Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Brand supporters- do you feel the same now

58 replies

Whereforartthoudave · 20/09/2023 10:57

More details are emerging about his behaviour and history towards women?

YABU - makes no difference, the ‘establishment’ are out to get him.
this is trial by media of an innocent man

YANBU - supported him too early. It’s becoming clear that he is an abuser.

OP posts:
Discwriter · 20/09/2023 12:47

What @Lazyusername said.

gogomoto · 20/09/2023 12:41

Neither, I don't know him, I don't know the truth but I strongly feel that the police, cps and courts are the appropriate agencies to deal with criminal offences not dispatches, not newspaper columns. If he's committed an offence he should be prosecuted for his crimes, being promiscuous and dumping women isn't a crime so just the things that are.

All this media attention means any trial cannot be fair.

I support justice not trial by media

Lazyusername · 20/09/2023 12:33

I am not a Russell Brand follower or fan. However, @ManateeFair 's statement that, "He is NOWHERE NEAR influential or important enough for 'the establishment' to give a flying fuck about him." is clearly incorrect. A quick search online told me that, "Russell Brand’s YouTube channel has 6.58 million subscribers and 1.12 billion video views as of September 5, 2023." He has 30 million subscribers across various channels. From taking a look at his Youtube channel (which I wouldn't have done previously) it seems he posts videos on controversial subjects, some of them silly such as alien interventions and some which do interest me such as people being nudged into a cashless society. He also has a pop at various members of the establishment who I could imagine would not like this at all considering the level of reach that he has.

With regard to the accusations, I do think they could very likely be true. But I don't want to live in a society where the media decides to spend years preparing a "hit" on people, releasing sensationalised "teaser" adverts and hints and then displaying before us a group of actors reading dialogue from scripts acting as victims coupled with dramatic music and cherry-picked lines from decades of comedy performances. They over-egged the pudding as far as I am concerned and these women have now been dragged into the whole circus. Present the facts in a non-sensationalist manner and people are more likely to listen. There can never be any trial for Brand now as no untainted jury could be found; the media have seen to that. I don't want to live in that sort of witch-hunt society.

PleaseGiveMeBackMySummer · 20/09/2023 11:32

Nah, fuck him! He's been quite happy to spend the last 20 years as a very overprivileged, overpaid, not even particularly funny comedian - who's used lewd and grotesquely vile filthy humour for his career (blow job til she gags anyone!) And according to lots and lots of clips from T. V. over the last week or so - along with statements from a number of women, it has been confirmed he is a disgusting letch, a pervert, and a sex pest. And always has been.

He's made a lot of money and had a very good life with his 'brand' of 'humour' and has used the media and the public for his fame and his shows and his books and his wealth, etc etc .. So he can take the other side of it now. He can't just decide now that he doesn't want press and media intrusion because it doesn't suit him.

He is obviously a disgusting pervert - and more and more women are coming out and saying it. The thing is, I'm not completely shocked by it - and I can't believe anybody is. Hang him out to dry is what I say. I don't give a shit about him. He has had 20 years of wealth and fame, and used the media and public for it.. He can't just pick and choose his 'coverage' and exposure now. His career is finished now and I really don't give a fuck.

ManateeFair · 20/09/2023 11:31

The idea that 'the establishment' is somehow 'out to get' Russell Brand is so fucking ridiculous that I hardly know where to start.

He is NOWHERE NEAR influential or important enough for 'the establishment' to give a flying fuck about him. And for those saying it was a mainstream media plot against him, did you fail to notice that the mainstream media itself (the BBC, C4, the tabloid press) were also heavily criticised in the documentary as being complicit in, and even celebrating, his behaviour?

Anyone who thinks there is an establishment/MSM plot to take down that fucking clown is utterly deluded. He's basically the millennial Jimmy Savile, except he's been exposed while he's still alive rather than after his death.

Zimunya · 20/09/2023 11:14

Agree with @BIWI - no conspiracy at all - a little bit of justice is finally catching up with him, that's all. I never found his particular brand of humour amusing, but even if I had, I would certainly not be supporting him.

BIWI · 20/09/2023 11:11

Neither of those options. He's always been a complete and utter sleazeball.

Nobody is 'out to get him' - it's been a serious, painstaking investigation that has been compiling all the evidence to prove that he is an abuser and a rapist. There are no conspiracy stories here about MSM.

tonystarksrighthand · 20/09/2023 11:09

YABU