Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do our souls know when we're going to pass away?

160 replies

SwiftieGrainger · 20/09/2023 22:45

Please, please do not read on if you find themes of loss or bereavement triggering. This is hopefully intended to be light hearted as a thread. I'm just wondering if anyone believes we subconsciously know when we or people close to us are going to pass away?

I am not hugely superstitious and I have no real view or opinion on the afterlife that makes me more susceptible to taking on such beliefs but I think I do. I was at work and for absolutely no reason at all as I heated up my pasta, I felt the need to call my dad's uncle. We rarely speak- he's an absolutely wonderful old man, but I have never called him in my life. I just did it without any real thought and I could not tell you why. It was lovely, just a light hearted chat that I found time for in my day but hugely unlike me. He peacefully passed away in his sleep the next day and I'm so glad I called. I'm also really glad that somehow the phone call happened when I'm usually so busy at work I don't even respond to texts. It's made me really happy tbh to know he knew I was thinking of him before he went, has anyone else had similar experiences?

Yabu - death is random and we can't know it on a cellular level
Yanbu - this is a common phenomenon

OP posts:
inloveandmarried · 21/09/2023 18:30

I 'feel' / 'see' / 'hear' lost relatives about 3 months before they return for their loved ones. Then their/my loved ones pass a few months later.

It's happened a few times now and it unsettles me but it's been the case each time.

I can only assume they are there to welcome their loved ones to the next phase. The departed loved ones do indeed seem know when mortals are close to passing.

Ilkleymoor · 21/09/2023 15:22

I read an interview with a paramedic once who said they thought it was very important to be honest with people who were dying. He had held the hand of people who had been hurt in road accidents and he knew they could not be saved. At first they would ask him if they were going to die and he would say you're ok, we'll move you soon or something else that avoided the question and they would continue to be in distress. Once he started to tell them yes, they were dying, they were calmer and died more peacefully and were less afraid.

I don't believe in souls but I do think that as animals we can recognise death is near and that we benefit from being able to be truthful about it.

Loobyloo68 · 21/09/2023 15:08

My mum was diagnosed with cancer in June, they gave her 4 to 6 months, I knew she was going to die on the 15th August, don't know how, I just did. And she did indeed pass away on the 15th August

ItsABrandNewDay · 21/09/2023 15:05

I think I beleive it.

My great grandad had spoken of seeing his late wife 2 weeks before he died and came down to dinner in a smart suit, where he died at the table.

My grandma died of a brain haemorrhage two days after my grandad was rushed into hospital with a major heart attack. He survived for another 6 years, but my grandma had always said she hoped she'd be the first to leave as she wouldn't cope without my grandad. That makes me beleive she died of a broken heart.

Days before my grandad passed away, he wrote a letter to my mum to say goodbye and detailing how he wanted his funeral so I beleive he knew. His was a sudden second heart attack and there'd been no outward indications beforehand.

dressedforcomfort · 21/09/2023 14:58

Generally, I'm sceptical about most 'woo' things. However, one of the known symptoms of sepsis is having a strong sense that you are dying. I do believe sometimes people are aware that their body is failing.

FlyingUnicornWings · 21/09/2023 14:58

SwiftieGrainger · 20/09/2023 22:45

Please, please do not read on if you find themes of loss or bereavement triggering. This is hopefully intended to be light hearted as a thread. I'm just wondering if anyone believes we subconsciously know when we or people close to us are going to pass away?

I am not hugely superstitious and I have no real view or opinion on the afterlife that makes me more susceptible to taking on such beliefs but I think I do. I was at work and for absolutely no reason at all as I heated up my pasta, I felt the need to call my dad's uncle. We rarely speak- he's an absolutely wonderful old man, but I have never called him in my life. I just did it without any real thought and I could not tell you why. It was lovely, just a light hearted chat that I found time for in my day but hugely unlike me. He peacefully passed away in his sleep the next day and I'm so glad I called. I'm also really glad that somehow the phone call happened when I'm usually so busy at work I don't even respond to texts. It's made me really happy tbh to know he knew I was thinking of him before he went, has anyone else had similar experiences?

Yabu - death is random and we can't know it on a cellular level
Yanbu - this is a common phenomenon

I don’t know the answer to your question, but I do know this is a beautiful story. May your dad’s uncle rest in peace x

TheBabylonian · 21/09/2023 14:49

Hare Krishna’, like gnostics; christian and non-christian; believe in the “universal mind” of which our souls are a part, that we are all connected creatures of spirit, trapped in reincarnating physical bodies.

For example, from a Jungian psychological perspective our physical bodies can be represented as a circle, at the centre of the circle is our real identity, our personal divinity, which the gnostics called the spirit, the pneuma or the nous. This is the nucleus of our atomic self if you will allow a more scientific analogy.

Between the physical body and the spirit is the soul, the psyche.

The soul/psyche can be thought of as our complex personality, a representation of the consciousness that contains our memories, feelings, wishes, habits and thoughts; these are our personal angels and demons.

If all of our souls are connected then this explains how our “angels” or “demons” (both words have the same etymological origin and mean the same thing - a demon is an angel is a demon) are able to communicate with each other.

Much like a weed is simply a flower or plant you don’t want (I love dandelions but many see them as a weed). Let’s say you have a habit that is not good for you or you don’t like then you should not feed that angel/demon, e.g. the demon drink or angel forgiveness. Both demon and angel are interchangeable as they are names for the same thing, like weeds/flowers it’s just a matter of personal choice if you want to feed that “spirit” or not.

ChilliNoodleGoodness · 21/09/2023 14:42

@SproutLady I had similar - although its not resulted in death...yet

One day a couple of months ago I woke feeling incredibly sad. I couldn't put my finger on why, I had an upset stomach and just this incredible sense of impending doom. Later that day I found out my best friend had been diagnosed with terminal pancreatic cancer.

I didn't even know he was having tests, he had kept everything quiet.

Cantthinkofadifferentname · 21/09/2023 14:41

Over 30 years ago I had a sense something was wrong with my DGM. Seen her earlier in the day, she was fine.
I phoned her, no reply. My DM went round and found her collapsed from a stroke.
Never had it since, but just knew something wasn't right, can't explain it

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 21/09/2023 14:33

I think it's just confirmation bias.

I agree. I don't believe in souls, guardian angels or sixth senses etc. I have no problem believing that a very ill person might get a physical feeling that they are slipping away, but I personally don't believe there's anything other-wordly or spiritual about that.

DrCoconut · 21/09/2023 14:28

Also, I knew when my dad died. I was 6 years old and he was living elsewhere. I can't explain it but it's like a light went out and I sensed it. A while later the phone rang and I said it was someone ringing to say that daddy is dead. My mum told me not to say such things as she went to answer it (old days when it was in the hall) and that's exactly what it was.

Oneearringlost · 21/09/2023 14:26

Daffidale · 20/09/2023 23:38

Rather grimly, doctors who work with people at end of life will tell you that people do often know they are dying. Some A&E Consultant I knew were discussing the signs they look for that someone is in a really bad way and they need to jump to it. They all said: when the patient says “I think I’m dying” or “I’m going to die”.

True. I'm a nurse, nearly 40 years in and my DH is a hospital consultant.

Statsinyoureyes · 21/09/2023 14:25

I think if you have a close friend or family member you can tell if they are pregnant way before they show. I think it must be a pheromone thing or some other subtle sign. It's happened to me a few times.

DrCoconut · 21/09/2023 14:25

My grandma always said that her great grandma woke up one day, did her usual chores and then put her Sunday best dress on. Everyone asked what that was about and she calmly said that she was going to meet her maker now and wanted to look her best. Obviously they didn't really believe it, told her not to talk like that etc. as far as they knew she was old but well. She went for her usual "granny nap" and never woke up.

LemonQuiche · 21/09/2023 14:24

It’s impossible to tell whether is an actual “thing” without comparing it against the times that it doesn’t happen. So how many times has someone’s relative or friend died where they haven’t felt compelled to contact them shortly before, or felt compelled to think about them? I’d suggest that those instances far outweigh the times when, for whatever reason, someone has an experience similar to your own.

Mooshamoo · 21/09/2023 14:24

I've had a near death experience. I was terribly sick when I was a teenager. I kept getting constant really bad chest infections to the point where I could barely breathe. One night I was in bed really sick and I was the worst I'd ever been I just couldn't breathe at all. I was fighting to breathe.

Next thing I was going upwards diagonally in a place that was all white. I was travelling upwards diagonally. I had this realisation that I was dying, I thought oh I'm dying! And then I thought but I'm only young I've more things to do, and I also thought of my mother coming in and finding my body and I couldn't bear it. I said "I want to go back I want to go back" and I went back

Castlerock44 · 21/09/2023 14:20

I watch a lot of "Near Death Experiences" on YouTube. There's a common theme in a lot of them where they say they knew they'd "gone home". Even if they'd had this experience years and years before they seem to remember in fine detail every bit of it and how it made them feel, and that it was nothing like a dream which will fade in time.

Amongst other things they talk of speaking telepathically, of an immense feeling of love, the intensity of colours of trees and flowers etc, the knowledge of all things, especially of the Universe. But more importantly they speak of their awareness of our Creator, that we are all part of God and the over riding feeling of love and perfect happiness.

Every single person that had these experiences didn't want to come back, but it wasn't "their time".... they have since had no fear of death, they know that we're only here to learn.......

Liv999 · 21/09/2023 14:20

I believe we do, my dad passed away a few years ago and about an hour before he passed he asked to see a priest, also his last words were " I'm going now" so yes he knew 💔

caringcarer · 21/09/2023 14:16

My Dad was ill with heart issues. I drove over 250 miles to visit him at the weekend intending to come back Sunday night but I couldn't leave him. I just knew when I left I wouldn't see him alive again. We shared a lovely few days together and he died on the Wednesday morning of a massive heart attack. I rang my sister who also lives far away and told her if she didn't come home that day she wouldn't see him alive. She didn't believe me and said I couldn't possibly know that and she'd come at the weekend. She ended up coming on the Friday 2 days after he'd died. He'd love to have seen her again and I found myself feeling angry with her because as soon as he died she rushed down. She just didn't believe me. I noticed when Mum was very ill she was there all the time so I think she regretted not coming to see Dad.

RichardArmitagesWife · 21/09/2023 14:07

I don’t think our “souls” know - but I’m about as spiritual as a cabbage.

I do think we can subliminally pick up on clues our conscious minds don’t notice, particularly about those we know well.

In a similar vein, I knew when my children were about to get ill before it happened as there was a tiny change in their scent. By the time they had symptoms, it was pronounced.

Mooshamoo · 21/09/2023 14:03

Oh another one about a dog.

I had a dog when I was a child and she lived for a very long time. She was part of the family. She lived until she was about 15.

I was 22 and I was working far away from home. The dog became very very sick and the vet said she had a tumour and was dying. I was young and I felt I couldn't take time off work for a sick dog (though I really should have). I couldn't get down home for three weeks as I had some work things or something I had to go to.
She was deteriorating fast. I used to ring home and my mum would hold the phone to the dogs ear.
I would say to her "hold on and wait for me to get home".

Mum said the dog was holding on to see me. Then near the end of the second week. My mum called the dog to the phone while I was on the phone, and the dog could barely walk and she collapsed. And I could hear her panting and suffering . And I said to her "it's ok go on , you don't have to wait for me to come and down and see you, you can go on, I love you, I don't want you to be suffering". And she died a couple of hours after that phone call.

I still feel sad

Bellaphant · 21/09/2023 14:03

My nan knew. She had a bit of dementia but was still living at home, fairly independent, etc. They went on holiday to Scotland, where she grew up. She came home saying, 'I can go /home/ now.' She fell over, hit her head and never woke up the week after.

EvilElsa · 21/09/2023 14:01

My grandad absolutely knew he was dying. I went to visit him in the hospital the night before he died and he was very chipper. I got him a fizzy drink from the shop, he was sitting up in bed fully alert, conscious and happy. I had taken my nan with us and left them to spend time together alone. When I came back he told me that his friends had come to visit him that day (these friends were long dead). I said I would see him soon and he chuckled and held my hand and told me to tell the kids he loved them and that he loved me. He died very early the next morning. I'm so glad my grandparents said what they wanted to say to each other (they met at 13 and he died at 86 so their love had been so long) and that they got their last goodbye.

Mooshamoo · 21/09/2023 13:56

I have known when people died, before I was told that they died.

Whatafustercluck · 21/09/2023 13:51

I'm not really woo and so was going to say it's all random. Then I remembered I was there when my nan died of a heart attack many years ago. She'd had dementia and no longer knew me from Adam. Immediately before all the alarms went off and nurses came rushing in, she looked me straight in the eyes and said her goodbyes to me - "God bless, be good". In that instant, she knew me and she knew without a doubt that she would die.

If you look at the dying 'process' for someone diagnosed with a life limiting disease, there is a very definite physiological process as the body shuts down. Changes in skin temperature, pallor, breathing. Those signs are used by professionals to determine how long a person has long left, to ensure their loved ones can say goodbye. Even before it gets to that stage, the person who is dying tends to behave in a certain way, do and say certain things, in preparation.

I'm not sure I believe in a remote 'connection' between two people that might drive contact with one another before death. It seems improbable.

I'm not triggered by this thread. In a way I'm finding it quite comforting as one of my dearest friends is having end of life care and has just days left. I whispered into the wind yesterday early morning that it was OK for her to let go, there is nothing she's left unsaid. Just in case she can sense me somehow.

Swipe left for the next trending thread