Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to take dog into supermarket

212 replies

amechange · 20/09/2023 20:47

I can't get supermarket deliveries. I am autistic, I am disabled because of it, and stress/anxiety causes me to do self destructive stims and behaviours, brings on disassociation, paranoia, sleep issues, suicidal ideation etc and I have agoraphobia as well. I have only ever been a few minutes away from home up till today when I pushed myself to go to the supermarket, I didn't go in. If I couldn't take my dog, I wouldn't have left the house. She is a tiny chihuahua. She is well behaved, she understands commands, but she isn't registered as anything, but she pretty much is a service dog. Even though she wasnt specifically trained to do a specific task to calm my anxiety down, having her there with me reduces my anxiety a lot compared to if I didn't have her. And at home when I feel anxious, she comes and sits by me/lets me hold her. I'm now in a position where I have to go in there to do my weekly shopping. She has a dog pram that closes all around, it was expensive and looks like a babies pram but isn't, its the ibiyaya retro luxe pram. She wouldn't be a danger to anyone/bother anyone/contaminate anything/get in the way, no one will notice it's a dog, I wont be showing her off/taking her out to show people if I took her in.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Snugglemonkey · 21/09/2023 19:49

Canisaysomething · 21/09/2023 09:21

Have you forgotten about allergies? People with pet allergies don’t want dogs in a space that is meant to be hygienic and is serving food. It’s bad enough allowing dogs in cafes.

It would be hygienic if the dog is in a pram. I think it is an environmental hazard, like hay fever.

amechange · 21/09/2023 18:11

vodkaredbullgirl · 21/09/2023 18:11

Looks like OP has vanished.

I have nothing to say.

OP posts:
vodkaredbullgirl · 21/09/2023 18:11

Looks like OP has vanished.

marymungoNminge · 21/09/2023 18:09

Yeah please don't.

Litmus1001 · 21/09/2023 17:46

overdrawn · 21/09/2023 17:10

@Litmus1001 omg. Once again, I am talking about supermarkets that explicitly have a policy to allow small dogs in if they are held. They are few and far between. You do not need to go to them! In the same way that I check if I am allowed in with my dog before going in (because that is what suits me and I don't go in if I am not allowed in) you can check if they do allow dogs and only go in if they don't (because that is what suits you!). I am in no way advocating that people with dogs enter into spaces that are not designated as dog friendly spaces! Any supermarket that I have been allowed into with a dog has a policy of you are allowed the dog if you carry it – so it's not going to be slobbering on food, or urinating in aisles. There are plenty of supermarkets that do not allow dogs into them (far more than do!) and people should not be taking dogs into those spaces – I am not arguing with you about that, nor saying that all supermarkets should be dog friendly! It's really not that hard to understand. Confused and I'm agreeing with you that dogs shouldn't be taken into supermarkets that don't allow it?!

Once again, you are failing to comprehend/ignoring all the information presented to you. You're come across a tad arrogant too, so we'll leave it at that.

Litmus1001 · 21/09/2023 17:45

Watchkeys · 21/09/2023 16:59

Generally speaking, most supermarkets allow well-behaved dogs on a leash inside their store

Did you read the article you posted, @Litmus1001 ? It's codswallop.

I get your modus operandi now, insults to prove your point.
Boring and pointless.

overdrawn · 21/09/2023 17:10

@Litmus1001 omg. Once again, I am talking about supermarkets that explicitly have a policy to allow small dogs in if they are held. They are few and far between. You do not need to go to them! In the same way that I check if I am allowed in with my dog before going in (because that is what suits me and I don't go in if I am not allowed in) you can check if they do allow dogs and only go in if they don't (because that is what suits you!). I am in no way advocating that people with dogs enter into spaces that are not designated as dog friendly spaces! Any supermarket that I have been allowed into with a dog has a policy of you are allowed the dog if you carry it – so it's not going to be slobbering on food, or urinating in aisles. There are plenty of supermarkets that do not allow dogs into them (far more than do!) and people should not be taking dogs into those spaces – I am not arguing with you about that, nor saying that all supermarkets should be dog friendly! It's really not that hard to understand. Confused and I'm agreeing with you that dogs shouldn't be taken into supermarkets that don't allow it?!

cuddlebear · 21/09/2023 17:09

I see dogs in supermarkets every visit so I don’t think anyone upholds any “rules” about them being banned.

I am confused as to how/why you can’t get home delivery though.

Watchkeys · 21/09/2023 16:59

Generally speaking, most supermarkets allow well-behaved dogs on a leash inside their store

Did you read the article you posted, @Litmus1001 ? It's codswallop.

Watchkeys · 21/09/2023 16:52

@Litmus1001

Thanks for that. There is no law against dogs in food shops. Your opinion doesn't change that. The rules posted by shops are at the shop's discretion, so if op asks and the shop is ok with it, you don't have a leg to stand on.

You're right, your state of mind makes no difference to my point, which is that your opinion can't be stated as fact with any authority other than your own. My opinion goes with the law, and the rules of the shops we're all talking about, so you can defer to them if you don't like it. They'll tell you how it all works, I'm sure.

Helpmepleaseimbusy · 21/09/2023 16:45

SirSamVimesCityWatch · 20/09/2023 20:53

Hmm I've had a quick look and it seems you can't register your own dog as anything in the UK. Sorry OP.

Look into local charities that may be able to get your shopping for you / go with you to the shop. Work up to being able to do more by using the dog to help you increase your confidence and skills and decrease your anxiety, then start to try to do little bits without the dog. Baby steps.

Nonsense. Each charity has their own procedures. Some provide dogs and with some, you can register your own dog provided you and your dog meet the criteria of the assistance dog (registered) charity that you are joining. You would become an in training member once you are accepted. Your dog would need to be trained to perform the behaviours to assist you with your specific disability/disabilities - this can take quite a while. However, there are certain dogs that won't be accepted such as banned breeds or tpy breeds (which I believe Chihuahua's fall under). I work with assistance dogs - it takes much more than just a good dog who listens a, although that is a good start.

Litmus1001 · 21/09/2023 16:38

Watchkeys · 21/09/2023 16:27

@Litmus1001

If a dog isn't a trained service dog it has no place in a supermarket

Dogs are legally allowed in food shops. It is at the discretion of the shop, and not at the discretion of an irate member of the public such as yourself. Those are the facts. There's no need for you to like or agree with them. However strong your opinion, it will still not be up to you or anybody else except the shop.

Dogs other than service dogs are not allowed in a lot of supermarkets, and there are clear signs stating this. That is factual information. If a policy is no dogs, then don't put the manager in the difficult of position of asking him/her to change a storewide policy to suit you.
Calling me 'irate' to further your argument is quite meaningless. partly because I am not and partly because that's a subjective opinion.
Failing to address the many points clearly made on this thread (such as allergies, fear of dogs, hygiene, dogs reacting to each other, risking the right of actual service dogs being allowed to come into shops) doesn't help your 'argument' either.

This is helpful and to the point. https://pethelpreviews.co.uk/are-dogs-allowed-in-supermarkets-uk/

Watchkeys · 21/09/2023 16:29

@Litmus1001

Have you missed all the posts stating 'why not

You really do think that if only people would simply read an opinion similar to yours, they'd agree with you, don't you?!

Watchkeys · 21/09/2023 16:27

@Litmus1001

If a dog isn't a trained service dog it has no place in a supermarket

Dogs are legally allowed in food shops. It is at the discretion of the shop, and not at the discretion of an irate member of the public such as yourself. Those are the facts. There's no need for you to like or agree with them. However strong your opinion, it will still not be up to you or anybody else except the shop.

Watchkeys · 21/09/2023 16:21

@BellaAndDave

Yes, it's a shame that a few deceptive people spoil it. I'd imagine that if you put your complaints about specific dogs that cause you such problems to the shop management, they'll have a second look at those dogs. Have you tried that? They might overlook certification, but I don't think they'd overlook a dog eating ham out of another customer's basket, or peeing on the bananas. Would they? What's your experience been when you've had this problem?

Litmus1001 · 21/09/2023 16:21

GreekDogRescue · 21/09/2023 16:15

Why not OP.
don’t listen to the naysayers who insist on following every law, even laws that don’t exist.
These are the sort of people who taped off beaches during lockdown; there are unfortunately rather a lot of them

Have you missed all the posts stating 'why not'?

Litmus1001 · 21/09/2023 16:20

Watchkeys · 21/09/2023 16:03

@Litmus1001

Yes, I have. I think op has a reasonable point re her dog bring a service dog, and I doubt that many would pretend to a member of shop staff that they had those issues, simply to get their dog into a shop.

What's your point re me having read those posts? Did you think that because I'd read them, I would need to agree with them?

I'm really not sure there's a slippery slope here. Most dog owners would be unlikely to need to take their dog into shops so badly that it would cause an overall issue. Most dog owners accept and accommodate the status quo, without the need to feign disability. Obviously on mn, the belief of many is that if this chaos carries on, we'll be finding dogs in our tins of soup before the day's out, but that's not real life.

OP''s dog isn't a service dog, and from what she has written, has not been trained in the way a service dog would be. She's calling it 'pretty much a service dog', when it sounds more like an emotional support dog - an entirely different thing.
The rest of what you have written is subjective/opinion, basically saying 'I don't think x will happen' and not addressing actual issues such as allergies and fear.
If a dog isn't a trained service dog it has no place in a supermarket.

Dwappy · 21/09/2023 16:16

fiddlesticksandotherwords · 21/09/2023 16:07

The OP is autistic and finds shopping very challenging, and the dog would give emotional support by its presence.

I'm sure that's true. But the issue is what happens when (like in America) people start wanting to bring all sorts of weird emotional support animals in? You'll first get people asking why not cats? Then as someone mentioned above you might get other emotional support animals like pigs, birds, goats etc. All very sweet animals in the right circumstances and places. But not to drag round a supermarket no matter how much support they give you. (And you can't use training as an excuse why only dogs. Because many dogs are not trained well at all yet some pigs and birds can be very well behaved and even trained to a certain extent).

GreekDogRescue · 21/09/2023 16:15

Why not OP.
don’t listen to the naysayers who insist on following every law, even laws that don’t exist.
These are the sort of people who taped off beaches during lockdown; there are unfortunately rather a lot of them

BellaAndDave · 21/09/2023 16:12

Watchkeys · 21/09/2023 12:16

There are shop managers managing this, and unless they feel they're having a problem with it, there's no problem. People don't generally take advantage by claiming a disability they don't have.

Unless you feel that there are loads of dogs in loads of supermarkets? I've seen no sign of this, is it a problem where you are?

I’ve seen a few “assistance” dogs that are clearly not trained to a high standard. I have a medical alert assistance dog (epilepsy) and it’s not the first time another dog in the supermarket has barked/pulled on its leash to try to get near to us/been sniffing at shelves/not walking to heel. If an assistance dog can’t behave appropriately in public it shouldn’t be working doing public access imo.

Many shop managers won’t challenge someone who has their dog dressed in assistance gear. I’m on many assistance dog FB groups and it’s shocking how many people think labelling an untrained dog or a puppy gives them instant access to places. The worst part is people in these groups are giving terrible advice to get emotional support dogs into shops/restaurants/concerts etc.

fiddlesticksandotherwords · 21/09/2023 16:07

parietal · 20/09/2023 21:56

if your dog is in the dog-carrier, how can it offer you any comfort?

The OP is autistic and finds shopping very challenging, and the dog would give emotional support by its presence.

Watchkeys · 21/09/2023 16:03

@Litmus1001

Yes, I have. I think op has a reasonable point re her dog bring a service dog, and I doubt that many would pretend to a member of shop staff that they had those issues, simply to get their dog into a shop.

What's your point re me having read those posts? Did you think that because I'd read them, I would need to agree with them?

I'm really not sure there's a slippery slope here. Most dog owners would be unlikely to need to take their dog into shops so badly that it would cause an overall issue. Most dog owners accept and accommodate the status quo, without the need to feign disability. Obviously on mn, the belief of many is that if this chaos carries on, we'll be finding dogs in our tins of soup before the day's out, but that's not real life.

ACertainKindOfLight · 21/09/2023 15:56

I love dogs but if you start taking your dog in, so will everyone else. I wouldn't think a supermarket environment is suitable for a dog, they can be very noisy and fraught. Customers these days argue over the slightest thing, your bound to have one causing a fuss over your dog.
Theres a man in the USA that has an alligator as a therapy pet. Takes it to the shops, another one has a goose, it squawks all the way round the store whilst it's owner talks very loudly to it, the staff look really fed up with it, especially when it messed all over the floor.

allthehops · 21/09/2023 15:41

quitefranklyabsurd · 20/09/2023 21:08

Just put a service dog vest on her and I imagine no one would bay an eyelid.

And there are plenty of threads on here with people rightfully complaining about exactly this.

We have a fake "assistance dog" in our town that's badly behaved/untrained and it makes it very difficult for genuine service dog owners. They end up being hassled by security guards/refused entry to places because of the fake ones who've gone in and barked/toileted/nicked things off the shelf.

So no, it's not ok.

Litmus1001 · 21/09/2023 15:28

Watchkeys · 21/09/2023 14:46

@HenriettaBaguetta

Generally be a considerate person

There are plenty of people on this thread, and in the rest of the world, who are far more considerate to OP's situation than yourself. Are we just meant to be considerate to people you agree with, or considerate to everyone?

What's this argument you're putting forward about supermarket managers having plenty to do? If they haven't time to answer a question from a customer with disabilities, is the customer going to feel that they're being considerate to them?

I'm not sure you've fully considered what it means to be considerate, ironically. It's not about your preferences and how you think the world 'should' be. Managers manage the shop, and the customers' queries. Customers aren't supposed to be minding the poor, overworked manager's feelings, when they're asking one question about one disability issue.

Have you read any of the posts explaining why it's a bad idea to encourage anything other than service dogs in supermarkets?

Swipe left for the next trending thread