Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to take dog into supermarket

212 replies

amechange · 20/09/2023 20:47

I can't get supermarket deliveries. I am autistic, I am disabled because of it, and stress/anxiety causes me to do self destructive stims and behaviours, brings on disassociation, paranoia, sleep issues, suicidal ideation etc and I have agoraphobia as well. I have only ever been a few minutes away from home up till today when I pushed myself to go to the supermarket, I didn't go in. If I couldn't take my dog, I wouldn't have left the house. She is a tiny chihuahua. She is well behaved, she understands commands, but she isn't registered as anything, but she pretty much is a service dog. Even though she wasnt specifically trained to do a specific task to calm my anxiety down, having her there with me reduces my anxiety a lot compared to if I didn't have her. And at home when I feel anxious, she comes and sits by me/lets me hold her. I'm now in a position where I have to go in there to do my weekly shopping. She has a dog pram that closes all around, it was expensive and looks like a babies pram but isn't, its the ibiyaya retro luxe pram. She wouldn't be a danger to anyone/bother anyone/contaminate anything/get in the way, no one will notice it's a dog, I wont be showing her off/taking her out to show people if I took her in.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
Watchkeys · 22/09/2023 19:49

D1nopawus · 22/09/2023 09:19

The OP has explained that she rarely goes out though. A dog that obeys commands at home won't automatically do the same in a supermarket with lots of distractions. It might of course, but if it doesn't, that will increase the pressure on OP.

OK, so let's dismiss the parts of what OP says that don't fit in with our own views, and then we can carry on yapping the same points as we were before?

I smell a flawed argument.

marshmallowfinder · 22/09/2023 19:12

Bloom15 · 20/09/2023 21:39

Sorry but that is awful

Plus I assume she bought it from the internet, not brought it.

birker · 22/09/2023 19:09

The OP has explained that she rarely goes out though. A dog that obeys commands at home won't automatically do the same in a supermarket with lots of distractions. It might of course, but if it doesn't, that will increase the pressure on OP.

100% this, I have a well trained, well socialised dog. Regularly take her to dog friendly cafes and she behaves well but this took a lot of training/practice and was definitely stressful. Wouldn't have fancied having extra stress if I was already anxious.

Despite her being well behaved in dog friendly establishments I still wouldn't trust her behaviour to be 100% spot on in a supermarket as she'd need time to learn and adapt. The new environment would be a lot for her to take in and far too many distractions for her to be 100% focussed on me and what I was telling her to do/not do.

WiddlinDiddlin · 22/09/2023 18:03

Tessabelle74 · 21/09/2023 00:30

Because she can't bend down easily and falls regularly, her dog helps her up when she falls. She has received training to do so. The only "official" trained dogs are guide dogs for the blind so how about you start calling all those other service dog users out for having fake service dogs?

This definitely isn't true, there are a range of organisations, many of which belong to the umbrella organisation ADUK that train dogs for various tasks, including hearing dogs, canine partners and more. There are medical detection dogs as well, the idea that ONLY Guide Dogs For The Blind are 'official' assistance dogs reallllllllly needs to die now.

An owner trained dog is still an official assistance dog - just not trained by being puppy raised on behalf of, and then kept in a training centre run by a particular organisation. There are owner training organisations as well like Dog A.I.D and Canine Generated Independence.

Then there are responsible owner/trainers who take their dogs to training classes, workshops and practicals, and have trainers come to them to work with them at home.

It is unfortunate that some people misuse the owner-trained option, but the solution is not to remove that option, it would disadvantage many people who need a very specific task dog, or who just can't wait to win the assistance dog lottery that is waiting for a charity supplied dog.

Tessisme · 22/09/2023 10:20

D1nopawus · 22/09/2023 09:59

Not yapping?

🤣🤣🤣 I don't know why this made me laugh so much!

D1nopawus · 22/09/2023 09:59

Not yapping?

SoupDragon · 22/09/2023 09:49

D1nopawus · 22/09/2023 09:19

The OP has explained that she rarely goes out though. A dog that obeys commands at home won't automatically do the same in a supermarket with lots of distractions. It might of course, but if it doesn't, that will increase the pressure on OP.

it's in an enclosed dog carrier. What commands does it need to obey?

D1nopawus · 22/09/2023 09:27

D1nopawus
The OP struggles to go out though, so it is likely that her dog hadn't been socialised. It's probably not at the level needed for a domestic dog to be in a shop - never mind the requirements for a service dog. I'm not saying this to criticise you OP, if you are still reading. It's just that the requirements are likely to be harder for you to meet.

I personally wont engage with this poster any more, they don’t appear to comprehend anything outwith their own agenda.

LOL. Of course I've got an agenda. I'm trying to point out that taking a chihuahua to Tescos is quite likely to add to the difficulties and stress of someone who is already struggling. And that's before considering that non-service dogs are not allowed in most supermarkets.

I completed understand why the OP is considering it, as she believes it could help. In her world, it seems like a logical solution. It's important for her to consider other perspectives too though, and to understand that other options could work better.

D1nopawus · 22/09/2023 09:19

Watchkeys · 21/09/2023 21:40

OP has specifically stated that the dog is well behaved and obeys commands.

The OP has explained that she rarely goes out though. A dog that obeys commands at home won't automatically do the same in a supermarket with lots of distractions. It might of course, but if it doesn't, that will increase the pressure on OP.

depressionpitofdoom · 22/09/2023 08:24

Watchkeys · 22/09/2023 07:40

@depressionpitofdoom

And how trolleys get used by animals at night

I agree with you that some PP's seem to have a false idea of how hygienically food is stored prior to sale in supermarkets. I'm curious about this trolley comment though. I've got images of badgers drunkenly pushing each other round Waitrose car park at 3am...

😂😂 nothing quite so amusing unfortunately but lots of rats, foxes, birds etc. Using them as climbing frames and toilets and they don't get disinfected every day.

SoupDragon · 22/09/2023 07:58

Litmus1001 · 21/09/2023 17:45

I get your modus operandi now, insults to prove your point.
Boring and pointless.

But did you actually read the whole of the article you linked to? It starts by saying that dogs (excluding service dogs) aren't allowed in any U.K. supermarkets, then goes on to say that most supermarkets don't allow them and then gives a list of some shops that do allow dogs in (Tesco and Aldi being the appropriate ones for this thread).

Watchkeys · 22/09/2023 07:40

@depressionpitofdoom

And how trolleys get used by animals at night

I agree with you that some PP's seem to have a false idea of how hygienically food is stored prior to sale in supermarkets. I'm curious about this trolley comment though. I've got images of badgers drunkenly pushing each other round Waitrose car park at 3am...

Watchkeys · 22/09/2023 07:36

@RandomButtons

Not sure who you're arguing with re Tesco? I'm saying it's up to Tesco whether they let dogs in or not, because there are no laws about dogs in food shops.

You seems to be arguing against this by saying that Tescos have a policy saying that they don't let dogs in.

depressionpitofdoom · 22/09/2023 07:16

SchadenfreudeIstMeinMittelname · 21/09/2023 13:57

But all supermarkets should be not allowing dogs in. It's a hygiene issue. Exemptions are made for properly trained service dogs because they can be trusted not to slobber over the food or urinate or defecate in the store.

Have you seen the warehouses where food is stored before being put on the supermarket shelves? And how trolleys get used by animals at night? Dogs would be the least of your worries. I personally don't like the idea of all dogs being allowed in supermarkets but that's because I personally know someone who would absolutely think nothing of taking their very large, intimidating dogs with them with no thought to who that might affect, but I think the hygiene argument isn't as great as a lot of people think because the warehouses are disgusting and many supermarkets have rats.

Watchkeys · 22/09/2023 06:01

they don’t appear to comprehend anything outwith their own agenda

Nor do you, @BellaAndDave You're saying OP is wrong because you don't understand her point of view, not because there are any rules or authorities about it. If she feels she needs the dog, and asks the shop and they're ok with it, your 'It's got to be the kind of assistance dog that I, personally understand' comes to nothing.

There's a lot of people on this thread reading from a rule book that doesn't exist, @amechange A shop is a private space into which the public are generally allowed, and as such, the shop is allowed to decide for itself whether to let your dog in, according to its own policies, and whether it is comfortable making exceptions. It's worth you asking. People barking loudly on this thread about 'Dogs shouldn't be allowed in shops!!' aren't referring to anything but their own opinion, so, unless you go about obeying rules that other people invent because they feel like it, you don't need to respect any of them, any more than they would need to respect your opinion if you said that they, themselves, shouldn't be allowed out of their houses. It's twaddle! There are plenty of food establishments that do allow dogs in, including some branches of some supermarkets, regardless of the opinions being thrown at you here. I hope that you can hear the sanity in this, and that, as long as you respect the law, and any rules in private spaces, you can mitigate your anxiety however you please. The world is much kinder to dogs than this thread; you've got lots of rabid posts here :)

Why can't you order your shopping for delivery, though, or click and collect? Wouldn't that save you the whole hassle?

BellaAndDave · 21/09/2023 23:45

D1nopawus · 21/09/2023 21:31

The OP struggles to go out though, so it is likely that her dog hadn't been socialised. It's probably not at the level needed for a domestic dog to be in a shop - never mind the requirements for a service dog. I'm not saying this to criticise you OP, if you are still reading. It's just that the requirements are likely to be harder for you to meet.

I personally wont engage with this poster any more, they don’t appear to comprehend anything outwith their own agenda.

BellaAndDave · 21/09/2023 23:43

WeeOrcadian · 21/09/2023 22:10

Because you didn't get the answers you wanted?

Because you don't want to answer the obvious questions like "how do you walk your dog if you have agoraphobia?" and "how have you gotten shopping until now?"?

I completely agree with you. I’m sick to the back teeth of people who think they’re entitled to take emotional support animals anywhere with them especially carrying them or in prams. An assistance dog needs to mitigate a disability. How can they mitigate a disability in a pram or being carried? I don’t take my medical alert dog everywhere with me as I often go out with DH or with family members, I only take her when I’m going out on my own. I’m also curious as to how a chihuahua can mitigate a disability as most reputable charities who train assistance dogs won’t look at that breed to train.

WeeOrcadian · 21/09/2023 22:10

amechange · 21/09/2023 18:11

I have nothing to say.

Because you didn't get the answers you wanted?

Because you don't want to answer the obvious questions like "how do you walk your dog if you have agoraphobia?" and "how have you gotten shopping until now?"?

Watchkeys · 21/09/2023 21:40

OP has specifically stated that the dog is well behaved and obeys commands.

D1nopawus · 21/09/2023 21:31

The OP struggles to go out though, so it is likely that her dog hadn't been socialised. It's probably not at the level needed for a domestic dog to be in a shop - never mind the requirements for a service dog. I'm not saying this to criticise you OP, if you are still reading. It's just that the requirements are likely to be harder for you to meet.

Watchkeys · 21/09/2023 21:17

all dogs need to be socialised to behave well around people and other animals long before they get anywhere near shops

Not really, they just need to be socialised to a standard level for a domesticated dog. There are food shops that let dogs in as long as they're well behaved and on a lead. The dogs don't need to be specially trained and it works fine. It's just about whether the shop will allow dogs in general, or be willing to make an exception to its rules for OP.

D1nopawus · 21/09/2023 21:00

OP I'm not sure this thread is helping much, but all dogs need to be socialised to behave well around people and other animals long before they get anywhere near shops. Dogs functioning as service dogs need extensive training. I suspect in your circumstances, you would struggle to train your dog to the standard required.

I understand why it looks like a solution, but it's unlikely to be successful, and truthfully, is probably not fair on your dog. I also think there is a risk it will add to your distress rather than resolve it.

A few people have asked how you got your shopping previously. If you felt able to answer, posters might be able to offer helpful suggestions.

RandomButtons · 21/09/2023 20:21

amechange · 21/09/2023 18:11

I have nothing to say.

I genuinely hope you get some support through this OP, I’ve had severe anxiety in the past and it’s horrible working through it. I couldn’t go into crowded spaces for a long time, so I get it, but taking your dog in isn’t the solution.

You’ve had some good suggestions in this thread, some outright rude idiots, and a bizzare bun fight over dogs and laws.

Maybe post in the mental health boards asking for positive ideas to help you cope.

Watchkeys · 21/09/2023 20:20

I get your modus operandi now, insults to prove your point
Boring and pointless

No, my point was that your article states that supermarkets in the uk generally allow dogs in. It's not true. It's codswallop. That's not an insult. The article you posted is neither stating the truth nor from a reputable source.

You're come across a tad arrogant too, so we'll leave it at that

Whereas you actually do know everything, @Litmus1001 ? Haha! Your comments get funnier and funnier! You're talking rubbish and then calling people who correct you names.

It's good you're leaving it there... although I bet you're not, really.

RandomButtons · 21/09/2023 20:18

Watchkeys · 21/09/2023 16:27

@Litmus1001

If a dog isn't a trained service dog it has no place in a supermarket

Dogs are legally allowed in food shops. It is at the discretion of the shop, and not at the discretion of an irate member of the public such as yourself. Those are the facts. There's no need for you to like or agree with them. However strong your opinion, it will still not be up to you or anybody else except the shop.

https://twitter.com/Tesco/status/990576733878353920?lang=en

Dogs are not allowed in Tesco according to Tesco unless they are service dogs or guide dogs.

So give over.

https://twitter.com/Tesco/status/990576733878353920?lang=en