Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to take dog into supermarket

212 replies

amechange · 20/09/2023 20:47

I can't get supermarket deliveries. I am autistic, I am disabled because of it, and stress/anxiety causes me to do self destructive stims and behaviours, brings on disassociation, paranoia, sleep issues, suicidal ideation etc and I have agoraphobia as well. I have only ever been a few minutes away from home up till today when I pushed myself to go to the supermarket, I didn't go in. If I couldn't take my dog, I wouldn't have left the house. She is a tiny chihuahua. She is well behaved, she understands commands, but she isn't registered as anything, but she pretty much is a service dog. Even though she wasnt specifically trained to do a specific task to calm my anxiety down, having her there with me reduces my anxiety a lot compared to if I didn't have her. And at home when I feel anxious, she comes and sits by me/lets me hold her. I'm now in a position where I have to go in there to do my weekly shopping. She has a dog pram that closes all around, it was expensive and looks like a babies pram but isn't, its the ibiyaya retro luxe pram. She wouldn't be a danger to anyone/bother anyone/contaminate anything/get in the way, no one will notice it's a dog, I wont be showing her off/taking her out to show people if I took her in.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Litmus1001 · 21/09/2023 15:27

Flickersy · 21/09/2023 13:40

No but it's like telling someone off for leaving the tap running when the river's burst its banks and your house is flooded. A pretty pointless argument in the circumstances.

It's not.
Germs are not the only potential issue with dogs in shops - lots of people are scared or allergic, and a supermarket isn't the place for non-service dogs.

Watchkeys · 21/09/2023 14:46

@HenriettaBaguetta

Generally be a considerate person

There are plenty of people on this thread, and in the rest of the world, who are far more considerate to OP's situation than yourself. Are we just meant to be considerate to people you agree with, or considerate to everyone?

What's this argument you're putting forward about supermarket managers having plenty to do? If they haven't time to answer a question from a customer with disabilities, is the customer going to feel that they're being considerate to them?

I'm not sure you've fully considered what it means to be considerate, ironically. It's not about your preferences and how you think the world 'should' be. Managers manage the shop, and the customers' queries. Customers aren't supposed to be minding the poor, overworked manager's feelings, when they're asking one question about one disability issue.

Litmus1001 · 21/09/2023 14:17

overdrawn · 21/09/2023 13:46

Just go to a supermarket that doesn't allow dogs! It's really not that hard.

Also, I'm not comparing dogs and children. 🙄 I'm saying I don't put myself in environments that I don't want to be in. I could have used music as an example instead if that's better – I don't like eating with loud music, so I avoid going into restaurants that play loud music. Some people enjoy this and it makes it a better experience for them. Good for them, and I'm glad there's spaces for everyone to enjoy.

Stop being so ridiculous about something that has zero impact on you unless you allow it to. If you know a supermarket allows dogs, and people are – within what the supermarket allows – taking dogs into the supermarket, then just don't go. If you put yourself in that situation then it's on you! (FWIW I'm not talking about people going into supermarkets that don't allow dogs and pretending they are service dogs – that's totally inappropriate).

'Just go to a supermarket that doesn't allow dogs! It's really not that hard.'

  • it would be a lot easier if people like you didn't take any dogs (except actual registered service dogs in there). Also, how do we know if a dog is in there or not before we go in? Most people would assume that random dogs are not in there!

'Also, I'm not comparing dogs and children. ' Also you....'In the same way, I will tend to avoid overtly family friendly restaurants as I like to have a bit of peace and quiet when dining out. I don't go around demanding that children not be allowed in any restaurants! That would be ridiculous as obviously some people want to eat out with children and it suits them to do so.'

  • I am not really sure why you think that's not comparing dogs and children.

'Stop being so ridiculous about something that has zero impact on you unless you allow it to'

  • Taking non-service dogs into a supermarket DOES impact other people though. Also, you are calling something ridiculous, just because you don't share that view. I could chose to call your point of view ridiculous too.

'(FWIW I'm not talking about people going into supermarkets that don't allow dogs and pretending they are service dogs – that's totally inappropriate).'

  • Many what say that what you are doing is fairly inappropriate too. Again, it's probably less that they welcome you with your dog, and more that they don't want to create a fuss in case you kick off (you might not react that way but someone else might). They are not paid enough to police what people should have the common sense to police themselves.
kitsuneghost · 21/09/2023 14:14

What of those that have anxiety around dogs
Supermarkets are a bit of a safe space for me as I don't have to encounter them

Its OK saying its in a pram you don't really see it
but its like a big spider under the bed
might not be bothering you but when you know it's there, you know it's there

SchadenfreudeIstMeinMittelname · 21/09/2023 13:57

overdrawn · 21/09/2023 13:46

Just go to a supermarket that doesn't allow dogs! It's really not that hard.

Also, I'm not comparing dogs and children. 🙄 I'm saying I don't put myself in environments that I don't want to be in. I could have used music as an example instead if that's better – I don't like eating with loud music, so I avoid going into restaurants that play loud music. Some people enjoy this and it makes it a better experience for them. Good for them, and I'm glad there's spaces for everyone to enjoy.

Stop being so ridiculous about something that has zero impact on you unless you allow it to. If you know a supermarket allows dogs, and people are – within what the supermarket allows – taking dogs into the supermarket, then just don't go. If you put yourself in that situation then it's on you! (FWIW I'm not talking about people going into supermarkets that don't allow dogs and pretending they are service dogs – that's totally inappropriate).

But all supermarkets should be not allowing dogs in. It's a hygiene issue. Exemptions are made for properly trained service dogs because they can be trusted not to slobber over the food or urinate or defecate in the store.

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 21/09/2023 13:53

You might not be able to get your dog registered as a service dog if she doesn't meet the requirements in training or if you aren't able to attend the training.

You can however join a waitlist to see if you can be matched with a trained autism service dog. This does mean another dog and another level of responsibility but it sounds like you are the sort of service user this service would benefit.

Chihuahuas aren't great autism service dogs as part of the service is that they're meant to put distance between you and other people, small dogs mean small distance, and they're not a breed known for their confidence.

overdrawn · 21/09/2023 13:46

Litmus1001 · 21/09/2023 13:32

The minute you compare dogs to children then the argument is lost. Non-service dogs do not need to be in supermarkets, no matter how much you think you can justify it.

Edited

Just go to a supermarket that doesn't allow dogs! It's really not that hard.

Also, I'm not comparing dogs and children. 🙄 I'm saying I don't put myself in environments that I don't want to be in. I could have used music as an example instead if that's better – I don't like eating with loud music, so I avoid going into restaurants that play loud music. Some people enjoy this and it makes it a better experience for them. Good for them, and I'm glad there's spaces for everyone to enjoy.

Stop being so ridiculous about something that has zero impact on you unless you allow it to. If you know a supermarket allows dogs, and people are – within what the supermarket allows – taking dogs into the supermarket, then just don't go. If you put yourself in that situation then it's on you! (FWIW I'm not talking about people going into supermarkets that don't allow dogs and pretending they are service dogs – that's totally inappropriate).

Flickersy · 21/09/2023 13:40

Litmus1001 · 21/09/2023 13:35

That's not an argument for allowing dogs though, just an aside.

No but it's like telling someone off for leaving the tap running when the river's burst its banks and your house is flooded. A pretty pointless argument in the circumstances.

Happyandtired · 21/09/2023 13:36

Supermarket worker here, at my store we often help people with additional needs and I've frequently been given shopping lists from people who otherwise couldn't do it themselves.

Could you give the supermarket a call, explain your situation and maybe go along and hand a list over at the doors? A bit like click and collect but more personal, it'll push you to interact but in a gentle way. That way you can take your dog but wait outside. A supermarket is a strange place for a dog so although you say yours is well trained, with music, crowds, alarms, back shutters getting opened, pallet moving, noisy cages etc it's a massive liability. Your dog could injure someone or themselves and ofcourse in terms of hygiene it's not great either. Other things to consider would be interaction with guide dogs and other service dogs, could you control your dog around other animals? I'm guessing if you rarely leave your house apart from a few minutes away then your dog is not very well socialised to big crowds, noises or other animals. It must be tricky but honestly give the place a call, I know we are very willing to help anyone.

Litmus1001 · 21/09/2023 13:35

Flickersy · 21/09/2023 13:14

Given the amount of people who don't wash their hands after using the toilet, someone holding a dog touching stuff in the supermarket is the least of your worries.

That's not an argument for allowing dogs though, just an aside.

Litmus1001 · 21/09/2023 13:32

overdrawn · 21/09/2023 13:24

@Litmus1001 Well, she is small enough that she can sit in one arm easily – so I have another arm free to do shopping, so yes, if you're allowed into a supermarket carrying your dog then her weight is definitely relevant 😂Also, even if she was left outside the supermarket, I would still be picking up food (that would be going in my basket, and no one else's) with hands that had touched my dog. I'm pretty sure people are going into supermarkets with far dirtier hands than mine! And, as in my previous post, most supermarkets are not dog friendly – just use those? That's why I don't see it as being an issue. In the same way, I will tend to avoid overtly family friendly restaurants as I like to have a bit of peace and quiet when dining out. I don't go around demanding that children not be allowed in any restaurants! That would be ridiculous as obviously some people want to eat out with children and it suits them to do so.

The minute you compare dogs to children then the argument is lost. Non-service dogs do not need to be in supermarkets, no matter how much you think you can justify it.

overdrawn · 21/09/2023 13:24

Litmus1001 · 21/09/2023 13:12

I suppose you are not going to find it contentious because it suits you.
There is no need to take a dog into a shop. Also, as she's in your arms, how do you actually pick anything up? Are you touching things with the arms/hands that have been wrapped around her? It also doesn't matter how little a dog weighs, that's irrelevant.

@Litmus1001 Well, she is small enough that she can sit in one arm easily – so I have another arm free to do shopping, so yes, if you're allowed into a supermarket carrying your dog then her weight is definitely relevant 😂Also, even if she was left outside the supermarket, I would still be picking up food (that would be going in my basket, and no one else's) with hands that had touched my dog. I'm pretty sure people are going into supermarkets with far dirtier hands than mine! And, as in my previous post, most supermarkets are not dog friendly – just use those? That's why I don't see it as being an issue. In the same way, I will tend to avoid overtly family friendly restaurants as I like to have a bit of peace and quiet when dining out. I don't go around demanding that children not be allowed in any restaurants! That would be ridiculous as obviously some people want to eat out with children and it suits them to do so.

HenriettaBaguetta · 21/09/2023 13:15

Watchkeys · 21/09/2023 12:16

There are shop managers managing this, and unless they feel they're having a problem with it, there's no problem. People don't generally take advantage by claiming a disability they don't have.

Unless you feel that there are loads of dogs in loads of supermarkets? I've seen no sign of this, is it a problem where you are?

And shop managers already have loads of shit to deal with. Them not having the time, mental or emotional capacity to deal with extra crap doesn't mean much.

So how about people just generally behave in a social and appropriate manner and not wait till someone calls them out and then they get defensive.

Don't take dogs into shops unless it's an assistance dog. Don't shoplift. Wear shoes. Wear appropriate clothing. Don't let your kids run round and put themselves or other people in danger. If you spill something, at least tell a member of staff. Don't just fill up a trolley and abandon it. Don't take frozen or perishable items out of your trolley because you've changed your mind and leave them on shelves or on the floor.

Generally be a considerate person. Don't be an arse that thinks that your 'rights' or the fact that people haven't complained to your face, or that a shop manager or shop worker should deal with your crap means it's fine.

Flickersy · 21/09/2023 13:14

Litmus1001 · 21/09/2023 13:12

I suppose you are not going to find it contentious because it suits you.
There is no need to take a dog into a shop. Also, as she's in your arms, how do you actually pick anything up? Are you touching things with the arms/hands that have been wrapped around her? It also doesn't matter how little a dog weighs, that's irrelevant.

Given the amount of people who don't wash their hands after using the toilet, someone holding a dog touching stuff in the supermarket is the least of your worries.

Litmus1001 · 21/09/2023 13:12

overdrawn · 21/09/2023 12:56

@Litmus1001 because sometimes when I’m out with the dog I need to pick something up from the supermarket? I’m not letting the dog nose around in any food or go on the ground or run up to anyone (she’s in my arms and weighs 4kg). The only supermarkets I take her into are those that allow it (I always check before going in, and many supermarkets that do allow dogs say only if you’re carrying them so the issue of dogs ‘contaminating’ food is a non issue) and so I really don’t see the issue with it. If you want to go into supermarkets where dogs aren’t allowed, great - there are plenty of those too! I’ll continue to use the ones that suit my needs and others can use ones that suit their needs (ie places that don’t allow dogs, of which there are lots). I honestly don’t understand why this is such a contentious issue 🤷‍♀️

Edited

I suppose you are not going to find it contentious because it suits you.
There is no need to take a dog into a shop. Also, as she's in your arms, how do you actually pick anything up? Are you touching things with the arms/hands that have been wrapped around her? It also doesn't matter how little a dog weighs, that's irrelevant.

overdrawn · 21/09/2023 12:56

@Litmus1001 because sometimes when I’m out with the dog I need to pick something up from the supermarket? I’m not letting the dog nose around in any food or go on the ground or run up to anyone (she’s in my arms and weighs 4kg). The only supermarkets I take her into are those that allow it (I always check before going in, and many supermarkets that do allow dogs say only if you’re carrying them so the issue of dogs ‘contaminating’ food is a non issue) and so I really don’t see the issue with it. If you want to go into supermarkets where dogs aren’t allowed, great - there are plenty of those too! I’ll continue to use the ones that suit my needs and others can use ones that suit their needs (ie places that don’t allow dogs, of which there are lots). I honestly don’t understand why this is such a contentious issue 🤷‍♀️

Litmus1001 · 21/09/2023 12:49

Watchkeys · 21/09/2023 12:16

There are shop managers managing this, and unless they feel they're having a problem with it, there's no problem. People don't generally take advantage by claiming a disability they don't have.

Unless you feel that there are loads of dogs in loads of supermarkets? I've seen no sign of this, is it a problem where you are?

If it is part of a chain then it's not up to managers to manage it, it's up to them to stick to whatever the policy is. Of course it's different with smaller independent stores.

Watchkeys · 21/09/2023 12:16

BellaAndDave · 21/09/2023 09:34

And this is the problem, anyone can slap an assistance dog vest on any dog and argue it’s a trained assistance dog as there is no regulatory body.

There are shop managers managing this, and unless they feel they're having a problem with it, there's no problem. People don't generally take advantage by claiming a disability they don't have.

Unless you feel that there are loads of dogs in loads of supermarkets? I've seen no sign of this, is it a problem where you are?

Litmus1001 · 21/09/2023 12:07

@overdrawn

'Despite what MN would have you believe, most people I've encountered when taking my dog out with me seem to actually really like it.'

Could it be that many people don't like it at all, but have just not said anything? Why are you even carrying a dog around a supermarket anyway?

SoupDragon · 21/09/2023 11:48

If the dog is completely enclosed in a carrier I think that's fine. It isn't wandering round sniffing stuff.

Studswagger · 21/09/2023 10:58

My son and my sister are both autistic and dogs in supermarkets would cause massive issues for both of them. 1) they are both frightened of dogs because they move in unexpected ways and they can’t read dog body language at all 2) they both have sensory issues and unexpected barking is awful for them 3) they both have fears about contamination of food- they would struggle to buy and eat food that a dog has been nosing around.

Guide dogs/properly trained service dogs are one thing- they don’t bark, approach people or stick their noses into things- but random dogs are not good.

HenriettaBaguetta · 21/09/2023 10:45

overdrawn · 21/09/2023 10:13

Some supermarkets are dog friendly (mostly for small dogs that can be carried) – perhaps ask the security at the door? I often take my very small dog into supermarkets I know are okay with it (she's carried in my arms) and have never had any issues. If anything it makes people smile and she gets lots of pats. If the supermarket isn't dog friendly, however, I wouldn't take her in. I know Planet Organic isn't dog friendly, but a lot of Co-Ops and Budgens are. Despite what MN would have you believe, most people I've encountered when taking my dog out with me seem to actually really like it. In the past three years, I've had one negative comment from someone and it was in a shop (not even a food shop) that was openly very dog friendly with dog bowls etc so it really didn't bother me!

I think you're making the mistake of thinking 'no-one has complained to me so no-one cares and it's fine' when lots of people generally avoid public confrontation.

It doesn't mean no-one is unhappy about it or annoyed or inconvenienced. Just that they haven't told you.

depressionpitofdoom · 21/09/2023 10:16

There are definitely more service dogs than those just for the blind, I know someone who's service dog alerts them to seizures for example and will give them enough warning to get themselves to safety and helps when the seizure takes place. That said, it may cause issues in the shop if your dog is not a registered service animal.

I really struggle with shops and I would definitely struggle if I couldn't get deliveries (I did really struggle during covid and thankfully had other people who could shop for me but without those people I don't know what I would have done). Does your supermarket have quiet hours when they dim the lights and stop the music? I find those really helpful when I don't have a choice, earplugs and sunglasses can help too although I can't stand sunglasses so it doesn't work for everyone.

I really do sympathise, supermarkets are my idea of torture, everything's too bright, too loud, too many smells and too many people who all seem to come out of nowhere and get too close and then they stare when you start stimming/having a meltdown which just makes it worse. It's 2023 and people still don't seem to have much tolerance for others. (As evidenced here with people telling OP to grow up because she struggles with something that most people are lucky enough to be able to take for granted).

overdrawn · 21/09/2023 10:13

Some supermarkets are dog friendly (mostly for small dogs that can be carried) – perhaps ask the security at the door? I often take my very small dog into supermarkets I know are okay with it (she's carried in my arms) and have never had any issues. If anything it makes people smile and she gets lots of pats. If the supermarket isn't dog friendly, however, I wouldn't take her in. I know Planet Organic isn't dog friendly, but a lot of Co-Ops and Budgens are. Despite what MN would have you believe, most people I've encountered when taking my dog out with me seem to actually really like it. In the past three years, I've had one negative comment from someone and it was in a shop (not even a food shop) that was openly very dog friendly with dog bowls etc so it really didn't bother me!

1stTimeMummy2021 · 21/09/2023 09:51

As someone who has an actual assistance dog from a registered charity, please don't do this. There is a reason my dog is a labrador, she needs to be big enough to do many different tasks, when I go out with my wheelchair she helps me so much but I find fake assistance dogs everywhere and they bark and misbehave and it's awful for correctly trained dogs. Maybe you could carry something with you, like a toy, it doesn't have to be big but something you can touch to help you feel better, it's called grounding and I used a small key chain toy before I had my dog.