Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

5 year old French School Magnet Punishment System

58 replies

Romika · 20/09/2023 16:59

My dear little 5 year old boy is at a state school in Paris, France. His new form teacher has instilled a system whereby each of the kiddies gets a different coloured magnet for each time they step slightly out of line, from white to yellow to pink blue red etc, or some such.. and he's terrified of doing anything it would seem, being late, speaking too loudly, because of the stigma attached.
Does this seem hideously punitive and might stifle independent thought etc, or am I being overly woke? I know that they can be little nutters but it seems a little extreme.
Thanks!

OP posts:
brittanyfairies · 20/09/2023 17:12

In my job (in France) I can visit 3 or 4 primary schools a day, they all have some form of discipline like this from GS to CM2. Some schools are stricter than others. I don't really see the children stressing, and actually teachers are starting to encourage good behaviour more, but sometimes teachers do have to give a cross, or a red traffic light or whatever form of classroom control they use. I much prefer this method to the teachers who stand and scream at classes, fortunately there are fewer and fewer of this type. I have also been known myself to ask a child if they would like me to put a cross against their name on the blackboard (more the CM1 and CM2). They always say no and calm themselves down. My own DCs were educated in France, it's not something I have a problem with.

LadyOfACertainAge · 20/09/2023 17:12

My 12 and 8 yo also had a cloud system when they were 5. It seems like it works to me, except that with the cloud there is positive encouragement/reward too.

TheLightProgramme · 20/09/2023 17:12

They had being on the sunshine or on the raincloud 2 yrs ago in our uk state primary.

Needmorelego · 20/09/2023 17:08

My daughter is 15 now so it's only 10 years ago that she was at the beginning of school.
They had "The Cloud". Everyday all the children are on a the regular cloud - so do something amazing the child gets put on the rainbow, do something naughty it's onto the rain cloud.
This apparently was very common a decade ago. I have no idea if it still is. The children didn't seem to mind it.
(This is English schools btw)

Allmarbleslost · 20/09/2023 17:06

Hideous. Public shaming is not the way to instil good behaviour. I wonder how many adults would accept being given a red magnet in front of the rest of the office for not sitting still at their desk or whatever.

LlynTegid · 20/09/2023 17:01

French children have to abide by standards and good behaviour. How refreshing.

Screamingabdabz · 20/09/2023 17:01

Well it appears to work! How else do you suggest they discipline a class of 5 year olds?

Swipe left for the next trending thread