Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this just sums up XL Bully owners?

717 replies

Ozarkz · 19/09/2023 16:15

Look North last night. Peter Levy is interviewing a woman who owns two XL Bullys. Both cropped and docked which she says happened in another country before she got them (yeah, course it did).

Peter asks her “so why do people want these dogs in the first place, what’s the attraction for you?”

She replies “well I wanted dogs that were good with kids and famines and stuff so we got XL Bully’s cos they’re great with kids”

Wtf? If I didn’t know better I’d swear this was a spoof interview. Good with kids and families?? These dogs have been responsible for the most human deaths in dog attacks in the UK in recent years!!! Just last week an 11 year CHILD was attacked by one of these dogs … so when looking for a child friendly dog she bypasses the golden retriever etc and goes for the breed with the biggest track record of killing humans …

He then asked her if she will comply with the muzzle when the laws are changed - she said NO.

Then the cherry on the cake … he asked her “would you leave your child alone with these dogs?” And she said “yes, absolutely. I leave my two year old alone with them all the time whilst I’m busy making dinner etc”

Honestly the interview couldn’t have been any more gobsmacking.

This just sums up XL bully owners doesn’t it? Thick as pig shit with no regard to their own safety or the safety of others.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
40
SemperIdem · 20/09/2023 23:33

@Boomboom22 rescuing a dog when you have children is extremely difficult because the people who run them tend to be very knowledgeable about dog behaviour and therefore suitability. They are strict and correctly so.

A large number of dogs in rescue homes are not there because of bite incidents but because of owner deaths or ignorance over exercise/health needs.

Boomboom22 · 20/09/2023 23:25

Everyone needs to write to their mp about taking this further. And quite possibly complain to the charity commission, every one of the dog charities is a disgrace. Any dog that bites at all should be pts immediately, no matter the reason, certainly not advertised to families and rehomed. Rescues shouldn't really be a thing, once a dog has been neglected or ill treated it is far too late.

PandoraRocks · 20/09/2023 23:21

Unfortunately, most of the stereotypes of Bully owners are true. This morning I was in a cafe when a young woman walked in. Tattoos all around her neck and an obvious 'trout pout'. Loads of makeup. Chav personified. She recognised a bloke and they both began slagging off the Bully ban and trotting out 'it's the owner not the dog' myth. Both Bully owners.
I wouldn't like to see a woman in her 20s like her trying to control one of these monsters.

humanity15 · 20/09/2023 23:14

*Due to it being a matter of public interest in terms of safety, I'm sharing the following.

People do not fully understand dogs, that is the problem.

Not just owners but many dog trainers, behaviourists and especially the major rescue charities.

The information the major rescue charities are giving out to the public is so dangerous.

Their "All Dogs Bite" and "Deed Not Breed" messages are totally irresponsible.

For the past few years myself along with a number of others have been trying to raise awareness of dangerous dogs.

I have also been campaigning to get better protection for those who work in the animal rescue secture and also for whistleblowers who I think few are yet to realise the importance of.

The dog control coalition which includes Dogs Trust, RSPCA, Blue Cross and Battersea are calling for Breed Specific Legislation to be dropped from the dangerous dogs act.

This would allow not just XL-Bully dogs to be legally owned here but all the dangerous dog breeds currently banned.

These charities which are meant to care about animal welfare have shown very little concern for all the innocent pets that have been brutally killed recently by other dogs. Most have been killed by the same types of dogs which they want to see made legal here.

Totally innocent people are being severely injured and killed in the most horrific ways, yet these charities continue to campaign for allowing these dogs to remain on our streets.

Dogs Trust have kept their own record on safety from the public, despite the public being the ones who fund them.

Dogs Trust have purposely withheld dangerous dog assessments from staff.

Failed to tell their staff dogs they were working with had injured other staff.

Failed to legally report under RIDDOR.

So many have been injured whilst working for this charity, some very seriously.

There is a video about Dogs Trust on youtube to raise public awareness as they have failed to be open with the public.

Places like Dogs Trust are the ones decision makers are listening to about dangerous dogs.

What everyone needs to know isn't just that all dogs bite.
People need to understand the different reasons why dogs bite and the true threat they pose.

A dog communicates using body language.
For instance if a stranger comes to close and the dog feels uncomfortable it may cower, growl, air snap etc.
If those warnings are ignored it may resort to biting.

Once it has been successful in communicating the dog will stop, so when the stranger backs away.

This is TOTALLY different to a dog that has a strong drive to fight.

Please research the term GAMENESS in relation to fighting dogs, it will explain alot.

All dogs have inherited characteristics. Certain ones are stronger in certain breeds depending on what they were originally bred for.

A breed originally bred for fighting will have a drive to do just that.
How strong that drive in an individual dog depends on what has been passed down through its lineage.

This means unlike a fearful dog it isn't going to snap if a stranger gets too close and stop when that person moves away.

It isn't going to give a quick bite if its in pain and you try and touch where it hurts.

What it means is a dog bred to fight and one which has a strong desire to do just that will not stop until its opponent is no more.

It knows the most vulnerable parts on another which is why you see so many injuries around the neck area.

It will often bite down and not let go.

It will completely ignore another dogs appeasement signals and continue to attack.

It will fight to the death.

These dogs are NOT like other dogs.

This is what makes them so dangerous.

They do not need to be trained to do this as they have a natural instinct for this already.

No amount of good will is going to change that.

This is your starting point before any external influences.

If you have a dog with a strong desire to fight you could be in serious trouble.

Having been bred to fight to the death, they will not stop even when they have suffered serious injuries to themselves.

They have an incredibly high pain threshold.

This is why such a statement as All Dogs Bite without proper explanation is so dangerous.

When it takes sometimes five people or tazers to get a dog off someone that is serious.

It doesn't mind how many cute pictures you take of the dog or how affectionate it is.

It doesn't matter how good a dog trainer or behaviourist anyone is there is only so much anyone can do to try and suppress a dogs natural instincts.

That desire will always be there, in certain circumstances that natural instinct will come out.

A good dog trainer or behaviourist will recognise this.
Many are starting to refuse to work with certain dogs because of the danger to themselves and because they know there is nothing they can really do, these dogs will always pose a serious threat.

Just because the dog hasn't shown that side of it pleae do not presume it is not there.
Many owners have only realised the true danger when it is too late.

With certain types of dogs instead of breeding this drive out the opposite is being done. The drive to fight is being bred into them on purpose.

In many XL-Bully dogs ones that showed people aggression were bred from.
With a small gene pool used it was almost guaranteed this would be passed down to their offspring.

The result is what we are now seeing on our streets.

This is not the dogs fault, they are totally innocent.

They are not good or bad they just are.

A dog that wants to bring you something is not bad because it was bred to retrieve.

A dog that wants to fight is not bad because it was bred to fight.

Just because we see one instinct as acceptable and one not is not the dogs fault.

We are the ones who have brought both these dogs into our homes and labelled them as pets.

This is what people are not being told but to keep everyone safe it is what everyone must know.

Animal charities, if they really care about dogs need to seriously look at all those being injured and killed by other dogs.

They need to look at why most of their shelters are full with only certain breeds.

They need to educate the public on different breeds of dogs and be honest around them.
The demand for certain breeds would drop and less dogs would be bred as a result.

If they really cared about dogs, that is what they would do.

People also need to look at what is in the interests of the dog.
Are certain breeds suitable in a home environment as pets and out on the streets with people and other dogs.

If the answer is no then putting them in that environment where you are asking them to completely suppress their natural instinct 100% of the time is probably going to lead to them ending up in a shelter or being put to sleep.

No dog lover wants to see that.

Increase Safety Standards for People Working with Rescue Dogs

https://youtu.be/mHREm4pO-CI?feature=shared

SemperIdem · 20/09/2023 22:59

@TorqueWrench of course you do. Your sort are always the same.

TorqueWrench · 20/09/2023 22:47

SemperIdem · 20/09/2023 22:44

Truly fascinated how this thread has taken the turn into “men are more likely to kill you than a dog”.

XL bully’s being dangerous is not a feminist issue, what a ridiculous straw man argument.

You're a bit late to the party. Thread has moved on. 😂

Nobody said it was a feminist issue. It was just an observation that people fixate on some risks whilst totally ignoring other bigger risks. Nothing more, nothing less.

I'm never going to post about 'feminist issues', I find most feminists incredibly tedious tbh.

SemperIdem · 20/09/2023 22:44

Truly fascinated how this thread has taken the turn into “men are more likely to kill you than a dog”.

XL bully’s being dangerous is not a feminist issue, what a ridiculous straw man argument.

BardRelic · 20/09/2023 22:41

Thanks @TorqueWrench that's interesting. Just shows how difficult it is to identify these breeds. And also that banning them is a game of whack a mole.

TorqueWrench · 20/09/2023 22:30

BardRelic · 20/09/2023 22:05

Well just look what happened with that poor woman in Caterham. Eight dogs together, one of them her own XL Bully and that was the one that killed her. There's a reason 'pack mentality' is known to take hold and results in people and animals doing things they wouldn't do on their own.

No, it was actually a pit bull which she'd rehomed after it bit a child, and it had already bitten her twice in the days leading up to the fatal attack. Her boyfriend was not keen on the dog apparently.

Previously, it was reported that the dog responsible was an American Bully XL, and the animal was destroyed following an investigation.

However, veterinary surgeon Dr Alison Robson - an expert court witness who examined Natasha's cause of death - has revealed that Stan was a pit bull, which is one of four breeds banned in the UK by the Dangerous Dogs Act of 1991.

In November last year, Natasha reportedly rescued Stan from owners who planned to put him down after he bit one of their children. He also bit Natasha twice in the days leading up to the tragic attack, a friend said.

https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/dog-walker-savaged-death-walking-30955005?int_source=amp_continue_reading&int_medium=amp&int_campaign=continue_reading_button#amp-readmore-target

MiniTheMinx · 20/09/2023 22:19

Well that sounds like a fun day out Confused just imagine the publicity if half a dozen of these dogs start on each other!

BardRelic · 20/09/2023 22:05

Well just look what happened with that poor woman in Caterham. Eight dogs together, one of them her own XL Bully and that was the one that killed her. There's a reason 'pack mentality' is known to take hold and results in people and animals doing things they wouldn't do on their own.

MrTiddlesTheCat · 20/09/2023 21:52

I've had dogs all my life and I know when there's a group it only takes one to get a bit over excited and then all hell lets loose.

BardRelic · 20/09/2023 21:44

MrTiddlesTheCat · 20/09/2023 21:23

Just seen that bully xl owners in Birmingham are organising a big bully meet, encouraging everyone to bring their bully xls all together to show everyone how gentle they are. 'Bring as many kids as possible' they encourage.

They really are quite insane.

Seems like a good way of proving that Bullies are dangerous, I just wish they'd leave the kids out of it.

MotherofGorgons · 20/09/2023 21:26

Good god! It's like those loony NRA meetings with kids and guns.

MrTiddlesTheCat · 20/09/2023 21:23

Just seen that bully xl owners in Birmingham are organising a big bully meet, encouraging everyone to bring their bully xls all together to show everyone how gentle they are. 'Bring as many kids as possible' they encourage.

They really are quite insane.

Iheartpizza · 20/09/2023 19:17

OldSu -

If the Bully had killed the Lab - I would consider that a completely disproportionate and violent response and not acceptable, whoever happened to be the instigator.

Look, we shall have to agree to disagree on this point.

Oldsu · 20/09/2023 18:29

BardRelic · 20/09/2023 09:37

@Oldsu have you seen, in real life not on video, what happens when a large bully/ pit bull or mastiff does attack another dog? I think if you had, you might see why comparisons with Labradors aren't helpful. Personally I don't think the XL bullies currently around should all be destroyed. I do think they should all be neutered.

As great as it is that some of them, with a huge amount of training from someone who knows what they're doing, are tolerant of other dogs, I don't think it means that they as a breed or type, overall, are safe. It's like saying guns are safe because trained police officers are fine with them. That doesn't, of course, mean it's suddenly ok to retract the gun laws. (And that's before we start on how dangerous the police can be).

The issue with XL bullies is their size and power, coupled with a killer instinct in many of them that can make them absolutely lethal to humans and to many other animals. Labradors can be a bit dubious, but they don't go for your throat and hold on until you're dead, or they are, because you looked at them a bit funny. And honestly, as someone used to reading animal body language, some of these dogs really are hair trigger and change mood in the blink of an eye. You don't get the gradual build up of signs that you get in the majority of other breeds. We don't need a knee jerk reaction to them, but we do need a very careful examination of how they are kept and we need to put measures in place to ensure the safety of all animals and people around them.

@BardRelic you are totally missing the point its not about what damage the lab would do in comparison to the bully its about the fact that without that video showing that the bully was totally under control and was being jumped on and his face bitten and was virtually under attack then he would have been blamed if the lab was killed or injured, not the out of control lab because of his size and breed he would have automatically been seen as the aggressor. No lab would have been taken away by the police, no lab would have been tasered or shot in that scenario but the bully would certainly have run the risk of one or the other.

Oldsu · 20/09/2023 18:09

Iheartpizza · 20/09/2023 12:36

Of course, the owner of the Lab puppy should not have allowed this to happen. He was 100% at fault.

However - the key issue here is that a Lab Puppy does not have the capability to maul in the same way! This was a mere slight inconvenience to the Bully owner.

If the situation had been reversed the Lab Puppy would have been dead.

Do you see the difference?

@Iheartpizza No the KEY issue here is if the bully had reacted and killed the lab, without the video showing how well trained the bully was and how it was provoked the bully would automatically have been seen as the aggressor, which is why people are now getting body cams. if the lab had been seen to attack the bully it would not run the risk of being seized by the police and put down or in the worse case scenario which is happening a lot wouldn't have been tasered or shot by the police, it would have been given the benefit of the doubt the bully wouldn't have been now do YOU see the difference

MajorIck · 20/09/2023 16:10

sandyhappypeople · 20/09/2023 16:06

Seems we’re on the same page mostly to be fair, I was originally replying to your post about it being the owner not the dog that is the problem, I normally agree with that generally, but not with this breed, I really believe that the violence bred into these dogs is the problem, and there’s very little any owner can do to fulfil these dogs to stop that natural instinct taking over, so I do think the dogs are the problem here (through no fault of their own unfortunately).

It seems so! Sorry if there was any confusion there, but I do agree that these dogs are an issue. It’s my belief that years of bad breeding has irrevocably ruined them, and unfortunately, it might be best to just stop the bloodlines where they are now. It’s also my belief that no “good” owners get these breeds. It might not be that they’re cruel, or rough, or anything else that’s typically considered “bad”, but even just ignorant and uninformed can be a dangerous mistake with this breed.

sandyhappypeople · 20/09/2023 16:06

MajorIck · 20/09/2023 15:50

That’s exactly what I was saying in my initial post too?? That instinct is what it is, and it’s up to the owners to recognize that? Not sure why you disagreed in the first place so?

I agree, these dogs should not be owned as it’s impossible to fulfill them. However what I was saying is it’s not the dogs fault for having instincts. Instincts aren’t a choice. Instinct cannot be perceived as a fault, because it’s not something comprehensible - it just is. It’s also not the dogs fault for being alive, that’s the fault of the people who facilitated their birth instead of taking steps to stop it. The dog didn’t have a choice in any of it.

People are at fault when they get these breeds and fail to recognize this fact. They’re at fault for getting them in the first place when there are hundreds of dog breeds who are not known to be prone to violence. But every dog owner should remember, regardless of the breed, if it has teeth and muscles, it carries some level of risk.

I have a hound, and like you have owned many different dogs throughout my life. She is well trained, mild mannered. She’s gentle, loves children and other animals - but I’d never leave her in the room with a child because if god forbid something snapped, she could do damage. That’s just a basic fact. She’s got a strong bite force, sharp teeth and muscle. It’s extremely unlikely that she’d ever do anything, but nothing is impossible. My responsibility to recognize that and protect her well-being as well as others in situations where there’s even the slightest possibility of something going wrong.

The people with these breeds are more likely to be the “bad” owners due to the type of attention they believe these dogs will bring. But I did mention the “good” owners in my original post too - the ones who are trying to do their best. Unfortunately, what makes a good owner is sometimes making the heartbreaking decision that this breed should not be owned. If they don’t make this decision, they switch very quickly to the “bad” owners imo

Edited

Seems we’re on the same page mostly to be fair, I was originally replying to your post about it being the owner not the dog that is the problem, I normally agree with that generally, but not with this breed, I really believe that the violence bred into these dogs is the problem, and there’s very little any owner can do to fulfil these dogs to stop that natural instinct taking over, so I do think the dogs are the problem here (through no fault of their own unfortunately).

MajorIck · 20/09/2023 15:58

sandyhappypeople · 20/09/2023 15:53

You’re kind of highlighting my point though, everything you’ve said about these dogs having a violence prone bloodline and running on instincts by it’s very definition means that the owners have no real control, you may as well have a tiger.

it’s okay saying people are at fault for their breeding/existence, I wholeheartedly agree, it is not the dogs fault that they have been bred this way, but no amount of good dog ownership can ever mitigate the risks these dogs pose if they just decide to go apeshit one day.

while I agree a lot of owners have no place owning any dog let alone one of these, it is a problem in the bloodline/breeding of the dog which creates these aggressive/violent behaviours and that can’t be ‘fixed’ with training people to take care of them, all the precautions in the world won’t stop one of these dogs on a rampage.

No, it won’t. But that’s still not the dogs fault.

People should recognize these breeds for what they are, and recognize that they are in no way capable of exerting control. Most people do, that’s why people like you and I wouldn’t have them.

However some people ignore this because they want to be perceived a certain way, or just choose to remain ignorant about their own lack of capability. Those are the people at fault for this. Had they not been so narcissistic to believe they were in control, these dogs wouldn’t be mass produced by money hungry breeders, and wouldn’t be a dime a dozen in dog attacks.

Being a good dog owner, imo, is not owning these types of dogs AT ALL. It’s recognizing your own ability and making a well informed choice when choosing a breed. If you can’t do that, you shouldn’t have a dog, let alone this type of breed. If you ignore all of this, and get the dog anyway, whatever happens is YOUR fault

sandyhappypeople · 20/09/2023 15:53

MajorIck · 20/09/2023 15:16

@sandyhappypeople it’s not the owners at all, it’s the bloodline, they come from dogs that are literally bred for aggression and fighting, it’s not the dogs fault.. but it is the dog that is the problem.

As per my previous post, you will see I included breeders in my list of people at fault. Breeders who continue to breed from a violence prone bloodline are at fault. People who purchase these dogs and refuse to take steps to circumvent a KNOWN issue with these breeds are at fault. People who refuse to take responsibility for the control of their pet are at fault.

The dog didn’t choose to be prone to violence. A dog doesn’t choose very much, nor do many other animals. They run on instinct. That’s what separates animals from humans - the fact that we can make choices and see potential outcomes before they occur.

Dogs, and most animals, do not have the mental capacity to fully understand the decisions they’re making. Babies dont have it either, not until they’re grown up. If a baby were to bite another child are crèche, would you say it’s the babies fault? No, of course not, because it’s a baby. It didn’t know what it was doing, or the consequences of that action. It was just an instinctual reaction to something that baby didn’t like (biting is a known reaction amongst SOME young toddlers). The people at fault were the adults not being prepared to remove that baby from the situation.

Edited

You’re kind of highlighting my point though, everything you’ve said about these dogs having a violence prone bloodline and running on instincts by it’s very definition means that the owners have no real control, you may as well have a tiger.

it’s okay saying people are at fault for their breeding/existence, I wholeheartedly agree, it is not the dogs fault that they have been bred this way, but no amount of good dog ownership can ever mitigate the risks these dogs pose if they just decide to go apeshit one day.

while I agree a lot of owners have no place owning any dog let alone one of these, it is a problem in the bloodline/breeding of the dog which creates these aggressive/violent behaviours and that can’t be ‘fixed’ with training people to take care of them, all the precautions in the world won’t stop one of these dogs on a rampage.

MajorIck · 20/09/2023 15:50

sandyhappypeople · 20/09/2023 15:40

Do you really believe that you could own a violent dog and control them out of sheer free will?

That’s pretty much the opposite of what I said, My point is breeds that are ‘prone to violence’ have no place in family homes, they are an accident waiting to happen and innocent people/children/other pets pay the price for people’s arrogance in thinking they can control them or put adequate ‘precautions’ in place, and they tend to be the ‘good’ owners! Bad owners wouldn’t give two shits about trying to mitigate the risks and are probably responsible for more attacks then good owners, but it’s still the dog that ultimately does the attacking.

I have three dogs, and owned dogs all my life, would never dream of having a breed like this, the problem is you just can’t control instinct, one of mine is a sight hound, his instincts are to chase, you can train behaviours to interrupt instincts or fulfil those needs in other ways (chasing tennis balls etc) but you’ll never stop them, it’s in their nature, how do you fulfil a dog that is bred for fighting/aggression?

That’s exactly what I was saying in my initial post too?? That instinct is what it is, and it’s up to the owners to recognize that? Not sure why you disagreed in the first place so?

I agree, these dogs should not be owned as it’s impossible to fulfill them. However what I was saying is it’s not the dogs fault for having instincts. Instincts aren’t a choice. Instinct cannot be perceived as a fault, because it’s not something comprehensible - it just is. It’s also not the dogs fault for being alive, that’s the fault of the people who facilitated their birth instead of taking steps to stop it. The dog didn’t have a choice in any of it.

People are at fault when they get these breeds and fail to recognize this fact. They’re at fault for getting them in the first place when there are hundreds of dog breeds who are not known to be prone to violence. But every dog owner should remember, regardless of the breed, if it has teeth and muscles, it carries some level of risk.

I have a hound, and like you have owned many different dogs throughout my life. She is well trained, mild mannered. She’s gentle, loves children and other animals - but I’d never leave her in the room with a child because if god forbid something snapped, she could do damage. That’s just a basic fact. She’s got a strong bite force, sharp teeth and muscle. It’s extremely unlikely that she’d ever do anything, but nothing is impossible. My responsibility to recognize that and protect her well-being as well as others in situations where there’s even the slightest possibility of something going wrong.

The people with these breeds are more likely to be the “bad” owners due to the type of attention they believe these dogs will bring. But I did mention the “good” owners in my original post too - the ones who are trying to do their best. Unfortunately, what makes a good owner is sometimes making the heartbreaking decision that this breed should not be owned. If they don’t make this decision, they switch very quickly to the “bad” owners imo

sandyhappypeople · 20/09/2023 15:40

MajorIck · 20/09/2023 15:07

An animal is, in fact, an animal.

The precautions I meant were not entirely surrounding potential mauling and maiming, but as we’re on the topic - if you own a breed that is prone to violence, then yes, you should absolutely take precautions like muzzles, harnesses and home security (high fences, gates, etc).

I think it’s very arrogant of you to believe you are above an animal in regards to control. Of course, owning a Bichon Frise is not going to require as many precautions, but it’s still an animal, and still capable of damage, however minor. Do you really believe that you could own a violent dog and control them out of sheer free will? Because if you believe that your dog will listen to your every command, and go against their nature at all times, 100% of the time, you are the exact type of owner to have an out of control dog

Being a responsible pet owner means training your animal, but remembering that they too have their own free will, and will act on it. It’s YOUR job to get ahead of this. If you don’t, you shouldn’t have that pet.

Edited

Do you really believe that you could own a violent dog and control them out of sheer free will?

That’s pretty much the opposite of what I said, My point is breeds that are ‘prone to violence’ have no place in family homes, they are an accident waiting to happen and innocent people/children/other pets pay the price for people’s arrogance in thinking they can control them or put adequate ‘precautions’ in place, and they tend to be the ‘good’ owners! Bad owners wouldn’t give two shits about trying to mitigate the risks and are probably responsible for more attacks then good owners, but it’s still the dog that ultimately does the attacking.

I have three dogs, and owned dogs all my life, would never dream of having a breed like this, the problem is you just can’t control instinct, one of mine is a sight hound, his instincts are to chase, you can train behaviours to interrupt instincts or fulfil those needs in other ways (chasing tennis balls etc) but you’ll never stop them, it’s in their nature, how do you fulfil a dog that is bred for fighting/aggression?