Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How important do you think it is to be on time for a GP appt

364 replies

Ireolu · 19/09/2023 12:06

Just that really.

Do you think it is important to turn up on time or early for a GP appt? Do you think you shd still be seen when you are 10 mins or more late for a 10 minute appt.

This is just for adults over 18 not for children. TIA for thoughts.

OP posts:
User1789 · 19/09/2023 14:27

OP, I understand your frustration (I really go, I used to work in a GP health centre), however, it would be good to know what you think about the consensus here that being 5 minutes late is clearly not ok, but it is perhaps unreasonable to be pulled up on it if the GP is running 20 minutes late and it doesn't really make a difference?

I do get that the public underestimate the level of lateness and cancellation though. A friend of mine recently trained to be a clinical psychologist and says there is a 25% no show rate for therapy sessions at the high profile London NHS clinic she works at. I think a lot of people on waiting lists for mental health treatment would be appalled if they knew this.

Pixie4192 · 19/09/2023 14:26

Definitely important. One late patient still being seen can make others who got there on time late too.

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 19/09/2023 14:25

Where do these anti NHS conspiracy theorists keep popping up from? Most of us are sick of them now. They are often incredibly entitled, despite knowing how busy even the government acknowledges the NHS is currently. Just go away and cause trouble elsewhere, will you? (Back to Tory HQ, in some cases, we hear. And especially on strike days?).

Fizbosshoes · 19/09/2023 14:23

JenniferBooth · 19/09/2023 14:05

Sadly drs can't operate the same way but wouldn't it be interesting if people paid a £10 non refundable deposit for appointments

So what do you think should happen about the £76 (£38 each way) that has just been wasted on a taxi ride to a hospital that then cancelled the appointment minutes before.

We will always see articles and opinions about how people should pay for missed appointments but the real reason it will never happen is because it would have to be reciprocated and that would cost the NHS ££££

And a lot of missed apts are the NHS own admin/system errors as you describe.
My DD had some orthodontic treatment at hospital. If we couldn't make the apt I called the number as instructed on the letter, with usually at least a weeks notice. On more than one occassion we were berated at the subsequent apt by both the receptionist and the dentist and put down as a no show. I had followed the instructions on the letter for cancelling, and either spoken to a receptionist or left a message. I wouldn't have been willing to pay a fine for that.

jays · 19/09/2023 14:23

RuthW · 19/09/2023 12:10

We won't see you if you are more than a few mins late.

But ‘we’ will see ‘you’ even if you’re an hour and a half late!

Lavender14 · 19/09/2023 14:22

I think it's very important to be on time given how under pressure the service is at the moment and also just because its the respectful thing to do. I do think sometimes life happens and you might be 5 or 10 minutes late, I think if you ring ahead and let them know what's happening it's nice if they can accommodate you but I wouldn't expect to be accommodated.

Viviennemary · 19/09/2023 14:19

Of course you need to be on time. But irritating when you sit and wait for ages.

usernother · 19/09/2023 14:17

Extremely important. And good manners. It's very rude to be late for any appointment. I wouldn't expect to be seen if I was 10 minutes late.

AutumnCrow · 19/09/2023 14:15

The NHS are already on its knees and so much resources are being wasted by people not showing up for their appointments.

You know that they 'DNA' patients who do actually turn up and check in for their appointments, right? But who don't get seen?

HollyFern1110 · 19/09/2023 14:14

Please don't attempt to patronise me. I actually work in a GP surgery (no I'm not a Receptionist) and have a much better idea of why GPs tend to run late than you do.

The vast majority are emergencies yes. We are a large practice & each day we, on average, call 2 ambulances. Some days this is 0 some days it's 4. On top of this each day there will be patients who the GP arranges emergency hospital assessment/admission for not via ambulance. This obviously takes a lot of time phoning through to the Registrar/Consultant to put the necessary arrangements in place. There are also complex patients who have a 10 minute appointment but need 30 minutes. If they are before you you're going to be late in.

Why on earth shouldn't a GP take a quick phone call from their wife? Or speak to a colleague. Do you never speak to your colleagues? I'm guessing this wasn't during your appointment? Was it even the GP you were waiting to see? Our GPs are in surgery for between 10 & 12 hours a day. They are entitled to statutory breaks the same as everyone else, although several rarely take them.

speakingofart · 19/09/2023 14:14

Very important, otherwise they can’t keep you waiting for an hour to be seen!

herewegoagainfriends · 19/09/2023 14:13

DoratheFlora · 19/09/2023 14:10

I am always early for GP appointments. GPs, however, never run to time. I don't think a 45 minute wait for a GP appointment when you need to get back to work is on personally.

I think it should be possible to book double slots.

It's not always possible to bring 'just one issue' to a GP appointment. It can be downright clinically unsafe for a GP to treat you based on one thing if you have a complex medical history - they may need to consider how it interacts with different conditions.

Only allocating 10 minutes per person is what causes the delays. Even if everyone turns up on time, not everyone can stick to 10 minutes.

Crazyjanes · 19/09/2023 14:10

People are desperately waiting for GP appointments. If you’re late you don’t get seen. End of.

Mumof2teens79 · 19/09/2023 14:10

Ireolu · 19/09/2023 12:29

I ask because I am a GP and wondered what the consensus was on this and what experience people have in their practices. I am always at least half an hour early for a shift and will typically work to the time booked. I prefer people to turn up on time or even a little early. Thanks for thoughts.

Ha, so that's interesting because I think you should always be early as per my first post.
But I once turned up at GP surgery for an 8.30 appointment and they didn't unlock the door till 8.30 exactly (could see team sat watching the clock)
Which meant 3 of us all trying to check in on a single touch screen system for an 8.30 appointment and obviously that took a few minutes, none of us called through till 8.40.....is this deliberate?

Appointments work both ways in my book, and I don't mind so much if you're running over....but if you start the day 10 minutes late???
If surgery is known for running late I can understand why patients start to factor that into their arrival time.

herewegoagainfriends · 19/09/2023 14:10

It depends.

For a GP appointment, I wouldn't expect to be seen late as I need the whole 10 minutes, and being seen late would have a knock on impact for all the other patients.

For a HCA appointment, it literally takes me 2 minutes (I'm in and out for a quick injection), so if I showed up a few minutes late, I'd hope they would still see me, as it wouldn't have a knock-on impact.

DoratheFlora · 19/09/2023 14:10

I am always early for GP appointments. GPs, however, never run to time. I don't think a 45 minute wait for a GP appointment when you need to get back to work is on personally.

HMW1906 · 19/09/2023 14:07

Don’t be late it has a knock on effect to the rest of the appointments. I aim to be at least 5 minutes early ideally 10 minutes.

Mumof2teens79 · 19/09/2023 14:05

You should be on-time ie arrive a few minutes before any appointment.
Obviously occasionally things are beyond your control, and I would hope a GP might try and fit you in, but it should expected and would only be possible if EVERYONE else had arrived early and could be shuffled up the order

JenniferBooth · 19/09/2023 14:05

Sadly drs can't operate the same way but wouldn't it be interesting if people paid a £10 non refundable deposit for appointments

So what do you think should happen about the £76 (£38 each way) that has just been wasted on a taxi ride to a hospital that then cancelled the appointment minutes before.

We will always see articles and opinions about how people should pay for missed appointments but the real reason it will never happen is because it would have to be reciprocated and that would cost the NHS ££££

Flossflower · 19/09/2023 14:03

I once arrived 35 minutes early for an MRI scan. It said on the instructions, I was sent to be 10 minutes early but I didn’t know the logistics of getting to the hospital. I asked if I could just wait in the waiting room. However, I was almost immediately called as the man before me had not turned up. I was told by the receptionist that he arrived late and was going ballistic because they had not put the staff and machine on hold for him.

EggInANest · 19/09/2023 14:00

Everyone should turn up on time - i.e in time to get booked in and ready to be seen at the appointment time, so arrive 5 mins before appt time.

Anyone late: get seen BUT when a space becomes free, maybe by someone else arriving late, and if you have to wait to be seen so be it.

Our surgery generally runs pretty much to tome and it pays to turn up a bit early because then if someone doesn't show, they just put you in early.

whatwasthatgrandma · 19/09/2023 14:00

ManchesterLu · 19/09/2023 13:53

If you're 10 minutes late for a 10 minute appointment, you've missed it, and it's someone else's appointment.

Surely you understand that?

No. Because if I arrive 10 mins late for a 10 minute appointment, its still the appointment of someone who was meant to be in 20 mins before that.

TripleDaisySummer · 19/09/2023 14:00

ShadyPaws · 19/09/2023 13:45

@TripleDaisySummer my dad does it but my mum...
"Oh it's a 5 min drive"
No, it's actually 15 and parking takes at least 10 mins... Grin

Me and dad are always early and permanently were asking mum to hurry the fuck up

That does remind me of a school mum friends who was always late to school with her child.

She said to me it's only 6 minute walk - I was well it a good 10 minutes from my house and you are another 5 minutes away - and your late every day so how can it be 6 minutes. She then insisted they'd timed it - and a few other down her street chipped in with it's at least 15 minutes - she was then on time for a few weeks till her DH started insisting it was 6 minutes again - ended up having to see head for persistent lateness.

I do accept there are people out there who find reality an inconvenience rather than something to deal with - but they are the odd ones.

bluestar5 · 19/09/2023 13:59

Of course you have to be on time and they would hopefully not see you if you are late!

The NHS are already on its knees and so much resources are being wasted by people not showing up for their appointments.

RosesAndHellebores · 19/09/2023 13:56

110% on time.
However I still bristle at the time I was 2/3 minutes late, unavoidably (I have no record of lateness) and the receptionist barked at me that it was up to the Dr whether I'd be seen as I was late "but sit down there and you'll find out". There were two people ahead of me and surgery was running late so what exactly the issue was I shall never know.

I think patients should always be on time. I also think that all hospital/GP staff shoukd apologise unequivocally when they keep patients waiting. Their time is important too.

My last two hospital appointments were running one and three quarter hours behind. Little communication and certainly no apology. I asked at reception whether the Dr would see me if I arrived an hour and three quarters late next time. I got the NHS eyeroll.

I think punctuality and respect for people's time works two ways. Doctors and nurses need to shape up a bit if they wish to be draconian.