Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect DH not to give in every time DD cries

137 replies

bananahanna · 19/09/2023 13:06

DH seems unable to tolerate our DD 19 mo crying, especially when it's in public. As a result she is very quickly learning that if she wants something she needs to cry, and if she's not getting it then she needs to up her screaming. I've tried to talk to him about it, explain it, send articles, demonstrate, model it myself. I feel like I've tried everything but his response is "it's so difficult to see her cry" or "she's our little girl, if we can stop her being upset we should!" (or something along those lines, when in private) or in public it's "people are looking at us" "this is so embarrassing" "we are disturbing people's dinners".

So I'm left with two problems
A) by default I become the baddie or the bad cop, whilst he's the nice parent, the best friend, the good cop. All just because I want to raise a nice person, not a spoilt brat
B) I'm left with a toddler who screams non-stop because she's learnt it's her way of getting things. For example, if she's on a walk with her dad she will cry and he will take her out of the pram (we get into an argument when we are on a walk together because he insists on doing this so I know he would 100% do it without me). So when I'm walking home from the park and she's decided she doesn't want to sit anymore, I've got a screaming toddler because she's learnt that's how she can get her way, unless I fancy carrying 12kg of baby along with pushing her pram with the other hand. Or same with if she wants me to give something she can't have - my husband will give it to her if she cries so she expects the same from me and screams the house down because I don't.

I'm a SAHM so really it's me who is suffering most of the time from her tantrums. He just comes in on weekends and for 1hr in the evening to be "nice dad".

If I talk to him about it the responses are all very much along the lines of "but she's my baby, I love her so much, how can you stop her, she's so little and I can't handle my poor lovely girl crying, do you have a heart"

OP posts:
OneMoreStepAlongTheRoadIGo · 19/09/2023 14:16

Yep Huffle I'm with you.

And ideally she'd ask to be carried rather than cry - but she's 19 months... so she is using what communication she can to ask for what she wants! I don't think asking for a carry is wrong, especially if she knows dad will when dad's out. Fine if mum wont/can't but it seems quite controlling not to let him carry a child who wants a carry.

And he is right she won't be small amd wanting a carry for ever. Mine misses when he used to do piggybacks!

DuploTrain · 19/09/2023 14:16

I agree with others re the pram. I never carry my toddler when he doesn’t want to sit in his pram.

But if DH wants to, that’s fine. But it means that he will have to do it all the time when he’s there, or he will have to be the one to comfort her if he decides not to.

You can still say no consistently though, she’ll learn that you don’t carry her.

AnneLovesGilbert · 19/09/2023 14:15

He’d do my fucking head in. His approach is all about him, not what’s best for her.

Of course it’s upsetting hearing our children cry, that’s what it’s designed to do. But it doesn’t always mean they’re in great distress and she’s not a newborn. She’ll be crying because she’s frustrated and doesn’t have the words for her feelings. It’s a parent’s job to give them the words, to acknowledge the feelings.

So you address it “you’re sad because you want the glass, it feels nice in your hand. It’s not safe for you to use it so I’m going to get you your favourite blue beaker and you can hold it all by yourself”, offer blue beaker, remove glass, point out the trees blowing in the wind out of the window and move on.

Which is probably what you’re doing and a more productive way to help shape behaviour without pandering and creating a monster, or ignoring your child’s wishes and feelings and making them feel minimised.

It’s harder, it takes longer, it takes repeating. It’s parenting rather than pandering which is the easy choice for the adult and a shit approach for the poor child.

Hufflepods · 19/09/2023 14:12

With the pram it's that she wants to be carried. Not walk. She wants to be carried. My boundary is that you can walk or be in the pram but I'm not carrying if the pram is with us (because I don't have enough hands and she's heavy, as is her pram!)

Eh, this is your boundary though. I feel like your DH is allowed to make his own decisions and if he’s happy to carry her the few times he’s out with her in the pram then it’s his choice.

Who cares if other people look? They're in a public place and babies are part of the public. We are raising a little human, surely that's far more important than someone's dinner?!

Disagree. Your parenting doesn’t need to be disruptive to other people in public. If she’s tantrumming or crying you either deal with it or remove her. Your ‘lesson’ isn’t more important than others.
Plus at 19 months the actual discipline you can use is so limited. Most of the things you’re trying to teach her she just won’t understand yet.

ImustLearn2Cook · 19/09/2023 14:12

When he says: "but she's my baby, I love her so much, how can you stop her, she's so little and I can't handle my poor lovely girl crying, do you have a heart"

Counteract with:

"but she's my baby, I love her so much, I want her to grow up having friends and getting along with people, how can you stop her from learning good boundaries, do you have a heart?”

Confrontayshunme · 19/09/2023 14:11

My DH went through this with our second. He was going through a stressful time at work, and after we discussed on a good, calm day(not one where we had argued about the issue), he admitted that he felt really overwhelmed at not being able to immediately solve the crying. It wasn't that he was wet or wanted to be a Disney dad, he just found the crying really triggering (just as many parents do). So we agreed that if she started crying, he would give us a break in the other room or outside or walk away and set a timer for 15 minutes. If I wasn't able to distract her by the time he got back, I would give her what she wanted, NOT him. It normally only took 5-10 mins though to find something else and distract her. Toddler discipline really thrives on distraction.

YouBelongHere · 19/09/2023 14:08

For what it's worth OP when I was a kid I saw my Dad one evening a week, lived the rest of the time with my Mum. One week she put a note in our overnight bag asking my Dad to wash my hair - he usually gave me a bath but didn't bother with my hair and this week it needed a wash. She told me she was putting it in there and to show him if he didn't notice.

I HATED having my hair washed and cried the moment I got to my Dad's because I didn't want him to do it, he immediately told me he wasn't going to if I didn't want to. As a kid I was pleased but as an adult I fume about it on behalf of my Mum. Let her be the bad guy and do all the parenting because you don't know how to deal with my tears for one night??

Also if I saw the three of you out in public and your DD began to cry I wouldn't think that was embarrassing, if you said no to something and she began to cry and he immediately caved in I would find that embarrassing.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 19/09/2023 14:08

Maybe you could try it yourself with him and it'll highlight how ridiculous it is

"Dh, I want a coffee, give me yours"
"No! You've got one"
"I want yours!!! Waaaaaaa!" Whilst throwing yourself on the floor and fake crying til he hands it over.

Then just stand up and say "this is what you will create"

And repeat for every interaction with him over the next week.

SunRainStorm · 19/09/2023 14:03

He needs to do some work on himself and work out why he has such a low tolerance for her showing negative emotions.

Feeling sad/angry/jealous or what have you is just a part of life. Part of being a parent is holding space for our children to feel those things- and teaching them they are strong enough and emotions are temporary etc. that's how we prepare them for the world and teach them to be resilient.

If he swoops in and solves everything for her, she's not going to learn those skills around resilience, confidence and emotional regulation. One day there will be a problem he can't solve, and she'll be ill equipped to weather it because he deprived her of opportunities to grow.

bananahanna · 19/09/2023 14:03

@OneMoreStepAlongTheRoadIGo

If they prefer to walk/sit I'd go with that. If he's happy to carry I don't see the problem? Mine loved being carried when they were small.*
*
Then she learns that she needs to cry to be carried. And I can't carry her as well as pushing the pram (and possibly carrying her toy in the other hand or a shopping bag) when it's just us 2 - I'm a SAHM. It's not sustainable for this to become a habit.

If they have a favourite cushion/blankey/toy they carry everywhere and it genuinely isn't a problem I don't see the issue there either. If its an item of yours I'd see about finding soemthing else they can carry instead rather than just saying no. *

Yes it's not a problem if it's her toy.* It is a problem if it's cushions from my sofa. And I'm suggesting offering an alternative - a random cloth or her own toy that we could bin. But she might cry for a bit because she wants the cushions from the sofa

Another thing is to practice "yes". Can I have a snack "yes when we get home" rather than "No not now, not until we get home. " or can we do X "yes on Saturday... shall I show you when Saturday is?" Rather than "no not til Saturday ".

If they are constantly upset I think it's up to us to help them through/ distract/find alternatives.*

Key word is DISTRACT and ALTERNATIVES.* But she cries for a bit and that's unbearable. Especially in public. Better to give her that glass of water that she could break, and then spend half an hour running after her trying to prevent her from breaking it, than take it away, offer her a bread roll / plastic cup / a toy instead because "everyone will be looking at us whilst she cries"

There's lots of ideas out there to support parenting without just saying no and leaving to cry.

OP posts:
BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 19/09/2023 14:02

He sounds like a lazy fucker tbh. He wants to say yes to everything because it's easier, then leave you with the actual issues it causes. How utterly disrespectful to you.

I think if you cannot get him to sort this issue with conversation, I'd attempt it with action - take yourself off out Friday as soon as he gets jn from work and tell him you'll be home Monday morning in time for him to leave for work.

It's extreme, of course. But he needs to see what a world of saying Yes to everything actually looks like. Especially if he has to deal with saying Yes all the time and sort a food shop, laundry and housework like you do all week too.

Marmalade71 · 19/09/2023 14:00

I will admit I'm kind of with him on the public behaviour thing, but in the opposite way. DS quickly learnt that behaviour which would just about be tolerated at home would result in a "scary mummy" response when out and about. To confirm he was never hit, but the reaction from me was so different to what he was used to he learned that "outside DS" needed to be obedient and quiet.

HappyMeal564 · 19/09/2023 14:00

I'm with you. Point out how difficult life will be for her when the other kids at school don't pander to her every whim and just leave her out. Poor girl it won't be her fault but that's what he's teaching her

OneMoreStepAlongTheRoadIGo · 19/09/2023 13:56

If they prefer to walk/sit I'd go with that. If he's happy to carry I don't see the problem? Mine loved being carried when they were small.

If they have a favourite cushion/blankey/toy they carry everywhere and it genuinely isn't a problem I don't see the issue there either. If its an item of yours I'd see about finding soemthing else they can carry instead rather than just saying no.

Another thing is to practice "yes". Can I have a snack "yes when we get home" rather than "No not now, not until we get home. " or can we do X "yes on Saturday... shall I show you when Saturday is?" Rather than "no not til Saturday ".

If they are constantly upset I think it's up to us to help them through/ distract/find alternatives.

There's lots of ideas out there to support parenting without just saying no and leaving to cry.

trevthecat · 19/09/2023 13:54

How is she going to cope as she gets older and others put boundaries in place? Like at nursery or school?

Noone wants to be friends with a child that screams every time they don't get their own way

OneMoreStepAlongTheRoadIGo · 19/09/2023 13:51

I wasn't happy with mine crying when mine were babies. It means they're unhappy or struggling with something.

I do like the how to talk books and they've done one for toddlers I think

A baby at 19months won't understand a lot of adult reasoning. So where somethings not appropriate I would try distraction or finding another way to satisfy their need if the way they want isn't suitable.

I wouldn't be happy regularly leaving to cry.

DuploTrain · 19/09/2023 13:47

I would enforce all your boundaries with my 2.5yo. However when he was 19 months some of the things he just wouldn’t understand at all.

But I agree that distraction/offering an alternative is much more effective. Especially giving biscuits because she’s crying - that’s ridiculous.

Get him to read “how to talk so little kids will listen” to understand about acknowledging emotions etc but still having boundaries.

bananahanna · 19/09/2023 13:46

Scarydinosaurs · 19/09/2023 13:42

I promise she’ll just think he’s a pushover.

she won’t love him more - children want boundaries and to be told no. It makes them feel safe.

in fact - I’d go down that road with him - he’s going to create an insecure child unless he has clear firm boundaries with her? Would that work?

Is there a parenting class he can do??

Please could you elaborate on how that makes her insecure? Thank you so much!! This might actually work with him

OP posts:
bananahanna · 19/09/2023 13:45

It's worse in public and he jumps to stop the tears within a millisecond with ANYTHING. His main reasoning is so that we don't embarrass ourselves and so that she isn't disturbing other people (and of course so that our little girl isn't crying or upset). How do I deal with the "embarrassing" reasoning? Where do I even begin?

Who cares if other people look? They're in a public place and babies are part of the public. We are raising a little human, surely that's far more important than someone's dinner?!

Side point - i was once told by an older man on a plane that he hoped to relax on the flight and my daughter (about 3 months then) disturbed him by crying. I asked why he didn't hire a private jet if he was strongly against flying with a baby. For some reason he didn't seem amused

OP posts:
Scarydinosaurs · 19/09/2023 13:42

I promise she’ll just think he’s a pushover.

she won’t love him more - children want boundaries and to be told no. It makes them feel safe.

in fact - I’d go down that road with him - he’s going to create an insecure child unless he has clear firm boundaries with her? Would that work?

Is there a parenting class he can do??

toomanyleggings · 19/09/2023 13:42

Your post is making me think I give in to my toddler too much. You’re not wrong

Maray1967 · 19/09/2023 13:40

bananahanna · 19/09/2023 13:24

@Peachpicklepie

Ex.6. If I'm drinking a glass of water and she wants to hold it instead and drop some omelette in it, I should just get myself a new glass of water rather than say "no"

O dear lord, you’ve got a right one here. He needs to hear, loud and clear, that this has to stop because if it doesn’t she will be the spoilt brat who no one wants to have around and who school staff dislike. He needs to get a grip.

Soubriquet · 19/09/2023 13:38

“Dh you’re being pathetic and if you continue she’s gonna be a spoilt brat throwing tantrums in shops because she can’t have a bar of chocolate”

He needs to start being firmer with her. Once she realises he’s standing up, she will soon stop her crying

suitcasecoveredincathair · 19/09/2023 13:37

with throwing omelette in my water "she doesn't understand it's quite disguising to drink, she's just playing, she won't understand

It’s his job to teach her things she doesn’t understand! (I know you know this.)

bananahanna · 19/09/2023 13:35

Peachpicklepie · 19/09/2023 13:34

Ooh ok, yes those sound like reasonable boundaries to me! She will learn though that if he's there she gets it, and when it's just you you'll not cave so it's all a bit pointless. He needs to step up and help her develop the skills she needs for school and beyond. He's setting her up for a fail here.

Edited

But equally I don't want to be bad cop or the strict parent ("my mum it's so boring, dad is so much fun") just for having reasonable boundaries?

OP posts: