Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

5 year old French School Magnet Punishment System

58 replies

Romika · 20/09/2023 16:59

My dear little 5 year old boy is at a state school in Paris, France. His new form teacher has instilled a system whereby each of the kiddies gets a different coloured magnet for each time they step slightly out of line, from white to yellow to pink blue red etc, or some such.. and he's terrified of doing anything it would seem, being late, speaking too loudly, because of the stigma attached.
Does this seem hideously punitive and might stifle independent thought etc, or am I being overly woke? I know that they can be little nutters but it seems a little extreme.
Thanks!

OP posts:
saltinesandcoffeecups · 20/09/2023 19:37

Can I ask why you all think this is extreme? I fully concede I’m a dinosaur 🦕 and got a few names on the blackboard (yes in chalk) during my time in school at that age. I even got a few of the dreaded check marks after my name.

No it wasn’t a pleasant experience, but at the end of the day they disappeared and tomorrow was a new day.

It also allowed the the teacher to call out bad behavior without stopping class.

I was a pretty normal kid and I’d guess most of us got our name written a few times. Maybe it’s just me but it would seem that if a child has an extreme reaction to this there are other issues at play that are more detrimental in the long term than being called out for not following the rules on occasion.

Iwasafool · 20/09/2023 19:34

It isn't just about the system, it is also about how it is administered. So the rule is children sit in their seats until told to do something else. Little Johnny forgets and starts to stand up and

a. Miss Honey looks at him and says "Johnny" and Johnny realises he needs to sit down so he does and Miss Honey smiles and gets on with the lesson.

B. Miss Trunchbull looks at him, shouts "sit down" and gives him his magnet.

Same magnet system, totally different for Johnny.

Sugargliderwombat · 20/09/2023 18:59

AndrewGarfieldsLaptop · 20/09/2023 17:50

Still is. I got it removed from my sons school

It's not common at all anymore, very outdated.

Sugargliderwombat · 20/09/2023 18:59

Screamingabdabz · 20/09/2023 17:01

Well it appears to work! How else do you suggest they discipline a class of 5 year olds?

Oh yes being terrified to make a mistake must work wonders for raising confident, independent learners.

HalfSiblingsMadeContact · 20/09/2023 17:53

Any discipline method becomes a problem when a child doesn't understand what they did wrong / what earned them a negative, or what they need to do to get a positive. My DS had the sun/cloud system when he was 5, and apparently spent most of year 1 on the cloud (according to a friend he came home with). He didn't seem to have a clue about it - and was accordingly not motivated to change his behaviour. Mind you, he didn't respond hugely to collecting merit points when he was 7 and 8 either.

OP - it's a huge shame your child is so terrified of getting it wrong. See if you can support them to figure out one thing to do/not do, at a time, and reassure them that getting something wrong is ok at times.

5foot5 · 20/09/2023 17:52

How big are these magnets? Do the kids ever get to handle them themselves or does the teacher control them all?

I would be a little worried in case one got swallowed. I would be petrified if more than one got swallowed, by the same child that is.

MrsMarzetti · 20/09/2023 17:51

We were given the belt at school and whilst i don't think we should be belting children, i can honestly say it hasn't caused me any lasting trauma after being belted once. I was at secondary school when the Belt was banned, the standards of behaviour changed within weeks. Suddenly well behaved pupils became little sods or even worse bullying little sods. We need some form of punishment.

AndrewGarfieldsLaptop · 20/09/2023 17:50

Needmorelego · 20/09/2023 17:08

My daughter is 15 now so it's only 10 years ago that she was at the beginning of school.
They had "The Cloud". Everyday all the children are on a the regular cloud - so do something amazing the child gets put on the rainbow, do something naughty it's onto the rain cloud.
This apparently was very common a decade ago. I have no idea if it still is. The children didn't seem to mind it.
(This is English schools btw)

Still is. I got it removed from my sons school

10HailMarys · 20/09/2023 17:44

and he's terrified of doing anything it would seem, being late, speaking too loudly

The idea is that they learn to be punctual and polite and they won’t learn that if they don’t see those things as bad behaviour with consequences. It doesn’t sound that bad to me.

I think the ‘terrified’ thing is perhaps more about his character and being new to a school environment than the system itself. Lots of kids are worried about rules and upsetting the teacher when they’re very little. I suspect he’d be just as terrified if he got a stern “No shouting please; we only use indoor voices” rather than a magnet.

BlackeyedSusan · 20/09/2023 17:40

Highlyflavouredgravy · 20/09/2023 17:15

I want you to imagine that you have a class of 30 children. You have teach them actual stuff so they need to behave, listen, etc

Can you all tell me how you would achieve this? There are, at most, 2 adults in the room.
I would love to know people's ideas. Any kind of ' sad cloud' is out, parents complain about break time being removed, can't get them to look at a wall, no time outs, no shouting, obviously no physical punishments

Five year olds, easy peasy to get most of them to behave well, even with more than thirty of them on your own... no need for names on the board.

Even the challenging ones who needed more support didn't get their name put on the board. Yes they got support to behave but it was more reminders of what they needed to do. Then there is the glare that melts concrete...

BertieBotts · 20/09/2023 17:36

YY "traffic light system" is the name for this kind of system more generally.

Phos · 20/09/2023 17:34

It's not much different from effort or behaviour ladders that are used here, is it?

Hotsaucegal · 20/09/2023 17:32

Interesting… to be honest not familar with this in a pedagogical setting but when I was scout and went to camp we had a bit of traffic light system. Interestingly we (the children) were also asked to evaluate our own behaviour. At the end of the camp we handed our traffic light cards to parents. Still a topic of amusement in our family as my twin brother allocated himself green lights for the whole week which was not the scores given by the camp leaders 🤭finding disciplinary system that works for all children and that all parents approve of is basically impossible. Maybe explain to your child that you want them to be as well behaved as possible but a bad magnet isn’t the end of the world and just because today you got a red one doesn’t mean that tomorrow you can get a green one :)

BertieBotts · 20/09/2023 17:31

It's a very common system and it's in use throughout the Western world - UK, US, Australia, a lot of EU countries.

That's not to say it's totally without it's critics as you can definitely find arguments against it. But it is very widely used and far from the worst option.

YachtMistress · 20/09/2023 17:27

Teachers need to be supported by parents when they have structures and frameworks for behaviour standards in classrooms. Pupils need and feel secure in calm and focused learning environments.

Mariposista · 20/09/2023 17:26

If it teaches them to behave...
Don't step out of lie and you have nothing to be afraid of.

Needmorelego · 20/09/2023 17:23

@caringcarer I used to live and work in a tourist town in England that had gazillions of school groups visiting every day.
The French teens were unbelievably dreadful in their behaviour.
Rude, Loud. No concept of waiting their turn. 🤣

Debini · 20/09/2023 17:22

I went to school in the 90’s. I was once made to stand on a chair in the middle of the classroom for forgetting my book. I don’t think they do things like that these days 🤣

Plusque · 20/09/2023 17:22

Needmorelego · 20/09/2023 17:08

My daughter is 15 now so it's only 10 years ago that she was at the beginning of school.
They had "The Cloud". Everyday all the children are on a the regular cloud - so do something amazing the child gets put on the rainbow, do something naughty it's onto the rain cloud.
This apparently was very common a decade ago. I have no idea if it still is. The children didn't seem to mind it.
(This is English schools btw)

DS had it in Year 1 and 2 at his UK village primary, and he’s only 11, so not that long ago.

DiDonk · 20/09/2023 17:22

My kids had something similar with green amber red - also in France.

Like a lot of these things the good kids were largely good, the bad ones didn't really care and everyone gets used to whatever system they use.

It's not going to stifle your child, at worst it might annoy them if they get a punition unjustly, although not as much as if they get a collective punishment in my experience!

BingoandBlueyForever · 20/09/2023 17:22

When do the magnets reset? The next day? Tell him you love him even if he’s got a magnet that day and that he can try again to have a day with no magnets tomorrow. Try to take the sting out of it for him. It’s just a reminder to keep to the behavior rules. If he gets it wrong sometimes that’s ok, he stops the bad behavior and tries again.

caringcarer · 20/09/2023 17:20

LlynTegid · 20/09/2023 17:01

French children have to abide by standards and good behaviour. How refreshing.

French children are generally well behaved and polite. I expect these teaching methods add to this. My friend was brought up and schooled in France for the first 9 years of her life. She has the most beautiful handwriting I have ever seen and when I commented on it once she said all French children must do proper handwriting.

Iwasafool · 20/09/2023 17:15

Needmorelego · 20/09/2023 17:08

My daughter is 15 now so it's only 10 years ago that she was at the beginning of school.
They had "The Cloud". Everyday all the children are on a the regular cloud - so do something amazing the child gets put on the rainbow, do something naughty it's onto the rain cloud.
This apparently was very common a decade ago. I have no idea if it still is. The children didn't seem to mind it.
(This is English schools btw)

My GS had the cloud when he started school about 12 years ago but their cloud was a rainy cloud, a normal cloud and a sunny cloud. When the children went into school they put their name on the cloud to show how they were feeling. I thought it was brilliant as the teacher knew who needed a bit of support and so on.

Highlyflavouredgravy · 20/09/2023 17:15

I want you to imagine that you have a class of 30 children. You have teach them actual stuff so they need to behave, listen, etc

Can you all tell me how you would achieve this? There are, at most, 2 adults in the room.
I would love to know people's ideas. Any kind of ' sad cloud' is out, parents complain about break time being removed, can't get them to look at a wall, no time outs, no shouting, obviously no physical punishments

Cheeesus · 20/09/2023 17:14

I wonder if they’re being rather strict on what counts as a misdemeanour. It doesn’t seem bad as a method, mine had similar five years ago.