Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this just sums up XL Bully owners?

717 replies

Ozarkz · 19/09/2023 16:15

Look North last night. Peter Levy is interviewing a woman who owns two XL Bullys. Both cropped and docked which she says happened in another country before she got them (yeah, course it did).

Peter asks her “so why do people want these dogs in the first place, what’s the attraction for you?”

She replies “well I wanted dogs that were good with kids and famines and stuff so we got XL Bully’s cos they’re great with kids”

Wtf? If I didn’t know better I’d swear this was a spoof interview. Good with kids and families?? These dogs have been responsible for the most human deaths in dog attacks in the UK in recent years!!! Just last week an 11 year CHILD was attacked by one of these dogs … so when looking for a child friendly dog she bypasses the golden retriever etc and goes for the breed with the biggest track record of killing humans …

He then asked her if she will comply with the muzzle when the laws are changed - she said NO.

Then the cherry on the cake … he asked her “would you leave your child alone with these dogs?” And she said “yes, absolutely. I leave my two year old alone with them all the time whilst I’m busy making dinner etc”

Honestly the interview couldn’t have been any more gobsmacking.

This just sums up XL bully owners doesn’t it? Thick as pig shit with no regard to their own safety or the safety of others.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
40
ehupo7 · 21/09/2023 17:26

RawOnions · 21/09/2023 17:23

What a gross comment. Shame on you.

well I think the point of the comparison is to highlight what an uncaring, bleak (and ill-informed) comment @Boomboom22 made

RawOnions · 21/09/2023 17:23

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 21/09/2023 12:40

once a dog has been neglected or ill treated it is far too late.

@Boomboom22 same as children in foster care then.

What a gross comment. Shame on you.

Boomboom22 · 21/09/2023 16:19

This is exactly the sort of crap dog owners come out with. Honestly. If you can't see the difference there is no hope!

Boomboom22 · 21/09/2023 16:16

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 21/09/2023 12:40

once a dog has been neglected or ill treated it is far too late.

@Boomboom22 same as children in foster care then.

You are sick
How can you compare kids to dogs.

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 21/09/2023 12:40

once a dog has been neglected or ill treated it is far too late.

@Boomboom22 same as children in foster care then.

SomeCatFromJapan · 21/09/2023 10:55

To be fair to staffies (proper, small staffies that meet the breed standard), they've been bred to have suitable pet temperaments for a very long time now, since dog-fighting was made illegal in the UK.

I think unfortunately they are crossed or backyard-bred for people that want something other than a nice pet.

oldwhyno · 21/09/2023 10:40

There are no legitimately good reasons to own one of these dogs rather than any one of the many safer breeds out there. Whatever wonderful characteristic people think they see in an XL Bully can be found in other dogs without the unnecessary risk. XL Their strength and aggression are exactly why people buy them, even if they're not honest enough to admit it.

anunlikelyseahorse · 21/09/2023 10:24

humanity15 spot on with you post, you can no more train out instinct, which is hard wired into the psyche, than I can train myself to stop fidgeting! I'm a terrible fidget, despite having numerous punishments for fidgeting in school.
There are numerous breeds which are hard wired to guard or fight. Some breeds you can train to guard and take a person down with only minimal injury eg Alsatians. Most 'shepherding' breeds, only make suitable family dogs with proper training. Growing up on a farm we had working collies. Awesome dogs, very intelligent, very responsive, but they aren't cuddly, fluffy pets, these are serious working dogs, which need to be out in the field for several hours.
Collies are hard wired to 'nip', this is so an errant flock member 'gets back into the fold', as a result sometimes you'll find a collie from working stock will still nip, if a member of the flock (human flock) is out of line. The difference between a 'nip' and proper aggressive bite is huge.... but it's absolutely not okay for any dog to bite or nip, but my point is all dogs have different instincts.
There is a very good reason why; spaniels make excellent customs dogs; Alsatians make excellent police/ shepherding dogs; collies make very good herding dogs, retrievers make the best guide dogs; Newfoundland's, St.Bernard's and Pyrenees mountain dogs all make excellent mountain rescue dogs. Jack Russells are very hard to train to get 100% recall, their instinct is to get on the trail of wildlife and hunt it down, but with good training they can make excellent family pets; And many bull breeds (staffies, pits, xl,) were all specifically bred for fighting, it would take years, and years of breeding to breed out that instinct. Bull breeds are also extremely energetic and like the collies I grew up with, need to be out walking / running for several hours a day. They aren't designed to live in cooped up conditions with only an hour or two of exercise.

BardRelic · 21/09/2023 10:00

you are totally missing the point its not about what damage the lab would do in comparison to the bully its about the fact that without that video showing that the bully was totally under control and was being jumped on and his face bitten and was virtually under attack then he would have been blamed if the lab was killed or injured, not the out of control lab because of his size and breed he would have automatically been seen as the aggressor.

Oh I get your point @Oldsu I just disagree with it. I'm also trying to explain to you why the bully will be the one that gets put down, and not necessarily the lab. It's as people have tried to explain, repeatedly. Bull dog breeds are very powerful and launch sustained attacks. Therefore, they will be treated differently from other dog breeds. From what you've said, the lab attacked the bully but the bully didn't react and was unharmed. But even you have admitted that the bully was capable of killing or injuring the lab - something that wouldn't have happened the other way around. That's why people are more worried about bull breeds than they are about labradors.

And when you think about it, if legislation was properly drawn up, it would benefit all breeds. If it concentrated on responsible ownership, training and breeding of all dogs, then all dogs would be better off. I've seen attacks similar to the one @BellaAndDave described, but between two equally matched dogs. They are absolutely horrific to witness. I won't go into details but they really are stomach churning. So yes, I'll be far more wary around these big, powerful breeds.

Dillane · 21/09/2023 09:37

Iheartpizza · 20/09/2023 13:41

This website gives the total number of fatalities in the USA. Over 700.

God knows how many more tens of thousands of incidents there have been, involving non fatal (but very serious) incidents including people and other animals.

I'm reading each case individually (about 200 so far) and an alarming proportion of those fatalities were killed by their own dogs, believing that it's all in how they are raised. No bad dogs, just owners.....

www.fatalpitbullattacks.com/

By August 1896, Sacramento enacted a pit "bulldog" ordinance. The dogs are known as savage. Also, there is a public call to ban pit "bulldogs" in the City of Chicago after a series of attacks

As far back as 1896 these dogs were known to be lethal. Shocking that these beasts are still in existence.

1896 Breed-Specific Pit Bull Law - Sacramento

As early as 1896, the City of Sacramento had a breed-specific pit bull law due to the extreme dangerousness of pit bulls.

https://www.fatalpitbullattacks.com/blog/2012/05/1896-breed-specific-pit-bull-law-sacramento/

Bluesky85 · 21/09/2023 09:36

Any dog can bite. But there’s a big difference between a single bite out of fear, pain or surprise, and a sustained attack. They are two completely different responses. The former is probably quite common, the second is possibly more breed dependent for dogs that are bred to attack/ fight/ kill.

ToBrieOrNotToBrieThatIsTheQuestion · 21/09/2023 09:19

BabyStopCryin · 21/09/2023 08:12

Our jack russel once bit my niece when she stepped on her tail - nasty bite too.

Any dog can bite. They are like people - even the most placid will ‘have an off day’ and act ‘out of character’. I’d rather that was a small dog you could fend off that a hulking big animal with a jaw that can wrap around your head.

Any dog can bite (and most will if you step on their tail), but a smaller dog will inflict less damage, more slowly.

Any human can punch, but I'd sooner be punched by a 5 year old than by Tyson Fury.

Dillane · 21/09/2023 09:07

Boomboom22 · 20/09/2023 23:25

Everyone needs to write to their mp about taking this further. And quite possibly complain to the charity commission, every one of the dog charities is a disgrace. Any dog that bites at all should be pts immediately, no matter the reason, certainly not advertised to families and rehomed. Rescues shouldn't really be a thing, once a dog has been neglected or ill treated it is far too late.

Rescues shouldn't really be a thing, once a dog has been neglected or ill treated it is far too late.-

What a ridiculous overarching statement.

ehupo7 · 21/09/2023 08:56

BabyStopCryin · 21/09/2023 08:12

Our jack russel once bit my niece when she stepped on her tail - nasty bite too.

Any dog can bite. They are like people - even the most placid will ‘have an off day’ and act ‘out of character’. I’d rather that was a small dog you could fend off that a hulking big animal with a jaw that can wrap around your head.

100% this

Our small dog is sweet, gentle and obedient as anything, but one time my sister gave her a kiss on the head while she was sleeping, and she instinctively started and bit her cheek.

Was immediately submissive afterwards, but the situation was so much easier to handle (and the bite so much less serious) as she is such a small dog.

People with bigger dogs who say ‘oh XX would never bite’ just demonstrate they don’t know what they’re talking about – any dog could react unexpectedly. It’s not personal, it’s something you have to be aware of.

I honestly don’t understand why people feel the need to have any big dog, and don’t think anyone should have a dog they couldn’t physically overpower if it attacked.

BabyStopCryin · 21/09/2023 08:12

Our jack russel once bit my niece when she stepped on her tail - nasty bite too.

Any dog can bite. They are like people - even the most placid will ‘have an off day’ and act ‘out of character’. I’d rather that was a small dog you could fend off that a hulking big animal with a jaw that can wrap around your head.

Diamondcurtains · 21/09/2023 07:57

I have two small dogs. My old bichon is temperamental and would never be rehomed. She was 7 weeks old when we got her. Was told she was 8 weeks. Looking back it was clearly a puppy farm. I moved her food bowl that first day we got her and she bit me. Even With lots of training and a behaviour specialist she still growls (she’s 10 now) if you move her food. She’s never bitten since but there’s absolutely no way I would have left her alone with the children when they were small. 99% of the time she’s absolutely lovely but I’m still wary of her around other people .

Boomboom22 · 21/09/2023 07:35

@Oldsu if that is true that charity should be shut down. Trying to get around the law for what, to keep people homeless as they will not be eligible to be housed with a dog. Lawyers who are deliberately evil, nice.

MotherofGorgons · 21/09/2023 07:16

@BellaAndDave The more you post the more I am horrified by your experience. You don't need to defend your actions or thinking. I wouldn't feel any remorse either at drowning this dog. I only wish the owners were punished.

Oldsu · 21/09/2023 01:47

BellaAndDave · 21/09/2023 00:13

Please read my post I made earlier. My lab was killed by an XL Bully. DH is a vet and refused to treat these dogs for years even before the attack. I trust his judgement. Have I met unpredictable breeds before? Of course I have. I’ve seen so many breeds in the surgery over 25 years and watched vet nurses and vets having to deal with peoples “babies”.

The day my dog was killed I have never seen a dog wagging its tail and throwing a 30kg lab about like a rag doll! Am I angry? Yes I am, I have children and grandchildren, I’m just glad my grandchildren weren’t there that morning. I know a dog isn’t like a child but that dog (the one that was rag dolled, the one that had its back broken and the one that had internal injuries so bad he could be saved) was a life line for me. He was my epilepsy medical assistance dog.

DH was bitten when he smacked it with a fence post over and over again but the thing just kept going, all the time wagging its tail. I won’t lie, he drowned it in the end. It came down to him or the dog… Do I have any remorse for the way that dog died? Absolutely not. As for the owners they can rot in hell for all I care.

@BellaAndDave So I can understand why you think that way of course I can, I feel the same way about the husky who attacked one of my Pugs who lost an eye in the encounter, it took two large men to get the husky away from my pug while the stupid owner just stood there, I was bitten myself, yet sorry I don't think all husky owners should rot in hell.

I also respect your husbands decision but of course I do know that many vets will treat bully types, I also know that a well respected charity who supports homeless and vulnerable people and their dogs (of all breeds and types ) are working out how to ensure these dogs meet legal requirements (once it is known what it will be) the same as well respected law firms who specialise in dog law are extending their support for owners of suspected xl bully types, just as I know that some dog charities and law firms will step away from the types. Just because some professionals like your husband have one view does not mean nor should it that others in the same professions will have the same mindset.

SkiingIsHeaven · 21/09/2023 01:03

It's a shame you can't neuter the owners too.

Iheartpizza · 21/09/2023 00:42

MrTiddlesTheCat · 20/09/2023 21:23

Just seen that bully xl owners in Birmingham are organising a big bully meet, encouraging everyone to bring their bully xls all together to show everyone how gentle they are. 'Bring as many kids as possible' they encourage.

They really are quite insane.

Anyone from this thread planning to go?!

TorqueWrench · 21/09/2023 00:19

Something needs to be done as they're defo over represented in attacks. However, what's interesting is that most experts seem to have a very different view to the posters on here and seem to believe it's poor training, which I can believe as chavs love them.

Either way, the end result is the same so something needs to happen.

BellaAndDave · 21/09/2023 00:13

Oldsu · 20/09/2023 18:29

@BardRelic you are totally missing the point its not about what damage the lab would do in comparison to the bully its about the fact that without that video showing that the bully was totally under control and was being jumped on and his face bitten and was virtually under attack then he would have been blamed if the lab was killed or injured, not the out of control lab because of his size and breed he would have automatically been seen as the aggressor. No lab would have been taken away by the police, no lab would have been tasered or shot in that scenario but the bully would certainly have run the risk of one or the other.

Please read my post I made earlier. My lab was killed by an XL Bully. DH is a vet and refused to treat these dogs for years even before the attack. I trust his judgement. Have I met unpredictable breeds before? Of course I have. I’ve seen so many breeds in the surgery over 25 years and watched vet nurses and vets having to deal with peoples “babies”.

The day my dog was killed I have never seen a dog wagging its tail and throwing a 30kg lab about like a rag doll! Am I angry? Yes I am, I have children and grandchildren, I’m just glad my grandchildren weren’t there that morning. I know a dog isn’t like a child but that dog (the one that was rag dolled, the one that had its back broken and the one that had internal injuries so bad he could be saved) was a life line for me. He was my epilepsy medical assistance dog.

DH was bitten when he smacked it with a fence post over and over again but the thing just kept going, all the time wagging its tail. I won’t lie, he drowned it in the end. It came down to him or the dog… Do I have any remorse for the way that dog died? Absolutely not. As for the owners they can rot in hell for all I care.

montysma1 · 21/09/2023 00:00

If you have one of these as your pet, you are indeed thick as shit. Regardless of how many degrees you have.

sandyhappypeople · 20/09/2023 23:45

Boomboom22 · 20/09/2023 23:25

Everyone needs to write to their mp about taking this further. And quite possibly complain to the charity commission, every one of the dog charities is a disgrace. Any dog that bites at all should be pts immediately, no matter the reason, certainly not advertised to families and rehomed. Rescues shouldn't really be a thing, once a dog has been neglected or ill treated it is far too late.

once a dog has been neglected or ill treated it is far too late.

That's really sad, and not necessarily true. People can be horrendous to dogs, there are so many dogs out there that have been terribly mistreated and never shown an ounce of aggression, they deserve a second chance.

My old boy was taken back to the RSPCA twice before I had him, it was last chance saloon, he was quite a big dog, quite stubborn to start off with before he settled in, he was a fluffy greyhound cross but no kidding he was the BEST dog, never showed any aggression to people, kids or other dogs, it just didn't seem to be in his nature, he was super chill and went everywhere with me, I had him for 14 years, he would have been PTS if I hadn't have given him a chance.

Swipe left for the next trending thread