Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect DH not to give in every time DD cries

137 replies

bananahanna · 19/09/2023 13:06

DH seems unable to tolerate our DD 19 mo crying, especially when it's in public. As a result she is very quickly learning that if she wants something she needs to cry, and if she's not getting it then she needs to up her screaming. I've tried to talk to him about it, explain it, send articles, demonstrate, model it myself. I feel like I've tried everything but his response is "it's so difficult to see her cry" or "she's our little girl, if we can stop her being upset we should!" (or something along those lines, when in private) or in public it's "people are looking at us" "this is so embarrassing" "we are disturbing people's dinners".

So I'm left with two problems
A) by default I become the baddie or the bad cop, whilst he's the nice parent, the best friend, the good cop. All just because I want to raise a nice person, not a spoilt brat
B) I'm left with a toddler who screams non-stop because she's learnt it's her way of getting things. For example, if she's on a walk with her dad she will cry and he will take her out of the pram (we get into an argument when we are on a walk together because he insists on doing this so I know he would 100% do it without me). So when I'm walking home from the park and she's decided she doesn't want to sit anymore, I've got a screaming toddler because she's learnt that's how she can get her way, unless I fancy carrying 12kg of baby along with pushing her pram with the other hand. Or same with if she wants me to give something she can't have - my husband will give it to her if she cries so she expects the same from me and screams the house down because I don't.

I'm a SAHM so really it's me who is suffering most of the time from her tantrums. He just comes in on weekends and for 1hr in the evening to be "nice dad".

If I talk to him about it the responses are all very much along the lines of "but she's my baby, I love her so much, how can you stop her, she's so little and I can't handle my poor lovely girl crying, do you have a heart"

OP posts:
DuploTrain · 20/09/2023 12:30

Natsmms16 · 20/09/2023 12:26

Your child is 19 months old, their brain is not capable of manipulation and attending to their needs will not make a spoilt child, contrary to what elder parents/grandparents may believe! There is probably an underlying reason why she is having tantrums in the first place.

Attending to their needs is giving them a cuddle and distraction… not giving them the packets of sugar to sprinkle over the table.

It sounds like OP is attending to her needs. DH is attending to her wants.

Natsmms16 · 20/09/2023 12:26

Your child is 19 months old, their brain is not capable of manipulation and attending to their needs will not make a spoilt child, contrary to what elder parents/grandparents may believe! There is probably an underlying reason why she is having tantrums in the first place.

Harrysarseinthedogbowl · 20/09/2023 11:53

Go away for a bit and leave your husband in sole charge of your daughter. A week should be long enough for him to get the point.

Hufflemuff · 20/09/2023 11:42

YANBU hes acting like a drip.

At what point is he going to say no? When she's a morbidly obese 6 year old because she's been fed biscuits like a barking seal to stop her crying?

When her teeth are falling out because she cries for sweets and fizzy?

Don't worry about her not loving you... continue to be the propper parent and he will catch on soon.

Get him to watch some supernanny episodes of kids who always got their own way!

oneandabitsugars · 20/09/2023 11:14

And if he's opening packets of sugar and letting her chuck it all over the table in a restaurant, I'd be judging him more for that than trying to distract with toys etc or taking her outside to distract her!

This. He needs to be saying the ‘No we don’t do that’ to her as well as you. Does he want a 6 year old doing this?

rainbowstardrops · 20/09/2023 10:56

Blimey, he'd infuriate me!!! Yes, she's still very young and I'd be careful to pick my battles but children need boundaries to feel safe.
When is he going to be able to tolerate his little princess having a strop because she can't have what she wants - when she's 5? 15? She's crying because this is her way of communicating at this age and he needs to realise this.
And if he's opening packets of sugar and letting her chuck it all over the table in a restaurant, I'd be judging him more for that than trying to distract with toys etc or taking her outside to distract her!

GrassWillBeGreener · 20/09/2023 10:34

I agree, the most important thing your DH needs to learn at this point is the art of distraction. (and of course keep practising this yourself) A clear "No" is actually really important at this age to keep children safe. There's a reason why 2 yr olds use "no" a lot themselves - one because they are learning they can make choices, and two because they've heard "no" a lot by the time they are 2!
So "No, that's Mummy's, here's yours", "No that's Daddy's shall we get you one just for you", "let's put the cushions back on the sofa then we can go outside", "no I can't carry you look at the bird in that tree / let's sing a song / we're going to have X for lunch as soon as we get home"

Good luck. It took me a very long time to properly learn how to do these things by which time I needed different skills because my children had grown up ... This morning's was convincing an 18 yr old to get out of bed and go for a walk because he's worried he needs to fix his sleep patterns before starting uni next week :)

freespirit333 · 20/09/2023 10:24

I was going to say YABU for thinking a 19 month old can be disciplined in such a way (it’s been a while as my youngest is almost 5) but then I read your examples and laughed. YADNBU OP, your DH sounds bonkers and I can just imagine these scenarios playing out when my DC were little, and no we didn’t give in to them. You are 100% correct in your approaches.

oneandabitsugars · 20/09/2023 10:19

Re the restaurant, I used to move the cutlery/sugar packets out of reach as soon as we sat down and we used to take a small toy for them to fiddle with. Kids that age explore and grab everything. The magnetic drawing thing with the pen attached is a great idea.
If they tried to grab stuff they shouldn't touching, then a 'no' and moving it away and distracting them with a toy/pointing something out over there usually worked. We didn't eat out much and didn't expect to stay in there for long.

I think there will be times when she will want to be carried and one of you will be happy to carry her (some lovely moments with my toddler boys on their Dad's shoulders) and times when you both will be too tired/bad back or whatever or you think she should walk/go in the buggy. She has to get used to that so he needs to get used to saying not now and putting up with the tears.

Five Minute Mum on Insta has a great book for out and about with kids. For ages 1-2 she carries things like little sensory fidget toys, a small Duplo car with wheels etc...

Anderson2018 · 20/09/2023 07:19

I feel like I was your husband in this situation and I do understand how he’s triggered with the crying as I can be the same with my son, my husband is the opposite and is very good at setting boundaries with no grey areas. Now nearly 3 years on we have a toddler that won’t misbehave for his dad but won’t listen to a word I say, which makes life very difficult for me, so he will soon realise that he’s been wrong. I have recently had to find a back bone because I have a determined wee boy who needs rules so I’m turning it around, it’s not too late. Me and my husband have had a lot of arguments over it but I do now realise he was right and they absolutely need rules, I always just thought he was too young for rules and hated when he was upset. I hope it works out for you guys and he eventually realised because it’s you that’s there full time and is going to have to deal with the behaviour. What I will say is that don’t worry too much about being the baddie, my husband is and my son absolutely adores him. your kid will have more respect for the parent with boundaries.

AllHopeandRainbows · 20/09/2023 07:12

Scarydinosaurs · 19/09/2023 13:42

I promise she’ll just think he’s a pushover.

she won’t love him more - children want boundaries and to be told no. It makes them feel safe.

in fact - I’d go down that road with him - he’s going to create an insecure child unless he has clear firm boundaries with her? Would that work?

Is there a parenting class he can do??

Came here to say exactly this - she definitely will not love him more. Children tend to resent and have no respect for parents like him. They feel insecure and anxious when there are no boundaries.

Perfect28 · 20/09/2023 06:25

Sorry i didn't get further than 'she is learning to cry when she wants something' well yes- that's sort of how babies are hardwired. We Are meant to respond to them...

SunRainStorm · 19/09/2023 23:47

bananahanna · 19/09/2023 19:33

@SunRainStorm I would expect that she can have a few sugar packets closed to play with. If she asks to open one we say "no" and distract her with a toy. If she keeps crying we try distract her with a different toy. We could start building something out of closed sugar packets. We could offer her a sip of water. But there are things you don't do and they are things that we would say "no" to. Just like if she asked to pour ketchup on the tablecloth (this hasn't actually happened but illustrates my point well). Would it be entertaining for a toddler? Yes. But should we instead offer crayons and a piece of paper? Probably.

For clarity - all the examples so far have actually happened. Not the ketchup one though.

I get it, but these are all normal 19 month old things to want to do.

You can't expect her to appreciate that while playing with the sugar packets closed is ok, opening them is not. It's not realistic from a developmental perspective. Since you know that's what she's going to want to do, then personally id remove all those things from the table before I sat her down at it. If you don't want to be 'bad cop' all the time, one way to avoid it is to anticipate the conflict and avoid it. Remove the things she can't play with, put her own toys there instead. She's a toddler, you can outsmart/out plan her a lot of the time.

Likewise the example earlier- if she's fighting on the pram then her DH to bring her in a carrier when he's with you. & Don't take her out of the pram when it's just you.

momonpurpose · 19/09/2023 22:35

He really needs to stop this nonsense. He will turn her into a child no one likes by refusing to set boundaries and make you look like the bad cop to boot. I think he really needs a parenting course since he's not understanding the common sense you have been trying to make him understand. Maybe hearing it from a stranger will help?

GodDammitCecil · 19/09/2023 22:12

YANBU at all OP - and your DH isn’t doing your DD any favours at all.

This book came out when I was either in the very late stages of pregnancy with DC1, or he’d just been born. Either way, he was very far from being either a ‘diva’ or a ‘dictator’, but I saw the guy being interviewed on TV and his core message resonated with me so strongly.

Divas and Dictators

Essentially, you should go out of your way to reward / recognise / give lots of attention to GOOD behaviour, as a way of encouraging lots more of it.

BAD behaviour should be ignored. That is sometimes hard to do when in public - but the essential message is - don’t give attention to bad behaviour - which is exactly what your DH is doing - because, as you are both seeing, that ensures it is repeated and repeated and repeated.

I have two lovely DC - now that may very well be (and probably is!) down to their inherent personalities and nothing to do with my parenting.

But from the moment both of them were born, I’ve always focused on giving loving attention when they exhibit pro-social behaviour (no matter how small / insignificant), and not giving them attention when they exhibited anti-social behaviour.

Maybe get him to have a read through.

Doesn’t he want his lovely daughter to grow up to be someone her peers like, and want to be around? Surely he does.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 19/09/2023 22:04

This might sound silly but does he have misophonia ? I have it for anything that’s squeaky or screechy, and I found baby’s cries very hard to handle.

You sometimes do have to put up with it though.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 19/09/2023 21:59

Yeah I was all ready to come on here and think you were U, but having read the examples YANBU

With the carrying thing, would he get a toddler sling and just carry her in that rather than bringing the pram in the first place?

oneandabitsugars · 19/09/2023 21:55

Mine older too. We try and meet in the middle.

Seriously79 · 19/09/2023 21:52

I'm living this right now, although DD is 4. My problem is around food - mummy says have an apple, daddy says have a chocolate bar.

DD wants to go on daddy's shoulders, daddy says no. DD whines and then daddy says yes.

We have spoken about it and DH is making efforts to stop giving in, and I'm also trying to loosen up, but it's hard!

Inkyblue123 · 19/09/2023 21:50

Just hold your line ; she will figure out who the push over is really quickly. My one will go to daddy to be carried - she’s know there is no chance of me picking her up with my bad back. I will give in on the biscuit though . I’m afraid you can’t force him to toughen ip. Maybe you need to go on a little trip for a couple of days and leave him dealing with her tantrum’s full time, he might have a change of heart

IslaWinds · 19/09/2023 21:35

I’m sorry, but as she is only 19mo I don’t think that deliberately letting her cry and get more upset is good parenting. She is too young to be spoilt and too young to understand why you won’t pick her up when she cries. I read your post and thought it must be a reverse.

Neolara · 19/09/2023 19:58

I'm wondering what your dh's childhood was like that makes it so hard for him to bear seeing his child upset.

Goldbar · 19/09/2023 19:55

@bananahanna . You would be ambitious imo to offer crayons and paper to a 19mo if you didn't want to be constantly retrieving them from the floor. I've had more success in the past with a magnetic drawing board with an attached pen. You can tie or hook it to the highchair.

It's possible I'm being unduly pessimistic and other people's DC were mini-picassos at that age, but mine tended to snap, chew or throw the crayons, or roll them off the table.

Hufflepods · 19/09/2023 19:52

FS this is a 1.5 year old. All the comments about how she’s never going to have any friends and no one will like her are mental 🤦‍♀️

Goldbar · 19/09/2023 19:50

There are different breeds of toddler. Some are restaurant-friendly, some are not. At that age, it doesn't have a lot to do with parenting.