Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this just sums up XL Bully owners?

717 replies

Ozarkz · 19/09/2023 16:15

Look North last night. Peter Levy is interviewing a woman who owns two XL Bullys. Both cropped and docked which she says happened in another country before she got them (yeah, course it did).

Peter asks her “so why do people want these dogs in the first place, what’s the attraction for you?”

She replies “well I wanted dogs that were good with kids and famines and stuff so we got XL Bully’s cos they’re great with kids”

Wtf? If I didn’t know better I’d swear this was a spoof interview. Good with kids and families?? These dogs have been responsible for the most human deaths in dog attacks in the UK in recent years!!! Just last week an 11 year CHILD was attacked by one of these dogs … so when looking for a child friendly dog she bypasses the golden retriever etc and goes for the breed with the biggest track record of killing humans …

He then asked her if she will comply with the muzzle when the laws are changed - she said NO.

Then the cherry on the cake … he asked her “would you leave your child alone with these dogs?” And she said “yes, absolutely. I leave my two year old alone with them all the time whilst I’m busy making dinner etc”

Honestly the interview couldn’t have been any more gobsmacking.

This just sums up XL bully owners doesn’t it? Thick as pig shit with no regard to their own safety or the safety of others.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
40
Ozarkz · 19/09/2023 18:05

GoryBory · 19/09/2023 18:01

OP how can you judge someone for getting an XL bully when you have a Doberman.

A Doberman has a similar bite force as an American pit bull.
And they’re obviously very strong and powerful.

This is why they were seen as status dogs and used as guard dogs to scare people off.

Obviously now they’ve gone out of fashion you don’t hear of how dangerous they are any more.

Less people are attacked/killed by them, not because they’ve changed their temperament or bite force but because they’re not seen as cool and therefore not as many idiots are getting them.

I actually love Dobermans and XL bullies but many people my age and older would judge you in exactly the same way walking a Doberman as if you were an XL bully.

Again, even when Dobermanns were at the height of popularity- deaths by them were extremely rare. A Dobermann is not bread to fight. It is bred to guard, but not fight. Big difference.

OP posts:
vitahelp · 19/09/2023 18:04

Put me up against the aggressive collie any day over one of these massive things. Might as well go for a stroll in a lion enclosure, don’t stand a chance if they turn.

Twistedex · 19/09/2023 18:04

Ozarkz · 19/09/2023 17:35

At the end of the day we need tough laws on dog breeding and dog ownership. All breeders must be licensed with clear documentation on what traits the dogs are being bred for. Example - I know a Dobermann breeder who is working towards eradicating DCM from the breed - this comes secondary to temperament of course, reducing prey drive whilst also maintaining the breeds desire to work.

Secondly - owners. License for all dog owners with applications to own a dog with clear documentation on why you want a certain breed and what that dog’s life will look like - Example -

“I want a Dobermann as I’m looking for an intelligent working dog I can work with in obedience trials (insert potential trainer with credentials). I have x y and z experience and can provide 3 character references”

This is an extreme example but this is the ideal way forward.

Now imagine the XL bully version of this scenario …

“I’m breeding for the following traits … errr … I want them as big as possible and errr … good at guarding and ummm … built like a brick shit house … “

“I want to own an XL bully because … errr … they make me look well ‘ard”

I mean come on … what possible reason would you want an xl bully

Look at that, you very nearly came up with a sensible, well thought out post.

Just let yourself down at the end, there.

Carouselfish · 19/09/2023 18:04

What about a law saying you can't own a dog you aren't physically strong enough to hang onto?

I mean, there are some soppy lions out there who are bonded with humans. Still no good having one on a lead down the park.

PoliticallyIncorrectHitchling · 19/09/2023 18:03

Twistedex · 19/09/2023 16:19

Yes, that's right, because every single XL Bully owner must be exactly the same 🙄

Don't be so bloody offensive and ignorant.

I find your statement offensive and ignorant

EeesandWhizz · 19/09/2023 18:02

GoryBory · 19/09/2023 17:14

Collies are responsible for loads of bites and are one of those breeds that are not for first time owners because without proper training they can easily turn aggressive.

They can be sharp and they can bite, but how many people have been killed by collies? Genuine question - there's loads of collies and collie crosses around, but I don't recall them ever being in the press for killing anyone, or for savagely attacking and killing other dogs.

ttcat37 · 19/09/2023 18:02

BelindaBears · 19/09/2023 17:54

So long as they latch on to some other breed that I’m capable of fighting off should it attack me or my child I don’t give a shit. It is the breed because that’s the point - people can’t fight these fuckers off.

Yeh I completely get what you’re saying. My point is that from birth, these dogs were all capable of being normal, functioning, non violent dogs that don’t kill people. But their breed characteristics in combination with the types of people who generally (and that is a generalisation- not all) want these dogs make them sadly more liable to be in this situation.
I don’t object to the measures being put in place, it’s safer for everyone and the dogs.

nopenotplaying · 19/09/2023 18:01

@Ozarkz she is our third. Rehomed as the previous owners 'had no time' she is the best dog ever. But strong and needs some lead education. She runs all day on our farm. I'm a professional, no face tattoos 🤣

The person that had her before us also had XL bullies. Pics of newborn baby sat with the dog on the sofa. She'd bred litters from our girl and then handed her off. No vaccines. No chip. She's in her forever home now.

She is a strong dog. I put a harness on and a collar so she has double leads. I won't ever let her off the lead. She runs free at home. I would be happy to put a muzzle on her if told to on walks but it would make me sad not to see her enjoying the sights and sounds.

She is due to be spayed soon as she does not need to have any more babies and I don't want them falling into the wrong hands or passed around. That's the risk.

Carouselfish · 19/09/2023 18:01

Tiny little woman at my dog training had a rhodesian ridgeback, up to her armpit. Ruined the class as it was prone to barking madly at the other dogs and she couldn't hold it. Why would she own that breed? Same with xl bullies. They don't just want a soppy dog. There is some weird power motive at play.
Agree, thick as pigshit move when it comes to understanding the role genetics play in dog behaviour or even what a dog IS. Accountant colleague may be good at maths but doesn't make him smart about dogs.

GoryBory · 19/09/2023 18:01

OP how can you judge someone for getting an XL bully when you have a Doberman.

A Doberman has a similar bite force as an American pit bull.
And they’re obviously very strong and powerful.

This is why they were seen as status dogs and used as guard dogs to scare people off.

Obviously now they’ve gone out of fashion you don’t hear of how dangerous they are any more.

Less people are attacked/killed by them, not because they’ve changed their temperament or bite force but because they’re not seen as cool and therefore not as many idiots are getting them.

I actually love Dobermans and XL bullies but many people my age and older would judge you in exactly the same way walking a Doberman as if you were an XL bully.

Iheartpizza · 19/09/2023 18:00

The short version - she's a simpleton.

Presil · 19/09/2023 18:00

VeloVixen · 19/09/2023 17:51

It’s because Peter Levy is a goady fucker.

Aw, I like him. His Wikipedia page seems to regularly get japed though - references to him being a keen collector of vintage underwear and that he has dated Carol Vorderman etc. It currently says that he likes bodysurfing.

theemmadilemma · 19/09/2023 18:00

@WillowCraft I could, but without the dogs they'd still be in house looking for them.

Though I accept that most dogs are a good deterrent.

I'm not denying the breed have a terrible name due to a certain type of owner. But it's sad imo, because with the right owners they are wonderful dogs. I know at least 6 other middle age professional women who own a similar breed and all of them responsible.

People are overlooking that every dog that has achieved this status previously, just as now is the 'it' dog fir a certain type of person who then create the issue with their behaviour.

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 19/09/2023 18:00

Gribbit987 · 19/09/2023 17:35

These types of dogs and staffies have always been heavily represented in rescues as those with less structured/secure lifestyles are attracted to them. “Decent” people regularly end up owning them.

I’ve fostered them before and it’s as simple as I’m a fosterer who takes the dog that needs fostering. They’ve all been placid docile lumps.

It’s ridiculous to write off an entire sub set of dogs due to a handful of idiot owners. These people will always be attracted to dogs that can be weaponised.

You should never leave any breed of dog alone with a child.

This person isn’t very bright. As such you would expect her to have some rather idiotic ideas. She will have made a lifetime of stupid decisions because she isn’t like you. She probably hasn’t had anything like your upbringing or opportunities. Sneering at those who clearly don’t know any better is pointless. Her view isn’t respected or valued in the real world so who cares what she is spouting.

It’s more concerning that you feel you are intelligent and yet are perpetuating this nonsense that certain dog types are dangerous and there are no “decent” owners of what is a very gentle breed in general.

Retrievers are notorious for biting and often have quite a high intensity disposition. Bull breeds tend not to. But obviously if abused - be that lack of exercise/stimulation/socialisation/positive training - their behaviour can be dangerous. Like any dog.

Good article with scientific research on the pointlessness of banning them:

https://amp.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/sep/11/banning-some-dog-breeds-in-the-uk-wont-stop-attacks-on-humans

Best and most intelligent and accurate comment on this thread.

MrsMarzetti · 19/09/2023 17:59

ColonelRhubarbBikini · 19/09/2023 16:24

She shouldn’t be responsible for a hamster let alone a very powerful dog breed.

I never ever left my kids alone with my dog. Meant I didn’t have an unsupervised piss for years but thems the breaks when you get a dog. The dog used to enjoy me reading out the shampoo bottle to him anyway Grin

She shouldn't be responsible for a child yet we allow such lowlifes to breed.

mbosnz · 19/09/2023 17:59

I work at a vets, in an 'interesting' area, and I see a lot of XL bully's, as well as every other breed.

I see owners who definitely perpetuate the stereotype in the OP. I see owners who do not relate to this stereotype at all.

Of all the dogs I have to be wary of, when they are brought in (and some we are instructed NOT to go out from behind the counter because the dog is so reactive and aggressive) I genuinely cannot think of one of our XL bully's who is like this. We have some that have to be given sedation before they come in, and wear a muzzle - we have that across the board for all breeds - from chihuahuas up.

The ones that are most reactive with other dogs are not the XL bully's.

They are extremely powerful dogs, and if they go off, it is not going to be pretty. I get that. I get frustrated with owners who have dogs they can barely maintain control of when the dog is calm - it's ridiculous. I see so many with labradors, german shepherds, Viszlas, etc, like this. And yes, XL bully's. But somehow, far less of the XL bully's, who tend to be some of the more placid of the bunch!

Anyway, I know this isn't going to make any difference, or change anyone's mind. But I do hate to see good dogs, and good owners (and there are good XL bully's, and good XL bully owners), demonised.

SomeCatFromJapan · 19/09/2023 17:58

It’s usually children, often babies.
I assume they think it’s some sort of animal.

I've just checked the UK stats and it's hardly the regular occurence you describe. One case with just a Jack Russell, one in conjuction with a Staffie and one a Jack Russell cross. Last incident was 2012.

SnowyPetals · 19/09/2023 17:57

Yep, the breed is being banned because they attract irresponsible owners who keep them in inappropriate environments. Not all, but a lot. The responsible owners can choose from all the hundreds of breeds that aren't banned.

rwalker · 19/09/2023 17:57

Twistedex · 19/09/2023 16:19

Yes, that's right, because every single XL Bully owner must be exactly the same 🙄

Don't be so bloody offensive and ignorant.

Let’s just compromise at the vast majority

NotQuiteHere · 19/09/2023 17:57

Greenshake · 19/09/2023 16:47

That’s totally untrue. Why don’t you read what Twistedex has just written?

Did Twistedex give the reason why to have this breed though?

She wrote:
"They're also extremely intelligent, loving dogs who are eager to please and easy to train if you put the time and effort in that you should put into owning any dog"
This could be said about many other breeds, why choose XL Bully? Because her friends had "accidental" litter?

People always say that their dog is trained and will never hurt anybody. They are of course wrong, nobody cannot reliably predict an animal's behaviour, so the owners must be ready to restrain their dog but it is hardly physically possible with breeds like that.

MrTiddlesTheCat · 19/09/2023 17:56

GoryBory · 19/09/2023 17:49

It’s usually children, often babies.
I assume they think it’s some sort of animal.

I’m surprised you’ve never heard of this. I can think of at least 3/4 separate cases of infants being killed by jack Russells.

That's surprising seeing as according to the Office of National Statistics there have only been 2 deaths by Jack Russells in the last 50 years.

Twistedex · 19/09/2023 17:55

But you know that not all bullies have cropped tails and ears, right? So that doesn't really fit with this theory that ALL XL owners are as thick as pig shit and common as muck.

BeignetPommes · 19/09/2023 17:55

Yes, they are all the same. No decent person of sound mind would WANT one of these dogs

Completely agree.

SomeCatFromJapan · 19/09/2023 17:55

Has someone reallybeen killed by a Jack Russell? Have to say, that would be an extraordinary bit of bad luck, did they trip up over it and bang their head?

It was a baby, sadly. But that's about all it would manage realistically and would have been prevented with appropriate supervision.

Appleass · 19/09/2023 17:54

You absolute ignorant *. I would get banned from here if I could respond to you how you deserve!