Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Had a party for DS and one mum brings an extra kid along

313 replies

MadameameBeans · 19/09/2023 15:38

We had a birthday party in our garden recently for DS (8).
Bouncy castle and food and party bags, the usual.
He chose who he wanted there (set a limit of 12-15 because the whole class would be a bit much), and we ended up with 13 who could make it.

One mum (who we don't even know) turns up with her eldest (invited) and then his younger sibling (5 or 6 ish?) in tow. And seemed to think that was totally fine to bring him along, despite him not being invited, no other siblings were there or invited.

She just turned up in the garden and said "His younger brother is tagging along. Do you want me to stay with them or can I go?" I very Britishly didn't want to cause a scene and was so shocked and embarassed that I didn't know what to say, so they stayed.

AIBU to think that that's totally out of order to just turn up and ask permission when she got there? She didn't contact me beforehand to ask if it was ok, or even drop the invited child off and then take the other one to the park around the corner. She's not a friend, hadn't even met her before!

So there was just some random younger child my DS didn't know at his party and there was the expectation from her that he would eat the party food and join in with everything.

Thankfully he was well-behaved, but him and the mum looked a bit put out when I said at the end that there were only party bags for the children that had been invited and we didn't have any spares.

Oh and to add further insult when they left and DS was opening his gifts, it turned out they had only given a card and no present!
DS said that the invited kid had handed him the card at the start of the party and said "My mum didn't get you a present because she didn't know what you like".
(because nobody could possibly guess what an 8-year-old might like - lego, or a game or chocolate or whatever. (she could have asked either of her kids what they like. What a ridiculous excuse.)

So she brings an uninvited kid to the party and then doesn't even bring a gift. Who the hell does that?!

OP posts:
Twinsmamma · 20/09/2023 17:56

It was 1 child? I’m speechless 🤣 I had more kids than were invited to my twins 2nd birthday party and I loved it, I must be one of those strange parents who doesn’t mind kids!

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 20/09/2023 17:53

My children are still toddlers so maybe my ignorance is due to their age, but REALLY?! What on earth is the big deal I can’t work out why you care?! More the merrier no?

Wow so you'd be fine if everyone's siblings were left for you to feed and look after, maybe more than doubling the size of the party? Fair play to you.

I'm just glad the party days are over.

AliOlis · 20/09/2023 17:51

Twinsmamma · 20/09/2023 17:49

My children are still toddlers so maybe my ignorance is due to their age, but REALLY?! What on earth is the big deal I can’t work out why you care?! More the merrier no?

Er.... No. 🤣

Twinsmamma · 20/09/2023 17:49

My children are still toddlers so maybe my ignorance is due to their age, but REALLY?! What on earth is the big deal I can’t work out why you care?! More the merrier no?

caringcarer · 20/09/2023 17:36

You could have said just leave the invited child on his own and you can amuse the other child at the park around the corner. Come back at X time to collect.

Eaumyword · 20/09/2023 17:25

Such a relief that my DS is all grown up - this used to happen a lot round our way. Tricky when the uninvited child queues up for a party bag and at one particular party, a child ate sooo much like a little hoover, we were frantically making extra sandwiches!
It's really tricky as these CF mothers rely on you being passive and letting it happen, plus you don't want to affect your child's friendships.
MN seems to be quite split on views on this, but I just think it's bad manners to foist uninvited siblings off, unless the host has already specifically made it clear they would be welcome, in which case that's fine.

StaunchMomma · 20/09/2023 17:21

This was my absolute pet peeve when having parties and I'm so glad to be over the years of this.

We had one repeat offender who was incredibly pushy and once snatched food out of my hands for her older child before I'd even fed the younger ones. In the end I decided to book activity parties and state on the invite that it was invited children only due to insurance purposes.

At least you'll be ready for it next time.

SaylessSayless · 20/09/2023 17:01

Now I'm on my 3rd child I'd say 'oh I had to limit him to 12 guests. It was hard for him to choose so if we were having any more children it would definitely be a child he knows, thank you'.

notacooldad · 20/09/2023 16:56

This happened to me a few times when my kids had parties.
To be honest I wasn't overly bothered. I never made party bags because quite frankly I couldn't be bothered. I just wanted all the kids to have fun.
If there had been a huge age difference and the spare kid was very young I would have said it was on mum to stay but it's just a kids party not a formal event so it was not a problem. Nothing to get worked up about.

Woodandsky · 20/09/2023 16:53

My kids were only 1 school year apart, DH worked long hours inc weekends so I inevitably would have to take both kids to drop off and pick up at parties.

Sometimes people asked if the sibling would like to stay and as a busy mum I wasn't about to say no! I would never have assumed though which I think is the problem here.

It's not as though it cost you anything to have an extra kid on the bouncy castle though, cheeky but hardly the end of the world in my opinion, I feel like you're over-reacting.

Ablar · 20/09/2023 16:50

There's an instagrammer that does this. They have 5 kids and no matter which one is invited to the party, they all go including mum and dad. Just leave the others at home with one of the parents. I wouldn't be amused if it happened and I'd have to tell them straight

Libra24 · 20/09/2023 16:40

It's a bit cheeky but you had an out.
Presents aren't mandatory. I don't think it should matter what they gave, I hate this gift expectation in general.

Bringonthesunforthewashing · 20/09/2023 16:21

@MadameameBeans i have been following your thread.

I have 3 kids, lots of parties!! Some of the responses on here are absolutely ridiculous. Only ever in mn world.

She was definitely a cf without doubt. You were well mannered and let the sibling stay. Then she didn’t get a present. You stated more than once you could understand that people are struggling with money and you get that.

See, my kids have been invited to a lot of parties in the past as you can imagine. There is no way I would have shown up without a present. Even when I had no money for a loaf of bread I wouldn’t have taken my child to the party without a present. As a parent you have a choice, let my child down and say no to going to the party, bite the bullet text the host and apologise and explain you really can’t afford a present and hope she understands.

Any person would understand receiving that text. I luckily didn’t have to, but I very easily could have.

but she neither. And brought the other child that none of the kids knew apart from his brother to gate crash a party. Not kids fault at all. Then she goes and leave you doing her childcare.

The response about inviting the whole class - well, what can you say to that mentality? I mean seriously!!!

Litmus1001 · 20/09/2023 16:19

Unfortunately this seems to happen a lot, for some odd reason.
You need to have a stock answer ready, such as: 'I think there's maybe been a misunderstanding, but we've limited the numbers so can't include siblings this time. I'll pop a little extra in X's (insert name of actual child invited) party bag so that they can both have something. See you at 4 (or whenever the party ends).' Once you include one or two uninvited siblings then it's harder to say no to more and/or you give the impression that it's ok in the future. People should know not to do this, but it's an age old problem for some reason!

Mothership4two · 20/09/2023 16:16

Yes of course she was rude and you should have said no OP, but she put you on the spot and you probably didn't want to start the party with awkwardness - I would have probably done the same. Children don't tend to want little ones tagging along and if they have had to think about who to invite (and who not to) were probably a bit 😕that there was some random young kid there but in the excitement of the party it probably wouldn't have been a big deal. If she was a friend of yours or had asked beforehand then that would have made a difference. Of course you don't have to invite a whole class! Party bags are for the guests and, unless you are psychic, you had no idea there was going to be a plus one - I would have probably just wrapped up a slice of birthday cake. Personally don't feel it is petty to not give this child a gift at their birthday party, it's being fair and treating the family as they have treated you (as you don't think they are hard up). Frankly, she should have given a £5 to cover childcare!

I never had a problem with uninvited siblings but at one party the mum dropping off made a fuss saying she had forgotten to bring my son's birthday present and had left it at home but wasn't going back home during the party, 'that's fine' I said, then when she collected her son she again made a fuss about the present and said she would drop it round to our home later that day and were we going to be in? We were.. She never did give him his present and I never looked at her the same way again! And the family were not destitute living on the breadline - far from it.

Afterrain · 20/09/2023 16:15

Exceptionally rude.
We have had lots of DC birthday parties at home and never had this happened.
I would have been too flabbergasted and embarrassed to say no to the extra child.
I wouldn't have had spare part bags either.

Kwasi · 20/09/2023 16:14

Where I live, it’s normal for soft play or village hall parties. People generally ask but it’s accepted and the sibling doesn’t get fed or a party bag unless it’s a buffet.

However, one of the mum’s invited 8 boys round for a hot tub party in the summer and even called the group chat ‘the boys’ but one mum (always the firs to ask if DD can come), asked if DD (3) could come. I thought that was out of order.

Your comment about the present is bang out of order and makes you sound grabby. We never expect presents and always state that on the invites. A couple of kids never bring them and I know their parents are not as well off as us.

LusaBatoosa · 20/09/2023 16:04

username5619 · 20/09/2023 10:15

@whatwasthatgrandma
Why is the truth offending you.
Reframing the situation and putting things into a perspective personally helps me worry less.

@RawOnions if our social rules cause more upset and stress than actually working in our benefit, may be it's time we reviewed them.

As someone from a ‘developing country’:

  • All ‘developing countries’ aren’t the same. There isn’t a monolithic culture that governs us all. To imply that there is is racist.
  • In my specific culture, in my specific country, no people do not routinely have the whole village over, feed all the children and not bother to count them. Etiquette, manners and basic consideration for others exist all over the world. And I have no idea how to even start tackling the ‘not counting children’ element.

Which cultures are you referring to, specifically? Where have you lived?

Whyohwhywyoming · 20/09/2023 15:54

YANBU for being annoyed about the extra kid, YABU for being annoyed about the present, the thing I hated most about my kids having parties was the sheer waste in gifts. I couldn’t care less if people didn’t bring one.

Bobbielikespeas · 20/09/2023 15:52

Who turns up to a party with no gift... Completely shameless. When I was young, our family had very little money but if there was a birthday party, you turn up with something! I remember buying something really cheap from a home bargains type of shop because it was all I could afford at the time but you wrap it up and still bring a gift! If the mum could afford the petrol to get to yours, she could have afforded something by way of a gift. The fact that she even made up an excuse to tell her kid to pass on says it all.

Snkt · 20/09/2023 15:46

I feel like I’m the only one that doesn’t think it’s rude?
When I hold a birthday/ gathering I always assume that a couple of people might have to decide last minute, not rsvp and show up. I am always prepared with extra food (I think it’s a little petty to think that they came and ate the food it’s what a party is for?) and a couple of extra goodie bags just in case. It’s a celebration and I would never be upset for someone extra being there. Also maybe they didn’t have the means to get a gift.. or they decided to come last minute and the point isn’t the gift it’s them being there to celebrate 😊

AliOlis · 20/09/2023 15:44

Pebblesontheside · 20/09/2023 13:39

You didn’t make up some spare party bags? Risky! I made up about 6 extras for my DC’s recent party, and they were all used up - some children lost the little toys from them on leaving, and yes - some extra children turned up last minute, and I was delighted to welcome them.
You sound incredibly tight to be honest - i can’t bear this transactional attitude around kids parties, that there has to be a big present given in return. Parties are about having fun, and the host should always be gracious, welcoming and hospitable.
And please tell me you didn’t actually consider telling the extra child they couldn’t go on the bouncy castle! Poor kid.

Well done for being "delighted to welcome" all comers to your child's party.
It's still the rule in polite society that if your name is not on the invitation; you're not invited.
Calling people tight doesn't change that 🤷🏻‍♀️

SirVixofVixHall · 20/09/2023 15:34

Redmat · 19/09/2023 15:40

You are not wrong. Uninvited children should not be at a party and she has no manners.

This.

Viviennemary · 20/09/2023 15:31

No it is absolutely not totally fine. It's cheeky and entitled. And cheeky to even ask and put the host in a difficult position. If your child was invited their name
would be on the invitation. Only on MN is this considered in any way acceptable behaviour.

username5619 · 20/09/2023 15:28

@whatwasthatgrandma it's my truth. I am talking about something I have direct personal experience of.
Being exposed to different cultures, is amazing, as there's so much to learn.