Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

I still fancy RB

656 replies

WesterChick · 19/09/2023 23:16

I've watched the documentary.

I still fancy RB.

I identify as a radical feminist.

I'm married with kids.

I think that if you are a heterosexual woman, you are either in denial on what men are or you accept what they are but find them irresistibly sexually attractive and so continue to be with them.

RB is simply what the vast majority of men would be like if they could get away with it.

Therefore - and because he's bloody good looking, funny and intelligent - and sexy - I will continue to fancy the pants off him.

I think women who are being all shocked and descusted at his behaviour need to consider what men are actually like. There's not some massive demarcation between him and other men.

OP posts:
LlynTegid · 20/09/2023 17:00

There are women who find Boris Johnson attractive. I view them as having low self-esteem.

I hope you get better soon OP. Liking Russell Brand is like defending the Krays because they were kind to their mother, it does not take away any evil.

Gifgirl · 20/09/2023 16:52

If one of my friends said something like this, I might suggest that they speak to a psychiatrist..

TheHoover · 20/09/2023 16:47

*Thicklegs · Today 07:48

Hi OP

In your fantasy of him, does he treat you better than he has other women? Are you the one that makes him see women differently? Or does he use you or rape you like he has others? Just want to understand the mindset. *

V good question. Especially as RB’s modus operandi was to try and make the woman he was with that night feel like they were oh so special, that all the other girls were just meaningless screws, that they may in fact be the one he has been searching for all his life….

Whatafustercluck · 20/09/2023 16:38

I've been in a few consensual relationships in my time, and had some flings and one night stands. I'm not sure whether you attract the wrong kind of men, but I can verify that from my own experience, and that of my female friends' perspectives, no, the majority of men are not like RB. And I'm a feminist, too, and can see all kinds of wrong in the world. My dh, my dad, my ds and my male friends are all equally, and genuinely, horrified. You just have a very warped taste in men.

LoobyDop · 20/09/2023 16:30

bemorebernard · 20/09/2023 16:21

Loopy you only had "an ideal" though because you knew of the previous accusation and then put it together with your own experience.

If you'd never been privy to that allegation would you have still had "an idea"? Be honest.

It’s impossible to tell, isn’t it. Any view I formed would always be based on hindsight, however hard I tried to ignore it. I’ll admit that while I was with him I made excuses for things I would now class as red flags. How conscious I was that I was doing that at the time. I don’t know.

Litmus1001 · 20/09/2023 16:26

I have always found him unattractive to look at and mediocre at best in terms of talent. His stunts were often also in bad taste. His 'new age' reinvention escaped me until recently, although I was aware he'd (apparently) overcome sex and drug addiction. Regardless of what he looks like, past 'stunts' or personas, and claim of rape needs to be taken seriously and properly investigated. For what it's worth I imagine some women (and men) found him very attractive in the past, and still do (some maybe more so because they feel sorry for him too).

bemorebernard · 20/09/2023 16:23

We need to start teaching children about consent from a young age . Both sexes . Only when people actually understand the concept of true and informed consent will this change .

bemorebernard · 20/09/2023 16:21

Loopy you only had "an ideal" though because you knew of the previous accusation and then put it together with your own experience.

If you'd never been privy to that allegation would you have still had "an idea"? Be honest.

sunglassesonthetable · 20/09/2023 16:20

People fancy what they fancy . I don't berate the op . And fame / prestige/ fortune make men more attractive to some women .

Don't think I've berated her.

Don't share her world view though or her taste in men.

And my brain affects my sexual preferences.

LoobyDop · 20/09/2023 16:18

bemorebernard · 20/09/2023 15:38

People go on to have relationships, marry men In cat 4 because even the perpetrators wouldn't view themselves in terms of having committed a rape . Someone fancies these men , someone marries them , often in blissful ignorance.

There will be people within your own social circles that you would never believe or know have committed rape .

Statistically it's a fact . Do you think Brands friends and family actually KNEW he had raped . . ? Or do you think they thought he was promiscuous and playing the field ?

I think you can have an idea. I had an ex who had been accused of rape as a teenager. It had been an extremely distressing experience for him- his parents were told, the police spoke to him, etc. He was absolutely adamant that she had consented, and she eventually withdrew the allegation. And when I was with him, I believed this and would have said so. He never raped me, or tried to.

But. He did pester for sex, and sulk when he didn’t get it. He was entirely focused on the injustice of the false accusation, and in general on his own needs and feelings, not anyone else’s. With hindsight, actually I do believe that he could have raped her. He’s not a bad man or a violent man. He’s just utterly self-centred and was never taught that the world doesn’t revolve around him. Everyone who knows him would recognise that description. They’d just be very reluctant to follow it to its natural conclusion. I’m entirely prepared to believe that there are as many men like that as there are the genuinely decent ones.

bemorebernard · 20/09/2023 16:18

I'm not having a go sunglassess but yes it's clear many women do not understand the psychology around rape and rapists .

And that's fine if you've never had to .

I didn't tell anyone about my rape . I then told one colleague and swore her to secrecy. I was embarrassed. How could I let that happen to me ? And that's also a thing . Victim guilt .

I felt I should have known better. I also
tend to go for unconventional men - so I do understand the ops frame of reference. It's so easy to say "how could you not know " when it's become public .

bemorebernard · 20/09/2023 16:12

There will be men who are perceived as sleazy and promiscuous who absolutely understand consent .

There are also men who appear wholesome and right on who don't .

People fancy what they fancy . I don't berate the op . And fame / prestige/ fortune make men more attractive to some women .

sunglassesonthetable · 20/09/2023 16:11

That is a complete misnomer . You are simply perpetuating the myths around rape .

I don't want to perpetuate any myths around rape.

I clearly have not done any in depth research into the subject nor liaised with any eminent psychologists in discussion.

Regardless , I don't agree with OP that "all men are" essentially not much different from RB. No. And plenty on here have echoed that view.

And in direct ref to OP, even if RB was my type, I would not still fancy him knowing what he was capable of. I find that puzzling in the extreme, among other things.

I question what this OP is all about tbh. I think it's very look at me and doesn't do anyone any favours especially as OP isn't discussing her point.

@bemorebernard

MooseBreath · 20/09/2023 15:49

I'm heterosexual and definitely not attracted to RB. Wasn't before all of this came out. He is incredibly pretentious and looks like he's riddled with STDs. No thank you.

bemorebernard · 20/09/2023 15:47

Lets put it like this if they were race horses I know which ones I'd put a bet on.

That is a complete misnomer . You are simply perpetuating the myths around rape .

sunglassesonthetable · 20/09/2023 15:42

'our world views'

sunglassesonthetable · 20/09/2023 15:41

Your personal experience of a man is not everyone else's . I'm. It a man hater. I enjoyed being married. I enjoy sex . But my eyes are open .

Totally agree my personal is not everyone else's. That's what I said to OP , our works view's are different.

I'm sure the eminent psychologist knows their stuff but I do not view every man as a rapist, given the chance.

Let's put it like this if they were race horses I know which ones I'd put a bet on.

But OP potentially knows RB is a rapist ( still to be confirmed ) or at the very least predatory and abusive . That's what I'm interested in really.

He does come with that 'neon sign'.

bemorebernard · 20/09/2023 15:38

People go on to have relationships, marry men In cat 4 because even the perpetrators wouldn't view themselves in terms of having committed a rape . Someone fancies these men , someone marries them , often in blissful ignorance.

There will be people within your own social circles that you would never believe or know have committed rape .

Statistically it's a fact . Do you think Brands friends and family actually KNEW he had raped . . ? Or do you think they thought he was promiscuous and playing the field ?

bemorebernard · 20/09/2023 15:33

Sorry loopy there are in fact 4 categories not 5. I had to go and refer to my notes from the rape masterclass delivered by rape crisis.

I think ALL women and men should have that input and ALL police forces and CPS should have it .

bemorebernard · 20/09/2023 15:30

sunglassesonthetable · 20/09/2023 15:23

But none of you women or men here know anyone capable ? Oh I bet you do . You just don't know it because they don't know it.

And is that category ALL men?

In context , yes - because you do not know who is in category 4 . Remember that men in that category Do NOT see themselves as rapists and as Brand has done here , deny and refute .

Statistically rape is a very easy crime to get away with.

So now , from my own experience of being raped , and through my work, I would view all men with a penis capable of potentially raping a woman .

Of course there are kind, gentle good men who understand consent.

But there is no way of knowing who they are. I'm sure RB wife would say she does not recognise her husband as a rapist . He has not done it to her .

He has apparently done it to others .

Your personal experience of a man is not everyone else's . I'm. It a man hater. I enjoyed being married. I enjoy sex . But my eyes are open .

LoobyDop · 20/09/2023 15:26

bemorebernard · 20/09/2023 15:21

And before anyone points it out I. Ow that's 4 categories. My point remains .

What is the 5th kind, just out of interest?

sunglassesonthetable · 20/09/2023 15:23

But none of you women or men here know anyone capable ? Oh I bet you do . You just don't know it because they don't know it.

And is that category ALL men?

bemorebernard · 20/09/2023 15:21

And before anyone points it out I. Ow that's 4 categories. My point remains .

bemorebernard · 20/09/2023 15:20

sunglassesonthetable · 20/09/2023 14:30

The idea that attraction is something purely physiological and involuntary is something I reject as it is far more complex than that. If it wasn't we wouldn't have scores of women on here talking about the "ick" caused by their partner's behaviours and opinions.

This. 👏🏼

And equally that " all men would do it, if they could get away with it " and simple slaves to their biology.

That's not what people are saying

The facts is most men who HAVE committed sexual assault or rape don't even see themselves as having done it

I've worked professionally with rape crisis . The largest category of rapist is the compensatory rapist , and they do NOT see themselves as rapists

The five categories are :
1/ the sadistic rapist - the likes of Fred west
2/ the angry rapist - often a frenzied attack , eg, Yorkshire ripper
3/ the opportunistic rapist - will use violence as a way of getting g sex but don't get off on the violence itself and will blame the victim

4/ the compensatory rapist what I'm talking about * they never use violence ,a d the most difficult to investigate. They are complex and clever . The DO NOT think they are rapists . They have distorted thinking and tell the,selves women like it, no means yes really, believe that women think they should be mind readers , and will normalise their behaviour. The CpS will often say there is not enough evidence.

This all came from an eminent psychologist I worked with who worked for rape crisis

They are by far the largest category of men who rape and will NEVER frame themselves as being rapists .

But none of you women or men here know anyone capable ? Oh I bet you do . You just don't know it because they don't know it.

Naunet · 20/09/2023 14:59

harryslife · 20/09/2023 14:56

Oh wind you neck in if you cannot handle a father on MN, its a fact all rapists are men by the very legal definition of rape. 🙄

What the fuck?!! Literally no need for an attitude.