Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

5 year old French School Magnet Punishment System

58 replies

Romika · 20/09/2023 16:59

My dear little 5 year old boy is at a state school in Paris, France. His new form teacher has instilled a system whereby each of the kiddies gets a different coloured magnet for each time they step slightly out of line, from white to yellow to pink blue red etc, or some such.. and he's terrified of doing anything it would seem, being late, speaking too loudly, because of the stigma attached.
Does this seem hideously punitive and might stifle independent thought etc, or am I being overly woke? I know that they can be little nutters but it seems a little extreme.
Thanks!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bemyclementine · 21/09/2023 21:27

My DC school do the cloud system mentioned by a pp. There seem to be 5 places. You start at the middle snd can be moved up or down. Often the naughty kids get moved up for minor good behaviour. The kids that behave generally stay I'm the middle.

User8743 · 21/09/2023 21:26

Behaviour management is a killer in teaching. Sometimes you spend more time controlling a class than teaching. It just takes one and then it is a domino effect.
Effective discipline will benefit your "dear little 5 year old boy ".

GhostofCastleMcDuckula · 21/09/2023 21:19

I mean, it’s better than when my French professor used to throw whiteboard pens at us for laughing at “piscine”

fearfuloffluff · 21/09/2023 16:19

I think you sound a bit precious tbh, with the 'dear little boy' and 'terrified' etc.

Can your all to him and explain how it's good to do the right things, everyone makes mistakes sometimes, it doesn't really matter that much in the wider scheme of things? That he'll always be a lovely boy but it's good to follow the rules at school?

My understanding is that European schools just don't do pastoral care in the same way as UK schools, they don't see themselves as having to pussyfoot around feelings so much.

dadoodoodoo · 21/09/2023 15:53

@BertieBotts it's the same on self-reported wellbeing studies such as PISA so not just a case of differential approaches to diagnosing mental health conditions.

goodkidsmaadhouse · 21/09/2023 12:17

BertieBotts · 20/09/2023 22:04

Yes, unfortunately, while the positive only ones are BETTER because they don't systematically label the children who can't fit into the system as "bad", they still have the same 2 main problems in that they don't look at why children aren't meeting behaviour expectations and they don't do anything to help children learn how or understand why to meet behavioural expectations. Plus, those systems can have their own issues if they end up getting used to try to counteract some of the issues, so children who are struggling get offered many more rewards/tokens for behaviours which are just expected, not rewarded in others - this can end up seeming unfair, and the children who are just in the middle, neither standout performance or "troublemakers" get overlooked and ignored.

I have heard good things about these (below) systems which have been used in schools. They work better for the kids who always end up on red, but apparently they ALSO tend to work well for the others too. Honestly I tend to think it's always a win if we're doing slightly better than the previous iteration, so non-violence is better than violence, unobtrusive punishment is better than outright humiliation, positive encouragement is better than punishment, and I agree with all the above points about the way that a system is being implemented being important too, but I do think these systems that look past behaviour are the best we have as of the current moment.

https://consciousdiscipline.com/

https://livesinthebalance.org/educators-schools/

https://zonesofregulation.com/for-your-school/

https://self-reg.ca/educators/

Yes... I've seen some of these used very successfully in schools. Though IME only when the staff/student ratios can support it, and that's where so many schools fall down. In the UK at least - or Scotland at least - the SLT policy is usually very much focused on supporting emotional literacy and regulation rather than reward/punishment. But staff can only do that in reality if they aren't spending most of their time on crowd control. I would love to hear from someone who has worked in a big, busy, vulnerable/mixed catchment primary school which has managed it - I'm sure they're out there!

BertieBotts · 20/09/2023 23:05

dadoodoodoo · 20/09/2023 22:18

Interesting that nearly all comparative studies show markedly better mental health outcomes for French children and young people than those in the uk. Obviously not necessarily a correlation with school discipline measures but I think we have to consider our more progressive regime is not translating into healthier, happier kids.

Do you know what this is based on? Because France has lower numbers for diagnoses of various mental health or developmental disorders but that doesn't necessarily mean that there is a lower prevalence of those disorders - it's thought to be related to the fact that there is a huge stigma about these things in French culture so people are less likely to seek a diagnosis in the first place.

TheWayTheLightFalls · 20/09/2023 22:29

@Needmorelego my kids’ school still has this.

literally everything Bertie wrote. 28 compliant kids, two who are on the cloud by the end of register and who then get moved up/rewarded for any basic shit the teacher can find.

Letsgetouttahere2023 · 20/09/2023 22:26

Children need to be taught boundaries. If parents won't do it any more then the school have to. You can always home school if your child is too precious

ElizaMulvil · 20/09/2023 22:24

Whatt · 20/09/2023 21:47

I could never live in France.
You must conform or else. Look at religion and how people with SEN are treated and shunned.

I'm not sure the French are very good at conforming. They certainly do know how to rebel ( history and current affairs tell me this.)

They have separation of state and religion whereas we have an established church with political representation in the Lords. I don't think many, maybe most, French people are very religious at all. Certainly when I taught in a French Secondary School with a boarding section, no pupil ever took up the offer of being let out to go to Church of a Sunday.

Years ago I went to a centre for severely mentally handicapped men near Paris. It was wonderful and the staff were sensitive and great with the people there so not sure about Sen provision complaints.

MrsCarson · 20/09/2023 22:18

My kids had the traffic lights system in the US, they all start the day on green.
It was only used in their classes for constant disruption and not listening over and over, when asked to do/not do something. Just about all the kids stayed on green all the time as they were normally acting like little kids do, it was the ones who were tearing about, being disruptive and not listening at all who moved off to Amber, then Red.

dadoodoodoo · 20/09/2023 22:18

Interesting that nearly all comparative studies show markedly better mental health outcomes for French children and young people than those in the uk. Obviously not necessarily a correlation with school discipline measures but I think we have to consider our more progressive regime is not translating into healthier, happier kids.

BertieBotts · 20/09/2023 22:04

goodkidsmaadhouse · 20/09/2023 21:37

Good explanation Bertie. I’m in Scotland and haven’t seen this system in use for a few years now - as in literally during the past few years it has been largely phased out. Unfortunately even the positive only behaviour management systems can have similarly negative outcomes - a P1 boy told me today that he is a bad person because he never gets house tokens…

Yes, unfortunately, while the positive only ones are BETTER because they don't systematically label the children who can't fit into the system as "bad", they still have the same 2 main problems in that they don't look at why children aren't meeting behaviour expectations and they don't do anything to help children learn how or understand why to meet behavioural expectations. Plus, those systems can have their own issues if they end up getting used to try to counteract some of the issues, so children who are struggling get offered many more rewards/tokens for behaviours which are just expected, not rewarded in others - this can end up seeming unfair, and the children who are just in the middle, neither standout performance or "troublemakers" get overlooked and ignored.

I have heard good things about these (below) systems which have been used in schools. They work better for the kids who always end up on red, but apparently they ALSO tend to work well for the others too. Honestly I tend to think it's always a win if we're doing slightly better than the previous iteration, so non-violence is better than violence, unobtrusive punishment is better than outright humiliation, positive encouragement is better than punishment, and I agree with all the above points about the way that a system is being implemented being important too, but I do think these systems that look past behaviour are the best we have as of the current moment.

https://consciousdiscipline.com/

https://livesinthebalance.org/educators-schools/

https://zonesofregulation.com/for-your-school/

https://self-reg.ca/educators/

goodkidsmaadhouse · 20/09/2023 21:55

Startyabastard · 20/09/2023 21:49

It is heartbreaking to hear that a 5 year old thinks they are a bad person for not achieving as well.
That child was me also, but it was more my home life that cemented that.
We need to stop attaching academic outcomes to validation and worth. It has to change.

I completely agree. And one of my goals for this school year is to make sure this boy knows how brilliant he is.

Hotsaucegal · 20/09/2023 21:53

Agree that fear (of punishment/sanction) is unethical tool but it is tool that is applied almost universally for everything.

Startyabastard · 20/09/2023 21:52

saltinesandcoffeecups · 20/09/2023 19:37

Can I ask why you all think this is extreme? I fully concede I’m a dinosaur 🦕 and got a few names on the blackboard (yes in chalk) during my time in school at that age. I even got a few of the dreaded check marks after my name.

No it wasn’t a pleasant experience, but at the end of the day they disappeared and tomorrow was a new day.

It also allowed the the teacher to call out bad behavior without stopping class.

I was a pretty normal kid and I’d guess most of us got our name written a few times. Maybe it’s just me but it would seem that if a child has an extreme reaction to this there are other issues at play that are more detrimental in the long term than being called out for not following the rules on occasion.

The system worked for you as a person, though.
As it has been proved with what the OP has said, this child goes home and worries.
No need for that.

Startyabastard · 20/09/2023 21:49

goodkidsmaadhouse · 20/09/2023 21:37

Good explanation Bertie. I’m in Scotland and haven’t seen this system in use for a few years now - as in literally during the past few years it has been largely phased out. Unfortunately even the positive only behaviour management systems can have similarly negative outcomes - a P1 boy told me today that he is a bad person because he never gets house tokens…

It is heartbreaking to hear that a 5 year old thinks they are a bad person for not achieving as well.
That child was me also, but it was more my home life that cemented that.
We need to stop attaching academic outcomes to validation and worth. It has to change.

Whatt · 20/09/2023 21:47

I could never live in France.
You must conform or else. Look at religion and how people with SEN are treated and shunned.

Startyabastard · 20/09/2023 21:45

@BertieBotts that is one of the most intelligent things I've ever heard. Nice analysis!!

monsterflake · 20/09/2023 21:43

I might be missing the point but punishing a 5 year old for being late is ridiculous. It's not like they can get themselves into school or often even be able to tell the time and know they are late. Same with the speaking too loud, do they take into account children with hearing difficulties for example who can be loud without realising? I don't think it's a terrible idea in general, but only for behaviour a child of that age can reasonably control!

Startyabastard · 20/09/2023 21:42

I trained (and failed miserably) to be a teaching assistant and this exact analogy was used in a year one classroom around 5 years ago.
I don't know how I feel about it, but with regards to the OP's son's experience, controlling anyone, especially by fear is unethical.

goodkidsmaadhouse · 20/09/2023 21:37

Good explanation Bertie. I’m in Scotland and haven’t seen this system in use for a few years now - as in literally during the past few years it has been largely phased out. Unfortunately even the positive only behaviour management systems can have similarly negative outcomes - a P1 boy told me today that he is a bad person because he never gets house tokens…

BertieBotts · 20/09/2023 21:32

Can I ask why you all think this is extreme?...it wasn’t a pleasant experience, but at the end of the day they disappeared and tomorrow was a new day...I was a pretty normal kid

It's not generally an issue with typical kids and tends to work well, which is why it is so widely used. As you found, most children will experience getting the "red light" occasionally, see it as a warning, and go oops, never mind, and get a clean slate the next day.

The problem with it as a system in general is that in every class there will be at least one, probably a small number of children who are constantly on red/orange. It's not working for these children. The system that only punishes does not help teach them what it is that they are expected to do, and it does not look at why they are not meeting the behaviour expectation. They essentially never get a clean slate because they are on red/orange very early in the day and never move off it. They will then have one of two reactions to the chart - either they will stop caring about it because it is impossible to satisfy, which means it has no motivational power at all, or they will become very anxious about it. The anxiety then fuels the unwanted behaviour, which instantly gets them put on orange/red again, so they are trapped. These children are then more often than not, simply written off as "bad". Well the system works for the other children. Look, they are all coping with it fine and they are all on green most of the time. Why can't you do it Matthew?

I am not a (school) teacher and I don't have a better system to suggest. I understand why it is used widely, and it's definitely better than some other systems. But that is the main reason why it is not considered ideal in modern teaching.

AuxArmesCitoyens · 20/09/2023 20:54

Molly499 · 20/09/2023 20:39

Discipline in French schools is very, very strict. No talking, no moving, no messing, and silence in class. The teachers certainly don’t want independent thought so forget that straight away. Your son will get used to it, he will have to.

Not for five year olds. Is he GS or CP? Either way there will still be a lot of learning through play and shared activities though CP will have more formal structure than GS.

Molly499 · 20/09/2023 20:39

Discipline in French schools is very, very strict. No talking, no moving, no messing, and silence in class. The teachers certainly don’t want independent thought so forget that straight away. Your son will get used to it, he will have to.