Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are teacher messaging apps reasonable?

232 replies

Elendel · 19/09/2023 19:01

I am a teacher in a secondary school.

I started in a new place a few months back. In this place, parents have an app on which they, and students, can message us 24/7 and we are expected to reply as soon as possible, but latest within 24h. The app filters out swearing, but other than that it can be a free-for-all.

I do not have time to respond within a typical school day as I am either teaching, in a meeting or on duty, and with briefings as well, responding to parents either falls within the 15min lunch I get (unpaid) or outside of those hours. Time is fully directed between 8.15 and 4.30 each day and PPA is the absolute minimum school can get away with.

Messages arrive any time between midnight (some students messaging at 1am!) and midnight again, but parents most often message after work (understandably) and will expect us to have responded by mid-day. Some are messages about reasons why homework isn't done, some are asking me about what happened in other subjects, yet others are to challenge detentions given.

Is this level of communication acceptable? It just feels like I'm never off work, because I spend a considerable amount of time responding to the messages of the 1200 students and their parents on top of doing my actual day job to keep up with communication demands.

YABU - get on with it, it's your job

YANBU - that's ridiculous

OP posts:
Carlessly · 20/09/2023 08:45

I can see how people think that their important email should really be answered ‘within one working day’. But actually, when/how do you expect the teacher to do this?

Depends on the interpretation of "important"
doesn't it! The only time I've expected (and received) an answer within a couple of hours was when some boys threatened to beat up DD. Another mum complains regularly to me that the teacher never answers her - but she regularly sends messages about stuff I would class as trivial and tell DD to ask the next day in class.

JussathoB · 20/09/2023 08:36

I can see how people think that their important email should really be answered ‘within one working day’. But actually, when/how do you expect the teacher to do this? The teacher spends their whole day in a class with usually 30 children and cannot reply to emails because they are teaching!
Equally it’s no go getting a big queue of emails to answer to … when would that happen- weekends? Middle of the night?
In the past children went to school without their parents having to constantly communicate on an individual basis with parents and deal with their demands which seem to be growing and growing over the years.

EightChalk · 20/09/2023 08:31

My parents really cared about my education, and I don't think they ever contacted my secondary school. They got reports and went to parents' evening and that was it. Same with my friends. I wonder why parents' expectations have changed so much over the past couple of decades, and why teachers are having to pander to them.

Danascully2 · 20/09/2023 08:25

It wouldn't bother me that people message at random times but the volume and the timeframe to reply would be impractical.

Stimpend · 20/09/2023 08:20

The reply window is ridiculous. Our schools both tell us not to expect answers speedily or out of hours.

I do think the problem is the school's expectations though, rather than parents emailing at 8pm. Emails should be able to be sent at the sender's convenience to be picked up at the recipient's, and recipients should be able to control the influx with do not disturb etc.

towriteyoumustlive · 20/09/2023 08:10

Elendel · 20/09/2023 04:25

There are currently 15 people who have voted that IABU.

I'm interested in those views, too - why is this okay?

Everyone else, yes, I am seriously looking into just working my minimum term here and leave. I am working in a big shortage subject, albeit in a TLR role.

In my school (academy) we have a rebellious group that fights against ridiculous apps like this!

Clearly messages need to be answered but the 24 hour time rule is crazy. I would tell the senior team that it is not feasible, you will check the messages once a day and respond to urgent ones.

I have a y7 tutor group and the parents seem more needy than the kids. I just give them a polite but firm message saying "as per school rules a forgotten PE kit is a detention unfortunately" etc...

I actually get some lovely parent thank you messages too!

AuditAngel · 20/09/2023 07:57

DC3 is in year 8. At our secondary the individual teachers are emailed directly for specific queries, but absence reported via app. I am amazed at the times some of the teachers respond to emails. I tend to email either before school, or during my working hours, but get replies at 10pm. When do these teachers get down time?

Carlessly · 20/09/2023 07:49

My youngest is still at primary. We are provided with the teachers' mobile numbers (although this year as DC has two class teachers it is a school mobile which gets left in the classroom) so we can contact if we have any issues to to e.g. register absences.

DC1 has just started secondary and after half term they are introducing an app. At the moment we have the class teachers mobile and email and have an office number (primary doesn't have this) to register absences. We have been asked not to send messages over private mobile once the app comes into use.

I would have thought an app was preferable?

Can you not use your screen time settings to silence it between 9pm and 7am or whenever suits you? It's not unreasonable to send a message to a teacher once your child has come home from school and you from work and told you of an issue. If it's urgent then I don't think it's unreasonable to expect an answer within one working day. If it's not urgent I'd expect a couple of days before I got an answer.

sakura06 · 20/09/2023 07:32

YANBU. Get out. Get out as soon as you can. We're not paid anywhere near enough to put up with being 'on call' 24 hours a day. Disgusting.

donquixotedelamancha · 20/09/2023 07:23

Time is fully directed between 8.15 and 4.30 each day

You must be waaay over the directed time budget.

Speak to your union. Stop doing the things that aren't part of your job. Look for another post asap.

crumblingschools · 20/09/2023 07:21

Tell parents to contact HT!

Boomboom22 · 20/09/2023 07:17

Most academies do follow the burgundy book, move schools. Slt culture shapes schools more than anything else.

fortheloveofjamdoughnuts · 20/09/2023 07:13

That's how to have a mental breakdown.

benoticanarsed · 20/09/2023 07:08

Dds school typically reply to emails within 3-4 days but mainly they don't bother at all.

This seems a bit daft.

DutchCowgirl · 20/09/2023 07:06

i’m not in the UK. Our school has such an app to message teachers (among other functions). Before Covid it was normal for parents to walk into the class on drop off and tell the teacher things like “our little Julia is upset because the dog died” and there would be an actual queue each morning at the teachers desk with parents. And we all considered this normal back in the days.

During Covid-years parents were not allowed in school so we got this app. And we could message the teacher instead op speaking to them at dropoff. Our teachers really liked the change, they don’t want to start their day with all the parents at their desk. Messages you can choose to read later, do a quick scan… real fysical people are harder to send away.
Some of the teachers of my sons respond immediately up until midnight. That seems unhealthy to me … but some do a quick short reply at 8 am the next day and that’s fine! Sometimes the teacher initiates contact like “Your son lost his jacket and we cannot find it in school, can you help us with it” and i reply as soon as i can (but also not immediately). But within 24h is ok I think, teacher took the effort to send me this message So it is polite to reply in time and not ignore her.

Newbutoldfather · 20/09/2023 07:03

I think @Rexxxxxx and @witmum have given some excellent advice.

I have to be honest, having worked in both the corporate world and in teaching, that teachers are very ‘obedient’ and SLT (being mostly ex teachers) manage their staff a bit like managing a classroom, totally inappropriate for the people they deem to be ‘senior professionals’.

The reality is that a lot of rules can be broken, particularly if you are a good teacher of a scarcity subject. They are hardly going to start a disciplinary for you replying to a non-urgent e mail in 48 hours! You need to follow your own professional advice here. So, very urgent e mails (health, safety, absence etc) are acted upon immediately, sensible queries within 72 hours (say) and pointless queries are ignored or replied to once, stating that you won’t be fielding this kind of enquiry again.

I would also bring up the App next time your school have a tick-box ‘well being’ inset and the Head says how important it is to him…..

Soontobe60 · 20/09/2023 06:22

Maddy70 · 19/09/2023 19:20

Every single one I've worked In. Its so much additional pressure

I’ve never worked in a school with these ridiculous expectations, and none of my teacher friends have.

witmum · 20/09/2023 06:15

I think you need to put the boundary in place and communicate it.

HOD I will only respond to queries between 8:30 and 5pm any messages that can not be responded to in the time will be left to the next day.

Parents/ pupils: leave it a month for your tutor group to settle . Then send out an FAQ sheet on who to contact when. e.g. lost planner go to the school office who hold lost property. Make parents aware of the amount of messages you are receiving and that the expectation in year 7 is that the pupil will be accountable.

If you do have a union then you are on a personal contract to negotiate the terms.

VeloVixen · 20/09/2023 05:56

It’s also setting the students up for unrealistic expectations in later life which does them no favours. I’m a uni lecturer, we have a five working day email answering policy.

VeloVixen · 20/09/2023 05:55

Insane, I’d definitely be job hunting.

could a little revolution be organised? All staff agree (quietly) to only answer stuff in your 8-4:30 contact time hours. If you don’t have time to answer stuff it waits till the next day, or the day after, or the day after. Head might go bonkers initially but realistically what can they do if every staff member sticks to this?

Clymene · 20/09/2023 05:19

I'd look for another job. It sounds horrendous.

Elendel · 20/09/2023 05:15

The contract only specifies the time we need to be at the academy, then has the standard "plus whatever time necessary to fulfil the role" kind of wording.

It has since been made clear, in a different context, that, as an academy, they didn't need to stick to anything in the Burgundy Book.

OP posts:
echt · 20/09/2023 05:09

Elendel · 20/09/2023 04:19

As an academy they don't have to stick to directed hours as described in the Burgundy Book.

There must be a contract of some kind. Worth looking at what it says.

Rexxxxxx · 20/09/2023 04:52

I had a job in which I’d be inundated with communication 24/7. I can recommend being much slower to respond to low urgency communication as people will often utilise other more efficient means of gaining information (website or whatever). A traffic light system might help, so red (respond in 24 hours Monday to Friday) for urgent reply’s (anything that involves important health issues or police or safeguarding), amber for medium importance communication (respond in 72 hours) and green (almost pointless emails) 7 days. Also send out standard info to everyone, so all parents receive extra curricula provision info reminder with who to contact directly.

Britneyfan · 20/09/2023 04:32

This sounds amazing as a parent but a nightmare for the teachers! My son’s school uses Google classrooms and he can message his teachers on there, they are quite good at responding quickly on there but don’t think there is any set expectation about timeframe for reply there. If I want to contact his teachers about something I call them or send an email and it would have to be fairly important to bother!