Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Had a party for DS and one mum brings an extra kid along

313 replies

MadameameBeans · 19/09/2023 15:38

We had a birthday party in our garden recently for DS (8).
Bouncy castle and food and party bags, the usual.
He chose who he wanted there (set a limit of 12-15 because the whole class would be a bit much), and we ended up with 13 who could make it.

One mum (who we don't even know) turns up with her eldest (invited) and then his younger sibling (5 or 6 ish?) in tow. And seemed to think that was totally fine to bring him along, despite him not being invited, no other siblings were there or invited.

She just turned up in the garden and said "His younger brother is tagging along. Do you want me to stay with them or can I go?" I very Britishly didn't want to cause a scene and was so shocked and embarassed that I didn't know what to say, so they stayed.

AIBU to think that that's totally out of order to just turn up and ask permission when she got there? She didn't contact me beforehand to ask if it was ok, or even drop the invited child off and then take the other one to the park around the corner. She's not a friend, hadn't even met her before!

So there was just some random younger child my DS didn't know at his party and there was the expectation from her that he would eat the party food and join in with everything.

Thankfully he was well-behaved, but him and the mum looked a bit put out when I said at the end that there were only party bags for the children that had been invited and we didn't have any spares.

Oh and to add further insult when they left and DS was opening his gifts, it turned out they had only given a card and no present!
DS said that the invited kid had handed him the card at the start of the party and said "My mum didn't get you a present because she didn't know what you like".
(because nobody could possibly guess what an 8-year-old might like - lego, or a game or chocolate or whatever. (she could have asked either of her kids what they like. What a ridiculous excuse.)

So she brings an uninvited kid to the party and then doesn't even bring a gift. Who the hell does that?!

OP posts:
Ozziedream · 19/09/2023 18:20

YANBU to be annoyed but YABU to say it was “Britishness” that stopped you saying sorry no you can’t drop and leave an uninvited younger sibling. That was the “lack of assertiveness” or “adultness”. To address the issues raised by pp (mysterious difficult social background or unknown issues), I probably would have given her the choice of staying and supervising her younger child or leaving with him.

Nelly91 · 19/09/2023 18:13

It's annoying for sure, especially because you limited numbers for a very good reason! However you never know what is going on behind the scenes. It might have been the only way she could bring her child along. It obviously would have been nice if she asked before hand. Sometimes these kids parties do creep up and forgetting to arrange childcare for other siblings does happen. Especially if she's a single mum. Not really an excuse for no present. A fiver in a card is pretty good! Just be mindful you don't know her or her situation.

Fedupwitheveryone · 19/09/2023 18:12

yes it is rude and i can't stand rudeness - but the problem is, if you turn away kids in this situation it's often the child who gets upset, when it's the parent you are cross with.
For what it's worth, the only ones who I've noticed doing this at our school tend to be the slightly socially awkward ones - ie they haven't differentiated between open parties we used to have (ie younger kids) and the smaller ones we doing now they are older. They don't seem to pick up on social cues that you don't want their extra kid there (this includes ones the parents are staying at, so they aren't just after free childcare)

Florabundance · 19/09/2023 18:12

Similar thing happened to my my sister and BIL, my neice and nephew's birthdays only fall a couple of days apart so she used to hold 'joint' parties for them, this was a few years ago when they were living in France, the parents all started to arrive to drop off the children and each of the parents would come in and shake hands with my sister and BIL before handing each child over, my sister noticed one particular man leaving his little boy at the front door then edging away, she asked both my niece and nephew who the little boy was and neither of them knew, my sister followed the man who was now beating a hasty retreat to his car, introduced herself and asked for the name of his little boy, he explained that although his son was not in the same class at school and hadn't been invited, he and his wife had been invited to an event at short notice so he 'assumed' it would be ok to leave him at the party and collect him later, my sister explained that they weren't there to provide free childcare and sent him packing.

WeeOrcadian · 19/09/2023 18:08

One child in DD's class got uninvited because her CF mother kept turning up with the child's older brother.... And later turned up with her toddler as well

CF at its finest

MadameameBeans · 19/09/2023 17:58

Zanatdy · 19/09/2023 17:55

Lack of gift wouldn’t bother me

It only bothered me as it was another example of her being cheeky on top of the main cheekiness in self-inviting a second kid. I'd never start a thread "I hosted a party and can you believe it, one of the kids didn't bring a present" because honestly it doesnt matter.

OP posts:
2023dana · 19/09/2023 17:58

Oh that’s bad 😳 You can’t show up and expect free childcare for uninvited children, I think it’s even worse that it was at your house and not in a venue. I would have 100% said it was fine too though because I would never make a scene in that scenario but inside I’d be raging! I think there’s a difference if it’s a party parents have to stay and it’s a young baby/toddler that’s the younger sibling as they might not have been able to get childcare and parent keeps them with them and doesn’t expect food/party bag etc.
My sister took my little one to a party as she doesn’t have kids but is close to the parent. I was mortified when she came back and said he hadn’t got a party bag as the mum didn’t know he was coming (he was invited) 😳 I thought why on earth didn’t you message her?!

EmmaPaella · 19/09/2023 17:57

Twistyemily · 19/09/2023 17:54

She was incredibly rude, but you had plenty of opportunity to let her know that.
"His younger brother is tagging along. Do you want me to stay with them or can I go?"
"I think there's been a misunderstanding. I haven't invited brothers and sisters, so yes of course you can go, but you'll need to take x with you.".

It is indeed very easy to type that. Not easy for everyone to actually say at an already stressful party in front of a child. The CF is at fault not the OP.

MadameameBeans · 19/09/2023 17:56

Twistyemily · 19/09/2023 17:54

She was incredibly rude, but you had plenty of opportunity to let her know that.
"His younger brother is tagging along. Do you want me to stay with them or can I go?"
"I think there's been a misunderstanding. I haven't invited brothers and sisters, so yes of course you can go, but you'll need to take x with you.".

Yes we established on page 1 that I'm too shy/nervous/a pushover and scared of confrontation, to even consider that as an option, even if it is the "right" thing to do!

OP posts:
supersonicginandtonic · 19/09/2023 17:56

Those saying it's ok for her to not bring a present as she may be unable to afford one. Well maybe the OP cannot afford to cater for extra kids and party bags

CruCru · 19/09/2023 17:55

Yeah, it's pretty annoying. I remember a friend at school (years ago - I am middle aged) whose mum would do this with her younger brother. Once we got a bit older it was easier to say that the party mum had only booked 8 tickets or that it was a girls' party.

A friend whose children are a decade older said that there was a dad at her children's school who would turn up with all five of his children and merrily wave them into her house and run away before she could object. It became a bit of a joke (and she stopped doing at-home class parties).

Zanatdy · 19/09/2023 17:55

Lack of gift wouldn’t bother me

Zanatdy · 19/09/2023 17:55

Lesson is always have a couple of spare party bags / food as someone always does this. I wouldn’t dare. I had an apology one year from a mum who sent her husband and couldn’t believe he just assumed she was invited and 2 people had to share a chair to accommodate her!

Twistyemily · 19/09/2023 17:54

She was incredibly rude, but you had plenty of opportunity to let her know that.
"His younger brother is tagging along. Do you want me to stay with them or can I go?"
"I think there's been a misunderstanding. I haven't invited brothers and sisters, so yes of course you can go, but you'll need to take x with you.".

DisquietintheRanks · 19/09/2023 17:53

madamreign · 19/09/2023 15:44

It's rude.

But I wouldn't judge to harshly.

She may be broke. The eldest might be nervous. Who knows.

😆 yes this is definitely nervous behaviour not cheeky fuckery. Be kind OP, lie down and make it easier for people to walk all over you.

MadameameBeans · 19/09/2023 17:51

eatdrinkandbemerry · 19/09/2023 17:47

You seem equally rude mentioning no present!
I'd rather not have a load of plastic tat and just be happy my son had a good day with his friends.

How is it rude? I didn't mention it to her, only on here as an example of her rudeness.
I'd never be so rude as to shame a parent at a party "why haven't you brought a present with you!?"

People keep going on about the gift in this thread and I feel I have to reply to clarify, and then others chip in with "you seem obsessed about this gift". I can't win!

If you think turning up to a small birthday party with no token gift, but with an uninvited child is absolutely fine, then that says more about you than it does about me.

OP posts:
Gymnopedie · 19/09/2023 17:50

There are regular threads about this and it seems like it's becoming the norm. It didn't used to happen. Given that most people think it's CF territory but don't say anything because they don't want to seem mean/they're put on the spot/they don't like confrontation, can I suggest a very small way of making a stand? Don't give the extras a party bag. Have only enough for the invited children (as OP did) and if a child drops out late on, don't let on. 'Sorry, there are only enough for the children who were invited'. Those PPs who anticipate this and do extra bags are just encouraging the CFs to carry on doing it.

It's only a small thing, the extras still get food and play games (if it's an at home party, soft play etc paid for parties are different) but it makes the point that they're not going to get everything - makes the point to the parents rather than the child.

MadameameBeans · 19/09/2023 17:49

AccountantMum · 19/09/2023 17:44

Are you sure when she said "His younger brother is tagging along. Do you want me to stay with them or can I go?"
She didn't mean her and her other child can go together or stay? Maybe she wasn't sure if she was able to leave her 8 year old?
If that is what she meant I don't think she has been rude - Otherwise this seems odd and would be the part which I would find rude (her leaving without the younger child).

I don't think the gift is rude most children that have attended my children's parties have brought gifts but I would not expect it or have any issue if someone did not bring a gift, they brought a card and came to celebrate with your child.

What she said was something like "His younger brother [Name] is tagging along today. Do you need to me to stay and chaperone [Name], or shall I go, and come back for them both at four?"

OP posts:
eatdrinkandbemerry · 19/09/2023 17:47

You seem equally rude mentioning no present!
I'd rather not have a load of plastic tat and just be happy my son had a good day with his friends.

AccountantMum · 19/09/2023 17:44

Are you sure when she said "His younger brother is tagging along. Do you want me to stay with them or can I go?"
She didn't mean her and her other child can go together or stay? Maybe she wasn't sure if she was able to leave her 8 year old?
If that is what she meant I don't think she has been rude - Otherwise this seems odd and would be the part which I would find rude (her leaving without the younger child).

I don't think the gift is rude most children that have attended my children's parties have brought gifts but I would not expect it or have any issue if someone did not bring a gift, they brought a card and came to celebrate with your child.

MouseKeys · 19/09/2023 17:42

@MadameameBeans whole class parties at home were definitely a thing when I was little too, until our parents realised taking just 2-3 friends to the ice rink or the cinema was much easier on them 🤣

Hotsaucegal · 19/09/2023 17:42

Definitely a bit cheeky/rude but not completely unheard of. I think she should have checked with you ahead of the party but probably didn’t because she didn’t want to run the risk of being refused. Given that the party was in the garden and it didn’t cost you anything extra ( compared to an activity birthday such as bowling or soft play where it’s price per head vs. Fixed cost) I’d just chalk it up as one of those things. Yes, as people have pointed out you could have just said no but better to stay in the good books of your children’s friends and their parents.

MadameameBeans · 19/09/2023 17:39

MouseKeys · 19/09/2023 17:35

Maybe it's a case of different strokes for different folks?
Where we are, it's pretty much expected that brothers and sisters will tag along to birthday parties especially as most parties round here are held either in the park or at the beach. My kid went to a party last Sunday where there were 4 "extras", I generally just buy extra sweets/crisps to put out for them so I wouldn't be bothered by this although I can see why you were.
(The parents I know also generally stay at parties and there is usually a bottle of rose or two for us to catch up over so I'm fine with staying 🤣)

Yeah, our garden is on the small side, barely room to squeeze the bouncy castle in, so it wasn't exactly as if we had room for extras. I guess I should be thankful it was just one! When I was a kid we had a massive garden and I used to invite the whole class!

OP posts:
M4J4 · 19/09/2023 17:37

MadameameBeans · 19/09/2023 15:55

"Not always easy in the moment though."

I don't do well with confrontation, and I felt bad to be put in the situation of telling a kid who has obviously been told by the mother "yes you can go too" that they can't. So it was easier to roll over and let them. Just won't invite that kid from the class again (even though it's totally not his fault!)

Next time this happens just say sorry I've said no to other siblings attending, it wouldn't be fair to let one stay. Please come back in 2 hours to collect.

MouseKeys · 19/09/2023 17:35

Maybe it's a case of different strokes for different folks?
Where we are, it's pretty much expected that brothers and sisters will tag along to birthday parties especially as most parties round here are held either in the park or at the beach. My kid went to a party last Sunday where there were 4 "extras", I generally just buy extra sweets/crisps to put out for them so I wouldn't be bothered by this although I can see why you were.
(The parents I know also generally stay at parties and there is usually a bottle of rose or two for us to catch up over so I'm fine with staying 🤣)