Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to entertain my mum

142 replies

AlyssaHasAChaaaaild · 20/09/2023 15:04

Mum is 84 and really fit and active. She moved in with us 2 years when my dad died and on the whole the new family dynamic works well. There are now 6 adults in the house all on different schedules but it's a happy household and she likes the coming and going. The point of her moving in was so that she wouldn't be lonely and that's certainly worked well.

BUT she wants to go out and do more eg cinema, theatre, day trips etc. So far she hasn't done any of this because she doesn't want to go alone and she has no friends.

DH and I live quite separate lives where he goes out a bit with friends and for his hobbies, kids are regularly in and out, but I am a total homebody and rarely go out at all.

Mum has now announced that she wants to go out once a week and do something but she is expecting me to join her partly for her own benefit but also she says because it would do me good.

It's making me pretty fed up. I'm happy to have her here and she does whatever she pleases and we accommodate her. If she needs a lift or help then I always drop everything, and during the day we spend a lot of time together. I feel like I'm doing my bit. I don't want to go on these outings but am being guilt tripped that if I don't then maybe she won't go after all so it's my fault that she has a boring life.

Am I being selfish?

OP posts:
Laiste · 21/09/2023 09:57

It's perfect storm isn't it OP?

It's so easy (and glib) to say ''well let DH give up his job and swap with you then'', but real life isn't a soap opera or a comedy show and bills have to be paid and shaking up the whole family set up is not the answer.

I feel like your thoughts have moved on a bit from 'Must i take my mother out!?

Is there any wriggle room you can see in the family dynamic which would help? How much of you life are you happy with, how much of your life would you change if you could?

Is this outing thing literally the straw that's broken the camel, or is the camel basically ok but just wants to chose the straws for once?

If that elaborate metaphor makes sense?! 😂

Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · 21/09/2023 09:57

If you weren't there, what would happen?
It sounds like your family could sorely do with a reminder of the importance of your role(s). Can't DD1 and DD2 go and stay with their grandparents for 24 hours? And your DM spend some time with DC3?

EllasGuitar · 21/09/2023 09:50

I’m so sorry you DH doesn’t see any value in the respite you’d receive by doing something for yourself.
It’s so important for you to remain robust for your girls. Carer burn out is real and the costs are high. I feel for you OP

AlyssaHasAChaaaaild · 21/09/2023 09:45

So many responses, thank you, and a lot to think about. In response:

I'd love to just go away and leave everyone to it and enforce a break for myself but it's not possible. DD2 needs 24/7 care and as recruiting carers is so hard I have to be around often to fill in the gaps. DD1 doesn't receive formal care but has regular issues that need my help so again I can't just disappear.

DM can't help with the caring needs and tbh DH has not been involved in much childcare for the last 20 years and tends to make things worse.

At the heart of this is definitely the issue that nobody thinks I do much. Each person asks for a little of my time each day without seeing what everyone else asks so I'm frequently described as being at home all day and doing nothing. On the rare occasions when I try and point out what exactly I am doing I know that nobody believes me, it's so frustrating.

For 19 years until we got respite I didn't have an uninterrupted night sleep, but everyone would tease me for napping during the day.

I was never going to be a SAHM, just a short career break after DS and hopefully a second child..... but then everything changed with the girls' arrival and DH genuinely feels aggrieved that I gave up work and left him to support us financially. He openly says how lucky I am (he hates his job).

The added pinch here is that I suspect DH will resent me going out with mum and enjoying myself while he is at work.

OP posts:
whilingawaytime · 21/09/2023 09:37

Laiste · 21/09/2023 09:13

The mother is perfectly capable of joining some groups but doesn't want to and has said it's OP taking her out or nothing. So OP is being held to ransom over the mother's life outside the house as well as inside ! 🙄

OP is being asked to go out and pretend to enjoy it and that's yet another job on her shoulders.

All the posters saying OP should do this and should do that ... ''you NEED to be going out more'' ect ect - just putting on the pressure like the rest of the family.

Drawer the line and say no. OP.

Practice here with me ....... no, i don't want to mum, thank you. I'll happily drop you off to a weekly group or whatever, but i'm happy spending my spare time to myself.

I think people who say what you say are just imagining introverts (and I feel strongly that introverts' needs must be respected).

They have never really seen shut-in SAHMs with zero social/outside life. They must think it's like an exaggeration to say never leave the house but it happens – and then it's years and years and the person is totally burnt out and divorced from reality and any semblance of a life.

Of course I don't mean to scaremonger or anything but surely we can agree going out twice a year – even just once – if in the right mood isn't too bad a suggestion?

"In the right mood" is crucial of course. As I said, I understand that people (especially me) NEED Home Alone time. It's non negotiable. Absolutely the home alone time HAS to come first, and probably all the Giving/SAHM time has to be pruned somewhere (lots of suggestions given) before she even feels capable of stepping out her door. Though of course so much easier said than done.

Laiste · 21/09/2023 09:32

@CurlewKate i thought the same thing 😂

CurlewKate · 21/09/2023 09:24

@Laiste "Drawer? Draw!"

That's the first time I've seen it that way round. Respect! 🤣

Laiste · 21/09/2023 09:14

Drawer? Draw!

Laiste · 21/09/2023 09:13

The mother is perfectly capable of joining some groups but doesn't want to and has said it's OP taking her out or nothing. So OP is being held to ransom over the mother's life outside the house as well as inside ! 🙄

OP is being asked to go out and pretend to enjoy it and that's yet another job on her shoulders.

All the posters saying OP should do this and should do that ... ''you NEED to be going out more'' ect ect - just putting on the pressure like the rest of the family.

Drawer the line and say no. OP.

Practice here with me ....... no, i don't want to mum, thank you. I'll happily drop you off to a weekly group or whatever, but i'm happy spending my spare time to myself.

Proudmum17 · 21/09/2023 09:11

This is about you losing yourself in other's needs and having no time for yourself. I think your mum recognises this but is trying to get you to do the wrong activities. I'd sit Dh down and kids and your mum and say I'm taking this week off here. I'm going to a hotel with gardens possibly a spa a bunch of books and I'm having some quiet time. If care for the kids is needed then dh and your mum can do a share for a change. And make this regular say once every 6 months to start with.

Therealjudgejudy · 21/09/2023 09:01

Op you sound like a lovely person and everyone just takes this fro granted and so you are completley taken advantage of.

You need to look after you and be careful you dont burn out.

whilingawaytime · 21/09/2023 08:54

Also, this is a suggestion out of nowhere, but depending on severity of SEN, can your mum not help you literally a tiny bit with your SEN kids (or spend time with the non SEN kid)?

In small doses it might be win win: grandma gets positive socialisation from interacting with grandkids, you get downtime.

whilingawaytime · 21/09/2023 08:50

GreyBlackBay · 21/09/2023 00:44

Try to seperate 'mum wants company doing stuff' and 'people think I should get out more and I don't want to'.

The latter is your own business and they can all bugger off.

On the former I feel it'd be nice for you and others to make an effort if this is the only way she can get out and enjoy her remaining years. It isn't just on you though, adult dc can catch a show or have a meal out with gran too.

Brill suggestion to separate both but ah I had a different POV. I thought she should honour/pay heed to the latter, and not so much the former.

I really identify with the value of decompressing alone at home. OP should absolutely preserve this home downtime.

But everyone, even the most introvert of introverts, needs to get out of the house at some point – even if it's just 2x a year. Some socialisation during those few times a year would be great too – that can include just a nature walk with 1 other person, be it mum or a friend.

It's crucial and essential for wellbeing. People were not made to stay home with no friends/life for years on end. Being a total shut-in hermit SAHM is good for no one. As OP says, that's partially where her mum is coming from – out of concern for OP. As OP herself says, her mother would be perfectly happy to choose activities OP likes.

As for serving her mum's needs, IMHO that's just adding to OP's "giving" plate. Some sacrifice is always necessary, but I feel for it to be real mother-daughter time without resentment, OP needs to encourage her mother to get some of her needs met elsewhere. Then maybe 1x-2x a month together would be nice.

I also wonder about prioritisation. Don't want to pull the "guilt trip" card but my own family member died recently. Muddled priorities become stark and clear once someone is gone forever. Now I know for sure I would prioritise bonding time 1x a week with my own parent, over 3x weekly full days of chores for parents of my separated spouse. I wonder if it's possible to weigh and re-calibrate long term priorities in OP's weekly scheduling.

2chocolateoranges · 21/09/2023 08:41

You and your husband have separate lives, your mum, children and in laws take up your time, I understand why you want time to yourself.

id maybe have an outing with mum once a month and I’d be looking for a part time job, something for me to do and means dh has to help out with his parents rather than everyone presuming that you are there for their own benefits!

TrashedSofa · 21/09/2023 08:33

Xmasbaby11 · 20/09/2023 23:41

At first I thought Yabu but when you explained your life is so busy looking after other people and you don’t even have a job to escape to , I felt like you already do so much for others, it’s no wonder you can’t bring yourself to to add to your load.

and I feel like it’s not really about this one request but about you doing everything for your family. Cooking, cleaning and admin for everyone sounds soul destroying. Is it possible to make some changes so you aren’t the default person for everyone?

Completely agree.

SkippySkip · 21/09/2023 08:32

Well you could make DM responsible for the cleaning or tidying or whatever - you could insist that DH does stuff - but in the end you are causing more anger and stress for yourself as they won't do it wihtout you nagging/supervising being seen as selfish and lazy (after all you are home all day)
It's a difficult position as you still have to live with them all.

Perhaps get a job.

How is your pension anyway?

Then no one can have the same expectations of you and the friends and rellies won't nag.
Men with these 'long hours', 'demanding' jobs - my DH had one - much better fun than being at home juggling all the balls. But he was the one that got sympathy. I suspect it's the same with yours. Plus he has weekends to please himself.

pickledandpuzzled · 21/09/2023 08:22

AlyssaHasAChaaaaild · 21/09/2023 00:36

I hadn't thought of it like that, but yes I guess I feel like I'm about to snap and my mum is getting the short straw when she isn't actually the main problem.

My kids are 22, 20, 20 but two of them have SEN and I am responsible for with caring or organising the care so I'm still a very hands on mum.

I remember reading the Sue Townsend woman who went to bed for a year years ago and now I just imagine myself doing something similar. Walking off down the beach is equally appealing.

Go to bed for a week.

You can warn DH if you need to. But remove yourself.

Rexxxxxx · 21/09/2023 07:21

OP I think you should book a holiday alone for 7 days, Sunday to Saturday, leaving DH to take a week off and run the house himself. Go alone, somewhere restful and warm. You’ve probably never had a proper break and are clearly at breaking point burnt out or simply incredibly unhappy with lone parenting SEN kids while lone supporting elders. You need time to reflect and think about your own needs and what would make you feel enriched long term. Looking after your own well-being is essential and you clearly need to make changes in your day to day life.

Do you love DH, do you want to be with him? Does he know how you feel? How empty you feel, with little agency and time without responsibilities. Your first port of call is telling him just how unhappy you are.

It’s DHs responsibility to discuss getting a cleaner/cook with his parents. He should be the one saying you’re at breaking point. However you can tell them yourself, that you’re at breaking point with family responsibilities so will knock cleaning/cooking on the head, along with other responsibilities. A few weeks of no cleaning and no cooking hopefully they might employ someone, if it takes a while to realise they need to pay for help then so be it.

DH needs to take charge of the kids for half a day at the weekend.

all the adults in the house can do the weekly trip with granny, so it’s a rota and you’ll take your turn.

Alternatively make an agreement, you’ll go out with her monthly as long as she spends time with a distant relative or friend monthly. You can both do something which pushes you out of your comfort zone.

SkippySkip · 21/09/2023 07:08

I also want to say that taking DM to the cinema once a week isn't going to make her feel busy and happy - she wants you to be her entertainments manager and that won't be enough.

You need to be firm eg you will go once or max twice to WI/ Church group/ Book Club/ U3A (the best bet imv) with her then she is on her own.

mrssunshinexxx · 21/09/2023 07:03

I'm sorry I have to be that ' I wish I had this set up with my mum' I would kill to of had my mum til that age and to live with me how precious I wouldn't turn down these opportunities to make memories with her op

EllasGuitar · 21/09/2023 06:58

As a fellow carer I completely get you OP.
Your mum lives with you, you don’t have to be responsible for her social life. You spend plenty of time with her and fundamentally you are not responsible for her happiness.

You sound close to burn out to me. Do you get any respite? Im worried a show could top you over the edge (although I may be projecting here 😀)

CurlewKate · 21/09/2023 06:46

Are you sure she hasn't got a point? I THINK if I was your mum I might be a bit worried about you.

SkippySkip · 21/09/2023 06:37

I think it's also the complete lack of recognition by ANYONE that you are doing great for everyone around you except yourself.

I am trying to think of how to sort out your position.

Perhaps sit down DM and DH and explain - perhaps with a written list - how much you do, how much is expected of you, how little you get appreciated by anyone and that you are finding it all too much.

No doubt DM will have an extreme strop as to how she brought you up and you are not willing to do a little for her in her later years. (Personally I think you were nuts to let her move in).

DH will be annoyed he is actually having to involve himself in the rest of the family.

But then leave them to stew. And think about it.

I think you could also sit down the ILs and say that you are getting older and tireder (or whatever reason you choose) and can't do everything for them now and that DH will be taking over the 'little' jobs you do. That will also give THEM something to ponder.

Again let them stew.

After a week or so as them all who is going to do the things you are no longer going to take on.

You have been mr niceguy and Miss Hero for decades but you are entitled to decide you want change. You will no longer be mr niceguy or Miss Hero but so what.

Willmafrockfit · 21/09/2023 06:05

but why on earth doesnt your dm join groups? there are plenty

how about a compromise, you go with her, and she joins a club

Sylver75 · 21/09/2023 05:23

You need to do something to change how your life is. You'll burn out. If your kids are all in their 20s, can the one that doesn't have SEN not help out? The ones that do and I apologise cos I've no experience but are you going to be able to do this level of caring for them forever? Something's got to give.

Honestly, a trip to the cinema is one of the best forms of escapism I find, it could well do you the world of good if you tried it. Your home isn't just a home, it's where you're constantly working, caring and sorting other people's needs. Maybe your mum realises that it might be a release for you to step away from that environment occasionally. It would also mean your husband & kids would have to sort themselves out on those days, which needs to be done too. You can't be always on call or on hand for others, they need to be able to function without you too.