Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Brand supporters- do you feel the same now

58 replies

Whereforartthoudave · 20/09/2023 10:57

More details are emerging about his behaviour and history towards women?

YABU - makes no difference, the ‘establishment’ are out to get him.
this is trial by media of an innocent man

YANBU - supported him too early. It’s becoming clear that he is an abuser.

OP posts:
BIWI · 23/09/2023 12:38
Grin

I'd hate to think what you imagine a right wing agenda would be then

Pinkflamingopants · 23/09/2023 11:48

@BIWI there’s a very strong left wing agenda in the western world.

Seychal · 23/09/2023 09:10

I had never heard of him until the last few days. I vaguely remembered the Andrew (?) Sachs interview being on a Radio 4 news bulletin years ago, but could not recall the interviewers / pranksters names. But then I don't need SM or bother with celebrity stuff (like the majority of people).

When I saw his picture last week I thought it was Johnny Depp in the news again at first. Russell Brand may well have 6 million of followers, but given the world has 8 billion people now that is 0.0007%. Given most of those will not avidly follow him the influence he has gets very, very small.

I suspect he is a bright yet manipulative individual exploiting all his skills to feed his addictions. Bright enough perhaps to foresee what was coming and to attempt to cover his tracks by creating a persona in the conspiracy arena.

autumnmakesmehappy · 23/09/2023 08:56

gogomoto · 20/09/2023 12:41

Neither, I don't know him, I don't know the truth but I strongly feel that the police, cps and courts are the appropriate agencies to deal with criminal offences not dispatches, not newspaper columns. If he's committed an offence he should be prosecuted for his crimes, being promiscuous and dumping women isn't a crime so just the things that are.

All this media attention means any trial cannot be fair.

I support justice not trial by media

In an ideal world, no, the media would not be the place for victims of rape and sexual assault to seek justice. However, we need to remember that conviction rates for these types of offensives are extremely low. Often women will seek assistance from the police only told be there is not enough evidence or you waited too long. Maybe these women felt this was the only way they could be heard? We need a complete overhaul of the system when it comes to how the police and criminal justice system deals with these allegations. I wish we lived in a world where women felt they could seek police assistance, as soon as the assault has taken place, and that their allegations are always taken seriously. It is not just women this happens to, people who report that they were abused as children are often met with the same attitude of 'oh, how are we ever going to prove this?' Even if there was some underlying reason behind why these journalists made the decision to investigate these particular claims, it does not mean they are not true! Brand's whole attitude towards women in the past, as demonstrated through his idea of being funny, was deplorable. I do not want my son to grow up in a world where those sorts of attitudes towards women and sex are seen as acceptable.

BIWI · 23/09/2023 08:39

What left wing establishment would that be then, @Pinkbubblybits? You are aware that we are 'governed' (if you can call this shower of shit a government) by an increasingly right wing political party?

Pinkbubblybits · 23/09/2023 08:28

Suspect both. He was an abuser, which is common in his industry. He has spoken against the left wing establishment, lost their protection and they are put to get him.

FrancescaContini · 23/09/2023 08:22

Always found him repulsive, made my skin crawl even seeing his face and before he opened his filthy mouth. I had the same feeling about JS as a child but couldn’t have articulated why. The fact that the two had been in cahoots years ago discussing naked young women confirms my instincts.

I agree with the above comment re RB being the millennial JS, and although the accounts of his persistent misogyny and abuse and assaults are difficult to hear, I’m so glad that he’s being exposed and will hopefully have to answer countless difficult questions.

BitOutOfPractice · 23/09/2023 08:14

So even with all those followers @Lazyusername do you think he was so close to bringing down western capitalist society that the “authorities” have made this stuff up to silence him? Because they’ve done a bad job of that. I imagine more people have watched his output this week than the last five years put together.

DynamicK · 23/09/2023 08:08

It goes back to the seedy side of the industry as a whole. He was protected when it suited everyone and now being exposed, just like others in the entertainment industry. There are open secrets about so many of these sleazy characters. Once it comes out then it's 'oh everyone knew. It was all done out in the open'

I watched his channel occasionally. He focused a lot on the corruption of big corporations and government which was always interesting and seemed well researched by his team.
It's undeniable that the corruption exists. There seems to be nothing more important than creating wealth for corporations and their shareholders and that does get prioritised.

I always thought he came across as a sleaze and used to wonder how he got so many women as he always just looked bedraggled and on substances. I'm disgusted with all the sending cars to school stuff, if it's true and more disgusted that I've realised that it's just so normalised in the entertainment industry. From Saville to R Kelly, Schofield to Brand.
Just hideous.

ByTheSea · 23/09/2023 07:48

PleaseGiveMeBackMySummer · 20/09/2023 11:32

Nah, fuck him! He's been quite happy to spend the last 20 years as a very overprivileged, overpaid, not even particularly funny comedian - who's used lewd and grotesquely vile filthy humour for his career (blow job til she gags anyone!) And according to lots and lots of clips from T. V. over the last week or so - along with statements from a number of women, it has been confirmed he is a disgusting letch, a pervert, and a sex pest. And always has been.

He's made a lot of money and had a very good life with his 'brand' of 'humour' and has used the media and the public for his fame and his shows and his books and his wealth, etc etc .. So he can take the other side of it now. He can't just decide now that he doesn't want press and media intrusion because it doesn't suit him.

He is obviously a disgusting pervert - and more and more women are coming out and saying it. The thing is, I'm not completely shocked by it - and I can't believe anybody is. Hang him out to dry is what I say. I don't give a shit about him. He has had 20 years of wealth and fame, and used the media and public for it.. He can't just pick and choose his 'coverage' and exposure now. His career is finished now and I really don't give a fuck.

Exactly!

kweeble · 23/09/2023 07:47

People couldn’t speak out for fear of being sued for slander and not being able to work again. So it was right for there to be a media investigation so these allegations could be made.
However it undermines the premise that the establishment are not out to get him when the Chair of a government committee immediately writes to Rumble to ask them to withdraw his access to earnings. It really is an own goal.

DinnaeFashYersel · 23/09/2023 07:37

I'd love to live in a world where women could get justice in court.

But that world doesn't exist so at least he's getting his comeuppance another way.

It's not as painful as the experience he caused his victims

Zimunya · 23/09/2023 07:29

PleaseGiveMeBackMySummer · 20/09/2023 12:53

As I said, there's nothing wrong with 'trial by media' when it's somebody that's made an illustrious career and millions of £££ out of using the media to make it happen. As I said, you can't just pick and choose when you get media intrusion.

And there is SO much evidence that Russell brand is an absolute hideous pervert and a sex pest. These women aren't fucking lying. Hmm

You use the media for your fame and your wealth and to be an overprivileged overpaid rich man, then you can take the shitty side of it as well. Them intruding on things you don't want them to intrude into is something you have to accept.. You don't get to pick and choose. He doesn't have that right. The media have every right to do what they're doing.

Agree.

Pinkflamingopants · 23/09/2023 07:27

@ManateeFair he has been a hugely influencial voice over the past few years. He has a massive podcast, YouTube channel and does tours. He has been one of the biggest anti establishment voices there is. His career didn’t die when he stopped comedy.

in answer to your question OP, I didn’t want to believe it when the stories first came out. I have enjoyed listening his stance on many things - Covid, climate change, Epstein flight logs etc, not that I’ve necessarily agreed with everything he said, but unlike the lefties I enjoy listening to all sides of the argument and don’t think anyone should be shut down for going against the grain. However, some of the stories have been very very telling. I had a friend who slept with RB when she was young (she has never indicated it was non consensual), and the circumstances she mentioned were very similar to one of the stories told in the press, where he essentially hunted down a young school girl and sent a car to her school to pick her up (my friend was older but he did send a car to her, a very long distance too) which told me it’s not a pack of lies by the media.

There is too much evidence weighted against him and he should be locked up for a very long time.

Coyoacan · 23/09/2023 06:34

I am not a Russell Brand follower or fan. However, @ManateeFair 's statement that, "He is NOWHERE NEAR influential or important enough for 'the establishment' to give a flying fuck about him." is clearly incorrect.

This. I don't watch Russell Brand and haven't watched or read the exposés, because I still think things should go through the courts but if the establishment do not want to get him, why did the Chair of the Culture, Media and Sport Committee try to shut down his source of earnings?

I'm disgusted that a member of the government has so little faith in the rule of law in the UK that they are trying to circumvent it.

Sarahzb · 23/09/2023 01:14

Don't want to see his awful lying sexist face again. Ek it's everywhere.

Henryhunter · 22/09/2023 20:43

The so called right wing press exposing him thank goodness hopefully this oily moron is finished. He hated the right wing and the left protected him. Just as they did Savil until a Tory pm could be blamed. Islington survivors. Nurses and doctors threatened by NHS management and the unions to protect labour from an NHS scandal in the seventies. When there is money to be made silence is the answer.

AnxiousPangolin · 20/09/2023 21:41

YABU for starting yet another thread about him.

Whereforartthoudave · 20/09/2023 21:31

‘I strongly feel that the police, cps and courts are the appropriate agencies to deal with criminal offences not dispatches, not newspaper columns.’

and if they police can’t be trusted, don’t give a damn, or don’t have evidence ? Investigative journalism may just have got the police the evidence they need

OP posts:
HappiestSleeping · 20/09/2023 17:16

PleaseGiveMeBackMySummer · 20/09/2023 11:32

Nah, fuck him! He's been quite happy to spend the last 20 years as a very overprivileged, overpaid, not even particularly funny comedian - who's used lewd and grotesquely vile filthy humour for his career (blow job til she gags anyone!) And according to lots and lots of clips from T. V. over the last week or so - along with statements from a number of women, it has been confirmed he is a disgusting letch, a pervert, and a sex pest. And always has been.

He's made a lot of money and had a very good life with his 'brand' of 'humour' and has used the media and the public for his fame and his shows and his books and his wealth, etc etc .. So he can take the other side of it now. He can't just decide now that he doesn't want press and media intrusion because it doesn't suit him.

He is obviously a disgusting pervert - and more and more women are coming out and saying it. The thing is, I'm not completely shocked by it - and I can't believe anybody is. Hang him out to dry is what I say. I don't give a shit about him. He has had 20 years of wealth and fame, and used the media and public for it.. He can't just pick and choose his 'coverage' and exposure now. His career is finished now and I really don't give a fuck.

Hopefully, he ends up inside, with a big cell mate called "Mary" experiencing the other side of that blow job till he gags. I hope it makes his mascara run too.

x2boys · 20/09/2023 14:55

Russell.Brand has always been controversial and a sleaze ball.,were there ever many supporters for him?
He's hardly Jimmy Saville,who.was seen by many as St Jim,and national.treasure .

BIWI · 20/09/2023 14:48

@gogomoto

I strongly feel that the police, cps and courts are the appropriate agencies to deal with criminal offences not dispatches, not newspaper columns. If he's committed an offence he should be prosecuted for his crimes, being promiscuous and dumping women isn't a crime so just the things that are

But the whole point of the investigation was that nobody in a position of power (be that his media bosses or the police) was doing anything about him even though his behaviour was widely known. And the women he assaulted and/or coerced were frightened to come forwards, because they were accusing someone more famous than them - and because they were worried that they wouldn't be believed (at best), and (at worst) that they might lose their jobs.

So it takes a long, serious investigation by respected journalists and newspapers to gather all the evidence together, so that the police can take things forward, and that any women involved are more confident about telling their stories.

The police are investigating it now (as are the BBC and other organisations that Brand was part of/employed by), so this builds a case whereby he can be dealt with on a legal basis.

Oh, and if you think this whole affair is just about him being promiscuous and dumping women, you are both naive and deluded.

londonrach · 20/09/2023 12:54

Neither. I always thought he strange and can't understand why he some called.popular.

PleaseGiveMeBackMySummer · 20/09/2023 12:53

gogomoto · 20/09/2023 12:41

Neither, I don't know him, I don't know the truth but I strongly feel that the police, cps and courts are the appropriate agencies to deal with criminal offences not dispatches, not newspaper columns. If he's committed an offence he should be prosecuted for his crimes, being promiscuous and dumping women isn't a crime so just the things that are.

All this media attention means any trial cannot be fair.

I support justice not trial by media

As I said, there's nothing wrong with 'trial by media' when it's somebody that's made an illustrious career and millions of £££ out of using the media to make it happen. As I said, you can't just pick and choose when you get media intrusion.

And there is SO much evidence that Russell brand is an absolute hideous pervert and a sex pest. These women aren't fucking lying. Hmm

You use the media for your fame and your wealth and to be an overprivileged overpaid rich man, then you can take the shitty side of it as well. Them intruding on things you don't want them to intrude into is something you have to accept.. You don't get to pick and choose. He doesn't have that right. The media have every right to do what they're doing.

Whereforartthoudave · 20/09/2023 12:47

To be clear - always thought he was a misogynistic pig. And am not in the least bit surprised to hear he is a rapist.
i’m genuinely baffled by his supporters, particularly women. Why on earth they would think any one cares about ‘silencing’ him in the first place is a mystery to me.
No-one other than his YouTube accolades give a shit about his hippy, dippy conspiracy theory nonsense.

OP posts: