Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Had a party for DS and one mum brings an extra kid along

313 replies

MadameameBeans · 19/09/2023 15:38

We had a birthday party in our garden recently for DS (8).
Bouncy castle and food and party bags, the usual.
He chose who he wanted there (set a limit of 12-15 because the whole class would be a bit much), and we ended up with 13 who could make it.

One mum (who we don't even know) turns up with her eldest (invited) and then his younger sibling (5 or 6 ish?) in tow. And seemed to think that was totally fine to bring him along, despite him not being invited, no other siblings were there or invited.

She just turned up in the garden and said "His younger brother is tagging along. Do you want me to stay with them or can I go?" I very Britishly didn't want to cause a scene and was so shocked and embarassed that I didn't know what to say, so they stayed.

AIBU to think that that's totally out of order to just turn up and ask permission when she got there? She didn't contact me beforehand to ask if it was ok, or even drop the invited child off and then take the other one to the park around the corner. She's not a friend, hadn't even met her before!

So there was just some random younger child my DS didn't know at his party and there was the expectation from her that he would eat the party food and join in with everything.

Thankfully he was well-behaved, but him and the mum looked a bit put out when I said at the end that there were only party bags for the children that had been invited and we didn't have any spares.

Oh and to add further insult when they left and DS was opening his gifts, it turned out they had only given a card and no present!
DS said that the invited kid had handed him the card at the start of the party and said "My mum didn't get you a present because she didn't know what you like".
(because nobody could possibly guess what an 8-year-old might like - lego, or a game or chocolate or whatever. (she could have asked either of her kids what they like. What a ridiculous excuse.)

So she brings an uninvited kid to the party and then doesn't even bring a gift. Who the hell does that?!

OP posts:
Dinobot · 21/09/2023 04:26

I think you're being unfair. Who knows what else was going on for them that day. Seems to me she would have asked if it was a planned thing. Just be kind. Next time you'll be clearer with that parent what you expect. Besides you didn't give the younger sibling anything - so no loss to you if thats what you're concerned about. And you definitely shouldn't be punishing the 8 year old friend by not inviting him again. He has no control over the situation and might possibly often be in similarly chaotic situations through no fault of their own.

Teenagehorrorbag · 21/09/2023 00:01

So rude! We did whole class parties in our garden throughout primary, and for those Mums with slightly younger siblings that we all knew, I'd invite them too (as an aside, so they didn't feel obliged to bring additional presents or anything) and it always worked well. E.g. 30 8 year olds and three or four younger ones. Some stayed depending on the age - but if you agree in advance you can plan food and do extra party bags. (Or say no, if there are reasons why that's not doable e.g. age of siblings, space available etc).

I can't remember if it started with one or two parents asking beforehand - quite likely. But no-one would turn up without asking before, and suggest they might be able to leave their little one! That's totally CF territory. She was hoping you would say 'yes leave the LO and I as a total stranger will look after him' so she could go off for a couple of childfree hours! WTAF?

Glad you made the point by not having a party bag, and not scrabbling around trying to make it OK. The older sibling was probably mortified. YADNBU!

SaylessSayless · 20/09/2023 23:04

JubileeQueen123 · 20/09/2023 22:53

Not rude - one extra kid at a party! Who cares. Can’t they just join in?

Well no, because the birthday boy could have invited more friends but was limited to 13 kids and then there were 14. He probably would have preferred another one of his friends there. He probably didn't want a young child he didn't know at his party when he couldn't have another boy from his class. The OP didn't want to look after a young child at the same time as hosting a party.

His mother didn't even stay so there was no need for the uninvited child to be there. It was rude and weird and worse than a parent staying at a young child's party with a younger sibling in tow as they don't have anyone else to look after them.

JubileeQueen123 · 20/09/2023 22:53

Not rude - one extra kid at a party! Who cares. Can’t they just join in?

Ilovecleaning · 20/09/2023 22:49

She’s probably got no money. I’ve seen people like this before. They’re broke and will push the boundaries sometimes to get freebies. Just put it behind you.

Missingpop · 20/09/2023 22:18

You say you don’t know this lady perhaps she didn’t know the area as well as you & didn’t know there was a park nearby that she could have taken younger child too; as to not giving a gift has it not occurred to you that maybe moneys very tight for her; she wouldn’t be the first or last parent who’s not been able to buy party gifts; maybe think outside the box before jumping on mumsnet to slate the poor woman; she’d probably be mortified it’s all over mumsnet.

ExpatAl · 20/09/2023 21:48

Op the women could that day have saved kittens, baked a cake for a little old lonely neighbour, foiled a bank robbery, had life saving surgery and swam over a river with both boys hanging on to her back to get to your birthday. What a blessing for your child and shame on you. You are very unreasonable indeed.

MiniBossFromAus · 20/09/2023 21:39

ShyMaryEllen · 20/09/2023 21:32

Well no. Not everyone will, because most people have better manners. But taking a relaxed view isn't the best idea with unlimited numbers of 6 year olds on a bouncy castle.

It's the entitlement that's irritating, I think. The OP's boy didn't ask all the class, so had to make choices, then some woman decides to overrule that by imposing her child - the boy could have invited another classmate instead.

I just don't get the entitlement slant - it's just a little boy in a backyard playing with other children.

Clearly there are two camps.

I would have probably invited him to stay, as well as any other siblings who showed up. Instead of getting upset about health and safety, I would just monitor the bouncy castle and intervene if things were getting a bit rough.

My three children had about 30 parties between them and we never had an accident or any sort of issue and we always had an open house style party when they were held at home, hall, park.

Maybe us Aussies are weird.

ShyMaryEllen · 20/09/2023 21:32

MiniBossFromAus · 20/09/2023 21:21

Come on. There is never going to be the case that all attendees will bring a sibling.

If you are so worried about safety - best go to a party venue where numbers are strictly monitored and extras aren't admitted - no pay no go.

I am bemused by the control around children's parties. Strictly enforced numbers in yout back garden.

Truly, who cares. Let them play. Have you forgotten being a child. Not everybody is out to get you, some of us take a more relaxed view.

There is a way to prevent this from happening. You could write - NO SIBLINGS on future invites.

Well no. Not everyone will, because most people have better manners. But taking a relaxed view isn't the best idea with unlimited numbers of 6 year olds on a bouncy castle.

It's the entitlement that's irritating, I think. The OP's boy didn't ask all the class, so had to make choices, then some woman decides to overrule that by imposing her child - the boy could have invited another classmate instead.

MiniBossFromAus · 20/09/2023 21:25

howaboutchocolate · 20/09/2023 18:00

Would you have been happy as an 8 year old to invite your ten or so friends to your party, only for the dynamic to totally change because everyone's younger siblings came too?

Would you be happy if you were expecting to host a group of 8 year olds and then suddenly had to babysit a load of 3/4/5/6 year olds too while their parents buggered off?

Birthday parties aren't childcare.

Sweet love of God. Did you really mention the dynamic of a back yard party for an 8 year old.

Listen to yourself. Crackers!!

MiniBossFromAus · 20/09/2023 21:21

ShyMaryEllen · 20/09/2023 14:25

Nobody has addressed the question of safety if everyone brought a stray sibling and the numbers doubled. It is a consideration when planning supervision for 6 year olds, surely? If it is 'not an issue', what stops everyone from feeling entitled to do it?

Come on. There is never going to be the case that all attendees will bring a sibling.

If you are so worried about safety - best go to a party venue where numbers are strictly monitored and extras aren't admitted - no pay no go.

I am bemused by the control around children's parties. Strictly enforced numbers in yout back garden.

Truly, who cares. Let them play. Have you forgotten being a child. Not everybody is out to get you, some of us take a more relaxed view.

There is a way to prevent this from happening. You could write - NO SIBLINGS on future invites.

SaylessSayless · 20/09/2023 21:14

Tryingtobedifferent · 20/09/2023 19:11

This thread is actually hilarious 😂
Asking AIBU and then when people say yes you are you don't accept it lol
Chalk it down to experience and move on. It's one extra child, albeit unplanned but still, just one! Is it cheeky, yes a bit but then it's also not the end of the world.
Also as a sidenote, after a party my kids couldn't tell you who brought which present, they get mixed up, put separate to the cards and if the present hasn't got a tag you're screwed! So I feel like you've made a much bigger thing of the present than was necessary

Think you have misunderstood.

90% of 2020 people said she was not being unreasonable.

So not so hilarious.

OhsoNat · 20/09/2023 20:17

Yes it is out of order to just expect, why wouldn’t she just take the younger one away with her but I wouldn’t judge on the present as not everyone has spare cash for things like that

Sickdissapointed · 20/09/2023 20:11

We held a swimming party for my daughter age 6. School friends and other children invited. One family turned up mum dad 3 siblings. Without asking they all swam ate the cake and helped themselves to soft drinks. We didn’t do party bags just a v small gift which they also helped themselves to. Totally violated.

whatwasthatgrandma · 20/09/2023 19:38

Tryingtobedifferent · 20/09/2023 19:11

This thread is actually hilarious 😂
Asking AIBU and then when people say yes you are you don't accept it lol
Chalk it down to experience and move on. It's one extra child, albeit unplanned but still, just one! Is it cheeky, yes a bit but then it's also not the end of the world.
Also as a sidenote, after a party my kids couldn't tell you who brought which present, they get mixed up, put separate to the cards and if the present hasn't got a tag you're screwed! So I feel like you've made a much bigger thing of the present than was necessary

Most of said yanbu, and she is NBU, so why would she accept the few oddballs who said yabu?

Scunnered123 · 20/09/2023 19:35

I sympathise. We had a soft play party and had 3 families turn up with siblings. One brought 2 parents and another parent left to "do some stuff about the house". They all paid entry for their uninvited sibling but then encouraged them to join in games and eat the party food, so I ended up getting billed for the "extras" after everyone had left. I was a bit dazed and confused at the brass neck of it all. Didn't happen again.

Tryingtobedifferent · 20/09/2023 19:11

This thread is actually hilarious 😂
Asking AIBU and then when people say yes you are you don't accept it lol
Chalk it down to experience and move on. It's one extra child, albeit unplanned but still, just one! Is it cheeky, yes a bit but then it's also not the end of the world.
Also as a sidenote, after a party my kids couldn't tell you who brought which present, they get mixed up, put separate to the cards and if the present hasn't got a tag you're screwed! So I feel like you've made a much bigger thing of the present than was necessary

Casperroonie · 20/09/2023 19:05

Yes rude, but you could have just said no....

AliOlis · 20/09/2023 18:54

Twinsmamma · 20/09/2023 18:09

It was 1 child? Or am I missing something here?

You certainly are.
If it's perfecty fine for everyone to bring siblings, the hosts could end up with double or treble (or more...) the number of children they'd actually invited.
So don't do it, however much you insist there's no issue 😬

Clairebairn · 20/09/2023 18:49

This happened at my 5yo son’s party in May. We’d hired a place for 30 kids and said explicitly no siblings because we couldn’t accommodate all of them. One mum shows up with her invited 5yo and uninvited sibling and acts like she didn’t know siblings weren’t invited. There were 4 of us hosting and we agreed that if they charged us for the sibling we’d just have to pay for him. It’s so awkward and incredibly rude but this mum has shown herself to be quite inconsiderate and not following the crowd so what can you do.

Activemama · 20/09/2023 18:33

I see where you are coming from. It's not ideal.

I wonder whether mum couldn't afford a gift, or is struggling with money?

Perhaps bringing both children was her way to ensure they were fed.

I obviously don't know the full circumstances, but a lot more people seem to be struggling financially, with them depending on the schools to feed their children, or food banks to put food on the table.

If that's not the case, then I think mum took to p*, but we don't really know what goes on behind closed doors.

I hope your child enjoyed their party. If nothing else, it's a good learning opportunity for you child.

riceuten · 20/09/2023 18:33

Yes it was wrong

No, I wouldn’t’ve made a fuss, in the grand scheme of things it wasn’t that much of a big deal.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 20/09/2023 18:31

I had one once who bought THREE siblings and the one invited. She is just the loveliest person, I really like her but I found it so odd. I can only think that she’s just so nice that she wouldn’t mind at all if people did this to her so she thought it was ok. It was in a hall with an entertainer so it WAS ok, but I still would never do that.

Twinsmamma · 20/09/2023 18:09

howaboutchocolate · 20/09/2023 18:00

Would you have been happy as an 8 year old to invite your ten or so friends to your party, only for the dynamic to totally change because everyone's younger siblings came too?

Would you be happy if you were expecting to host a group of 8 year olds and then suddenly had to babysit a load of 3/4/5/6 year olds too while their parents buggered off?

Birthday parties aren't childcare.

It was 1 child? Or am I missing something here?

howaboutchocolate · 20/09/2023 18:00

Twinsmamma · 20/09/2023 17:49

My children are still toddlers so maybe my ignorance is due to their age, but REALLY?! What on earth is the big deal I can’t work out why you care?! More the merrier no?

Would you have been happy as an 8 year old to invite your ten or so friends to your party, only for the dynamic to totally change because everyone's younger siblings came too?

Would you be happy if you were expecting to host a group of 8 year olds and then suddenly had to babysit a load of 3/4/5/6 year olds too while their parents buggered off?

Birthday parties aren't childcare.

Swipe left for the next trending thread