. He peacefully passed away in his sleep the next day and I'm so glad I called. I'm also really glad that somehow the phone call happened when I'm usually so busy at work I don't even respond to texts. It's made me really happy tbh to know he knew I was thinking of him before he went, has anyone else had similar experiences?

Yabu - death is random and we can't know it on a cellular level
Yanbu - this is a common phenomenon

OP posts:
Fightyouforthatpie · 21/09/2023 13:45

My Mum definitely knew she was dying - said goodbye to us all.

Jasperdale · 21/09/2023 13:37

Oh. @Processingprocesses that made me well up 😞

Litmus1001 · 21/09/2023 13:31

Castlerock44 · 21/09/2023 13:29

But I've never really seen how anyone actually "forces' these views on anyone. Just relating their experiences is probably all they do and I can't actually think of anything by that that could possibly upset someone. After all it's just someone else's experience, it's not being forced on anyone.

Some people do force their views on others, within families, relationships, friendship groups etc.
Some people assume that their experience can be applied generally, sadly.

Castlerock44 · 21/09/2023 13:29

Litmus1001 · 20/09/2023 23:39

I agree with you.

(I have no issue with someone believing certain ideas about death, if it comforts them, as long as they don't force those ideas on others.)

But I've never really seen how anyone actually "forces' these views on anyone. Just relating their experiences is probably all they do and I can't actually think of anything by that that could possibly upset someone. After all it's just someone else's experience, it's not being forced on anyone.

Castlerock44 · 21/09/2023 13:21

I'm a true believer. In the weeks leading up to my mum's death, even though she had Alzheimer's and didn't know who any of us were, she was constantly telling us she saw her mum and her mum was waiting for her.

She might not have been aware she was dying but she died so peacefully with a smile on her face. It was amazing to see her face, it was just so serene and young again.

Pandor · 21/09/2023 13:20

I would say no as I also don’t believe we have a “soul”. We have a consciousness which is linked to our brain activity, and we have self awareness, but I don’t know what we have or that would count as evidence of a “soul”.

BeagleMum1 · 21/09/2023 13:15

MasterBeth · 21/09/2023 08:48

There's no such thing as a soul, so no.

That's your opinion

AlwaysPrettyOnTheInside · 21/09/2023 13:09

People that have had a near death experience say their life flashed before their eyes. That must happen in other circumstances too then? Ie a elderly person in a bed as opposed to a car crash for instance. So they will know at the end at least.

And there are often reports of people saying loved ones have come for them, often a few days in advance.

With regards to the grandad that left his funeral plan on the table, and others that have done things like that, its a shame they didn't write what they felt/saw/knew too.

Hbh17 · 21/09/2023 09:15

It depends on whether you believe we have such a thing as "a soul". To me, death is simply when our physical body ceases to function. That's it. Nothing else.

heartofglass23 · 21/09/2023 09:06

Most death isn't quick so most people know they are dying.

Redavocadoes · 21/09/2023 09:04

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Coffeemakers · 21/09/2023 09:01

MasterBeth · 21/09/2023 08:48

There's no such thing as a soul, so no.

There’s no proof either way ? Maybe there is maybe there isn’t ? Our consciousness must transfer somewhere though even if it’s not into a further consciousness/awareness it’s not as if that never existed. Whether it ceases at death or carries on as a ‘soul’ nobody can say with any certainty

MarsandMercury · 21/09/2023 08:59

Every time she flies, my mum reminds me where her will is. Ditto when she goes into surgery, which is often. If either of those things resulted in her death, I can see it would be tempting to say she knew. For sure it's a comforting thought. I still don't believe it's any kind of sign though.

Elmo230885 · 21/09/2023 08:59

There's no right or wrong thing to believe, personally I think anything you can take comfort in is useful during the grieving process.

My Autie passed away after a very quick decline from early onset Alzheimers. She passed a few hours after the last person close to her had visited, it felt like she hung on.

On the day my grandma passed away I said to my husband that that day would be the last time I saw her. She passed whilst I was with her. She was quite ill and I had been seeing her a lot but that day just felt different. That day was 20 years to the day after my Grandad passed and she was due to be moved from her home to a hospice/care home the next day due to her needs and family being unable to continue doing what we were doing. My grandma had always said the only way she was leaving that house was in a box!

MasterBeth · 21/09/2023 08:48

There's no such thing as a soul, so no.

Namechangedtoanswerthisone · 21/09/2023 08:44

MarsandMercury · 20/09/2023 23:05

I think it's just confirmation bias. You are ignoring all the times you rang a loved one on a whim and they didn't die next day! I've had that feeling multiple times about my ageing and poorly parents - must call them - that sudden feeling of being desperate to speak now, despite being busy. So far, touch wood, they are very much still with us!

Indeed. People can turn anything into proof if they want to enough. People that want to believe look for anything that they think proves that and ignores anything that doesn't.

Who knows OP. There is no actual repeatable evidence so basically people are guessing or giving their opinions.

Coffeemakers · 21/09/2023 08:27

SwiftieGrainger · 20/09/2023 23:04

Oh my goodness I love this so much what a lovely thought

I hope as well that wherever our souls go, that if a loved one still on earth is thinking about / sad about someone they’ve lost that a similar thing happens, I’d love to think that my dad and others I’ve lost know when I’m thinking about them

notcurrentlyactive · 21/09/2023 08:17

I'm a Christian and yes OP, I believe our souls can know even if our conscious mind doesn't.

My mum died suddenly several years ago. She was due to have minor surgery and the night before she told me she'd taken off her wedding ring and put it in a drawer 'in case something happens to me'. I laughed and said 'nothing's going to happen'. She told me she'd had a dream that she'd died. We chatted it through and laughed and decided it was just her brain playing tricks. She was otherwise healthy and just needed a minor op.

She had the op and unexpectedly went into cardiac arrest and died. She was a Christian too and I think her soul/spirit knew.

MarsandMercury · 21/09/2023 08:16

budgetingnovice1993 · 21/09/2023 06:37

The op said she does not usually call great uncle. Never called him prior to that occasion.

He was an elderly man. Have you never thought 'oh I'd better call them now they won't be around forever' about a very elderly relative? I may be a bit morbid but when someone is very old I have a 'this may be the last time,' feeling about almost any interaction.
As for some of the foreboding feelings mentioned by others, I have these all the time (see the 'bit morbid' bit). I'm occasionally right -but usually wrong! I'm sure it's possible to unconsciously pick up subtle vibes that indicate something is wrong, but our brains come up with predictions all the time. We only really notice when they happen to be correct, especially in dramatic circumstances.

IncompleteSenten · 21/09/2023 08:07

Our bodies absolutely know when life is ending. The process starts several weeks before death and there are clearly observable changes so yes on a fundamental level whether you want to call that the soul or the subconscious or biology or whatever, our body knows.

Whether we know when others are dying - who knows? maybe we know they are ill or have seen signs but not consciously recognised them, maybe they are on our minds because of that.

ChaToilLeam · 21/09/2023 08:05

I somehow knew when my grandad passed - I woke up at 5am with the knowledge that he had gone, and a few minutes later my granny called.

I’m not a woo person so still find it strange and inexplicable. Didn’t happen with my other grandparents.

Nottodaty · 21/09/2023 07:39

My Gran recently passed away. She was in hospital after a fall, the doctors & nurses thought she would recover. We didn’t, my Gran still with her sense of humour knew, she wanted reassurance that her children had been to see her & on her last day she kept asking my sister who the person was by the head of her bed (there wasn’t anyone)

She died in her sleep after a week in the hospital, the staff all shocked but somehow us as a family knew she wasn’t going to leave that hospital - we all spent a lovely week with her and each other laughing and crying at times! It’s something special to us that we got to do it.

Sceptre86 · 21/09/2023 07:38

My mil had a strong urge to call her brother last week. He had been unwell and was in hospital. At 4pm last Saturday she said she needed to ring him urgently ( sil had borrowed her phone). She got it back and phoned him, only to be told by the relative that answered that he was on his way to meet his maker. The Dr had just told them and they were about to start phoning his family. He died an hour later. She said she had a sinking feeling in her belly and knew she had to call him.

Years ago my mum was going to visit my grandad which she did weekly. I had exams and so she didn't ask me if I wanted to come. I had a bad dream that night as if he was calling for me and I couldn't get to him. I went to go see him and kissed him as we left ( that side of family aren't big on hugs and kisses) it took him by surprise but oh the smile I received. He told me to come the following week and I promised I would. He died the following week.

I'm convinced my wonderful dad in law knew he was on his way.

Processingprocesses · 21/09/2023 07:36

Jasperdale · 20/09/2023 22:53

I absolutely believe in this. I remember visiting my friends grandad (we were only about 12 so he wasn’t actually very old maybe 60’s) was in good health absolutely normal. When we left he stood in the step waving goodbye to us and I was really choked up I knew I was never going to see him again somehow. Had to pretend to my friend I wasn’t feeling well but the memory is so clear. He died in his sleep that night.

Oh gosh this sounds so familiar. My grandad was from Darlington. However he lived in the South and had a relatively standard English accent.

One day I went to see him with my new baby boy. And when I went to say goodbye he cuddled me tight and said in a soft Yorkshire accent "cheerio, love" and he waved me off.

It was so weird. And I knew something wasn't right. I left and called my Dad.

My Grandad had a nasty heart attack the day after. Left his funeral plan on the table ready for us all.

Dollmeup · 21/09/2023 07:29

I think people can often sense before it happens. I'm not a spiritual person and think there is probably a biological reason that we don't fully understand yet.

I'm a nurse and sometimes patients have a smell about them when they are terminally ill. I used to work with an older nurse who often to get a strong feeling when someone was going to die soon though she could never explain why, she said she just "knew".

Patients often seemed to know themselves and apparently you can get a sense of "impending doom" when your body is going in to shock before you necessarily show the symptoms.

Older people often seem to just accept their time to go and are at peace with it, which I have always found comforting.

I don't know how to explain when people sense it when they are not with the person, for example reaching out after a period of estrangement though. I expect it's just fortunate timing but who knows really.